Reappraising the classics - the case for a dynamic reformulation of the labour theory of value

Freeman, Alan (1994): Reappraising the classics - the case for a dynamic reformulation of the labour theory of value.

Abstract

This article argues that simultaneous equation systems, widely regarded as a standard formalisation of labour value theory, import equilibrium assumptions which rule out a realistic or consistent theory of price formation. An alternative, dynamic formalisation exists yielding time-varying or dynamic labour values free of such assumptions.

We show that simultaneous equation systems, formally equivalent to neoclassical general equilibrium systems, cannot represent technical change or economic growth and apply only to hypothetical static economies in which neither the scale of output nor the technology changes. The resulting static values are a special, limiting case of dynamic values, which converge to them only tendentially and in the absence of technical change. Under conditions of technical change, dynamic values — and the prices and profit rates derived from them — differ systematically from those derived from simultaneous equation systems, and therefore provide a different foundation for economics.

We show that the behaviour of dynamic values corresponds more closely to observed reality than either neoclassical equilibrium prices or static labour values by showing how, in a dynamic framework, the rate of profit can, and in general does, fall despite productivity-enhancing technical change.

These results provide a rigorous foundation for the study of capital movements and technical change which is superior to conventional neoclassical price theory, calling for a radical reappraisal of the debate on value in this century.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: The University of Greenwich
• Language: English
• Keywords: Non-equilibrium; value theory; TSSI; Rate of Profit; Okishio Theorem; Marxist Economics
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B12 - Classical (includes Adam Smith); O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O4 - Economic Growth and Aggregate Productivity > O41 - One, Two, and Multisector Growth Models; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B14 - Socialist ; Marxist

References

Alberro, J and Persky, J, 1979. "The Simple Analytics of Falling Profit Rates, Okishio's Theorem and Fixed Capital", Review of Radical Political Economics,vol7, Spring.

Albarracin, J. 1984. Chapter in Mandel and Freeman [1984]

Andrews, M, 1984. "On the Importance of the Equilibrium Assumption to the Okishio Theorem Result". Working Paper, Rutgers University.

Andrews, M, 1987. "Technical Change in Postwar U.S. Agriculture and the Falling Rate of Profit." Working Paper, Rutgers University, Cook College, New Brunswick, New Jersey.

Arrow, K.J. and Debreu, G., 1954. Existence of an Equilibrium for a Competitive Economy. (Pubs?)

Baumol, B, 1961. Economic Dynamics (pubs?)

Birkhoff, G and MacLane, S, 1963. A Survey of Modern Algebra. New York:Macmillan.

Böhm-Bawerk, E.V. 1896 'On the Close of Marx's System' English Translation in Sweezy [1966]. Originally published as 'Zum Abschluss des Marxschen Systems', in Otto von Boenigk(ed), 1896. Staatswissenschaftliche Arbeiten,Berlin.

von Bortkiewicz, L 1951. "Value and Price in the Marxian System", English translation in International Economic Papers 2.

von Bortkiewicz, L (date?). 'Böhm-Bawerk's Criticism of Marx', English translation in International Economic Papers 2.

von Bortkiewicz, L, 1907. 'On The Correction of Marx's Fundamental Theoretical Construction', English Translation in Sweezy [1966]. Originally published in Jahrbücher für Nationalökonomie und Statistik, 1907

BronfenBrenner, M, 1968. 'Das Kapital for the Modern Man' in Horowitz [1968], pp 205-226.

Cameron, B., 1952. 'The Labour Thory of Values in Leontieff's Models', The Economic Journal, vol 62 pp 191-197

Carchedi, G, 1984 'The Logic of Prices as Values', Economy and Society Vol 13 No 4, pp431-455

Carchedi, G, 1988. 'Marxian Price Theory and Modern Capitalism', International Journal of Political Economy, Fall 1988, pp6-109

Carchedi, G, 1992. Frontiers of Political Economy. London:Verso

Carnap, R, 1958. Introduction to Symbolic Logic and its Applications. New York: Dover

Debreu, Gerard, 1971. Theory of Value. An Axiomatic Analysis of Economic Equilibrium, New Haven and London.

Dmitriev, V. K, 1905. Economiceski ocerki.Moscow. Published in French as Essais économiques: Esquisse de synthèse organique de la theorie de la valeur-travail et de la theorie de l'utilité marginale, Paris 1968 (Nuti translation into English?)

Dobb, Maurice, 1972. Theories of Value and Distribution since Adam Smith. Cambridge:CUP.

Ernst, John R, 1982. 'Simultaneous Valuation Extirpated: A Contribution to the Critique of the Neo-Ricardian Concept of Value', Review of Radical Political Economics 14(2):pp85-94.

Fine, B and Harris, L, 1976 "Controversial Issues in Marxist Economic Theory", in Milliband and Saville, eds, Socialist Register.

Fine, B and Harris, L, 1979. Rereading Capital. London:McMillan; New York:Comlumbia University Press.

Freeman, A, 1991. A Dynamic Simulation Model of a Capitalist Economy. CSE conference 1991

Freeman, A, 1992. The Mathematical Construction of a Value Measure, working paper, Economics Division, University of Greenwich

Freeman, A, 1993. Price and value: a continuous, general formulation, working paper, Economics Division, University of Greenwich

Gantmacher, F. R., The Theory of Matrices, Volume II. New York:Chelsea.

Gershgorin, S, 1931. Über die Abrenzung der Eigenwerte einer Matrix. Izv Akad Nauk SSSR Ser Mat. 7, 749-754; 16,

Georgescu-Roegen, N.[1950] 'Leontief's System in the Light of Recent Results', Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol 32 pp217ff

Giussani, P 1992 "The Determination of Prices of Production" in International Journal of Political Economy, Vol 21, No 4, Winter 1991-2

Giussani, P. 1993 'Values in Joint Production', working paper, Economics Division, University of Greenwich.

Goodwin, R and Punzo, L 1987. The Dynamics of a Capitalist Economy. Boulder, Colorado: Westview and Cambridge:Polity

Hahn, F, 1984. Keynesian Economics and General Equilibrium Theory: Reflections on Some Current Debates in Hahn, F Equilibrium and Macroeconomics. Oxford: Blackwell

Harcourt, G C, 1972. Some Cambridge Controversies in the Theory of Capital. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Harrod, R F, 1937. An Essay on Dynamics

Harrod, R.F., 1948. Towards and Economic Dynamics. London:MacMillan.

Horowitz, D, 1968. Marx and Modern Economics, New York: Monthly Review Press

Hunt, E and Schwartz, J(date?). The Subtle Anatomy of Capitalism. London

Hunt, E and Schwartz, J, 1972. A Critique of Economic Theory. London:Penguin

Kliman, A, 1988. 'The Profit Rate Under Continuous Technological Change', Review of Radical Political Economics, 20(2&3): pp283-289.

Kliman, A and McGlone, T, 1988. 'The Transformation Non-Problem and the Non-Transformation Problem', Capital and Class 35:56-83.

Laibman, D, 1987 "Growth, Technical Change and Cycles: Simulation Models in Marxist Economic Theory", Science and Society, Vol 51, Winter 1987-1988, pp 414-438

Leontieff, Wassily W., et al., Studies in the Structure of the American Economy, New York: Oxford University Press, 1953.

Mandel, 1974 Late Capitalism. London, Verso

Mandel 1984. "Gold, Money and the Transformation Problem" in Mandel and Freeman (1984) Mandel & Freeman, (eds) 1984 Marx, Ricardo and Sraffa London:Verso

Marx, 1957, Wage Labour and Capital. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House

Marx, 1968a. Theories of Surplus Value, Part I. London:Lawrence and Wishart

Marx, 1968b. Theories of Surplus Value, Part II. London:Lawrence and Wishart

Marx, 1968c. Theories of Surplus Value, Part III. London:Lawrence and Wishart

Marx, 1977a. Capital, Volume I. London:Penguin

Marx, 1972. Capital, Volume III. London:Penguin

Marx, 1976. Value Studies by Marx. London:New Park

Marx 1977b Results of the Immediate Production Process, printed in Marx 1977a May, K, 1951. "Value and Price of Production: a Note on Winternitz's Solution." Economic Journal pp596-599, December.

Meek, Ronald, 1956. 'Some Notes on the Transformation Problem', Economic Journal vol 66, pp94-107

Meek, Ronald, 1973. Studies in the Labour Theory of Value. London: Lawrence and Wishart. Morishima, M, 1973. Marx's Economics, Cambridge

Morishima and Catephores, 1979. 'The Transformation Problem: a Markov Process', Value, Exploitation and Growth, McGraw-Hill.

Morishima, M and Seton, F, 1961. 'Aggregation in Leontief Matrices and the Labour Theory of Value', Econometrica vol 29, pp203-222.

Nakicenovic, N, 1988. Dynamics of Change and Long Waves. Working Paper,Laxenburg (Austria): International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis(IIASSA)

Naples, M, 1985. "Dynamic Adjustment and Long-run Inflation in a Marxian Model", Journal of Post-Keynesian Economics Fall 1985, Vol 8 No 1

Naples, M, 1988. "Is a Uniform Profit Rate Possible? A Logical-Historical Analysis", Science and Society Vol 52 No. 1, Spring 1988, pp83-93.

Naples, M, "Time, Money, Equilibrium and the Labour Theory of Value." Working Paper, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey.

Naples, M "Methodology and the Transformation Problem", Working Paper, Rutgers University von Neumann, John, 1937. 'Über ein ökonomisches Gleichungssystem und ene

Verallgemeinerung des Brouwerschen Fixpunktsatzes', in Menger, C, (ed), 1938. Ergebnisse eines Mathematischen Seminar, translated by G Morgenstern into English as 'A Model of General Economic Equilibrium', Review of Economic Studies 1945, pp1-9

Okishio, N, 1961. "Technical Change and the Rate of Profit", Kobe University Economic Review, No. 7, 86-99

Okishio, N, 1972. 'On Marx's Production Prices', Keizaigaku Kenkyu, 19.

Pasinetti, l, 1977. Lectures in the Theory of Production. New York: Columbia

Phillips, E.G, 1960. A Course of Analysis, Cambridge: CUP

Ramos, Alejandro and Rodriguez-Herrera, 1993. 'The transformation of values into prices of production, luxury articles and commercial capital', Plusvalore, No. 13, Milano.

Robinson, J, 1942. An Essay on Marxian Economics, London

Samuelson, P. A, 1970. 'The Transformation from Marxian Values to Competitive 'prices': A Process of Rejection and Replacement', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences vol 67, pp423-425

Samuelson, P. A, 1971. 'Understanding the Marxian Marxian Notion of Exploitation: A Summary of the So-Called Transformation Problem Between Marxian Values and Competitive Prices', Journal of Economic Literature, vol 9 pp399-431

Savran, S, 1978. "Surplus, Wages and Reproduction: Contradictions of Sraffian Economics". Working Paper, Centro Studi di Economia Politica, 20124 Milano via Tadino 33.

Savran, S, 1979. "On the Theoretical Consistency of Sraffa's Economics." Capital and Class, 12.

Savran, S, 1980. "Confusions Concerning Sraffa (and Marx): Reply to Critics", Capital and Class, 7.

Savran, S, 1984 in E Mandel and A Freeman (eds), op cit.

Semmler, 1984. Competition, Monopoly, and Differential Profit Rates. New York: Columbia University Press

Seneta, E, 1973. Non-negative Matrices: an Introduction to Theory and Applications, London:George Allen and Unwin

Seton, F, 1957. "The Transformation Problem", Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 24 pp149-160.

Shaikh, A, 1973. 'The So-called Transformation Problem: Marx vindicated', mimeograph, New School for Social Research, New York

Shaikh, A, 1977, 'Marx's Theory of Value and the "Transformation Problem"' in J Schwartz (ed) The Subtle Anatomy of Capitalism. Goodyear.

Shaikh, A, 1981 "The Poverty of Algebra" in I. Steedman(ed) The Value Controversy. London: Verso

Shaikh, A, 1984. "The Transformation from Marx to Sraffa" in Mandel and Freeman (eds) op cit

Sraffa, P, 1960. The Production of Commodities by means of Commodities. London: Cambridge University Press.

Steedman, I, 1977. Marx After Sraffa. London: Verso

Sweezy, P, 1948. The Theory of Capitalist Development, London 1942

Sweezy, P, 1966(ed). Karl Marx and the Close of his System, pub:Kelley reprints three seminal papers: 'Karl Marx and the Close of his System' by Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk; 'Böhm-Bawerk's Criticism of Marx' by Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz and 'On The Correction of Marx's Fundamental Theoretical Construction' also by Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz.

Tugan-Baranovsky, M, 1905. Theoretische Grundlagen des Marxismus, Leipzig

Varga, R Matrix Iterative Analysis, 1963. New Jersey:Prentice-Hall.

Walker, Richard, 'The Dynamics of Value, Price and Profit', Capital and Class 35:146-181

Walras, L, 1926. Éléments d'Économie politique pure, translated in Jaffé, 1954. Elements of Pure Economics

Winternitz, J, 1948. "Values and Prices: a Solution of the So-called Transformation Problem." The Economic Journal, June

Wolff, R, Callari, A and Roberts, B, 1984 "A Marxian Alternative to the Traditional 'Transformation Problem'" in Review of Radical Political Economics Vol 16(2/3) 115-135 (1984)

Wolff, R, Roberts, B and Callari, A, 1982. 'Marx (not Ricardo's) Transformation Problem: a Radical Reconceptualisation' History of Political Economy vol 14 No 4., pp 564-582