Water management strategies in urban Mexico: Limitations of the privatization debate

Barkin, David and Klooster, Daniel (2006): Water management strategies in urban Mexico: Limitations of the privatization debate.

Abstract

Water management provides a critical lens onto the development process. For the last several centuries, improvements in clean water and sanitation have contributed to better health and increased life expectancies. Currently, however, developing countries seem unable to make much progress in bringing these benefits of development to significant sectors of their citizens. Water coverage is incomplete and water is of uneven quality. Just as serious, however, are the environmental impacts of water extraction, untreated sewage disposal, and the depletion of water sources through excessive withdrawals and pollution. In this research report, we present a framework for the analysis of the social appropriation of water based upon the concept of the New Culture of Water. Using that framework, we review the Mexican water sector in light of a set of original case studies. Although privatization might have some role to play in improving the performance of certain functions of water management agencies, it has clearly not proved superior to the public agencies we review. More importantly, however, the privatization solution has proved incapable of tackling the very serious problems of environmental destruction and the over-exploitation of finite water sources that plague the country. Our review of water management in Mexico, therefore, sheds light on some of the contradictions of a development process that is far from sustainable.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Water management; Mexico; New Culture of Water; Privatization
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H41 - Public Goods; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q53 - Air Pollution ; Water Pollution ; Noise ; Hazardous Waste ; Solid Waste ; Recycling; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H76 - State and Local Government: Other Expenditure Categories; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q2 - Renewable Resources and Conservation > Q25 - Water; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H23 - Externalities ; Redistributive Effects ; Environmental Taxes and Subsidies; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q57 - Ecological Economics: Ecosystem Services ; Biodiversity Conservation ; Bioeconomics ; Industrial Ecology; N - Economic History > N5 - Agriculture, Natural Resources, Environment, and Extractive Industries > N56 - Latin America ; Caribbean

References

Arrojo Agudo, Pedro (ed.). Lo público y lo privado en la gestión del agua: Experiencias y reflexiones para el siglo XXI. Madrid: Ediciones de Oriente y del Mediterráneo; 2005.

Arrojo Agudo, Pedro. “Hacia una nueva cultura del agua”, Cuadernos del CENDES, 2005ª; 22(59):139-143.

Bakker, Karen J. A Political Ecology of Water Privatization. Studies in Political Economy. 2003; (70):35-58.

Ballestero, Maureen, Ernesto Brown, Andrei Jouravlev, Ulrich Küffner, and Eduardo Zegarra. Administración del agua en América Latina: Situación actual y perspectivas. Serie Recursos Naturales e Infraestructura. No. 90. Santiago, Chile: CEPAL; 2005. Document number LC/L.2299-P. Available on internet.

Balanyá, Belén; Brid Brennan, Olivier Hoedeman, Satoko Krishimoto, and Philipp Terhorst. Reclaiming Public Water: Achievements, struggles and visions from around the world. Amsterdam: TNI; 2005.

Barkin, David. Innovaciones mexicanas en el manejo del agua. México: Centro de Ecología y Desarrollo, 2001.

Barlow, Maude and Tony Clarke. Blue Gold: The battle against corporate theft of the world's water. New York: The New Press; 2002.

Bauer, Carl J. Siren Song: Chilean Water Law as a Model for International Reform. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future; 2004.

Bennett, Vivienne (ed.). Opposing Currents: The Politics of Water and Gender in Latin America. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield; 2004.

Caldera Ortega, Alex Ricardo. Agua, participación privada y gobernabilidad: cambio institucional en el servicio del agua potable y alcantarillado en la ciudad de Aguascalientes (1989-2001). Caleidoscopio. 2004; 16:7-39.

Castro, José Estebán. Decentralization and modernization in Mexico: The management of water services. Natural Resources Journal; 1995; 35:3:1-27.

Castro, José Estebán, Karina Kloster, et al. Ciudadanía y gobernabilidad en la cuenca del río Bravo-Grande. In: Blanca Jiménez, and L. Marin, eds. El Agua en México vista desde la Academia. México: Academia Mexicana de Ciencias; 2004.

CNA. (Comisión Nacional de Agua.), Subdirección General de Infraestructura Hidráulica Urbana. Situación del Subsector Agua Potable, Alcantarillado, y Saneamiento a diciembre de 2003, México: CNA; 2004.

CNA. (Comisión Nacional de Agua.) La participación privada en la prestación de los servicios de agua y saneamiento: Conceptos básicos y experiencias. 2a ed. México: CNA; 2003.

CNA. (Comisión Nacional del Agua.) Lineamientos para el Programa Nacional de Agua Potable y Alcantarillado. México: CNA; 1989.

Dourojeanni R., Axel. Water Resources and River Basin Management in Latin America. Santiago, Chile: CEPAL; 2000.

Dourojeanni R., Axel, Andrei Jouravlev, and Guillermo Chávez. Gestión del agua a nivel de cuencas: teoría y práctica. Santiago, Chile: CEPAL; 2002, (LC/L.1777-P, Serie Recursos Naturales e Infraestructura No. 47).

Estache, Antonio and Lourdes Trujillo. La Privatización en América Latina en la Década de los Anos 90: Aciertos y Errores. Revista Asturiana de Economía. 2004; 31:37-59.

Grosse, Robert, Stefan Thimmel, and Javier Taks. Las Canillas Abierta de América Latina: La resistencia a la apropiación privada del agua en América Latina y en el mundo. Montevideo: Casa Bertolt Brecht; 2004.

Hall, David, Kate Bayliss, and Edmundo Lobina (PSIRU, Greenwich University). Still fixated with Privatization: A critical review of the World Bank's Water Resources Sector Strategy; 2001: 35-55. Available on web: http://www.psiru.org

IADB (Inter-American Development Bank). Country Program Evaluation: Mexico 1990-2000; 2003. http://www.iadb.org/ove/re259eng.pdf

Idelovitch, Emanuel and Klas Ringstok. Private Sector Participation in the Water Supply and Sanitation in Latin America. Washington, DC: World Bank; 1995.

Jiménez Torrecilla, Néstor and Javier Martínez-Gil. The New Culture of Water in Spain: A philosophy towards a sustainable development; translated from article: Rolde (Revista de Cultura Argonesa), Zaragoza; 2003. http://www.unizar.es/fnca/docu/docu67.pdf

Kaika, Maria. The Water Framework Directive: A New Directive for a Changing Social, Political and Economic European Framework. European Planning Studies. 2003; 11:3:299-316.

Larson, A. M. Natural Resources and Decentralization in Nicaragua: Are local governments up to the job? Natural Resources Journal. 2002; 30:17-31.

Loftus, Alexander J. and David A. McDonald. Liquid Dreams: A political ecology of water privatization in Buenos Aires. Environment and Urbanization. 2001; 13:2:179-199.

Mumme, Stephen and Christopher B. Brown. Decentralizing Water Policy on the U.S.-Mexico Border. In: Scott Whiteford and Robert Melville, (eds.), Protecting a Sacred Gift: Water and Social Change in Mexico. San Diego: Center for U.S.-Mexico Studies; 2002; pp. 231-252.

Olivera, Oscar. Cochabamba: Water war in Bolivia. Boston: South End Press; 2004.

Page, Ben. Paying for water and the geography of commodities. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers. 2005; 30:3:293-306.

Perló, Manuel and Arsenio González Reynoso. ¿Guerra por el Agua en el Valle de México? Estudios sobre las relaciones hidráulicas entre el Distrito Federal y el Estado de México. México: UNAM and Editorial Miguel Angel Porrua; 2005.

Pineda Pablos, Nicolás. Urban Water Policy in Mexico: Municipalization and Privatization of Water Services. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Texas, Austin; 1999

Roemer, Andrés. Derecho y Economía: Políticas públicas del agua. México: Centro de Investigación y Docencia Económicas, Sociedad Mexicana de Geografía, Miguel Ángel Porrúa; 1997.

Stiglitz, Joseph E. Globalization and its Discontents. New York: WW Norton; 2002.

Tendler, Judith. Good Government in the Tropics. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press; 1997.

Thobani, M. Formal water markets: Why, when and how to introduce tradable water rights. World Bank Research Observer. 12, 1997.

Vera Cartas, Jordi. Stakeholder Participation in Mexican Water Policy. Masters Degree Essay, Environmental Policy Group, Wageningen University, Netherlands; 2005

von Weizsäcker, Ernst Ulrich, Oren R. Young, and Matthias Finger. Limits to Privatization: How to avoid too much of a good thing; A Report to the Club of Rome. London: Earthscan; 2005.

Warner, Jeroen and Alejandra Moreyra. Conflictos y Participación: Uso múltiple del agua. Montevideo: Nordan; 2004.

Wester, Phillipus, Douglas J. Merrey, and Marna De Lange. Boundaries of consent: Stakeholder representation in river basin management in Mexico and South Africa. World Development. 2003; 31:5:797-812.

Williamson, John. What Should the Bank Think about the Washington Consensus? Washington, DC: Institute for International Economics; 1999.

World Bank. Water Resources Sector Strategy: Strategic directions for World Bank engagement. Washington, D.C.: World Bank; 2004.

World Bank. Mexico: Private Participation in Infrastructure: Investment and Performance Challenges. Washington, D.C.: World Bank; 2001.

World Bank. Private Sector Participation in the Water Supply and Wastewater Sector: Lessons from six developing countries. Washington, DC: World Bank; 1996.

WWAP. UN World Water Assessment Programme. Water for People, Water for Life: The United Nations World Water Development Report. Paris: UNESCO; 2003.