Crowding Out Effect of Public Borrowing: A Case of Pakistan

Khan, Rana Ejaz Ali and Gill, Abid Rashid (2009): Crowding Out Effect of Public Borrowing: A Case of Pakistan.

Abstract

To meet the public deficit, Government of Pakistan has been disproportionately borrowing from the scheduled banks and general public which are also the source of funding for private investment. Even the public sector corporations are doing the same. From the crowding out perspective borrowing and public expenditure are the same, as borrowing is mainly undertaken for financing expenditures. The issue of crowding out or crowding in effect of public borrowing on private investment needs considerable attention. The current study has investigated the crowding-out effect of public borrowing on private investment in the country. An investment function of three independent variables, i.e. public borrowing, GDP and lending rate has been estimated through unit root test, co-integration test and vector error correction model. The time series data of 34 years, i.e. fiscal year of 1971-72 to 2005-06, taken from Federal Bureau of Statistics and Finance Division, Government of Pakistan has been used. The results do not corroborate the crowding-out hypothesis in Pakistan explaining the market imperfections and substantial amount of excess liquidity. The results provide the evidence of crowding-in effect, which explains the direction of public expenditures towards private sector through contractors, politicians and bureaucrats, instead of public projects. The provision of subsidy, transfer payments, and substantial amount of micro-credit also explain the phenomenon of crowding-in. The evidence has important implications for fiscal management. To avoid unnecessary inflation and external indebtedness associated with deficit financing, government should rely on domestic sources. As long as excess liquidity prevails in financial system, the domestic resources, other than State Bank of Pakistan may be used to meet the deficit without hurting private investment.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Public Borrowing; Private Investment; Interest Rate; Subsidies; Transfer Payments
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E51 - Money Supply ; Credit ; Money Multipliers; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E2 - Consumption, Saving, Production, Investment, Labor Markets, and Informal Economy > E22 - Investment ; Capital ; Intangible Capital ; Capacity; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates

References

Akkina, K. R. and M. A. Celebi (2002) The Determinants of Private Fixed Investment and the Relationship between Public and Private Capital Accumulation in Turkey. The Pakistan Development Review 41(3): 243-254

Atukeren, E. (2005) Interaction between Public and Private Investment: Evidences from Developing Countries, KYKLOS, 58(3):307-330.

Chakraborty, L. S. (2006) Fiscal Deficit, Capital Formation, and Crowding-Out: Evidence from India. National Institute of Public Finance and Policy, Working Paper: No.43

Cumbers, A. and Birch (2006) Public Sector Spending and Regional Economic Development: Crowding-Out or Adding Value? Centre for Public Policy for Regions, University of Glasgow.

Erden, L. and R. G. Holcombe (2005) The Effects of Public Investment on Private Investment in Developing Economies. Public Finance Review 33(5): 575-602

Erden, L. and R. G. Holcombe (2006) The Linkage between Public and Private Investment: A Cointegration Analysis of a Panel of Developing Countries. Eastern Economic Journal 32(3): 479-492

Erenburg, S. J. (1993) The Relationship between Public and Private Investment. The Jerome Levy Economics Institute of Bard College and Eastern Michigan University, Working Paper: No. 85

FBS (1999) Fifty Years of Pakistan. Federal Bureau of Statistics (FBS), Finance Division, Islamabad. FBS (various years) Pakistan Economic Survey. Federal Bureau of Statistics (BBS), Finance Division, Islamabad.

Hyder, K. (2001) Crowding-out Hypothesis in a Vector Error Correction Framework: A case study of Pakistan. The Pakistan Development Review 40(4): 633-650

Jayaraman, T. K. (1998) Private Investment in Fiji: 1977-1994, Did Government Investment Have any Crowding-out Effect. South Pacific Study 18(2): 57-67

Johansen, S. (1988) “Statistical Analysis of Cointegration Vectors”, Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control”, 13:231-254.

Johansen, S. (1991) Estimation and Hypothesis Testing of Cointegration Vector in Guassrion Vector Autoregression Models. Econometrica, 59:1551-1580.

Johansen, S. and K. Juselius (1990) Maximum Likelihood Estimation and Inference on Cointegration with Application to the Demand for Money. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 52:169-210.

Looney, R. E. (1995) Public Sector Deficits and Private Investment: A Test of the Crowding-out Hypothesis in Pakistan’s Manufacturing Industry. The Pakistan Development Review, 34(3): 277-292

Looney, R. E. and P. C. Frederiken (1997) Government Investment and Follow-on Private Sector Investment in Pakistan, 1972-1995. Journal of Economic Development 22(1): 91-100

Loony, R. E. (1999) Government Investment in Manufacturing: Stimulus or Hindrance to Pakistan’s Private Sector? International Journal of Social Economics 26(4): 521-36

Majumder, A. M. (2007) Does public Borrowing Crowd-Out Private Investment? The Bangladesh Evidence. Policy Analysis Unit, Working Paper Series: WP 0708

Mitra, P. (2006) Has Government Investment Crowded-Out Private Investment in India?, Available at http://www.aeaweb.org/annual_mtg_papers/2006/0108_1015_0102

Naqvi, N. H. (2002) Crowding-in or Crowding-out? Modelling the Relationship between Public and Private Fixed Capital Formation Using Co-integration Analysis: the Case of Pakistan 1964-2000. The Pakistan Development Review 41(3): 255-276

Rashid, A. (2005) Public/Private Investment Linkages: A Multivariate Cointegration Analysis. The Pakistan Development Review 44(4): 805-817

Rossiter, R. (2002) Structural Cointegration Analysis of Private and Public Investment. International Journal of Business and Economics 1(1): 59-67

Saeed, H. and A. Ali (2006) The Impact of Public Investment on Private Investment: A Disaggregated Analysis. The Pakistan Development Review 45(4): 639-663

Spector, L. C. (2005) Macroeconomic Models and the Determination of Crowding-Out. Department of Economics, Ball State University Working Paper: No. 200511

Thomas, Jr. (2000) Money Banking and Economic Activity. Wiley and Sons.