Naughty or nice? Punishment and the interaction of formal and informal incentives in long-term contractual relationships

Schieffer, Jack and Wu, Steven Y. (2010): Naughty or nice? Punishment and the interaction of formal and informal incentives in long-term contractual relationships.

Abstract

The paper develops a model of repeated interaction between a buyer and a seller, which is then tested via laboratory experiments. The model allows for both formal and informal incentives in the contractual relationship between the parties. Formal incentives are explicit, performance-conditioned obligations enforced by third parties, such as a binding bonus paid for meeting an objectively measurable criterion. Informal incentives are non-binding promises to reward good performance. Although they are not enforced by external institutions, parties engaged in long-term interactions have incentives to “keep their words” about these promises and such payments can provide motivation for desirable performance. The current literature posits that these two types of incentives can function either as complements, so that joint use leads to better outcomes than either alone, or as substitutes, so that the availability of formal incentives may actually undermine the effectiveness of informal incentives. This study uses laboratory experiments to provide a rigorous test of hypotheses about the interaction of these incentives. The observed results suggest that the complementarity effect occurs in certain situations, but that the substitution effect does not occur as predicted, possibly because people do not punish transgressions in the manner that the theoretical model assumes.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Relational contracts, experimental economics
• Subjects: L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L14 - Transactional Relationships ; Contracts and Reputation ; Networks; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C9 - Design of Experiments > C92 - Laboratory, Group Behavior; D - Microeconomics > D0 - General > D02 - Institutions: Design, Formation, Operations, and Impact

References

Baker, G., R. Gibbons, and K. J. Murphy, 1994. “Subjective Performance Measures in Optimal Incentive Contracts, ”Quarterly Journal of Economics 109: 1125-1156.

Bernheim, B.D. and M.D. Whinston, 1998. “Incomplete Contracts and Strategic Ambiguity,” American Economic Review 88: 902-932.

Brown, M., A. Falk, and E. Fehr, 2004. “Relational Contracts and the Nature of Market Interactions.” Econometrica 72(3): 747-780.

Dixit, A., 2004. Lawlessness and Economics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Dmitri, C., 2003. “Contracting in Tobacco? Contracts Revisited,” Washington: U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, TBS 254-01.

Fehr, E. and S. Gächter, 2002; “Do Incentive Contracts Undermine Voluntary Cooperation?” Working Paper No. 34, Institute for Empirical Research in Economics, University of Zurich.

Fischbacher, U., 2007. “z-Tree: Zurich Toolbox for Ready-made Economic Experiments.” Experimental Economics, 10: 171-178.

Frey, B., 1997. “A Constitution for Knaves Crowds Out Civic Virtues,” The Economic Journal 107: 1043-1053.

Klein, B, and K. Leffler, 1981. “The Role of Market Forces in Assuring Contractual Performance,” Journal of Political Economy 89(4): 615-641.

Kreps, D.M., P. Milgrom, J. Roberts, and R. Wilson, 1982. “Rational Cooperation in the Finitely Repeated Prisoners’ Dilemma,” Journal of Economic Theory 27: 245-252.

Lazzarini, S.G., G.J. Miller, and T.R. Zenger, 2004. “Order with Some Law: Complementarity versus Substitution of Formal and Informal Arrangements,” Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization 20: 261-298.

Levin, J., 2003. “Relational Incentive Contracts,” American Economic Review 93: 835-857.

MacDonald, J., J. Perry, M. Ahearn, D. Banker, W. Chambers, C. Dmitri, N. Key, K. Nelson, and L. Southard, 2004. “Contracts, Markets, and Prices: Organizing the Production and Use of Agricultural Commodities,” Washington: U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Agricultural Economic Report No. 837.

MacLeod, W.B., 2007. “Reputations, Relationships, and Contract Enforcement,” Journal of Economic Literature 45: 595-628.

Schmidt, K.M. and M. Schnitzer, 1995. “The Interaction of Explicit and Implicit Contracts,” Economics Letters 48: 193-199.

Shapiro, C. and J. Stiglitz, 1984. “Equilibrium Unemployment as a Worker Discipline Device,” American Economic Review 74(3): 433-444.

Tesler, L.G., 1980. “A Theory of Self-Enforcing Agreements,” Journal of Business 53(1): 27-44.

Wu, S.Y. and B. Roe, 2007a. “Contract Enforcement, Social Efficiency, and Distribution: Some experimental Evidence,” American Journal of Agricultural Economics 89(2): 243-258.

Wu, S.Y. and B. Roe, 2007b. "Discretionary Latitude and Relational Contracting," IZA Discussion Papers 2879, Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA).