A Cross-national analysis of the relations between school choice and effectiveness differences between private-independent and public schools

Dronkers, Jaap and Avram, S (2010): A Cross-national analysis of the relations between school choice and effectiveness differences between private-independent and public schools. Forthcoming in: Sociological Theory and Methods (October 2010)

Abstract

We apply propensity score matching to the estimation of the disparity in school effectiveness between the privately owned, privately funded school sector and the public one in a sample of 25 countries in Europe, America and Asia. This technique allows us to distinguish between school choice and school effectiveness processes and thus, to account for selectivity induced variation in school effectiveness. We find two broad patterns of private independent school choice: the choice as a social class reproduction choice; and the choice of an outsider’s for a good-equipped school. As regards school effectiveness, our results show that, after controlling for selectivity and school choice processes, the initial higher reading scores of students in private-independent schools become comparable to those public schools students in a majority of countries. However, in a few countries average reading scores remain higher in the private independent sector even after introducing controls for school choice induced selectivity. The opposite pattern, namely of higher average reading scores in the public sector has also been found in four countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: school choice; school effectiveness; PISA data; public schools; private government-independent schools
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D71 - Social Choice ; Clubs ; Committees ; Associations; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J24 - Human Capital ; Skills ; Occupational Choice ; Labor Productivity

References

Alexander, K. L. and A. M. Pallas. 1983. "Private Schools and Public Policy: New Evidence on Cognitive Achievement in Public and Private Schools" Sociology of Education 56:170-182.

Ball, S. J. 1993. "Education Markets, Choice and Social Class: The Market as a Class Strategy in the UK and the USA" British Journal of Sociology of Education 14:3-19.

Ball, S. J. 1997. "On the cusp: parents choosing between state and private schools in the UK: action within an economy of symbolic goods" International Journal of Inclusive Education 1:1-17.

Ball, S. J., R. Bowe and S. Gewirtz. 1995. "Circuits of schooling: A sociological exploration of parental choice of school in social class contexts" Sociological Review 43: 52-78.

Bryk, A. S., V. E. Lee and P. B. Holland. 1993. Catholic schools and the common good. Cambridge (Mass.)/ London: Harvard University Press.

Chubb J. E and T. M. Moe. 1990. Politics, Markets and America's Schools. Washington DC: Brookings Institution Press.

Coleman, J.S. and T. Hoffer. 1987. Public and private high schools. The impact of communities. New York: Basic Books.

Coleman, J. S., T. B. Hoffer and S. Kilgore. 1982. High school achievement: Public, Catholic and other private schools compared. New York: Basic Books.

Corten, R. and J. Dronkers. 2006. "School Achievement of Pupils from the Lower Strata in Public, Private Government-Dependent and Private Government-Independent Schools: A cross-national test of the Coleman-Hoffer thesis" Educational Research and Evaluation 12:179-208.

Dehejia, R. and W. Sadek. 2002. “Propensity score matching methods for non-experimental causal studies” Review of Economics and Statistics 84:151-161.

Dronkers, J. and S. Avram. 2010. “A Cross-national Analysis of the Relations between School Choice and Effectiveness Differences between Private-Dependent and Public Schools” Educational Research and Evaluation 16:151-176.

Dronkers, J. and P. Robert. 2004. "Has educational sector any impact on school effectiveness in Hungary? A comparison of the public and the newly established religious grammar schools" European Societies 6:205-236.

Dronkers, J. and P. Robert. 2008a. "Differences in Scholastic Achievement of Public, Private Government-Dependent and Private-independent Schools: A Cross-National Analysis" Educational Policy 22:541-577.

Dronkers, J. & P. Robert. 2008b. "School Choice in the Light of the Effectiveness Differences of Various Types of Public and Private Schools in 19 OECD Countries" Journal of School Choice 2:260-301.

Echols, F. H. and J. D. Willms. 1995. "Reasons for School Choice in Scotland" Journal of Education Policy 10:143-156.

Gamoran, A. 1996. "Student Achievement in Public Magnet, Public Comprehensive, and Private City High Schools" Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 18:1-18.

Godwin, R. K. and F. R. Kemerer. 2002. School Choice Tradeoffs. Liberty, Equity, and Diversity. Austin: University of Texas Press.

Goldring, E. B. and K. J. R. Phillips. 2008. "Parent preferences and parent choice: the public-private decision about school choice" Journal of Education Policy 23: 209-230.

Gorard, S. 1999. "Planning Ahead in a 'Market' for Schools: Predicting Patterns of School Choice" Evaluation and Research in Education 13:132-143.

Goyette, K. 2008. "Race, Social Background, and School Choice Options" Equity & Excellence in Education 41:114-129.

Greeley, A. M. 1982. Catholic High Schools and Minority Students. New Brunswick: Transaction Books.

Hoffer, T. B. 1998. "Social Background and Achievement in Public and Catholic High Schools" Social Psychology of Education 2:7-23.

Hoffer, T., A. M. Greeley, and J. S. Coleman. 1985. “Achievement Growth in Public and Catholic Schools” Sociology of Education 58:74-97.

Jarvis, H. and S. Alvanides. 2008. "School choice from a household resource perspective: Preliminary findings from a north of England case study" Community, Work & Family 11:385-403.

Jeynes, W. 2002. "Educational Policy and Effects of Attending a Religious School on the Academic Achievement of Children" Educational Policy 16:406-424.

Langouët, G. and A. Léger. 1994. École publique ou école privée? Trajectoires et réussites scolaires. Paris: Editions Fabert.

Morgan, S. L. 2001. "Counterfactuals, causal effect heterogeneity, and the Catholic school effect on learning" Sociology of Education 74:341-374.

Morgan, S. L. and C. Winship. 2007. Counterfactuals and Causal Inference. Methods and Principles for Social Research. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Neal, D. 1997. "The Effects of Catholic Secondary Schooling on Educational Achievement" Journal of Labor Economics 15:98-123.

Noell, J. 1982. "Public and Catholic Schools: A Reanalysis of "Public and Private Schools" Sociology of Education 55:123-132.

Rosenbaum, O.D. and D. Rubin. 1983. "The central role of the propensity score in observational studies of causal effects“ Biometrika 70:41-55.

Sammons, P., J. Hillman and P. Mortimore. 1995. Key characteristics of effective schools: A review of school effectiveness research. London: Office for Standards in Education and Institute of Education.

Scheerens, J. and R. Bosker. 1997. The Foundations of Educational Effectiveness. Kidlington /New York /Toyko: Pergamon.

Somers, M.-A., P. J.McEwan and J. D. Willms. 2004. “How Effective Are Private Schools in Latin America?” Comparative Education Review 48:48-69

Teddlie, C. and D. Reynolds. 2000. The international handbook of school effectiveness research. London: Falmer.

Vandenberghe, V. and S. Robin. 2004. "Evaluating the effectiveness of private education across countries: a comparison of methods" Labour Economics 11:487-506.

Willms, J. D. 1985. "Catholic-School Effects on Academic Achievement: New Evidence From the High School and Beyond Follow-up Study" Sociology of Education 58:98-114.

Witte, J. F. 2000. The Market Approach to Education. An Analysis of America's First Voucher Program. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Yang, P. and N. Kayaardi 2004. "Who chooses non-public schools for their children?" Educational Studies 30:231-249.