Words or deeds – what matters? Experience of recentralization in Russian security agencies

Libman, Alexander (2011): Words or deeds – what matters? Experience of recentralization in Russian security agencies.

Abstract

Although decentralization is often modeled as an outcome of bargaining over rents and poli-cies, intuitively it seems possible that public statements, symbols and status often have a great impact on this process. The paper studies the relative importance of the “real” political actions versus the changes of symbolic nature in the bargaining over devolution and secession, using the unique laboratory of the personnel recentralization in the Russian security agencies in 2000-2007. While in the 1990s regional branches of federal ministries were mostly captured by regional governors, in 2000s Putin replaced the heads of agencies by new bureaucrats, cut-ting the connections to the region. The paper finds a robust influence of symbolic gestures made by regional governments in the earlier bargaining process on appointments, even if the actual devolution policies did not matter. Symbolic actions seem to play a crucial role in the decisions in this highly sensitive area.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: devolution; bargaining; fiscal federalism; transition economies
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D78 - Positive Analysis of Policy Formulation and Implementation; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P26 - Political Economy ; Property Rights

References

Abbink, Klaus, and Jordi Brandts (2007): “Political Autonomy and Independence: Theory and Experimental Evidence.” Mimeo

Ai, Chunrong, and Edward C. Norton (2003): “Interaction Terms in Logit and Probit Models.” Economics Letters 80:123-129

Arzaghi, Mohammad, and J. Vernon Henderson (2005): “Why Countries Are Fiscally Decentralizing.” Journal of Public Economics 89 (July):1157-89

Bahry, Donna (2005): “The New Federalism and the Paradoxes of Regional Sovereignty in Russia.” Comparative Politics 37:127-46

Becker, Jonathan (2004): Lessons from Russia: A Neo-Authoritarian Media System. European Journal of Communication 19(2):139-163

Blume, Lorenz, and Stefan Voigt (2008): Federalism and Decentralization – A Critical Survey of Frequently Used Indicators. MAGKS Working Paper No. 21

Buchanan, James M., and Roger L. Faith (1987): “Secession and the Limits of Taxation: Towards a Theory of Internal Exit.” American Economic Review 77 (December):1023-31

Chebankova, Elena (2006): “The Unintended Consequences of Gubernatorial Appointments in Russia, 2005-06.” Journal of Communist Studies and Transition Politics 22(December):457-84

CIPKR (2003): “Vybory-2003: Regional’nyi Aspekt.” Mimeo

Crosson, Rachel, Boles, Terry, and J. Keith Murnighan (2003): “Cheap Talk in Bargaining Experiments: Lying and Threats in Ultimatum Games.” Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 51 (June):143-59

Dixit, Avinash, and Thomas Romer (2006): “Political Explanations of Inefficient Economic Policies – An Overview of Some Theoretical and Empirical Literature.” Mimeo

Dowley, Kathleen M. (1998): “Striking the Federal Bargain in Russia: Comparative Regional Government Strategies.” Communist and Post-Communist Studies 31 (December):359-80

Elinder, Mikael, Jordahl, Henrik, and Panu Poutvaara (2008): “Selfish and Prospective: Theory and Evidence of Pocketbook Voting.” IZA Discussion Paper No. 3763

Enikolopov, Ruben, Zhuravskaya, Ekaterina, and Sergei Guriev (2002): “Rossiiskiy Federalism: Scenarii Razvitiya.” Mimeo

Fearon, James D. (1997): “Signalling Foreign Policy Interests”. Journal of Conflict Resolution 41(1):68-90

Fearon, James D. (1994): “Domestic Political Audience and the Escalation of International Disputes”. American Political Science Review 88(3):577-592

Feld, Lars P., Schaltegger, Christoph, and Jan Schnellenbach (2008): “On Government Centralization and Fiscal Referendums.” European Economic Review 52 (May):611-45

Feld, Lars P., and Jan Schnellenbach (2004): “Beguenstigt fiskalischer Wettbewerb die Politikinnovation und –diffusion? Theoretische Anmerkungen und erste Befunde aus Fallstudien“, in: Schaltegger, Christoph A., and Stefan Schaltegger (eds.): Perspektiven der Schweizer Wirtschaftspolitik. Zuerich: vdf

Forsythe, Robert, Kennan, John, and Barry Sopher (1991): “An Experimental Analysis of Strikes in Bargaining Games with One-Sided Private Information.” American Economic Review 81 (March):253-78

Gambetta, Diego (1991): “’In the Beginning was the Word…’ The Symbols of the Mafia.” European Journal of Sociology 32:53-77

Gel’man, Vladimir (2006): “Vozvrashenie Leviafana? Politika Recentralizatsii v Sovremennoi Rossii.” POLIS 2 (April): 90-109

Goode, J. Paul (2007): “The Puzzle of Putin’s Gubernatorial Appointments.” Europe-Asia Studies 59 (May):365-99

Hale, Henry E. (2005): “The Makeup and Breakup of Ethnofederal States: Why Russia Survives Where the USSR Fell.” Perspectives on Politics 3:55-70

Horowitz, Ruth, and Gary Schwartz (1974): “Honor, Normative Ambiguity and Gang Violence.” American Sociological Review 39 (April):238-51

Houba, Harold, and Wilko Bolt (2002): Credible Threats in Negotiations: A Game-Theoretic Approach. Heidelberg: Springer

Jarocinska, Elena (2004): “Determinants of Intergovernmental Transfers in Russia: Political Factors versus Objective Criteria.” Mimeo

Kahn, Jeffrey, Trochev, Alexei, and Nikolai Balayan (2009): “The Unification of Law in the Russian Federation.” Post-Soviet Affairs 25 (October-December):310-46

Konovalov, Aleksandr (2004): Istoriya Kemerovskoi Oblasti v Biografiyakh Partiinykh Rukovoditelei. Kemerovo: Kuzbassvuzizdat

Konovalov, Aleksandr (2006): Partiynaya Nomenklatura Sibiri v Sisteme Regional’noi Vlasti (1945-1991). Kemerovo: Kuzbasvuzizdat

Levitt, Stephen, and Sudhir Alladi Venkatesh (2000): “An Economic Analysis of a Drug-Selling Gang’s Finances.” Quarterly Journal of Economics 115 (August):755-89

Libman, Alexander (2010): “Constitutions, Regulations, and Taxes: Contradictions of Different Aspects of Decentralization.” Journal of Comparative Economics, forthcoming

Liscow, Zachary D. (2007): “Why Didn’t the North Let the South Secede? Evidence of Economic Motivations from Presidential Elections Data.” Mimeo

Malashenko, Aleksei (209): Ramzan Kadyrov: Rossiiski Politik Kavkazskoi Nacional’nosti. Moscow: Carnegie Center, ROSSPEN

Norton, Edward C., Wang, Hua, and Chunrong Ai (2004): “Computing Interaction Effects and Standard Errors in Logit and Probit Models.” Stata Journal 4(2):154-167

Obydenkova, Anastassia (2008): Democratization, Regionalization and Europeanization in Russia: Interplay of National and Transnational Factors. Saarbrücken: VDM Verlag

Panizza, Ugo (1999): “On the Determinants of Fiscal Centralization: Theory or Evidence.” Journal of Public Economics 74 (October):93-139

Petrov, Nikolai (2009): “Nasledie Imperii I Regionalism.” In Miller, Aleksei (ed.): Nasledie Imperiy I Budushee Rossii. Moscow: NLO, pp. 381-454

Polishchuk, Leonid (2001): “Legal Initiatives of Russian Regions: Determinants and Effect.” In Murrell, Peter (ed.): Assessing the Value of Law in Transition Economies. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, pp. 330-68

Popov, Vladimir (2004): “Fiscal Federalism in Russia: Rules versus Electoral Politics.” Comparative Economic Studies 46 (December):515-41

Risse, Thomas (2000): Let’s Argue! Persuasion and Deliberation in International Relations. International Organization 54 (Winter):1-39

Ross, Cameron (2003): Putin’s Federal Reforms and the Consolidation of Federalism in Russia: One Step Forward, Two Steps Back! Communist and Post-Communist Studies 36 (March): 29-47

Rozmarinsky, I. (2004): “Postkeinsinaskaya Model’ Cheloveka I Khosyastvennoe Povedenie Rossiyan v 1990-e Gody.” Ekonomicheskiy Vestnik RSU 3 (January): 62-73

Sheng, Yumin (2007): “Global Market Integration and Central Political Control: Foreign Trade and Intergovernmental Relations in China.” Comparative Political Studies 40 (May): 405-34

Solnick, Steven L. (2002): “Federalism and State-Building: Post-Communist and Post-Colonial Perspectives.” In Reynolds, Andrew (ed.): The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management, and Democracy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 171-205

Stoner-Weiss, Kathryn (2006): Resisting the State: Reform and Retrenchment in Post-Soviet Russia. Cambridge: Cambirdge University Press

Tingley, Dustin, and Barbara Walter (2008): “Can Cheap Talk Help Build Reputations? An Experimental Analysis.” Mimeo

Toft, Monica Duffy. 2003. The Geography of Ethnic Conflict: Identity, Interest, and the Indivisibility of Territory. Princeton: Princeton University Press

Treisman, Daniel S. (1996): “The Politics of Intergovernmental Transfers in Post-Soviet Russia.” British Journal of Political Science 26 (July): 299-335

Treisman, Daniel S. (1998): “Fiscal Redistribution in a Fragile Federation: Moscow and the Regions in 1994.” British Journal of Political Science 28 (January): 185-222

Treisman, Daniel S. (1999): After the Deluge: Regional Crises and Political Consolidation in Russia. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press

Treisman, Daniel S. (2002): “Defining and Measuring Decentralization: A Global Perspective.” Mimeo

Treisman, Daniel S. (2006): “Explaining Fiscal Decentralization: Geography, Colonial History, Economic Development, and Political Institutions.” Commonwealth and Comparative Politics 44 (November): 289-325

Vainberg, Anna, and Tatyana Rybnikova (2006): “Institutcional’nye i Geograficheskie Faktory Razvitiya Regionov Rossii.” Mimeo

Voronov, Vladimir (2005): “Mentologiya Dvadtsat’ Pervogo Veka.” Novoe Vremya, August 7

Walter, Barbara F. 2006. Building Reputation: Why Governments Fight Some Separatists, but Not Others. American Journal of Political Science 50(2):313-330

Young, Robert (2004): “Secession as Revolution.” Homo Oeconomicus 21 (March): 373-395

Zolotareva, M.V. (1999): Respubliki v Sostave Rossiyskoy Federacii: Nekotorye Aspekty Pravovogo Polozheniya. Moscow: MSU