Challenges for smallholder market access: a review of literature on institutional arrangements in collective marketing

Ton, Giel (2008): Challenges for smallholder market access: a review of literature on institutional arrangements in collective marketing. Published in: Stewart Postharvest Review , Vol. 5, No. 2008 (1 October 2008): pp. 1-6.

Abstract

Purpose of the review: This review presents recent research on collective action in agricultural markets, focusing on the institutional settings that increase market access for smallholder farmers. It focuses attention on challenging research areas that try to understand and resolve the inherent contradictions that exist between members in the group and between the group and others. Findings: Collective action in agricultural markets is facilitated by institutional arrangements that effectively resolve the inherent tensions within groups as well as between farmers and other economic agents. Research explores the logic of collective marketing and the impact of trust and reputation on the mediation of opportunistic action in groups. Special attention is given to institutional arrangements on the interface between vertical and horizontal coordination in food chains, especially related to strategies of producer organisations to by-pass middlemen, to meet quality requirements in modern markets and to effectively use postharvest technologies. Research points to the importance of formal and informal rules and regulations in enabling farmers’ organisations to bulk and process agricultural products. Directions for future research: Informed decision making by value chain actors on replicating or upscaling institutional arrangements to improve the performance of their value chain needs information on its social embeddedness and its relation with the legal environment. More comparative research is needed on “workable models” and “best practices” for facilitating collaborative marketing in developing countries.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: farmers’ organisations; markets; cooperatives, bulking; opportunistic behaviour; enabling policies
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D23 - Organizational Behavior ; Transaction Costs ; Property Rights; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O17 - Formal and Informal Sectors ; Shadow Economy ; Institutional Arrangements; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q13 - Agricultural Markets and Marketing ; Cooperatives ; Agribusiness

References

North DC. Institutions, institutional change and economic performance. Cambridge, UK, Cambridge University Press; 1990.

Williamson OE. The new institutional economics: taking stock, looking ahead. Journal of Economic Literature 2000;38(3):595–613.

North DC. Institutions. The Journal of Economic Perspectives 1991:5 (1):97–112.

World Bank. Building institutions for markets. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2002.

Bosc P-M, Eychenne D, Hussein K, Losch B, Mercoiret M-R, Rondot P, et al. Reaching the rural poor: the role of rural producers organisations (RPOs) in the World Bank Rural Development Strategy – background study. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2001.

Dorward A, Kydd J, Morrison J and Urey I. A Policy agenda for pro-poor agricultural growth. World Development 2004;32(1):73.

Williamson OE. The Lens of Contract: applications to economic development and reform. Maryland: IRIS-USAID; 2002. 8 Porter ME. Clusters and the new economics of competition. Harvard Business Review 1998:76(6):79–90.

de Soto H. The mystery of capital: why capitalism triumphs in the west and fails everywhere else. New York, Basic Books; 2003.

DFID. Making markets work for the poor: a framework paper. London: DFID; 2000.

World Bank. Agricultural investment sourcebook. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2004.

World Bank. Reaching the rural poor: a renewed strategy for rural development. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2003.

IFAP. Empowering smallholder farmers in markets. IFAP-ECART; 2008.

Bates RH. Markets and states in tropical Africa: the political basis of agricultural policies. California, University of California Press; 2005.

Krueger AO. Government failures in development. The Journal of Economic Perspectives 1990;4(3):9–23.

Rashid S, Cummings Jr R and Gulati A. Grain marketing parastatals in Asia: results from six case studies. World Development 2007;35 (11):1872–1888.

World Bank. World Development Report 2008: Agriculture for Development. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2007.

IAC. Realizing the promise and potential of African agriculture: science and technology strategies for improving agricultural productivity andfood security in Africa. Amsterdam: InterAcademy Council; 2004.

Gibbon P and Ponte S. Trading down: Africa, value chains, and the global economy. Philadelphia, Temple University Press; 2005.

Losch B. Global restructuring and liberalization: Côte d’Ivoire and the end of the international cocoa market? Journal of Agrarian Change 2002;2(2):206–227.

Timmer CP. The macro dimensions of food security: economic growth, equitable distribution, and food price stability. Food Policy 2000;25 (3):283–295.

Hussein K. Producer organizations and agricultural technology in West Africa: institutions that give farmers a voice. Development 2001;44 (4):61–66.

Ruben R, Slingerland M and Nijhoff H. Agro-food chains and networks for development. Springer; 2006.

Reardon T and Berdegué JA. The rapid rise of supermarkets in Latin America: challenges and opportunities for development. Development Policy Review 2002;20(4):371–388.

Vorley B, Fearne A and Ray D. Regoverning markets: a place for smallscale producers in modern agrifood chains? London, IIED - Gower Publishing Ltd; 2007.

Bernard T, de Janvry A, Collion MH, Rondot P and Sadoulet E. Do village organizations make a difference in African rural development? A study for Senegal and Burkina Faso. University of California, Berkeley, Mimeo; 2006.

Mercoiret MR, Pesche D and Bosc PM. Rural producer organizations (RPOs) for pro-poor sustainable development. Washington, World Bank Publications; 2006.

Ton G, Bijman J and Oorthuizen J. Producer organisations and market chains: facilitating trajectories of change in developing countries. Wageningen, Wageningen Academic Publishers; 2007.

Penrose-Buckley C. Producer organisations: a guide to developing collective rural enterprises. London, OXFAM; 2007.

Wennink B, Nederlof S and Heemskerk W. Access of the poor to agricultural services: the role of farmers’ organizations in social inclusion. Amsterdam, KIT - Royal Tropical Institute; 2007.

Shepherd AW. Approaches to linking producers to markets. A review of experiences to date. Agricultural Management, Marketing and Finance Occasional Paper. FAO; 2007.

Lundy M, Ostertag C and Best R. Value adding, agroenterprise and poverty reduction: a territorial approach for rural business development. Globalization of Agricultural Research conference 2002:25–27.

Hellin J, Lundy M and Meijer M. Farmer organization, collective action and market access in meso-America. Washington: CAPRI-IFPRI; 2007.

Vellema S. The local cultures of contract farming-the export of fresh asparagus from the Philippines to Japan. Cross-continental Food Chains 2005:125–137.

Berdegué JA. Cooperating to compete: associative peasant business firms in Chile. Wageningen, Wageningen University; 2001.

Flores L, Commandeur D, Ton G and Zijm G. Coaching organisational transitions towards increased market orientation: SNV’s experience with producer organisation support in the Bolivian valleys. In: Producer organisations and market chains: facilitating trajectories of change in developing countries, Ton G, Bijman J and Oorthuizen J (editors). Wageningen, Wageningen Academic Publishers; 2007.

Mansfield F. Discipline, internal motivations, and cooperation in a rural production cooperative. Environments 2005;33(1):61–80.

Olson M. The logic of collective action; The President and Fellows of Harvard College; 1965.

Platteau JP and Seki E. Heterogeneity, social esteem and feasibility of collective action. Journal of Development Economics 2007;83(2):302–325.

Murray-Prior R. The role of grower collaborative marketing groups in developing countries. Stewart Postharvest Review 2007;2007(6).

Ortmann GF and King RP. Agricultural cooperatives I: history, theory and problems. Agrekon 2007;46(1):40–68. 42 Swinnen J and Vandeplas A. Vertical coordination, rent distribution, and development: LICOS Discussion Paper 184, Leuven; 2007.

Bingen J, Serrano A and Howard J. Linking farmers to markets: different approaches to human capital development. Food Policy 2003;28(4):405–419.

Ruben R and Lerman Z. Why Nicaraguan peasants stay in agricultural production cooperatives. European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies 2005;78: 31–48.

Hendrikse G and Bijman J. Ownership structure in agrifood chains: the marketing cooperative. American Journal of Agricultural Economics 2002;84(1):104–119.

Robbins P, Bikande F, Ferris S, Kleih U, Okoboi G and Wandschneider T. Collective Marketing for smallholder farmers: the territorial approach to rural agro-enterprise development. Bogota: CIAT; 2005.

Fafchamps M. Market institutions in Sub-Saharan Africa: theory and evidence. MIT Press; 2004.

Hayami Y. Communities and markets for rural development under globalization: a perspective from villages in Asia. Keynote address at European Association of Agricultural Economists, Florence, September 2004:8–11.

Peppelenbos LC. Trading up: building cooperation between farmers and traders in Africa. Amsterdam, KIT/IIRR; 2008.

Shiferaw B, Obare G and Muricho G. Rural institutions and producer organizations in imperfect markets: experiences from producer marketing groups in semi-arid eastern Kenya. Collective Action and Property Rights (CAPRi) Working Paper; 2006.

Thorp R, Stewart F and Heyer A. When and how far is group formation a route out of chronic poverty? World Development 2005;33(6):907–920.

Pollet P and Develtere I. Development co-operation: how co-operatives cope. Leuven: HIVA-CERA-BRS; 2004.

Saul M. The organization of a West African grain market. American Anthropologist 1987;89(1):74–95.

Kurien V. India’s milk revolution investing in rural producer organizations. In: Ending poverty in South Asia: ideas that work, Narayan-Parker D (editor). Washington, World Bank; 2007.

Das TK. Between trust and control: developing confidence in partner cooperation in alliances. The Academy of Management Review 1998;23 (3):491–512.

Batt PJ and Jayamangkala N. International Symposium on Improving the Performance of Supply Chains in the Transitional Economies; Acta Horticulturae 699, ISHS; 2006. 57 Sartorius K and Kirsten J. A framework to facilitate institutional arrangements for smallholder supply in developing countries: An agribusiness perspective. Food Policy 2007;32(5–6):640–655.

Coulter J, Goodland A, Tallontire A and Stringfellow R. Marrying farmer cooperation and contract farming for service provisioning in liberalising Sub-Saharan Africa. Natural Resource Perspectives 1999(48).

Vellema S. Making contract farming work. Society and technology in Philippine transnational agribusiness. Maastricht: Shaker Publishing; 2002.

Smith LED, Stockbridge M and Lohano HR. Facilitating the provision of farm credit: the role of interlocking transactions between traders and Zamindars in crop marketing systems in Sindh. World Development 1999;27(2):403–418.

Bijman J. Essays on agricultural co-operatives: governance structures in fruit and vegetable chains. Rotterdam, ERIM – LEI; 2002.

Coulter J and Onumah G. The role of warehouse receipt systems in enhanced commodity marketing and rural livelihoods in Africa. Food Policy 2002;27(4):319–337.

von Benda-Beckmann F. Scapegoat and magic charm: law in development theory and practice. Journal of Legal Pluralism & Unofficial Law 1989;28:129.

Lyon F. Trust, networks and norms: the creation of social capital in agricultural economies in Ghana. World Development 2000;28(4):663–681.

Van der Meer K, Burcroff R, Larson D and Vijverberg W. The rural investment climate: it differs and it matters. Washington, World Bank; 2006.

Mendoza M and Ton G. Manual de procedimientos jurídicos y tributarios para organizaciones económicas campesinas. Sucre: CIOEC-SNV; 2003.

Vermeulen S, Woodhill J, Proctor F and Delnoye R. Chain-wide learning for inclusive agrifood market development: a guide to multi-stakeholder processes for linking small-scale producers with modern markets. London and Wageningen: IIED - CD&CI Wageningen UR; 2008.

Cullinan C. Law and markets: improving the legal environment for agricultural marketing. Rome, FAO; 1999. 69 Chen HT. Theory-driven evaluations: Sage Publications Inc; 1994.