Why does mutual fund performance not persist? The impact and interaction of fund flows and manager changes

Bessler, Wolfgang and Blake, David and Lückoff, Peter and Tonks, Ian (2010): Why does mutual fund performance not persist? The impact and interaction of fund flows and manager changes.

Abstract

This paper investigates the reasons for the lack of long-term persistence in the investment performance of actively managed equity mutual funds. We document that the responses of investors, fund managers, and investment management companies to past performance have an important impact on future performance. Conditioning on fund flows and manager changes allows us to predict future performance of both past outperforming (winner) and past underperforming (loser) funds. Recent winner funds, experiencing neither high inflows nor the departure of a skilled fund manager, outperform by 3.60 percentage points based on risk-adjusted returns in the following year, relative to winner funds suffering from both effects. We also find that the performance of the worst performing funds experiencing both the replacement of the fund manager (internal governance) and high outflows (external governance) enjoy a subsequent increase in performance of 2.40 percentage points in the following year, relative to loser funds not experiencing these effects. Among loser funds, in particular, both mechanisms appear to interact strongly.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Mutual Funds; Performance Persistence; Fund Flows; Manager Turnover
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G29 - Other; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation; G - Financial Economics > G3 - Corporate Finance and Governance > G32 - Financing Policy ; Financial Risk and Risk Management ; Capital and Ownership Structure ; Value of Firms ; Goodwill

References

Alexander, Gordon J., Gjergji Cici and Scott Gibson. 2007. Does Motivation Matter When Assessing Trade Performance? An Analysis of Mutual Funds. Review of Financial Studies 20:125–150.

Baks, Klaas P. 2006. On the Performance of Mutual Fund Managers. Working Paper, Emroy University.

Berk, Jonathan B. and Richard C. Green. 2004. Mutual Fund Flows and Performance in Rational Markets. Journal of Political Economy 112:1269–1295.

Berk, Jonathan B. and Ian Tonks. 2007. Return Persistence and Fund Flows in the Worst Performing Mutual Funds. Working Paper No. 13042, NBER.

Bollen, Nicolas P. B. and Jeffrey A. Busse. 2005. Short-Term Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance. Review of Financial Studies 18:569–597.

Bris, Arturo, Huseyin Gulen, Padma Kadiyala and P. Raghavendra Rau. 2007. Good Stewards, Cheap Talkers, or Family Men? The Impact of Mutual Fund Closures on Fund Managers, Flows, Fees, and Performance. Review of Financial Studies 20:953–982.

Brown, Stephen J. and William N. Goetzmann. 1995. Performance Persistence. Journal of Finance 50:679– 698.

Busse, Jeffrey A. and Paul J. Irvine. 2006. Bayesian Alphas and Mutual Fund Persistence. Journal of Finance 61:2251–2288.

Carhart, Mark M. 1997. On Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance. Journal of Finance 52:57–82.

Carhart, Mark M., Jennifer N. Carpenter, Anthony W. Lynch and David K. Musto. 2002. Mutual Fund Survivorship. Review of Financial Studies 15:1439–1463.

Carpenter, Jennifer N. and Anthony W. Lynch. 1999. Survivorship Bias and Attrition Effects in Measures of Performance Persistence. Journal of Financial Economics 54: 337–374.

Chen, Hsiu-Lang, Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Russ Wermers. 2000. The Value of Active Mutual Fund Management: An Examination of the Stockholdings and Trades of Fund Managers. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 35:343–368.

Chen, Joseph, Harrison Hong, Ming Huang and Jeffrey D. Kubik. 2004. Does Fund Size Erode Mutual Fund Performance? The Role of Liquidity and Organization. American Economic Review 94:1276–1302.

Chevalier, Judith and Glenn Ellison. 1999a. Are Some Mutual Fund Managers Better Than Others? Cross- Sectional Patterns in Behavior and Performance. Journal of Finance 54:875–899.

Chevalier, Judith and Glenn Ellison. 1999b. Career Concerns of Mutual Fund Managers. Quarterly Journal of Economics 114:389–432.

Cohen, Randolph B., Joshua D. Coval and Lubos Pastor. 2005. Judging Fund Managers by the Company They Keep. Journal of Finance 60:1057–1096.

Cooper, Michael J., Huseyin Gulen and P. Raghavendra Rau. 2005. Changing Names with Style: Mutual Fund Name Changes and Their Effects on Fund Flows. Journal of Finance 60:2825–2858.

Coval, Joshua and Erik Stafford. 2007. Asset Fire Sales (and Purchases) in Equity Markets. Journal of Financial Economics 86:479–512.

Cremers, Martijn and Antti Petajisto. 2009. How Active is Your Fund Manager? A New Measure that Predicts Performance. Review of Financial Studies 22:3329–3365.

Dahlquist, Magnus, Stefan Engström and Paul Söderlind. 2000. Performance and Characteristics of Swedish Mutual Funds. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 35:409–423.

Dangl, Thomas, Youchang Wu and Josef Zechner. 2008. Market Discipline and Internal Governance in the Mutual Fund Industry. Review of Financial Studies 21:2307–2343.

Das, Sanjiv Ranjan and Rangarajan K. Sundaram. 2002. Fee Speech: Signaling, Risk-Sharing, and the Impact of Fee Structures on Investor Welfare. Review of Financial Studies 15:1465–1497.

De Bondt, Werner F. M. and Richard Thaler. 1985. Does the Stock Market Overreact?. Journal of Finance 40:793–805.

De Bondt, Werner F. M. and Richard Thaler. 1987. Further Evidence on Investor Overreaction and Stock Market Seasonality. Journal of Finance 52:557–581.

Del Guercio, Diane and Paula A. Tkac. 2008. Star Power: The Effect of Morningstar Ratings on Mutual Fund Flow. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, forthcoming.

Ding, Bill and Russ Wermers. 2006. Mutual Fund Performance and Governance Structure: The Role of Portfolio Managers and Boards of Directors. Working paper, University of Maryland.

Edelen, Roger M. 1999. Investor Flows and the Assessed Performance of Open-End Mutual Funds. Journal of Financial Economics 53:439–466.

Elton, Edwin J., Martin J. Gruber and Christopher R. Blake. 1996a. The Persistence of Risk-Adjusted Mutual Fund Performance. Journal of Business 69:133–157.

Elton, Edwin J., Martin J. Gruber and Christopher R. Blake. 1996b. Survivorship Bias and Mutual Fund Performance. Review of Financial Studies 9:1097–1120.

Elton, Edwin J., Martin J. Gruber, Das Sanjiv and Matthew Hvlaka. 1993. Efficiency with Costly Information: A Reinterpretation of Evidence from Managed Portfolios. Review of Financial Studies 6:1–22.

Evans, Richard B. 2010. Mutual Fund Incubation. Journal of Finance, forthcoming.

Fama, Eugene F. and Kenneth R. French. 1993. Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds. Journal of Financial Economics 33:3–56.

French, Kenneth R. 2008. Presidential Address: The Cost of Active Investing. Journal of Finance 63:1537–1573.

Gallagher, David R. and Prashanthi Nadarajah. 2004. Top Management Turnover: An Analysis of Active Australian Investment Managers. Australian Journal of Management 29:243–274.

Gervais, Simon, Anthony W. Lynch and David K. Musto. 2005. Fund Families as Delegated Monitors of Money Managers. Review of Financial Studies 18:1139–1169.

Goriaev, Alexei, Theo E. Nijman and Bas J. M. Werker. 2008. Performance Information Dissemination in the Mutual Fund Industry. Journal of Financial Markets 11:144–159.

Gruber, Martin J. 1996. Another Puzzle: The Growth in Actively Managed Mutual Funds. Journal of Finance 51:783–810.

Hendricks, Darryll, Jayendu Patel and Richard Zeckhauser. 1993. Hot Hands in Mutual Funds: Short-Run Persistence of Relative Performance. 1974–1988. Journal of Finance 48:93–130.

Hu, Fan, Alastair R. Hall and Campbell R. Harvey. 2000. Promotion or Demotion? An Empirical Investigation of the Determinants of Top Mutual Fund Manager Change. Working paper, Duke University.

Huij, Joop and Marno Verbeek. 2007. Cross-Sectional Learning and Short-Run Persistence in Mutual Fund Performance. Journal of Banking and Finance 31:973–997.

Ivković, Zoran and Scott Weisbenner. 2009. Individual Investor Mutual Fund Flows. Journal of Financial Economics 92:223–237.

Karoui, Aymen and Iwan Meier. 2009. The Performance and Characteristics of Mutual Fund Starts. European Journal of Finance 15:487–509.

Keswani, Aneel and David Stolin. 2008. Which Money is Smart? Mutual Fund Buys and Sells of Individual and Institutional Investors. Journal of Finance 63:85–118.

Khorana, Ajay. 1996. Top Management Turnover: An Empirical Investigation of Fund Managers. Journal of Financial Economics 40:403–427.

Khorana, Ajay. 2001. Performance Changes Following Top Manager Turnover: Evidence from Open-End Mutual Funds. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 36:371–393.

Lunde, Asger, Allan Timmermann and David Blake. 1999. A Cox Regression Analysis. Journal of Empirical Finance 6:121–152.

Lynch, Anthony W. and David K. Musto. 2003. How Investors Interpret Past Fund Returns. Journal of Finance 58:2033–2058.

Massa, Massimo, Jonathan Reuter and Eric Zitzewitz. 2010. Why Should Firms Share Credit with Employees? Evidence from Anonymously Managed Mutual Funds. Journal of Financial Economics 95:400–424.

Nohel, Tom. Z., Jay Wang and Lu Zheng. 2010. Side-by-Side Management of Hedge Funds and Mutual Funds. Review of Financial Studies, forthcoming.

O'Neal, Edward S., 2004. Purchase and Redemption Patterns of U. S. Equity Mutual Funds. Financial Management 33:63–90.

Parrino, Robert, Richard W. Sias and Laura Starks. 2003. Voting with Their Feet: Institutional Ownership Changes Around Forced CEO Turnover. Journal of Financial Economics 68:3–46.

Pastor, Lubos and Robert F. Stambaugh. 2002. Mutual Fund Performance and Seemingly Unrelated Assets. Journal of Financial Economics 61:315–349.

Pastor, Lubos and Robert F. Stambaugh. 2003. Liquidity Risk and Expected Stock Returns. Journal of Political Economy 111:642–685.

Pollet, Joshua M. and Mungo Wilson. 2008. How Does Size Affect Mutual Fund Behavior?. Journal of Finance 63:2941–2969.

Sapp, Travis and Ashish Tiwari. 2004. Does Stock Return Momentum Explain the “Smart Money” Effect?. Journal of Finance 59:2605–2622.

Sawicki, Julian and Frank Finn. 2002. Smart Money and Small Funds. Journal of Business Finance and Accounting 29:825–846.

Shefrin, Hersh and Meir Statman. 1985. The Disposition to Sell Winners Too Early and Ride Losers Too Long: Theory and Evidence. Journal of Finance 40:777–790.

Sirri, Erik R. and Peter Tufano. 1998. Costly Search and Mutual Fund Flows. Journal of Finance 53: 1589–1622.

Tonks, Ian. 2005. Performance Persistence of Pension-Fund Managers. Journal of Business 78:1917–1942.

Wermers, Russ. 2000. Mutual Fund Performance: An Empirical Decomposition Into Stock-Picking Talent, Style, Transactions Costs, and Expenses. Journal of Finance 55:1655–1695.

Yan, Xuemin (Sterling). 2008. Liquidity, Investment Style, and the Effect of Fund Size on Fund Performance. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 43:741-768.

Zheng, Lu. 1999. Is Money Smart? A Study of Mutual Fund Investors' Fund Selection Ability. Journal of Finance 54:901-933.