Sexual orientation and social exclusion in Italy

Botti, Fabrizio and D'Ippoliti, Carlo (2012): Sexual orientation and social exclusion in Italy.

Abstract

This work explores the role of discrimination in shaping individuals’ lives and opportunities, with specific respect to sexual orientation. The role of sexual orientation in explaining earning differences has been increasingly emphasized in empirical literature on discrimination mainly as a result of the growing availability of data sources on gays and lesbian populations. Available evidence predominantly converges on the one hand on the identification of discrimination treatments for gays and positive wage differential for lesbian women with respect to heterosexual counterparts. On the other hand, disagreement pervades interpretations of the predominant above-described labour market outcome. In trying to move beyond such conflicting views, we consider a holistic approach to social exclusion, defined as individuals’ ability to fully participate to social life by examining five domains: monetary poverty, labour market attachment, housing conditions, subjective well-being, and education. Three samples of different waves of the Banca d’Italia “Survey on household income and wealth” (SHIW - 2006, 2008 and 2010) were pooled in order to perform the empirical analysis on a reasonably sized sample of heterosexual couples identified according to a cohabitation criteria. Following the SHIW characteristics and definition of household, we are able to differentiate homosexual couples belonging to a sub-population of out same-sex couples from those who are not openly out about their homosexual relationship. We develop an understanding of social exclusion as a non-dichotomous concept (that is, one is not necessarily “included” or “excluded”, but a continuum of intermediate conditions exist) through fuzzy analysis techniques and develop a synthetic index of inclusion/exclusion as well as a number of partial indexes, composed of several variables pertaining to a certain domain. Overall indicators of social exclusion are examined for the full sample and for the sub-sample of workers only, comparing individuals cohabiting in same-sex couples with heterosexual counterparts. Our results point out that a significant and non-negligible portion of the social exclusion suffered by lesbian and gay couples cannot be accounted for by observable factors and may therefore be attributed to the impact of discrimination. Coherently with the existing literature, we find a differentiated impact on gay men and lesbian couples. However, and possibly more relevantly, we also find significant differences between the couples of “out” homosexual individuals and those composed of “closeted” individuals.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Sexual orientation, social inclusion, fuzzy analysis
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J7 - Labor Discrimination > J71 - Discrimination; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D10 - General; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I32 - Measurement and Analysis of Poverty; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches > B54 - Feminist Economics

References

Alkire S. (2007), “Choosing Dimensions: The Capability Approach and Multidimensional Poverty”, Chronic Poverty Research Centre Working Paper, n. 88.

Alkire S. and Foster J. (2011), “Counting and multidimensional poverty measurement”, Journal of Public Economics, vol. 95, n. 7–8, pp. 476–487.

Allegretto S. and M.M. Arthur (2001), “An Empirical Analysis of Homosexual/Heterosexual Male Earnings Differentials: Unmarried and Unequal?, Industrial and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 54, n. 3, pp. 631-646.

Antecol H., A. Jong and M. Steinberger (2008), “The Sexual Orientation Wage Gap: The Role of Occupational Sorting and Human Capital”, Industrial and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 61, n. 4, pp. 518-543.

Arabsheibani G., A. Marin and J. Wadsworth (2005), “Gay Pay in the UK”, Economica, 72, pp. 333-347.

Badgett L. (1995), “The Wage Effects of Sexual Orientation Discrimination, Industrial and Labour Relations Review, Vol. 48, n. 4, pp. 726-739.

Barbagli M. and A. Colombo (2001), Omossessuali moderni. Gay e Lesbiche in Italia, Bologna: Il Mulino.

Barr T. (2009), “With Friends Like These”, American Journal of Economics and Sociology, Vol. 68, n. 3, pp. 703-746.

Becker G. (1991), A Treatise on the Family, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Berenger V. and Verdier-Chouchane A. (2007), “Multidimensional Measures of Well-Being: Standard of Living and Quality of Life Across Countries”, World Development, vol. 35, n. 7, pp. 1259-1276.

Berg N. and D. Lien (2002), “Measuring the Effect of Sexual Orientation on Income: Evidence of Discrimination?” Contemporary Economic Policy, Vol. 20, n. 4, pp. 394–414.

Black D., G. Gates, S. Sanders, and L. Taylor (2000), “Demographics of the Gay and Lesbian Population in the United States: Evidence from Available Systematic Data Sources”, Demography, 37(2), pp. 139-64.

Black D., H. Makar, S. Sanders, and L. Taylor (2003), “The Earning Effects of Sexual Orientation”, Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 56, n. 3, pp. 449-469.

Black D., S. Sanders, and L. Taylor (2007), “The Economics of Lesbian and Gay Families”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 21, No 2, pp. 53-70.

Blandford J.M. (2003), “The Nexus of Sexual Orientation and Gender in the Determination of Earnings”, Industrial & Labour Relations Review, Vol. 56, n. 4, pp. 622-642.

Booth A. and J. Frank (2008), “Marriage, Partnership and Sexual Orientation: a Study of British University Academics and Administrators”, Review of the Economics of the Household, Vol. 6, n. 4, pp. 409-422.

Botti F., Corsi M. and D’Ippoliti C. (2012), “The gendered nature of multidimensional poverty in the European Union”, presented at the joint URPE-IAFFE session on “Gender Disparities in Debt, Health Outcomes and Poverty” at the ASSA meeting 2012, January 6th-8th 2012, Chicago (IL).

Brandolini, A. (2008), “On applying synthetic indices of multidimensional well-being: Health and income inequalities in selected EU countries”, Temi di discussione, n. 668, Bank of Italy.

Brown C. (1998), “Sexual Orientation and Labour Economics”, Femisist Economics, Vol. 4, n. 3, pp. 89-95.

Carpenter C. (2005), “Self-Reported Sexual Orientation and Earnings: Evidence from California”, Industrial & Labour Relations Review, Vol. 58, n. 2, pp. 258-273.

Carpenter C. (2007), “Revisiting the Income Penalty for Behaviorally Gay Men: Evidence from NHANES III”, Labour Economics, Vol. 14, n. 1, pp. 25-34.

Carpenter C. (2008), “Sexual Orientation, Income, and Non-Pecuniary Economic Outcomes: New Evidence form Young Lesbians in Australia”, Review of Economics of the Households, Vol.6, pp. 391-408.

Cheli B. and Lemmi A. (1995), “A ‘Totally’ Fuzzy and Relative Approach to the Multidimensional Analysis of Poverty”, Economic Notes by Monte dei Paschi di Siena, vol. 24, n. 1, pp. 115-134.

Chiappero-Martinetti E. (2008), “Complexity and vagueness in the capability approach: strengths or weaknesses?”, in Alkire S. et al. (eds.), The capability approach: concepts, applications and measurement, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Chiappero-Martinetti E. and Roche J.M. (2009), “Operationalization of the capability approach, from theory to practice: a review of techniques and empirical applications” in Chiappero-Martinetti E. (ed.), Debating Global Society: Reach and Limits of the Capability Approach, Milan: Fondazione Feltrinelli.

Clain, S. and Leppel, K. (2001), “An Investigation into Sexual Orientation Discrimination as an Explanation for Wage Differences”, Applied Economics, Vol. 33, Issue 1, pp. 37-47.

Croteau J.M. (1996), “Research on the Work Experiences of Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual People: An In tegrative Review of Methodology and Findings”, Journal of Vocational Behaviour, Vol. 48, n. 18, pp. 195-209.

Curtarelli M., L. Incagli, and C. Tagliavia (2004), “La qualità del lavoro in Italia”, Studi e Ricerche, Isfol.

Day, N.E. (2000), “The Relationship Among Reported Disclosure of Sexual Orientation, Antidiscrimination Policies, Top Management Support and Work Attitudes of Gay and Lesbian Employees”, Personnel Review, vol. 29, n. 3, pp. 346-363.

Deutsch, J. and Silber, J. (2005), “Measuring multidimensional poverty: An empirical comparison of various approaches”, Review of Income and Wealth, vol. 51, n. 1, pp. 145–174.

Drydakis N. (2009), “Sexual Orientation Discrimination in the Labour Market”, Labour Economics, Vol. 16, pp. 364-372.

Elmslie B. and E. Tebaldi (2007), “Sexual Orientation and Labour Market Orientation”, Journal of Labour Research, Vol. 28, n. 3, pp. 436-453.

European Commission (2004), Joint Report on Social Inclusion 2004, Brussels.

Frank J. (2006), “Gay Glass Ceiling”, Economica, Vol. 73, pp. 485-508.

Goldin C. (1990), “Understanding the Gender Gap: An Economic History of American Women”, New York: Oxford University Press.

Goldsmith A. H., J. R. Veum and W. Darity (1997), “The Impact of Psychological and Human Capital on Wages”, Economic Inquiry, 35, pp. 815-829.

Griffith K.H., and M.R. Hebl (2002), “The Disclosure Dilemma for Gay Man and Lesbians: ‘Coming Out’ at Work”, Journal of Applied Psycology, Vol. 87, n. 6, pp. 1191-1199.

Heineck G. (2009), “Sexual orientation and earnings: evidence from the ISSP”, Applied Economic Letters, Vol. 16, Issue 13, pp. 1351-1354.

Herek G.M. (1988), “Heterosexuals’ attitudes toward lesbians and gay men: correlates and gender differences”, The Journal of Sex Research, Vol. 25, n. 4, pp. 451–477.

Herek G. (2008), “Hate Crimes and Stigma-Related Experiences Among Sexual Minority Adults in the US: Prevalence Estimates from a National Probability Sample”, Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 24, pp. 54-74.

King E.B., J.M. Cortina (2010), “The Social and Economic Imperative of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgendered Supportive Organizational Policies”, Industrial Organizational Psychology, Vol. 3, pp. 69-78.

Kite M.E. and B.E.Jr Whitley (1996), “Sex differences in attitudes toward homosexual persons, behaviors, and civil rights: a meta-analysis”, Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, Vol. 22, n. 4, pp. 336–353.

Klavitter M.M., and V. Flatt (1998), "The Effect of State and Local Antidiscrimination Policies on Earnings for Gays and Lesbians", Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, Vol. 17, n. 4, pp. 658-686.

Laumann E., J. Gagnon, R. Michael, and S. Michaels (1994), The Social Organization of Sexuality: Sexual Practices in the United States, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Lemmi A. and Betti G. (eds.) (2006), Fuzzy Set Approach to Multidimensional Poverty Measurement, New York: Springer.

Leppel K. (2009), “Labour Force Status and Sexual Orientation”, Economica, Vol. 76, pp. 197-207.

Mays V.M., and S.D. Cochran (2001), “Mental Health Correlates of Perceived Discrimination Among Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual Adults in the United States”, American Journal of Public Health, Vol. 91, n. 11, pp. 1869-1876.

Plug E. and P. Berkhout (2004), “Effects of Sexual Preferences on Earnings in the Netherlands”, Journal of Population Economics, Vol. 17, pp. 117-131.

Plug E. and P. Berkhout (2008), “Sexual Orientation, Disclosure and Earnings”, The Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA) Discussion Paper, n. 3290.

Qizilbash M. (2003), “Vague language and precise measurement: the case of poverty”, Journal of Economic Methodology, vol. 10, n. 1, pp. 41-58.

Qizilbash M. and Clark D. (2005), “The Capability Approach and Fuzzy Poverty Measures: An Application to the South African Context”, Journal of Social Indicators Research, vol. 74, pp. 103-129.

Ragin C. and Pennings P. (eds.) (2005), “Special issue on fuzzy sets and social research”, Sociological Methods & Research, vol. 33, n. 4.

Ragins B.R., and J.M. Cornwell (2001), “Pink Triangles: Antecedents and Consequences of Perceived Workplace Discrimination Against Gay and Lesbian Employees”, Journal of Applied Psychology, Vol. 86, n. 6, pp. 1244-1261.

Riess B. F., J. Safer and W. Yotive (1974), “Psychological test data on female homosexuality: a review of the literature”, Journal of Homosexuality, Fall, 1, 71±85.

Roche J.M. (2008), “Monitoring Inequality among Social Groups: A Methodology Combining Fuzzy Set Theory and Principal Component Analysis”, Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, vol. 9, n. 3, pp. 427 -452.

Smith G.S., and K.M. Ingram (2004), “Workplace Heterosexism and Adjustment among Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Individuale: The Role of Unsupportive Social Interactions”, Journal of Counselling Psychology, Vol. 51, n. 1, pp. 57-67.

Tebaldi E., and B. Elmslie (2006), “Sexual orientation and labor supply”, Applied Economics, Vol. 38, Issue 5, pp. 549-562.