Heterogeneity of the Maghreb: the results of optimized monetary rules

Belhadj, Aam (2009): Heterogeneity of the Maghreb: the results of optimized monetary rules. Published in: Global Business and Management Research: An International Journal , Vol. 1, No. 3 & 4 (2009): pp. 1-24.

Abstract

The launch of the euro has fed doubts concerning the constitution of an optimal European monetary zone. Indeed, the differences in legal, institutional and cultural frameworks… as well as the diversity of the productive and financial European systems may have led to the idea that Europe does not constitute a viable monetary zone. In Africa, the decision of African Central Bank governors to adopt a single currency by 2021 and the call from the union of Maghreb banks in November 2007 to create one currency for the Maghreb (Algeria, Libya, Morocco, Mauritania and Tunisia) raises the same doubts as to the efficiency of such decisions. In this preliminary work, we have tried to evaluate implicitly the pertinence of such decision by showing in a first section the heterogeneity of Maghrebian monetary regimes. We have tried to illustrate in a second section this heterogeneity via a model describing the functioning of the economy of these countries. Finally, we have attempted to show in a third section the consequences of these heterogeneities by simulating optimal monetary rules defined for each country. Our results suggest that these countries will need divergent Taylor rules and that the decision to belong to the same monetary union where a common monetary policy will be conducted proved to be unsuitable.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Monetary policy, exchange rate, heterogeneity, Taylor rule, Maghreb
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance > F40 - General; F - International Economics > F5 - International Relations, National Security, and International Political Economy > F50 - General; F - International Economics > F3 - International Finance > F30 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E58 - Central Banks and Their Policies; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E52 - Monetary Policy; F - International Economics > F4 - Macroeconomic Aspects of International Trade and Finance > F47 - Forecasting and Simulation: Models and Applications; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E40 - General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E47 - Forecasting and Simulation: Models and Applications

References

Abdallah Z. & Ilmane M-C (2007): « Central Bank independance and monetary policy inca transition economy: the case of Algeria (1990-2005) » paper presented at Eight Mediterranean Social and Political Research Meeting, Florence and montecatini terme 21-25 March 2007.

Achy L. & Sekkat K. (2000): « The European Single Currency and MENA’s Manufactured Export to Europe » Femise Research Programme, June.

Allen D. (2006): « Trade liberalization, factor market flexibility, and growth: The case of Morocco and Tunisia » World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3857, March.

Ball L. (1997): « Efficient rules for monetary policy » Johns Hopkins University, January.

Ball L. (1998): « Policy rules for open economies » Research Discussion Paper 9806.46

Bangaké C, Belhadj A & Jedlane N (2007): « Toward Maghreb Monetary Unification: What does the theory and history tell us?” African Review of Money Finance and Banking, forthcoming.

Ben Ali M-S. (2006): « Capital account liberalization and exchange rate regime choice, what scope for flexibility in Tunisia?” William Davidson Institute Working Paper Number 815, March.

Benbouziane M. & Benamar A. (2004): « The relationship between money and prices in the Maghreb Countries: A cointegration analysis » 11th Annual Conference of the Economic Research Forum (ERF), Beirut – Lebanon – December 16-28.

Bordo M.D. & Jonung L. (1999): “The future of EMU: what does the history of monetary unions tell us?” NBER Working Paper 7365.

Boughrara A. (2003): « What do we know about monetary policy and transmission mechanism in Morocco and Tunisia » 10 th annual conference of the Economic Research Forum (ERF), Marrakech-Morocco-December 18-21.

Boughzala M. & Saidane D. (2005): « Liberalization of the Banking Sector in Tunisia » in « Impact of liberalization of trade in services: Banking, Telecommunications and Maritime transport in Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia and Turkey » Femise Research Programme, December.

Boughzala M. Boughrara A. & Moussa H. (2007): « Credibility of inflation targeting in Morocco and Tunisia » paper presented at Eight Mediterranean Social and Political Research Meeting, Florence and montecatini terme 21-25 March 2007.

Bouoiyour J. Marimoutou V. et Rey S. (2004) : “Taux de change réel d’équilibre et politique de change au Maroc : une approche non paramétrique » Économie internationale n° 97 (1).

Calvo G-A. & Reinhart C-M. (2000): “Fear of Floating” Mimeo, University of Maryland, January.

Dack J-V (1999) : « Implementing monetary policy in emerging market economies: an overview of issues » Monetary policy operating procedures in emerging market economies BIS Policy Papers n°5, March.

Darrat A-F. & Pennathur A. (2002): “Are the Arab Maghreb countries really integratable? Some evidence from the theory of cointegrated systems”, Review of Financial Economics n°11.

Djelassi M. (2004): « Les conséquences des réformes financières sur les structures de financement en Tunisie » Techniques Financières et Développement n° 74, Mars.

Domat I. & Shabsigh G. (1999) : « Real exchange rate behaviour and economic growth : Evidence from Egypt, Jordan, Morocco and Tunisia » IMF Working Papers 99/40,March.

Dropsy V. & Grand N. (2004) : « Exchange rate and inflation targeting in Morocco and Tunisia » Working paper, September.

Dyer P. (2005): « Disponibilité de main-d’oeuvre, chômage et création », Banque mondiale, Table Ronde du Maghreb: Tunis, 24-25 mai.

Eichengreen B. (2002): « Lessons of the Euro for the Rest of the World » Working Paper PEIF 2, University of California, December.

Fanizza D. Laframboise N. Martin E. Sab R. & Karpowicz I. (2002): « Tunisia’s experience with real exchange rate targeting and the transition to a flexible exchange rate regime » IMF Working Papers 02/190, November. 47

Filosa R. (2001): « Monetary policy rules in some mature emerging economies » BIS Papers No 8.

Finaish M. & Bell E. (1994): « The Arab Maghreb union » IMF Working Papers 94/55, May.

Goodhart C. (1995):”The Political Economy of Monetary Union” Chap 12 in Kenen P «Understanding interdependence. The macroeconomics of the open economy ».

Haddou S. (2002): « Règles de rétro-action et réformes monétaires : quelques propos sur le cas tunisien » Mondes en Développement, Tome 30, p118 – 79.

Hallett A-H. & Weymark D-N. (2001): « The cost of heterogeneity in a monetary union » Working Paper N°01-W28, December.

Hatipoglu O. & Alper E. (2007): “Taylor rule estimation in emerging markets” paper presented at Eight Mediterranean Social and Political Research Meeting, Florence and montecatini terme 21-25 March 2007.

Ilmane M-C (2006): « Réflexions critiques sur la politique monétaire en Algérie : objectifs, instruments et résultats (2000–2004) » Cahier de CREAD, n°75/2006.

IMF (2004): « Monetary Policy Implementation at Different Stages of Market Development » October 26.

Jedlane N. (2006): « Unification monétaire et Caisses d'émission au Maghreb », Colloque IDEAL « L’intégration africaine: quelle stratégie? Pour quelle insertion dans l’économie mondiale ? » Organisé le 4 novembre à L’Université Catholique de Lille.

Kamar B. (2004) : « De facto exchange rate policies in the MENA region : toward deeper cooperation » 11th Annual Conference of the Economic Research Forum for the Arab countries, Iran and Turkey, Beirut – Lebanon– December 16-18.

Koranchelian T (2004) : The Equilibrium Real Exchange Rate in a Commodity Exporting Country : Algeria’s experience » IMF Working Paper n°135, July.

Masson P. et Pattillo C. (2004): « Une monnaie unique pour l’Afrique ? », Finance et Développement, Décembre.

Mishkin F-S. (1999) : « International experiences with different monetary policy regimes » Journal of Monetary Economics 43 p 579-605.

Mohanty M-S. & Klau M. (2001): « What determines inflation in emerging market economies? BIS Papers No 8.

Neaime S. (2007): « Monetary policy transmission and targeting mechanisms in the MENA region: An empirical investigation », paper presented at Eight Mediterranean Social and Political Research Meeting, Florence and montecatini terme 21-25 March 2007.

Nemouchi F. (2007): « Chocs pétroliers et politiques monétaires en Algérie » 11èmes Rencontres Euro-méditerranéennes “Le financement des économies des pays riverains de la Méditerranée”, Nice, 15-16 novembre.

Penot A. Pollin J-P et Seltz V (2001) : « Hétérogénéité de la zone euro et politique monétaire unique » document de recherche, LEO.

Sorsa P. (1999) : « Algeria : the real exchange rate, export diversification and trade protection » IMF Working Paper 99/49, April.

Tahari A, Brenner P, De Vrijer E, Moretti M, Senhadji A, Sensenbrenner G & Solé Juan (2007) : « Financial Sector Reforms and Prospects for Financial Integration in Maghreb Countries » IMF Working Paper 07/125, May.48

Talor J. (1993), « Discretion versus Policy Rules in Practice », Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy, vol. 39, décembre, pp. 195-214.

Taylor J. (1998a) : « The robusteness and efficiency of monetary policy rules as guidelines for interest rate setting by the European Central Bank » Institute for international economic studies, Stockholm University, August.

Taylor J. (1998b): « An Historical Analysis of Monetary Policy Rules », NBER Working Paper Series, n° 6768, octobre.

Treichel V. (1997): « Broad money demand and monetary policy in Tunisia » IMF Working Papers 97/22, March.

World Bank (2006): « Is there a new vision for Maghreb economic integration ? » Volume I: Main Report, Social and Economic Development Group Middle East and North Africa Region, November.