Tipping, firm strategy, and industrial organization

Azar, Ofer H. (2006): Tipping, firm strategy, and industrial organization.

Abstract

Tipping is a phenomenon that has been studied for many years, but is receiving increased attention in recent years. The magnitude of tips is very large – in the US, for example, tips in the food industry alone amount to about $42 billion each year, and tips are given in many other establishments and countries, so annual worldwide tips are much higher than that. Millions of workers in the US alone derive most of their income from tips and tipping is prevalent in numerous countries and occupations. These are all good reasons to study tipping, but it is clear that tipping has created much interest also because it is puzzling from a theoretical perspective. The common assumption in economics that people maximize utility (which is derived by consuming various goods) subject to a budget constraint implies that people should give up money only when they receive something in return. This is not the case, however, when people tip: service has already been provided by the time the tip is given, so the tip is a voluntary payment that does not buy something real (such as improved service) in return. The literature on tipping can be divided to two main areas. The first area can be termed "understanding tipping behavior." This includes studies that try to understand why people tip, what affects their tipping behavior, why tipping is different across countries, etc. The second research area, which started to receive attention more recently, can be defined as "tipping, firm strategy, and industrial organization." This part of the literature deals with the effect of tipping on firms and markets. For example, firms can sometimes choose between voluntary tipping and compulsory service charges – which one is better for the firm? How should the existence of tips affect optimal pricing by the firm? How should firms monitor workers and provide incentives to them when tipping exists? Why does tipping exist in some industries but not in others? Does tipping increase social welfare in industries in which it is the norm? All these questions belong to this second research area and demonstrate the close relationship of tipping to industrial organization and firm strategy. Several review articles made an attempt to summarize and synthesize the extensive literature in the area of understanding tipping behavior, but no article has offered an extensive literature review that focuses on the area of "tipping, firm strategy, and industrial organization." The purpose of this paper, therefore, is to review and summarize the literature in this area of research.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Institution: Ben-Gurion University of the Negev
• Language: English
• Keywords: tipping; firm strategy; business strategy; industrial organization; social norms; norms; restaurants; waiters; servers; the service industry; tips; gratuities; strategy
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D11 - Consumer Economics: Theory; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z13 - Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology ; Social and Economic Stratification; L - Industrial Organization > L8 - Industry Studies: Services > L83 - Sports ; Gambling ; Restaurants ; Recreation ; Tourism; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D12 - Consumer Economics: Empirical Analysis; A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A12 - Relation of Economics to Other Disciplines

References

Arrow, Kenneth J., “Political and Economic Evaluation of Social Effects and Externalities,” in M. Intriligator, ed., Frontiers of Quantitative Economics (Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1971), 5-25. Azar, Ofer H. (2003). “The Implications of Tipping for Economics and Management.” International Journal of Social Economics, 30 (10), 1084-1094. Azar, Ofer H. (2004a), "What Sustains Social Norms and How They Evolve? The Case of Tipping." Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 54 (1), 49-64. Azar, Ofer H. (2004b), “The History of Tipping – from Sixteenth-Century England to United States in the 1910s” Journal of Socio-Economics, 33 (6), 745-764. Azar, Ofer H. (2004c), “Optimal Monitoring with External Incentives: The Case of Tipping.” Southern Economic Journal, 71 (1), 170-181. Azar, Ofer H. (2005a), “The Social Norm of Tipping: Does it Improve Social Welfare?” Journal of Economics, 85 (2), 141-173. Azar, Ofer H. (2005b), “Who Do We Tip and Why? An Empirical Investigation." Applied Economics, 37 (16), 1871-1879. Azar, Ofer H. (2006), "Tipping Motivations and Behavior in the US and Israel: Results of an Experimental Survey." Working paper, Ben-Gurion University of the Negev. Azar, Ofer H. (2007a), "Do People Tip Strategically, to Improve Future Service? Theory and Evidence," Canadian Journal of Economics, 40(2), 515-527. Azar, Ofer H. (2007b), “Why Pay Extra? Tipping and the Importance of Social Norms and Feelings in Economic Theory.” Journal of Socio-Economics, 36 (2), 250-265. Azar, Ofer H. (2007c), “The Social Norm of Tipping: A Review.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 37 (2), 380-402. Azar, Ofer H. (2007d), "Incentives and Service Quality in the Restaurant Industry: The Tipping – Service Puzzle," Applied Economics, forthcoming. Azar, Ofer H. and Yossi Tobol (2008), "Tipping as a Strategic Investment in Service Quality: An Optimal-Control Analysis of Repeated Interactions in the Service Industry," Southern Economic Journal, forthcoming. Barkan, Rachel, Ido Erev, Einat Zinger and Mayan Tzach (2004), “Tip Policy, Visibility and Quality of Service in Cafes,” Tourism Economics, 10 (4), 449-462. Barkan, Rachel and Aviad Israeli (2004), “Testing Servers’ Roles as Experts and Managers of Tipping Behaviour,” Service Industries Journal, 24 (6), 91-108. Ben-Zion, Uri and Edi Karni (1977), "Tip Payments and the Quality of Service," in O.C. Ashenfelter & W.E. Oates (Eds.), Essays in Labor Market Analysis, New York: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 37- 44. Bodvarsson, Orn (2005), “Restaurant Tips and Service Quality: A Reply to Lynn.” Applied Economics Letters, 12 (6), 345-346. Bodvarsson, Orn and William Gibson (1994), “Gratuities and Customer Appraisal of Service: Evidence from Minnesota Restaurants,” Journal of Socio-Economics, 23(3), 287-302. Bodvarsson, Orn and William Gibson (1997), “Economics and Restaurant Gratuities: Determining Tip Rates,” American Journal of Economics and Sociology, 56(2), 187-203. Bodvarsson, Orn and William Gibson (1999), "An Economic Approach to Tips and Service Quality: Results of a Survey," The Social Science Journal, 36(1), 137-147. Bodvarsson, Orn B., William A. Luksetich and Sherry McDermott (2003), “Why do Diners Tip: Rule of Thumb or valuation of Service?,” Applied Economics, 35, 1659-1665. Conlin, Michael, Michael Lynn and Ted O'Donoghue (2003), "The Norm of Restaurant Tipping," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 52, 297-321. Crusco, April H. and Christopher G. Wetzel (1984), “The Midas Touch: The Effects of Interpersonal Touch on Restaurant Tipping,” Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 10 (December), 512-517. Elster, Jon, “Social Norms and Economic Theory,” Journal of Economic Perspectives 3 (Fall 1989), 99-117. Hemenway, David (1993), Prices & choices: microeconomic vignettes, 3rd Ed. Lanham, MD: University Press of America. Hornik, Jacob (1992), “Tactile Stimulation and Consumer Response,” Journal of Consumer Research, 19 (December), 449-458. Israeli, Aviad and Rachel Barkan (2004), “Developing a Framework for Rewards in Combined Production/Service Businesses: The Case of Tipping in the Restaurant Industry,” International Journal of Service Industry Management, 15 (5), 444-459. Jacob, Nancy and Alfred Page (1980), “Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization: The Buyer Monitoring Case,” American Economic Review, 70 (June), 476-478. Lynn, Michael (1994), “Neuroticism and the Prevalence of Tipping: A Cross-Country Study,” Personality and Individual Differences, 17(1), 137-138. Lynn, Michael (1997), “Tipping Customs and Status Seeking: A Cross-Country Study,” International Journal of Hospitality Management, 16(2), 221-224. Lynn, Michael (2000a), "National Personality and Tipping Customs," Personality and Individual Differences, 28, 395-404. Lynn, Michael (2000b), "National Character and Tipping Customs: The Needs for Achievement, Affiliation, and Power as Predictors of the Prevalence of Tipping," International Journal of Hospitality Management, 19, 205-210. Lynn, Michael (2001), “Restaurant Tipping and Service Quality: A Tenuous Relationship,” Cornell H.R.A. Quarterly, (January), 14-20. Lynn, Michael (2004), “Restaurant Tips and Service Quality: A Commentary on Bodvarsson, Luksetich and McDermott (2003)," Applied Economics Letters, 11, 975-978. Lynn, Michael (2006), “Tipping in restaurants and Around the Globe: An Interdisciplinary Review.” Ch. 31, pp. 626-643. In Morris Altman (Ed.) Handbook of Contemporary Behavioral Economics: Foundations and Developments, M.E. Sharpe Publishers. Lynn, Michael and Andrea Grassman (1990), “Restaurant Tipping: An Examination of Three ‘Rational Explanations’,” Journal of Economic Psychology, 11 (June), 169-181. Lynn, Michael and Kirby Mynier (1993), “Effect of Server Posture on Restaurant Tipping,” Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 23(8), 678-685. Lynn, Michael, George M. Zinkhan and Judy Harris (1993), “Consumer Tipping: A Cross-Country Study,” Journal of Consumer Research, 20 (December), 478-485. Lynn, Michael, Joseph-Mykal Le, and David S. Sherwyn (1998), “Reach Out and Touch Your Customers,” Cornell H.R.A. Quarterly, 39 (June), 60-65. Lynn, Michael and Michael McCall (2000a), "Gratitude and Gratuity: A Meta-Analysis of Research on the Service-Tipping Relationship," Journal of Socio-Economics, 29, 203-214. Lynn, Michael and Michael McCall (2000b), "Beyond Gratitude and Gratuity: A Meta-Analytic Review of the Predictors of Restaurant Tipping," working paper, School of Hotel Administration, Cornell University. Lynn, Michael and Tony Simons (2000), “Predictors of Male and Female Servers’ Average Tip Earnings,” Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 30, 241-252. Parrett, Matthew B. (2003), “The Give and Take on Restaurant Tipping,” Unpublished doctoral dissertation in Economics, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA. Post, Peggy (1997), Emily Post’s Etiquette, 16th Edition. New York: HarperCollins. Rogelberg, Steven G., Robert Ployhart, William Balzer and Robert Yonker (1999), "Using Policy Capturing to Examine Tipping Decisions," Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 29(12), 2567-2590. Ruffle, Bradley J. (1998), "More Is Better, But Fair Is Fair: Tipping in Dictator and Ultimatum Games," Games and Economic Behavior, 23, 247-265. Ruffle, Bradley J. (1999), "Gift Giving with Emotions," Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 39, 399-420. Schein, John E., Edwin F. Jablonski and Barbara R. Wohlfahrt (1984), The Art of Tipping: Customs and Controvesies, Wausau, WI: Tippers International. Schwartz, Zvi (1997), "The Economics of Tipping: Tips, Profits and the Market's Demand-Supply Equilibrium," Tourism Economics, 3(3), 265-279. Schwer, R. Keith and Rennae Daneshvary (2000), "Tipping Participation and Expenditures in Beauty Salons," Applied Economics, 32, 2023-2031. Sisk, David and Edward Gallick (1985), "Tips and Commissions: A Study in Economic Contracting," Working Paper No. 125, Bureau of Economics, Federal Trade Commission, Washington, DC. Star, Nancy (1988), The International Guide to Tipping, New York: Berkley Books. Stephen, Renee and Richard L. Zweigenhaft (1986), “The Effect on Tipping of a Waitress Touching Male and Female Customers,” Journal of Social Psychology, 126 (February), 141-142. U.S. Census Bureau (2006), Statistical Abstract of the United States, 2006 Edition. Available online at http://www.census.gov/prod/www/statistical-abstract.html. Wessels, Walter John (1997), "Minimum Wages and Tipped Servers," Economic Inquiry, 35, 334-349. Woodhead, Robert (2000), “Tipping – A Method for Optimizing Compensation for Intellectual Property,” Unpublished paper at <http:/tipping.selfpromotion.com/>.