Selling Substitute Goods to Loss-Averse Consumers: Limited Availability, Bargains and Rip-offs

Rosato, Antonio (2013): Selling Substitute Goods to Loss-Averse Consumers: Limited Availability, Bargains and Rip-offs.

Abstract

Why are some sale items subject to limited availability while other substitute items are available in large quantities and are priced relatively high at the same point in time? Can such a retail strategy lure consumers into purchasing the more expensive item? This paper characterizes the profit-maximizing pricing and product-availability strategies for a retailer selling two substitute goods to loss-averse consumers and shows that limited-availability sales can manipulate consumers into an ex-ante unfavorable purchase. Consumers have unit demand, are interested in buying only one good, and their reference point is given by their recent rational expectations about what consumption value they would receive and what price they would pay. The seller maximizes profits by raising the consumers' reference point through a tempting discount on a good available only in limited supply (the bargain) and cashing in with a high price on the other good (the rip-off), which the consumers buy if the bargain is not available to minimize their disappointment. The seller might prefer to offer a deal on the more valuable product, using it as a bait, because consumers feel a larger loss, in terms of forgone consumption, if this item is not available. I also show that the bargain item can be a loss leader, that the seller's product line is not welfare-maximizing and that she might supply a socially wasteful product. The model suggests that the current FTC Guides Against Bait Advertising, by allowing retailers to employ limited-availability sales, could reduce consumer and social welfare.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Retail Pricing; Reference-Dependent Preferences; Loss Aversion; Limited Availability; Bait and Switch; Loss Leaders.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D11 - Consumer Economics: Theory; D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D42 - Monopoly; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L11 - Production, Pricing, and Market Structure ; Size Distribution of Firms

References

Abeler, J., A. Falk, L. Goette and D. Huffman (2011), "Reference Points and Effort Provision" American Economic Review, 101(2), 470-492.

Aguirregabiria, V. (2005), "Retail Stockouts and Manufacturer Brand Competition" Mimeo.

Ambrus, A. and J. Weinstein (2008), "Price Dispersion and Loss Leaders" Theoretical Economics, 3(4), 525-537.

Anderson, E., G.J., Fitzsimons, and D. Simester (2006), "Measuring and Mitigating the Cost of Stockouts" Management Science, 52(11), 1751-1763.

Anderson, E., E. Nakamura, D. Simester and J. Steinsson (2012), "Temporary Sales: On Autopilot and Funded by Frequent Flyer Accounts" Mimeo.

Anupindi, R., M. Dada and S. Gupta (1998), "Estimation of Consumers Demand with Stock-Out Based Substitution: An Application to Vending Machine Products" Marketing Science, 17 (4) 406-423.

Aperjis, C. and F. Balestrieri (2010), "Loss Aversion Leading to Advantageous Selection" Mimeo.

Balachander, S. and P.H. Farquhar (1994), "Gaining More by Stocking Less: A Competitive Analysis of Product Availability" Marketing Science, 13 (1) 3-22.

Balestrieri, F. and J. Leao (2011), "The Market for Surprises: Selling Substitute Goods through Lotteries" Mimeo.

Baye, M.R., J. Morgan and P. Scholten (2006) "Information, Search, and Price Dispersion," Chapter 6 in Handbook in Economics and Information Systems Volume 1 (T. Hendershott, Ed.), Amsterdam: Elsevier.

Bell, D. (1985), "Disappointment in Decision Making under Uncertainty" Operations Research, 33(1), 1-27.

Bils, M. (2004), "Studying Price Markups from Stockout Behavior" Mimeo.

Breugelmans, E., K. Campo and P. Nisol (2006), "Opportunities for Active Stock-Out Management in Online Stores: The Impact of the Stock-Out Policy on Online Stock-Out Reactions" Journal of Retailing, 82(3), 215-228.

Campo, K., E. Gijsbrechts and P. Nisol (2000), "Towards Understanding Consumer Response to Stock-Outs" Journal of Retailing, 76(2), 219-242.

Campo, K., E. Gijsbrechts and P. Nisol (2003), "The Impact of Retailer Stockouts on Whether, How Much and What to Buy" International Journal of Research in Marketing, 20(3), 273-286.

Carbajal, J.C. and J. Ely (2012), "Optimal Contracts for Loss Averse Consumers" Mimeo.

Chakravarty, A.K and S. Ghose (1994), "Strategic Underproduction with Product Switching" Computers and Operations Research, 21(1), 39-56.

Chen, Z. and P. Rey (2012), "Loss Leading as an Exploitative Practice" American Economic Review, 102(7), 3462-3482.

Chevalier, J.A., A.K. Kashyap and P.E. Rossi (2003), "Why Don't Prices Rise During Periods of Peak Demand? Evidence from Scanner Data" American Economic Review, 93(1), 15-37. Conlon, C.T. and J.H. Mortimer (2011), "Effects of Product Availability: Experimental Evidence" Mimeo.

Crawford, V. and J.J. Meng (2011), "New York City Cab Drivers' Labor Supply Revisited: Reference-Dependent Preferences with Rational-Expectations Targets for Hours and Income" American Economic Review, 101(5), 1912-1932.

Daido, K. and T. Murooka (2012), "Team Incentives and Reference-Dependent Preferences" Mimeo.

Dana, J.D., Jr. (1999), "Equilibrium Price Dispersion under Demand Uncertainty: The Roles of Costly Capacity and Market Structure" Rand Journal of Economics, 30(4), 632-660.

Dana, J.D., Jr. (2001a), "Monopoly Price Dispersion under Demand Uncertainty" International Economic Review, 42(3), 649-670.

Dana, J.D., Jr. (2001b), "Competition in Price and Availability when Availability is Unobservable" Rand Journal of Economics, 32(4), 497-513.

Daughety, A.F. and J.F. Reinganum (1991), "Endogenous Availability in Search Equilibrium" Rand Journal of Economics, 22(2), 287-306.

DeGraba, P. (1995), "Buying Frenzies and Seller-Induced Excess Demand" Rand Journal of Economics, 26(2), 331-342.

DeGraba, P. (2006), "The Loss Leader is a Turkey: Targeted Discounts from Multi-Product Competitors" International Journal of Infustrial Organization, 24(3), 613-628.

DellaVigna, S. and U. Malmendier (2004), "Contract Design and Self-Control: Theory and Evidence" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 119(2), 353-402.

Deneckere, R. and P. McAfee (1996), "Damaged Goods" Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 5(2), 149-174.

Deneckere, R. and J. Peck (1995), "Competition over Price and Service Rate when Demand is Stochastic: A Strategic Analysis" Rand Journal of Economics, 26(1), 148-162.

Eisenhuth, R. (2012), "Reference Dependent Mechanism Design" Mimeo.

Eisenhuth, R. and M. Ewers (2012), "Auctions with Loss Averse Bidders" Mimeo.

Eliaz, K. and R. Spiegler (2006), "Contracting with Diversely Naïve Agents" Review of Economic Studies, 73(3), 689-714.

Eliaz, K. and R. Spiegler (2008), "Consumer Optimism and Price Discrimination" Theoretical Economics, 3(4), 459-497.

Eliaz, K. and R. Spiegler (2011a), "On the Strategic Use of Attention Grabbers" Theoretical Economics, 6(1), 127-155.

Eliaz, K. and R. Spiegler (2011b), "Consideration Sets and Competitive Marketing" Review of Economic Studies, 78 (1), 235-262.

Eliaz, K. and R. Spiegler (2012), "Reference Dependence and Labor-Market Fluctuations" Mimeo.

Ellison, G. (2005), "A Model of Add-on Pricing" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 120(2), 585-637.

Emmelhainz, M.A., J.R. Stock and L.W. Emmelhainz (1991), "Consumer Responses to Retail Stock-outs" Journal of Retailing, 67(2), 139-147.

Ericson Marzilli, K.M. and A. Fuster (2011), "Expectations as Endowments: Evidence on Reference-Dependent Preferences from Exchange and Valuation Experiments" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 126(4), 1879-1907.

Fay, S. and J. Xie (2008), "Probabilistic Goods: A Creative Way of Selling Products and Services" Marketing Science, 27(4), 674-690.

Fitzsimons, G.J. (2000), "Consumer Response to Stockouts" Journal of Consumer Research, 27(2), 249-266.

Gabaix, X. and D. Laibson (2006), "Shrouded Attributes, Consumer Myopia, and Information Suppression in Competitive Markets" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121(2), 505-540.

Gerstner, E. and J. Hess (1990), "Can Bait and Switch Benefit Consumers?" Marketing Science, 9(2), 114-124.

Gilbert, R. and P. Klemperer (2000), "An Equilibrium Theory of Rationing" Rand Journal of Economics, 31(1), 1-21.

Gill, D. and V. Prowse (2012), "A Structural Analysis of Disappointment Aversion in a Real Effort Competition" American Economic Review, 102(1), 469-503.

Grant-Worley, J., N.C. Saltford and C. Zick (1982), "Unavailability of Advertised Products in Selected Non-Food Stores" Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economcis, 6(3), 237-249.

Gruen, T., D. Corsten and S. Braradwaj (2002), "Retail Out of Stocks: A Worldwide Examination of Causes, Rates and Consumer Responses" Grocery Manufacturers of America, Washington, D.C.

Grubb, M. (2009), "Selling to Overconfident Consumers" American Economic Review, 99(5), 1770-1807.

Gul, F. (1991) "A Theory of Disappointment Aversion" Econometrica, 59(3), 667-686.

Hahn, J., J. Kim, S. Kim and J. Lee (2012), "Screening Loss Averse Consumers" Mimeo.

Heffetz, O. and J. List (2011), "Is the Endowment Effect a Reference Effect?" NBER Working Paper No. w16715.

Heidhues, P. and B. Kőszegi (2008), "Competition and Price Variation when Consumers are Loss Averse" American Economic Review, 98(4), 1245-1268.

Heidhues, P. and B. Kőszegi (forthcoming), "Regular Prices and Sales" Theoretical Economics.

Heidhues, P., B. Kőszegi and T. Murooka (2012), "Inferior Products and Profitable Deception" Mimeo.

Herweg, F. and K. Mierendorff (forthcoming), "Uncertain Demand, Consumer Loss Aversion, and Flat-Rate Tariffs" Journal of the European Economic Association.

Herweg, F., D. Müller and P. Weinschenk (2010), "Binary Payment Schemes: Moral Hazard and Loss Aversion" American Economic Review, 100(5), 2451-2477.

Hess, J. and E. Gerstenr (1987), "Loss Leader Pricing and Rain Check Policy" Marketing Science, 6 (4), 358-374.

Hosken, D. and D. Reiffen (2004a), "Patterns of Retail Price Variation" Rand Journal of Economics, 35 (1), 128-146.

Hosken, D. and D. Reiffen (2004b), "How Retailers Determine which Products Should Go on Sale" Journal of Consumer Policy, 27 (2), 141-177.

Jing, X. and M. Lewis (2011), "Stockouts in Online Retailing" Journal of Marketing Research, 48 (2), 342-354.

Kahneman, D. and A. Tversky (1979), "Prospect Theory: An Analysis of Decision under Risk" Econometrica, 47 (2), 263-291.

Kahneman, D., J.L. Knetsch and R. Thaler (1990), "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem" Journal of Political Economy, 98(6), 1325-1348.

Kahneman, D., J.L. Knetsch and R. Thaler (1991), "Anomalies: The Endowment Effect, Loss Aversion, and Status Quo Bias" Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5(1), 193-206.

Kamenica, E. (2008), "Contextual Inference in Markets: On the Informational Content of Product Lines" American Economic Review, 98(5), 2127-2149.

Karle, H. (2012), "Creating Attachment through Advertising: Loss Aversion and Pre--Purchase Information" Mimeo.

Karle, H.,and M. Peitz (2012), "Competition under Consumer Loss Aversion" Mimeo.

Karle, H., G. Kirchsteiger and M. Peitz (2012), "Loss Aversion and Consumption Choice: Theory and Experimental Evidence" Mimeo.

Katz, B.G. and J. Nelson (1990), "Product Availability as a Strategic Variable: The Implications of Regulating Retailer Stockouts" Journal of Regulatory Economics, 2(4), 379-395.

Kim, M. and S.J. Lennon (2011), "Consumer Response to Online Apparel Stockouts" Psychology and Marketing, 28(2), 115-144.

Klemperer, P. and A.J. Padilla (1997), "Do Firms' Product Lines Include too Many Varieties?" Rand Journal of Economics, 28 (3), 472-488.

Konishi, H. and M. Sandfort (2002), "Expanding Demand through Price Advertisement" International Journal of Industrial Organization, 20(7), 965-994.

Kőszegi, B. (2010), "Utility from Anticipation and Personal Equilibrium" Economic Theory, 44(3), 415-444.

Kőszegi, B. and M. Rabin (2006), "A Model of Reference-Dependent Preferences" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 121(4), 1133-1165.

Kőszegi, B. and M. Rabin (2007), "Reference-Dependent Risk Attitudes" American Economic Review, 97(4), 1047-1073.

Kőszegi, B. and M. Rabin (2009), "Reference-Dependent Consumption Plans" American Economic Review, 99(3), 909-936.

Lal, R. and C. Matutes (1994), "Retail Pricing and Advertising Strategies" Journal of Business, 67 (3), 345-370.

Lange, A. and A. Ratan (2010), "Multi-dimensional Reference-dependent Preferences in Sealed-bid auctions: How (most) Laboratory Experiments Differ from the Field" Games and Economic Behavior, 68 (2), 634-645.

Lazear, E. (1986), "Retail Pricing and Clearance Sales" American Economic Review, 76(1), 14-32.

Lazear, E. (1995), "Bait and Switch" Journal of Political Economy, 103(4), 813-830.

Loomes, G. and R. Sudgen (1986), "Disappointment and Dynamic Consistency in Choice under Uncertainty" Review of Economic Studies, 53 (2), 271-282.

Macera, R. (2012), "Intertemporal Incentives Under Loss Aversion" Mimeo.

Nakamura, E. (2008), "Pass-Through in Retail and Wholesale" American Economic Review P&P, 98(2), 430-437.

Nakamura, E. and J. Steinsson (2008), "Five Facts about Prices: Reevaluation of Menu Cost Models" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 123 (4), 1415-1464.

Nocke, V. and M. Peitz (2007), "A Theory of Clearance Sales" Economic Journal, 117 (7), 964-990.

Novemsky, N. and D. Kahneman (2005), "The Boundaries of Loss Aversion" Journal of Marketing Research, 42 (2), 119-128.

Ozcan, T. (2008), "Involuntary Switching Behavior in Restricted Decision Environments: Consumer Responses to Stockouts" PhD Dissertation, University of Rhode Island. Pashigian, P.B. (1988), "Demand Uncertainty and Sales: A Study of Fashion and Markdown Pricing" American Economic Review, 78(5), 936-953.

Pashigian, P.B and B. Bowen (1991), "Why are Products Sold on Sales? Explanations of Pricing Regularities" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106 (4), 1015-1038.

Pavlov, G. (2011), "Optimal Mechanism for Selling Two Goods" B.E. Journal of Theoretical Economics, 11(1).

Rhodes, A. (2011), "Multiproduct Retailing" Mimeo.

Rubinstein, A. and R. Spiegler (2008), "Money Pumps in the Market" Journal of the European Economic Association, 6(1), 237-253.

Salop, S. and J. Stiglitz (1977), "Bargains and Ripoffs: A Model of Monopolistically Competitive Price Dispersion" Review of Economic Studies, 44 (3), 493-510.

Song, C. (2012), "An Experiment on Reference Points and Expectations" Mimeo.

Spiegler, R. (2006), "Competition over Agents with Boundedly Rational Expectations" Theoretical Economics, 1(2), 207-231.

Spiegler, R. (2011), Bounded Rationality and Industrial Organization, Oxford University Press, New York.

Spiegler, R. (2012a), "Monopoly Pricing when Consumers are Antagonized by Unexpected Price Increases: A "Cover Version"of the Heidhues-Kőszegi-Rabin Model" Economic Theory, 51 (3), 695-711.

Spiegler, R. (2012b), "Incentivizing Participation under Reference-Dependent Preferences: A Note" Mimeo.

Sprenger, C. (2011), "An Endowment Effect for Risk: Experimental Tests of Stochastic Reference Points" Mimeo.

Strausz, R. (2007), "Regulating Availability with Demand Uncertainty" German Economic Review, 8(2), 107-121.

Taylor, J.C. and S.E. Fawcett (2001), "Retail On-Shelf Performance of Advertised Items: An Assessment of Supply Chain Effectiveness at the Point of Purchase" Journal of Business Logistics, 22 (1), 73-89.

Tversky, A. and D. Kahneman (1991), "Loss Aversion in Riskless Choice: A Reference-Dependent Model" Quarterly Journal of Economics, 106 (4), 1039-1061.

Thanassoulis, J. (2004), "Haggling over Substitutes" Journal of Economic Theory, 117(2), 217-245.

Varian, H. (1980), "A Model of Sales" American Economic Review, 70(4), 651-659.

Verbeke, W., P. Farris and R. Thurik (1998), "Consumer Response to the Preferred Brand Out-of-Stock Situation" European Journal of Marketing, 32(11), 1008-1028.

Watson, R. (2009), "Search and Availability in Monopolistic Competition" Mimeo.

Zhou, J. (2011), "Reference Dependence and Market Competition" Journal of Economics and Management Strategy, 20(4), 1073-1097.

Zhou, J. (2012), "Multiproduct Search" Mimeo.

Zinn, W. and P.C. Liu (2001), "Consumer Response to Retail Stockouts" Journal of Business Logistics, 22 (1), 49-71.