Taking Uncertainty Seriously: Simplicity versus Complexity in Financial Regulation

Aikman, David and Galesic, Mirta and Gigerenzer, Gerd and Kapadia, Sujit and Katsikopolous, Konstantinos and Kothiyal, Amit and Murphy, Emma and Neumann, Tobias (2014): Taking Uncertainty Seriously: Simplicity versus Complexity in Financial Regulation. Published in: Financial Stability Paper No. 28 (2 May 2014)

Abstract

Distinguishing between risk and uncertainty, this paper draws on the psychological literature on heuristics to consider whether and when simpler approaches may out-perform more complex methods for modelling and regulating the financial system. We find that: (i) simple methods can sometimes dominate more complex modelling approaches for calculating banks’ capital requirements, especially if limited data are available for estimating models or the underlying risks are characterised by fat-tailed distributions; (ii) simple indicators often outperformed more complex metrics in predicting individual bank failure during the global financial crisis; (iii) when combining information from different indicators to predict bank failure, “fast-and-frugal” decision trees can perform comparably to standard, but more information-intensive, regression techniques, while being simpler and easier to communicate.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Bank regulation; financial regulation; uncertainty; simplicity; heuristics; Basel 2; risk modelling
• Subjects: A - General Economics and Teaching > A1 - General Economics > A12 - Relation of Economics to Other Disciplines; G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

Aikman, D, Barrett, P, Kapadia, S, King, M, Proudman, J, Taylor, T, de Weymarn, I and Yates, T (2011), Uncertainty in macroeconomic policy-making: art or science? Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A, vol. 369, no. 1956, pages 4798-4817.

Aikman, D, Haldane, A and Kapadia, S (2013), Operationalising a macroprudential regime: goals, tools and open issues, Banco de España Financial Stability Review, 24, 9-30.

Anderson, R. and May, R. (1991). Infectious diseases of humans: dynamics and control. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.

Arjani, N and Paulin, G (2013), ‘Lessons from the financial crisis: bank performance and regulatory reform’, Bank of Canada Discussion Paper, 2013-4.

Arrow, K. J. and Debreu, G. (1954). Existence of an equilibrium for a competitive economy. Econometrica 22: 265–290.

Bailey, A (2012), ‘The challenges in assessing capital requirements for banks’, speech given at the Bank of America Merrill Lynch conference, London, 6 November.

Bank of England and Financial Services Authority (2012), ‘The PRA’s approach to banking supervision’, PRA approach documents, October.

Bank of England (2014), ‘The Financial Policy Committee’s powers to supplement capital requirements: a Policy Statement’, January.

Benartzi, S. and Thaler, R.(2001), ‘Naive diversification strategies in defined contribution saving plans’, American Economic Review, American Economic Association, 91(1), 79-98.

Bikhchandani, S, Hirshleifer, D and Welch, I (1992), ‘A theory of fads, fashion, custom, and cultural change as informational cascades’, Journal of Political Economy, 100(5), pages 992-1,026.

Black, F. and Scholes, M. (1973). The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities. Journal of Political Economy 81 (3): 637–654.

BCBS (2000), Credit ratings and complementary sources of credit quality information, Basel Committee on Banking Supervision Working Papers, No. 3.

BCBS (2005), ‘An Explanatory Note on the Basel II IRB Risk Weight Functions’, July.

BCBS (2006), ‘Basel II: International Convergence of Capital Measurement and Capital Standards: A Revised Framework – Comprehensive Version’, June.

BCBS (2010), ‘Calibrating regulatory minimum capital requirements and capital buffers: a top-down approach’, October.

BCBS (2013), ‘The liquidity coverage ratio and liquidity risk monitoring tools’, January.

BCBS (2014), ‘Basel III: The Net Stable Funding Ratio: Consultative Document’, January.

Bologna, P (2011), ‘Is there a role for funding in explaining recent US banks’ failures? IMF Working Paper, 11/180.

Bower, B. (2011), Simple heresy: Rules of thumb challenge complex financial analyses. Science News, 179, 26–29.

Brighton, H. and Gigerenzer, G. (2012). How heuristics handle uncertainty. In P. M. Todd, G. Gigerenzer and the ABC Research Group, Ecological rationality: Intelligence in The World (pp. 33-60). New York: Oxford University Press.

Caballero, R.J. and Pindyck, R.S. (1996), ‘Uncertainty, Investment, and Industry Evolution’, NBER Working Paper No. w4160.

Caccioloi, F. Marsili, M., and Vivo, P. (2009), ‘Eroding market stability by proliferation of financial instruments’, European Physical Journal B, 71, 467-479.

Camerer C. (1999). Behavioral economics: Reunifying psychology and economics. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 96, 10575-7.

Carney, M (2012), ‘Some current issues in financial reform’, remarks at the Canadian Club of Montréal, Montréal, 8 November.

Czerlinski, J., Gigerenzer, G. and Goldstein, D.G. (1999). How good are simple heuristics? In Gigerenzer, G, Todd, P M and the ABC Research Group, Simple heuristics that make us smart (pp. 97-118). New York: Oxford University Press.

Derman, E. and Wilmott, P. (2009), The Financial Modelers' Manifesto, Wilmot.com.

DeMiguel, V., Garlappi, L. and Uppal, R. (2007). Optimal versus naïve diversification: How inefficient is the 1/N portfolio strategy? Review of Financial Studies, 22, 1915-1953.

Finansinspektionen (2013), Risk weight floor for Swedish mortgages. See http://www.fi.se/upload/90_English/20_Publications/20_Miscellanous/2013/riskviktsgolv-svenska-bolan-12-11920-21maj2014-eng.pdf.

Friedman, B M (2010), ‘Is our financial system serving us well?’ Daedalus, 139(4), pages 9-21.

Gai, P., Haldane, A.G. and Kapadia, S. (2011), Complexity, concentration and contagion, Journal of Monetary Economics, Vol. 58, Issue 5, pages 453-470.

Gai, P. and Kapadia, S. (2010), Contagion in Financial Networks, Proceedings of the Royal Society A, vol. 466, no. 2120, pages 2401-2423.

Geman, S., Bienenstock, E. and Doursat, E. (1992). Neural networks and the bias/variance dilemma. Neural Computation, 4, 1-58.

Giese, J., Nelson, B., Tanaka, M., Tarashev, N. (2013), How could macroprudential policy affect financial system resilience and credit? Lessons from the literature, Financial Stability Paper No 21, Bank of England.

Gigerenzer, G. and Selten, R. (Eds.) (2001). Bounded Rationality: The Adaptive Toolbox. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Gigerenzer, G. and Brighton, H. (2009). Homo heuristicus: Why biased minds make better inferences. Topics in Cognitive Science, 1, 107-143.

Gigerenzer, G., Hertwig, R. and Pachur, T. (Eds.) (2011). Heuristics: The Foundations of Adaptive Behavior. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Goodhart, C (1975), Problems of monetary management: the U.K. experience, Papers in Monetary Economics, Reserve Bank of Australia.

Green, L.A. and Mehr, D.R. (1997). What alters physicians’ decisions to admit to the coronary care unit? Journal of Family Practice, 45, 219-226.

Haldane, A. G. and Madouros, V. (2012), The Dog and the Frisbee, Speech given at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City’s 36th Economic Policy Symposium, Jackson Hole, 31 August.

Hansen, M.H., Hurwitz, W.N. and Madow, W.G. (1953). Sample Survey Methods and Theory. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Hansen, L.P. and Sargent, T.J. (2007), Robustness, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

International Monetary Fund (2009): Global Financial Stability Report. Chapter 3: Detecting Systemic Risk.

International Monetary Fund (2011): Global Financial Stability Report. Chapter 2: How to Address the Systemic Part of Liquidity Risk.

Kahneman D. and Tversky A. (1979). Prospect theory: An analysis of decision under risk. Econometrica, 47, 263-291.

Kahneman, D. 2011. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Kapadia, S., Katsikopoulos, K. and Kothiyal, A. (2014), TBA

Katsikopoulos, K. V. (2011). Psychological heuristics for making inferences: Definition, performance, and the emerging theory and practice, Decision Analysis, 8, 10-29.

Katsikopoulos, K. V., Schooler, L. J., and Hertwig, R. (2010). The robust beauty of mediocre information. Psychological Review, 117, 1259-1266.

Knight, F. H. (1921). Risk, Uncertainty and Profit. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

Laeven, L. and Valencia, F. (2010), ‘Resolution of Banking Crises: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly’, IMF Working Paper, 10/146.

Luan, S., Schooler, L. J. and Gigerenzer, G. (2011). A signal-detection analysis of fast-and-frugal trees. Psychological Review, 118, 316-338.

Lucas, R (1976), Econometric Policy Evaluation: A Critique, in Brunner, K.; Meltzer, A., The Phillips Curve and Labor Markets, Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy 1, New York: American Elsevier, pp. 19–46,

Makridakis, S. and Hibon, M. (1979). Accuracy of forecasting: an empirical investigation (with discussion). Journal of the Royal Statistical Society A 142, 97-145.

Makridakis, S. and Hibon, M. (2000) The M3-competition: results, conclusions and implications. International Journal of Forecasting, 16, 451-476.

Mandelbrot, B.B. and Hudson, R.L. (2004). The (Mis)Behavior of Markets: A Fractal View of Risk, Ruin, and Reward. New York: Basic Books.

Markowitz, H. M. (1952), Portfolio Selection, Journal of Finance, 7 (1), pp 77-91.

Martignon, L., Katsikopoulos, K. V. and Woike, J. K. (2008). Categorization with limited resources: A family of simple heuristics. Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 52, 352-361.

Martignon, L. and Hoffrage, U. (2002). Fast, frugal, and fit: Simple heuristics for paired comparison. Theory and Decision, 52, 29-71.

May, R. and Arinaminpathy, N. (2010) . Systemic risk: the dynamics of model banking systems. Journal of the Royal Society Interface 46, 823–838.

Merton, R. C. (1969), Lifetime Portfolio Selection under Uncertainty: The Continuous-Time Case, Review of Economics and Statistics, 51 (3), August, pp 247-57.

Moody’s Investors Service (2012), Corporate default and recovery rates, 1920-2011.

Mugford, S. T., Mallon, E. B. and Franks, N. R. (2001). The accuracy of Buffon’s needle: A rule of thumb used by ants to estimate area. Behavioral Ecology, 12, 655-658.

Norges Bank (2012). Financial Stability Report, November.

Petrie, M. and Halliday, T. (1994). Experimental and natural changes in the peacock’s (Pavo cristatus) train can affect mating success. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 35, 213-217.

Rabin M. (1998). Psychology and economics. Journal of Economic Literature, 36, 11-46.

Ratnovski, L and Huang, R (2009), Why are Canadian banks more resilient? IMF Working Paper, WP/09/152.

Simon, H. A. (1955). A behavioral model of rational choice. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 69, 99-118.

Subbarao, D (2011), ‘India and the global financial crisis: what have we learnt?’, speech given at the South Asia Research Centre of the Australian National University, Canberra, 23 June.

Taguchi, G and Clausing, D (1990), ‘Robust quality’, Harvard Business Review, 68(1), 65-75.

Taleb, N. (2007). The Black Swan: The Impact of the Highly Improbable. New York: Random House.

Tarullo, D.K. (2008), Banking on Basel: The Future of International Financial Regulation. Washington D.C: Peterson Institute for International Economics.

Tucker, P (2012), Competition, the pressure for returns, and stability. Speech given at the British Bankers’ Association Annual Banking Conference, London, 17 October.

Vazquez, F, and Federico, P. (2012), ‘Bank Funding Structures and Risk: Evidence from the Global Financial Crisis’. IMF Working Paper, 12/29.

Wübben, M. and Wangenheim, F. v. (2008). Instant customer base analysis: Managerial heuristics often ‘‘get it right.’’ Journal of Marketing, 72, 82-93.