Scarcity Climate Rents in Emissions Permit Markets with Oligopoly Competition

André, Francisco J. and de Castro, Luis Miguel (2015): Scarcity Climate Rents in Emissions Permit Markets with Oligopoly Competition.

Abstract

Prior research has shown, firstly, that firms subjected to a cap-and-trade system can enjoy scarcity rents and, secondly, that they can manipulate the price of permits as a rent seeking behaviour. We analyse these issues using a duopoly model under Cournot and Stackelberg competition. We identify the different sources of scarcity rents and determine under which conditions they can generate incentives for the firms to lobby the permit price up. We show that, under reasonable assumptions, Stackelberg competition eliminates incentives to collude if ther is no grandfathering. However, such incentives appear if there is an initial free allocation of permits, which is a policy argument against grandfathering. This effect is increasing with the amount of permits allocated to the leader and those parameter changes that undermine the leader’s advantage in output production or reduce the leader’s abatement cost.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Emissions permits, Collusion, Market power, Duopoly, Stackelberg model
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D4 - Market Structure, Pricing, and Design > D43 - Oligopoly and Other Forms of Market Imperfection; L - Industrial Organization > L1 - Market Structure, Firm Strategy, and Market Performance > L13 - Oligopoly and Other Imperfect Markets; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q5 - Environmental Economics > Q58 - Government Policy

References

Alvarez, F. and André, F.J. (2014) “Auctioning vs. Grandfathering in Cap-and-Trade Systems with Market Power and Incomplete Information”, Environmental and Resource Economics, In press. DOI 10.1007/s10640-014-9839-z.

André, F.J., González, P. and Porteiro, N. (2009) “Strategic quality competition and the Porter Hypothesis”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 57: 182-194.

Ehrhart, K.M, Hoppe, C. and Löschel, R. (2008) “Abuse of EU Emissions Trading for Tacit Collusion”, Environmental and Resource Economics 41: 347-361.

Ellerman, A.D., Convery, F.J. and de Perthuis, C. (2010) “Pricing Carbon: the European Emissions Trading Scheme. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Ellerman, A. D., and Joskow, P. L. (2008) “The European Union's Emissions Trading System in Perspective”. Arlington, VA: Pew Center on Global Climate Change.

Fullerton, D. and Metcalf, G.E. (2001) “Environmental controls, scarcity rents, and pre-existing distortions”, Journal of Public Economics 80: 249-267.

Hahn, R. (1984) “Market Power and Transferable Property Rights”, Quarterly Journal of Economics 99: 753–765.

Hintermann, B. (2011) “Market Power, Permit Allocation and Efficiency in Emission Permit Markets”, Environmental and Resource Economics 49: 327-349.

Hintermann, B. (2015) “Market Power in Emission Permit Markets: Theory and Evidence from the EU ETS”, Environmental and Resource Economics. Published on line 07 July 2015. DOI 10.1007/s10640-015-9939-4.

Kalkuhl, M. and Brecha, R.J. (2013) "The Carbon Rent Economics of Climate Policy", Energy Economics 39: 89-99. MacKenzie, I.A. and Ohndorf, M. (2012) "Cap-and-trade, Taxes and Distributional Conflict", Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 63: 51-65.

Misiolek, W. and Elder, H. (1989) “Exclusionary manipulation of markets for pollution rights”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 16: 156–66.

Mohr, R.D. and Saha, S. (2008) “Distribution of Environmental Costs and Benefits, Additional Distortions, and the Porter Hypothesis, Land Economics 84: 689-700.

Newell, R. G., Pizer, W.A. and Raimi, D. (2013) “Carbon Markets 15 Years after Kyoto: Lessons Learned, New Challenges”, The Journal of Economic Perspectives 27: 123-146.

Sartzetakis, E.S. (1997) “Tradeable Emission Permits Regulations in the Presence of Imperfectly Competitive Product Markets: Welfare Implications”, Environmental and Resource Economics 9: 65-81.

Sartzetakis, E.S. (2004) “On the Efficiency of Competitive Markets for Emission Permits”, Environmental and Resource Economics 27: 1-19.

Sijm, J., Neuhoff, K., & Chen, Y. (2006) “CO2 cost pass-through and windfall profits in the power sector” Climate policy 6: 49-72.

Stavins, R.N. (1998) “What Can We Learn from the Grand Policy Experiment: Positive and Normative Lessons from the SO2 Allowance Trading”, Journal of Economic Perspectives 12: 69-88.

Von der Fehr, N.H. (1993) “Tradeable emissions rights and strategic interaction”. Environmental and Resource Economics 3: 129–151.