Microfinance and Moneylenders: Long-run Effects of MFIs on Informal Credit Market in Bangladesh

Berg, Claudia and Emran, Shahe and Shilpi, Forhad (2016): Microfinance and Moneylenders: Long-run Effects of MFIs on Informal Credit Market in Bangladesh.

Abstract

Using two surveys from Bangladesh, this paper provides evidence on the effects of microfinance competition on village moneylender interest rates and households’ dependence on informal credit. The views among practitioners diverge sharply: proponents claim that MFI competition reduces both the moneylender interest rate and households’ reliance on informal credit, while critics argue the opposite. Taking advantage of recent econometric approaches that address selection on unobservables without imposing standard exclusion restrictions, we find that the MFI competition does not reduce moneylender interest rates, thus partially repudiating the proponents. The effects are heterogeneous; there is no perceptible effect at low levels of MFI coverage, but when MFI coverage is high enough, the moneylender interest rate increases significantly. In contrast, households’ dependence on informal credit tends to go down after becoming MFI member, which contradicts part of the critic’s argument. The evidence is consistent with a model where either MFIs or moneylenders engage in cream skimming, and fixed costs are important in informal lending.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Microfinance, Moneylenders, Microcredit, Interest Rates, Informal Borrowing, Long-run Effects, Bangladesh, Identification through Heteroskedasticity
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C3 - Multiple or Simultaneous Equation Models ; Multiple Variables; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O12 - Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O17 - Formal and Informal Sectors ; Shadow Economy ; Institutional Arrangements

References

Abadie, A. and G. Imbens (2002) “Simple and Bias-Corrected Matching Estimators for Average Treatment Effects,” Technical Working Paper T0283, NBER.

Aleem, I (1993) “Imperfect Information, Screening, and the Costs of Informal Lending: A Study of a Rural Credit Market in Pakistan” in The Economics of Rural Organizations: Theory, Practice, and Policy, edited by Karla Hoff, Avishay Braverman, and Joseph E. Stiglitz , Oxford University Press.

Alexander-Tedeschi, G. and D. Karlan (2009), “Cross-sectional Impact Analysis: Bias from Drop-Outs”, FAI, Yale University.

Armendáriz, B., and J. Morduch (2010) The Economics of Microfinance, Second Edition, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

Altonji, J. T. Elder, and C. Taber (2005) “An Evaluation of Instrumental Variable Strategies for Estimating the Effects of Catholic Schooling,” The Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 40, No. 4 (Autumn, 2005), pp. 791-821.

Banerjee, A. (2003), “Contracting Constraints, Credit Markets, and Economic Development”, Chapter in Advances in Economics and Econometrics: Theory and Applications, Eighth World Congress, Volume III Edited by Mathias Dewatripont, Lars Peter Hansen and Stephen J. Turnovsky.

Banerjee, A. (2013) “Microcredit Under the Microscope: What Have We Learned in the Past Two Decades, and What Do We Need to Know?” Annual Review of Economics, 5, pp. 487–519.

Bell, Clive (1990) “Interactions between Institutional and Informal Credit Agencies in Rural India” The World Bank Economic Review, vol. 4, No. 3: pp. 297-327

Berg, Claudia and M. Shahe Emran (2015), “Does Microfinance Help the Ultrapoor Cope with Seasonal Shocks? Evidence from Seasonal Famine (Monga) in Bangladesh”, working paper, George Washington University.

Black, D., and J. Smith. (2004), How robust is the evidence on the effects of college quality? Evidence from matching. Journal of Econometrics.

Blundell, R. and Monica Costa Dias (2009), “Alternative Approaches to Evaluation in Empirical Microeconomics”, Journal of Human Resources, Summer 2009, Vol. 44, No.3.

Busso, M., J. DiNardo, and J. McCrary (2014) “New Evidence on the Finite Sample Properties of Propensity Score Reweighting and Matching Estimators,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 96(5), pp. 885-897

Chowdhury, S, M.S. Emran, D. Mallick, F. Shilpi (2015), “The Long-term Effects of Microfinance on Household Outcomes, in Bangladesh: Evidence from Multiple Panel Data Sets,” Working Paper, World Bank.

Ebbes, Peter, Michel Wedel, Ulf Böckenholt (2009) “Frugal IV alternatives to Identify the Parameter for an Endogenous Regressor”, Journal of Applied Econometrics, 24: pp. 446–468

Emran, M. Shahe and Zaoyang Hou (2013), “Access to Markets and Rural Poverty: Evidence from Household Consumption in China”, Review of Economics and Statistics, May, 2013.

Emran, M. Shahe and Forhad Shilpi (2012) “The Extent of the Market and Stages of Agricultural Specialization” Canadian Journal of Economics, August, 2012.

Emran, M. Shahe and Yan Sun (2011) “Magical Transition? Intergenerational Educational and Occupational Mobility in Rural China: 1988-2002”, working paper, GWU and IFPRI.

Emran, M. Shahe, Virginia Robano, and Stephen C. Smith (2014) “Assessing the Frontiers of Ultra-Poverty Reduction: Evidence from CFPR/TUP I, an Innovative Program in Bangladesh,” Economic Development and Cultural Change, vol. 62, no. 2, January 2014, pp 339-380.

Farré, Lídia, Roger Klein, and Francis Vella (2013) “A parametric control function approach to estimating the returns to schooling in the absence of exclusion restrictions: an application to the NLSY”, Empirical Economics, 43 (1), 2013.

Farre, Lidia, Roger Klein and Francis Vella (2012), “Does Increasing Parents' Schooling Raise the Schooling of the Next Generation? Evidence based on Conditional Second Moments”, Oxford Bulletins of Economics and Statistics, (2012), vol 74(5), p.p. 676-690

Ghosh, Parikshit, Dilip Mookherjee, and Debraj Ray (1999) “Credit Rationing in Developing Countries: An Overview of the Theory”, in D. Mookherjee and D. Ray Ed. Readings in Development Economics.

Hartarska, V., Shen, X., and R. Mersland, (2013), “Scale Economies and Elasticities of Substitution in Microfinance Institutions,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 37(1): 118-131.

Harvey, A. C. “Estimating Regression Models with Multiplicative Heteroscedasticity,” Econometrica, Vol. 44, No. 3 (May, 1976), pp. 461-465.

Heckman, James, H. Ichimura, and P. Todd (1998), “Matching as an Econometric Evaluations Estimator”, Review of Economic Studies, vol. 65, No. 2.

Heckman, James and Salvador Navarro-Lozano (2004) “Using Matching, Instrumental Variables, and Control Functions to Estimate Economic Choice Models,” The Review of Economics and Statistics, 86(1), pp. 30-57.

Hirano, K. and G. Imbens (2001) “Estimation of Causal Effects using Propensity Score Matching: An Application to Data on Right Heart Catheterization,” Health Services and Outcome Research Methodology, vol. 2, pp. 259-278.

Hoff, K, A. Braverman, and J. E. Stiglitz, eds. (1993), The Economics of Rural Organization: Theory, Practice, and Policy. New York: Oxford University Press.

Hoff, Karla and Joseph E. Stiglitz (1998) “Moneylenders and Bankers: Price-Increasing Subsidies in a Monopolistically Competitive Markets” Journal of Development Economics 55: 485-518.

Jain, Sanjay and Ghazala Mansuri (2003) “A little at a time: the use of regularly scheduled repayments in microfinance programs,” Journal of Development Economics, vol. 72(1), pages 253-279.

Kanbur, Ravi, (1979). "Impatience, Information and Risk Taking in a General Equilibrium Model of Occupational Choice," Review of Economic Studies, Wiley Blackwell, vol. 46(4), pages 707-18, October.

Karlan, D. and J. Morduch (2010), “Access to Finance”, Chapter in Handbook of Development Economics, Vol. 5, Edited by Dani Rodrik and Mark Rosenzweig.

Kihlstrom, R.E. and J-J. Laffont (1979) “A General Equilibrium Entrepreneurial Theory of Firm Formalization Based on Risk Aversion,” The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 87, No. 4 (Aug., 1979), pp. 719-748.

Klein, Roger and Francis Vella (2010) “Estimating a Class of Triangular Simultaneous Equations Models Without Exclusion Restrictions” Journal of Econometrics, 154, 154-164

Klein, Roger and Francis Vella (2009a) “A Semiparametric Model for Binary Response and Continuous Outcomes under Index Heterocedasticity” Journal of Applied Econometrics, 24: 735-762

Klein, Roger and Francis Vella (2009b) “Estimating the Returns to Endogenous Schooling Decisions via Conditional Second Moments” Journal of Human Resources, 44(4), pp. 1047-1065

Lechner, M. R. Miquel, and C. Wunch (2011) “Long-Run Effects of Public Sector Sponsored Training in West Germany,” Journal of the European Economic Association, 9, pp. 742-784.

Lewbel, Arthur (2012) “Using Heteroskedasticity to Identify and Estimate Mismeasured and Endogenous Regressor Models”, Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 30, 67-80.

Mallick, Debdulal, 2012. "Microfinance and Moneylender Interest Rate: Evidence from Bangladesh," World Development, Elsevier, vol. 40(6), pages 1181-1189.

Mallick, Debdulal and Nabin, Munirul, (2010). “Where NGOs Go and Do Not Go?,” MPRA Paper 27185, University Library of Munich, Germany.

Matin, Imran, et al. (2008), “Crafting a Graduation Pathway for the ultra-poor: Lessons and Evidence from a BRAC Programme”, RED Working Paper, BRAC.

Matin, Imran (1998), “Mis-Targeting by the Grameen Bank: A Possible Explanation”, IDS Bulletin, Volume 29 Issue 4, Pages 51 – 58.

Maurer, J, Roger Klein and Francis Vella, (2011). "Subjective Health Assessments and Active Labor Market Participation of Older Men: Evidence from a Semiparametric Binary Choice Model with Nonadditive Correlated Individual-specific Effects," The Review of Economics and Statistics, MIT Press, vol. 93(3), pages 764-774, August.

McIntosh, C. and B. Wydick (2005) “Competition and Microfinance,” Journal of Development Economics 78, December 2005, pp. 271-298.

McKinnon, Roland (1973) Money and Capital in Economic Development, Washington, D.C.: Brookings Institution.

Mersland, Roy and R. Øystein Strøm (2010) “Microfinance Mission Drift?” World Development, Elsevier, vol. 38(1), pages 28-36.

Millimet, Daniel L. and Rusty Tchernis (2013) “Estimation of Treatment Effects without an Exclusion Restriction: with an Application to the Analysis of the School Breakfast Program”, Journal of Applied Econometrics, Vol. 28 (6), pp. 982-1017

Mookherjee, Dilip and Alberto Motta (forthcoming) “A Theory of Interactions Between Microfinance and Informal Lenders,” Journal of Development Economics.

Rabbani, Mehnaz, Vivek A. Prakash, and Munshi Sulaiman, (2006) “Impact Assessment of CFPR/TUP: A Descriptive Analysis Based on 2002-2005 Panel Data”, BRAC TUP Working Paper No. 12, July 2006.

Rahman, R. I., (2003), “Future Challenges Facing the MFIs of Bangladesh: Choice of Target Groups, Loan Sizes and Rate of Interest”, Working Paper, BIDS, Bangladesh.

Rigobon, Roberto (2003) “Identification Through Heteroskedasticity”, The Review of Economics and Statistics, 85(4): 777-792.

Robinson, Marguerite S. (2001) The Microfinance Revolution: Sustainable Finance for the Poor, World Bank, Washington, DC

Salim, M (2011), “Revealed Objective Functions of Microfinance Institutions: Evidence from Bangladesh”, University of Virginia.

Schroeder, Elizabeth (2014), “The Impact of Microcredit Borrowing on Household Consumption in Bangladesh”, Working Paper, Georgetown University.

Schultz, Theodore W, (1975). "The Value of the Ability to Deal with Disequilibria," Journal of Economic Literature, American Economic Association, vol. 13(3), pages 827-46, September.

Siamwalla, A, Chirmsak P, Mipon, P , Ploenpit S, Prayong, N, Wanrak, M, and Yuavares, T. (1993), “The Thai Rural Credit System and Elements of a Theory: Public Subsidies, Private Information, and Segmented Markets.” In K. Hoff, A. Braverman, and J. E. Stiglitz, eds., The Economics of Rural Organization: Theory, Practice, and Policy. Oxford University Press.

Sinha, S. and I, Matin (1998) “Informal credit transactions of micro-credit borrowers in rural Bangladesh”, IDS Bulletin, Vol - 29, Issue - 4, October - 1998

Von Pischke, J.D., Dale W.Adams, and Gordon Donald, eds. (1983) Rural Financial Markets in Developing Countries: Their Use and Abuse. Baltimore, Md.: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

Zaman, Hassan (2004) “The Scaling-Up of Microfinance in Bangladesh: Determinants, Impact, and Lessons,” Policy Research Working Paper, The World Bank.

Zeller, M, Sharma, Ahmed, and Rashid (2001) “Group-Based Financial Institutions for the Rural Poor in Bangladesh: An Institutional and Household-Level Analysis” IFPRI Research Report.