How to Measure the Local Economic Impact of Universities? Methodological Overview

Kotosz, Balázs and Lukovics, Miklós and Molnár, Gabriella and Zuti, Bence (2016): How to Measure the Local Economic Impact of Universities? Methodological Overview. Published in: Regional Statistics , Vol. 2, No. 5 (February 2016): pp. 3-19.

Abstract

Today, the realization that certain economic units, such as universities or other large tertiary educational institutions have an impact on the economy of their region has gained prominence. There is a growing demand for precise studies on the economic impact of such entities, and the issue has attracted considerable attention in the scientific community. The examination of their economic impact is especially interesting when we compare regions with different levels of development, characterized by a successful international university. The different methods used in the literature render comparisons difficult; therefore, our focus is to recommend a method for investigating universities in different countries. In the absence of regional input-output matrices, a multiplier based approach is suggested for the first and second mission (education and research), while the application of a set of indicators is recommended for the third mission (knowledge transfer-related). There are several substantial problems in assessing the economic impact of universities. First, the definition of impact; second, measuring and estimating first-round expenditures and avoiding double-counting; third, estimating the model parameters (e.g. multipliers); fourth, the quantification of third mission activities. In this paper, we clarify theoretical definitions, resolve some contradictions, and consequently, recommend a feasible method considering the circumstances in Hungary.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: impact study, university, Hungary
• Subjects: O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O18 - Urban, Rural, Regional, and Transportation Analysis ; Housing ; Infrastructure; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P25 - Urban, Rural, and Regional Economics; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R10 - General

References

ALLGURN, M. (2010): The Economic Impact of the South Dakota Public University System Government Research Bureau, The University of South Dakota, Vermilion, South Dakota, USA.

ARMSTRONG, H. W.–DARRALL, J.–GROVE-WHITE, R. (1994): Building Lancaster’s future: economic and environmental implications of Lancaster University’s expansion to 2001 Department of Economics and the Centre for the Study of Environmental Change, Lancaster University, Bailrigg UK.

ARMSTRONG, H. W.–TAYLOR, J. (2000): Regional Economics and Policy Blackwell, Oxford.

ARTHUR, W. B. (1990): Positive Feedbacks in the Economy Scientific American 262 (2): 92–99.

BAJMÓCY, Z. (2011): Bevezetés a helyi gazdaságfejlesztésbe JATEPress, Szeged.

BASLÉ, M.–LE BOULCH, J-L. (1999) L’impact économique de l’enseignement supérieur et de la recherche publique sur une agglomération de Rennes Revue d’Economie Régionale & Urbaine 1: 115–134.

BLACKWELL, M.–COBB, S.–WEINBERG, D. (2002): The Economic Impact of Educational Institutions: Issues and Methodology Economic Development Quarterly 16 (1): 88–95.

BLEANEY, M. F. – BINKS, M. R. – GREENAWAY, D. – REED, G. – WHYNES, D. K. (1992): What does a university add to its local economy? Applied Economics 24 (3): 305–311.

BLAIR, J. P.–CAROLL, M.C. (2009): Local Economic Development. Analysis, Practices and Globalization SAGE, London.

BRYDEN, J. M. (2010): Local Development In: Hart, K.–Laville, J-L.–Cattani, A. D. (eds): The Human Economy pp. 248–260., Polity, Cambridge.

CAFFREY, J.–ISAACS, H. H. (1971): Estimating the impact of a College or University on the Local Economy American Council on Education, Washington, DC.

D’ALLEGRO, M.–PAFF, L. A. (2010): Estimating the Economic Impact of Higher Education: A Case Study of the Five Colleges in Berks County, Pennsylvania Professional File 117: 1–17.

DUSEK, T. (2003): A felsőoktatás lokális termelésre és jövedelmekre gyakorolt hatása In: Rechnitzer, J.–Hardi, T. A Széchenyi István Egyetem hatása a régió fejlődésére pp. 60–71., Széchenyi István Egyetem Gazdaság- és Társadalomtudományi Intézet, Győr.

DUSEK, T.–LUKOVICS, M. (2011): Analysis of the economic impact of the Budapest Airport on the local economy 58th Annual North American Meetings of the Regional Science Association International (RSAI). Miami, Florida, USA.

ELLIOT, D.–LEVIN, S.–MEISEL, J. (1988): Measuring the economic impact of institutions of higher education Research in Higher Education 28 (1): 17–33.

GAGNOL, L.–HÉRAUD, J-A. (2001): Impact économique régional d’un pôle universitaire: application au cas strasbourgeois Revue d’Economie Régionale & Urbaine 4: 581–604.

GARRIDO-ISERTE, R.–GALLO-RIVERA, M. T. (2010): The impact of the university upon local economy: three methods to estimate demand-side effects Annals of Regional Science 44: 39–67.

HARSÁNYI, G.–VINCZE, S. (2012). A magyar felsőoktatás néhány jellemzője nemzetközi tükörben Pénzügyi Szemle 57 (2): 226–245.

HUGGINS, R.–COOK, P. (1997): The economic impact of Cardiff University: innovation, learning and job generation Geojournal 41 (4): 325–337.

IFT (2012): Szegedi Tudományegyetem Intézményfejlesztési Terv Szegedi Tudományegyetem, Szeged.

JAEGER, A.–KOPPER, J. (2013): Measuring the Regional “Third-Mission-Potential” of Different Types of HEIs Niederrhine Institute for Regional and Structural Research (NIERS). Hochschule Niederrhein - University of Applied Sciences, Mönchengladbach, Germany.

JOHNSON, T. M. (1994): Estimating the Economic Impact of a College or University on a Nonlocal Economy. PhD dissertation, Texas: Texas Tech University.

KLOPHAUS, R. (2008): The impact of additional passengers on airport employment: The case of German airports Airport Management 2 (3): 265–274.

KOLLÁR, K. (2011): A helyi gazdaságfejlesztés szereplőinek vizsgálata In: Róbert, P. (szerk): Magyarország társadalmi-gazdasági helyzete a 21. század első évtizedeiben. http://kgk.sze.hu/images/dokumentumok/kautzkiadvany2011/kreativgondolkodas/KollarKatalin.pdf (downloaded: 01/03/2016)

KOTOSZ, B. (2013a): The Local Economic Impact of Higher Education Institutions in Hungary. In: Khavand, K. J. (ed): Intellectual Capital Management. Global Perspectives on Higher Education, Science and Technology pp. 45–60., IICM, Zanjan.

KOTOSZ, B. (2013b): Regionális multiplikáció és egy alkalmazása Jelenkori társadalmi és gazdasági folyamatok 8 (1-2): 39–45.

KOTOSZ, B. (2014): L’impact économique local des universités: le cas de la Hongrie Paper presented at Métropolisation, cohésion et performances: quels futurs pour nos territoires – 51ème colloque de l’ASRDLF, Marne-la-Vallée (France), 7-9 juillet 2014.

LAREDO, P. (2007): Toward a third mission for Universities UNESCO Research Seminar for the Regional Scientific Committee for Europe and North Amerika, 5-6 March 2007, Paris.

LENGYEL, I. (2009): Knowledge-based local economic development for enhancing competitiveness in lagging areas of Europe: the case of the University of Szeged: In: Varga, A. (ed): Universities, Knowledge Transfer and Regional Development pp. 321–349., Edward Elgar, Cheltentam.

LENGYEL, I.–RECHNITZER, J. (2004): Regionális gazdaságtan Dialóg-Campus Kiadó, Budapest- Pécs.

LENGYEL, I.–SZAKÁLNÉ KANÓ I. (2012): Competitiveness of Hungarian Urban Micro-regions: Localization Agglomeration Economies and Regional Competitiveness Function. Regional Statistics 2 (1): 27–44.

LUKOVICS, M. (2010): Az egyetemek lehetséges szerepe a régiók versenyképességének javításában Kézirat, SZTE GTK, Szeged.

LUKOVICS, M.–DUSEK T. (2014a): Economic Impact Analysis of the ELI R&D Infrastructure and Science Park Journal Mittelforum and Next Europe 1 (1): 72–85.

LUKOVICS, M.–DUSEK, T. (2014b): The Economic Impact of the ELI R&D Infrastructure and Science Park in the Szeged sub-region Diverse Regions: Building Resilient Communities and Territories. Regional Studies Association Annual International Conference 2014, Izmir, Turkey.

LUKOVICS, M.–ZUTI, B. (2013): Successful universities towards the improvement of regional competitiveness: “Fourth Generation” universities Paper presented at the “European Regional Science Association (ERSA) 53th Congress „Regional Integration: Europe, the Mediterranean and the World economy” 53th Congress of the European Regional Science Association, Palermo, Italy.

LUKOVICS M.–ZUTI B. (2014): Egyetemek a régiók versenyképességének javításáért: „negyedik generációs” egyetemek? Tér és Társadalom 28 (4): 77–96.

MEZEI, C. (2006): A helyi gazdaságfejlesztés fogalmi meghatározása Tér és Társadalom 20 (4): 85–96.

MOLAS-GALLART – CASTRO-MARTÍNEZ (2007): Ambiguity and conflict in the development of ‘Third Mission’ indicators. Research Evaluation, 16(4): 321–330.

MOLAS-GALLART, J.–SALTER, A.–PATEL, P.–SCOTT, A.–DURAN, X. (2002): Measuring Third Stream Activities SPRU, University of Sussex, Brighton.

MOLNÁR, G. (2015): Egyetemek gazdaságfejlesztési hatásainak számszerűsítése: a harmadik misszió mérési lehetőségei Szakdolgozat, Szegedi Tudományegyetem, Szeged.

MOLNÁR, G.–ZUTI, B. (2015): Egyetemek gazdaságfejlesztési hatásainak mérése XXXII. OTDK április 10-12. Budapesti Gazdasági Főiskola KKK, Budapest.

NEMES NAGY, J. (2009): Terek, helyek, régiók Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest.

OECD (2004): On the Edge: Securing a Sustainable Future for the Higher Education Paris.

PALSSON, M. – GÖRANSSON, B. – BRUNDENIUS, C. (2009): Vitalizing the Swedish university system: implementation of the ‘third mission’ Science and Public Policy 36 (2): 145–150.

PÁLNÉ KOVÁCS, I. (2003): A területfejlesztés irányítása PTE KTK Regionális Politika és Gazdaságtan Doktori Iskola Habilitációs Előadások sorozata. PTE KTK, Pécs.

PAWLOWSKI, K. (2009): The ‘fourth generation university’ as a creator of the local and regional development Higher Education in Europe 34 (1): 51–64.

POLT, W.–RAMMER, C.–GASSLER, H.–SCHIBANY, A.–SCHARTINGER, D. (2001): Benchmarking Industry-Science Relations: the role of framework conditions Report to the Federal Ministry of Economy and Labour, Austria and to the European Commission, Vienna.

RYAN, J.–MALGIERI, P. (1992): Economic Impact Studies in Community Colleges: The Shortcut Method. National Council for Resource Development Resource Paper 48: 23.

SZÉKELY, A. (2011): A határon átnyúló agglomerációk turizmusának típusai. Jelenkori társadalmi és gazdasági folyamatok 6 (1-2): 126–131.

SZÉKELY, A. (2013): Regionális multiplikáció a szegedi Árkád példáján In: Rechnitzer, J., Somlyódiné P. E.–Kovács, G. (eds): A hely szelleme – a területi fejlesztések lokális dimenziói pp. 565–573., Széchenyi István Egyetem, Győr.

VARGA, A. (2001): Universities and Regional Economic Development: Does Agglomeration Matter? In Johannson, B.–Karlsson, C.–Stough, R. (eds): Theories of Endogenous Regional Growth pp. 345–367., Springer, Berlin.

VARGA, A.–HAU-HORVÁTH, O.–SZABÓ, N.–JÁROSI, P. (2014): Environmental Innovation Impact analysis with the GMR-Europe Model Regional Statistics 4 (2): 3–17.

WEST, G. R.–JACKSON, R. W. (1998) Input-output+econometric and econometric+input-output: model differences or different models? Journal of Regional Analysis and Policy 28 (1): 33–48.

WISSEMA, J. G. (2009): Towards the third generation university. Managing the university in transition Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

ZUTI, B.–LUKOVICS, M. (2014): “Fourth Generation” Universities and Regional Development In: Hamm, R.–Kopper, J. (eds.): Higher Education Institutions and Regional Development pp. 14–31., Mönchengladbach.