Why and How should the EU budget be reformed?

Mare, Mauro (2015): Why and How should the EU budget be reformed?

Abstract

If there is one subject that has been thoroughly explored for many years it is the EU’s finances. Institutional actors, like the Commission or the European Parliament, or many academic experts have all provided valuable and largely converging “diagnoses” on the “weaknesses” of the EU budget. The analysis of the allocation of functions in a multilevel Europe can fruitfully start from the lesson of the fiscal federalism theory. This theory can give many useful insights to the existing European effort to review the current allocation of functions between the European Union and member states. Although this theory has been developed in quite different contexts from the present European one, it can be helpful in providing guidelines for the future European construction. The conventional wisdom – the conclusion of the traditional fiscal federalism theory – argues that the functions of redistribution and stabilization should be attributed to the central level of government, while the function of allocation, in particular in the case of impure or local public goods19 should be transferred to sub central level, namely national governments. However, this theory has always been referred to federal countries and has been applied in federalist contexts while the current European Union is quite far from this dimension. Moreover, fiscal federalism is per se a static theory that stems from mature federations, while the present-day EU needs a dynamic, flexible approach that may guide the institutional process and the economic building. The design of competence allocation in a well-settled, mature federation, it is quite an easy task, while finding the right mix of competence distribution in an evolving process, from an economic union to a quasi-federal entity, is a different and daunting issue. What the European Union needs is a simple but sound rule which can help in its building process and in revising the distribution of government responsibilities among the central tier and the national ones along the road of European integration. Of course, this does not imply that the path has been definitely charted and that we are bound to move to a federal dimension. Even better, recent institutional developments seems to show that the European Union can even remain a single market or a simple economic union; but a flexible blueprint is needed. In this paper we address major pitfalls of the current Eu budget and we propose some possible reforms in the structure of its financing and current revenue.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Eu Budget, Fiscal federalism
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H73 - Interjurisdictional Differentials and Their Effects; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Amato, G.-Marè, M. (2005) Using a New VAT for Taxing Consumption and Financing the EU Budget, mimeo, Rome, August.

Aujean, M. (1995) “Value Added Tax in the Internal Market: a First Assessment”, EC Tax Review, n. 1.

Baldwin, R. (1996) “Discussion”, Economic Policy, n. 23, October.

Baldwin, R. (2007) “EU VAT Fraud: part 1-5”, Vox, 14-22 June, in www.voxeu.org

Begg, I. (2005) Funding the European Union: Making Sense of the EU Budget, A Federal Trust Report on the European Union’s Budget, March.

Berglas, S. (1981), "Harmonization of Commodity Taxes. Destination, Origin and Restricted Origin Principle", Journal of Public Economics, vol. 16.

Bird, R. (1989) “Tax Harmonization in Federations and Common Markets” in M. Neumann-K. W. Roskamp (eds.), Public Finance and Performance of Enterprises, Detroit, Wayne State University Press.

Bird, R. (1994) “Cost and Complexity of Canada’s VAT: The GST in International Perspective”, Tax Notes International, vol. 8, no.1, January.

Bird, R. (1999) “Rethinking Subnational Taxes: A New Look at Tax Assignment”, IMF Working Paper, no. 99, December.

Bird, R.-Gendron, P. (1998) “Dual VATs and Cross-Border Trade: Two Problems, One Solution”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 5, n. 3, July.

Bird, R.-Gendron, P. (2000) “CVAT, VIVAT, and Dual VAT: Vertical Sharing and Interstate Trade”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 7, n. 3, July.

Bird, R.-Gendron, P. (2001) “VATs in Federal States: International Experience and Emerging Possibilities”, Working Paper, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University, no. 4, April.

Bird, R.-Mintz, J.-Wilson, T. (2006) “Coordinating Federal and Provincial Sales Taxes: Lessons from the Canadian Experience”, National Tax Journal, vol. 59, no. 4, December.

Bonino, E.-De Andreis, M. (2011) “Federation Lite, or what the United States of Europe might look like”, mimeo, December.

Boyer, D.-Russell, S. (1995), “Is it Time for a Consumption Tax?”, National Tax Journal, vol. 48, n. 3, september.

Burgess, R.-Howes, S.-Stern, N. (1995) “Value-Added Tax Options for India”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 2, n. 1 May. 88

Buti, M-Nava, M. (2003) Towards a European Budgetary System, CEPS Working Document No.203, Brussels, October.

Cipriani, G.-Marè, M. (2003) La finanza dell'Unione europea tra allargamento e ambizioni, Working Paper SIEP, November.

Cipriani, G.-Marè, M. (2007) Can the EU Budget Be Reformed? , paper presented at the XIX Villa Mondragone International Economic Seminar on The Economic Future of Europe, Rome, June 25- 26.

Cipriani, G.-Pisani, S. (2004) The European Budget: An Alternative to Budgetary Balances to Assess Costs and Benefits for the Member States, Working Paper Siep, October 2004.

Cipriani, G. (2006), The Responsibility for implementing the Community budget, CEPS, Working Document No 247, June.

Cipriani, G. (2008), The context for some serious re-thinking of the European Union's budget. Cnossen, S. (1993), “Harmonization of Indirect Taxes in the EEC", British Tax Review, no. 3.

Cnossen, S. (1998), “Global Trends and Issues in Value Added Taxation", International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 5, n. 3, July.

Cnossen, S. (2002) “Tax Policy in the European Union: A Review of Issues and Options”, CESIfo Working Paper, n. 758, August.

Cnossen, S.-Shoup, C. (1987), "Coordination of Value-added Taxes", in S. Cnossen (a cura di) Tax Coordination in the European Communities, Kluwer, Dewenter, Holland.

Commission des Communautés européennes (1996), Un système commun de TVA: Un programme pour le Marché unique, Bruxelles, 22 luglio, COM(96) 328 final.

Commissione delle Comunità Europee (2000), Strategia volta a migliorare il funzionamento del regime Iva nel mercato interno, Comunicazione della Commissione al Consiglio e al Parlamento Europeo, Bruxelles, 7 giugno COM(2000)348 def.

Commissione Europea (2004) Structures of the taxation systems in the EU: 1995-2001- 2003, Brussels.

Congressional Budget Office (1992), Effects of Adopting a Value Added Tax, February, Washington, D.C.

Convenevole, R. (1996) “L’evasione dell’Iva in Italia: a quanto ammonta, come si può contrastarla”, mimeo, Secit, Roma.

Convenevole, R. (1997) “L’evidenza empirica dell’evasione Iva in alcuni paesi membri e i suoi legami logici con la problematica della stima esauriente del Pnl”, mimeo, Roma, 19 giugno.

Copenaghen Economics (2009) EU Budget Review: Option for Change, The Dutch Ministries of Finance, Economic Affairs and Agriculture, June.

Corte dei Conti Europea (1998) Relazione speciale n° 6/1998 sul bilancio del sistema delle risorse basate sull’IVA e sul PNL, Lussemburgo, http://www.eca.eu/

Corte dei Conti Europea (2000) Relazione speciale n° 17/2000 relativa al controllo, da parte della Commissione, dell’affidabilità e della comparabilità dei PNL degli Stati membri, Lussemburgo.

de Mello, L. (2007) “The Brazilian “Tax War”: The Case of Value-Added Tax Competition among the States”, Working Paper Economic Department, OECD, no. 544, 14 February.

Dosser, D. (1967), "Economic Analysis of Tax Harmonization" in C. Shoup (a cura di) Fiscal Harmonization in Common Markets, New York, Columbia University Press.

Due, J. (1973) “The Case for the Use of the Retail Form of Sales Tax in Preference to the Value Added Tax”, in R. Musgrave (a cura di) Broad-Based Taxes. New Options and Sources, John Hopkins University Press, Baltimora.

Due, J. (1987) “The Choice between a Value Added Tax and a Retail Sales Tax”, in Report of Proceedings of the 37th Tax Conference, Quebec, Canada, Canadian Tax Foundation..

Due, J. (1988) Indirect Taxation in Developing Countries, John Hopkins University Press, Baltimora.

Due, J. (1990) “Some Unresolved Issues in Design and Implementation of Value Added Taxes”, National Tax Journal, n. 4, december.

Ebrill, L.-Keen, M.-Bodin, J.- Summers, V. (2001), The Modern VAT , IMF, Washington, D. C.

Emerson, M. –Aydin, S.-De Clerck-Sachsse, J.-Noutcheva, G.. (2006) Just what is this ‘absorption capacity’ of the European Union, CEPS Policy Brief, no. 113, September.

European Commission (2007) Vat Rates Applied in the Member states of the European Community, DOC/2137/2007, Brussels, May.

European Commission (1996), A Common System of VAT : A programme for the Single Market, Brussels, 22 July, COM(96) 328 final.

Fehr, H.-Rosenberg, C.-Wiegard, W. (1994), "Should the EU Adopt the Origin Principle for VAT after 1997?", Finanzarchiv, vol. 51.

Feldstein, M.-Krugman, P. (1989) “International Trade Effcets of Value Added Taxation“, NBER Working Paper, no. 3163, November

Genser, B.-Haufler, A.-Sorensen, P. (1995), "Indirect Taxation in an Integrated Europe: Is There a Way of Avoiding Trade Distortions without Sacrificing National Tax Autonomy?", Journal of Economic Integration, vol. 10, n. 2, june.

Genser, B. (2003) “Coordinating VATs between EU Member States”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 10.

Goulard, S.-Nava, M. (2002) Un financement plus démocratique du budget européen : un défi pour la Convention européenne, European Commission, Revue Francaise du Finances Publiques.

Gros, D.-Micossi, S. (2005) A Better Budget for the European Union, CEPS Policy Brief, No. 66, February.

Grossman, G. (1980) “Border Tax Adjustment: Do They Distort Trade?”, Journal of International Economics, n. 1 February.

Haufler, A. (1993), Commodity Tax Harmonization in the European Community, Heidelberg, Physica-Verlag.

Hellerstein, W. (2005) “US Subnational States Sales Tax Reform: The Streamlined Sales Tax Project, mimeo, paper presented at International Tax Dialogue VAT Conference, Rome, Italy, March 14-15.

International Tax Dialogue (2005) The Value Added Tax: Experiences and Issues, mimeo, paper presented at International Tax Dialogue VAT Conference, Rome, Italy, March 14-15.

Jimenez, J. P. (2010) Brazilian Subnational VAT: Problems, Proposals for Reform and Prospects, slides presented at the Forum of Federations: Making the 18th Amendment and NFC Award Work, Islamabad, 30-31 October.

Keen, M. (1991), "Aspect of Tax Coordination in the European Communities", IFS Working Paper, n. W91/5, January.

Keen, M. (1993), "The Welfare Economics of Tax Coordination in the European Communities. A Survey", Fiscal Studies, vol. 14, n. 2, May.

Keen, M., (2000) “CVAT, VIVAT, and All That: New Forms of Value-Added Tax for Federal Systems”, Canadian Tax Journal, vol. 48, no. 2. 90.

Keen, M., (2002) “Some International Issues in Commodity Taxation”, IMF Working Paper, no. 124, July.

Keen, M., (2005) The VAT Experience, paper presented at the International Tax Dialogue VAT Conference, 15-16 March, Rome, mimeo.

Keen, M. (2007) “VAT Attacks!”, IMF Working Paper, no. 142, June.

Keen, M.-Lockwood, B. (2007) “The Value Added Tax: Its Causes and Consequences”, IMF Working Paper, no. 183, July.

Keen, M.-Smith, S. (1996) “ViVat: an Alternative VAT for the EU”, Economic Policy, n. 23, October. Keen, M.-Smith, S. (2000) “Viva VIVAT”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 7, n. 3, July.

Keen, M.-Smith, S. (2007) “VAT Fraud and Evasion: What Do We Know, and What Can Be Done?”, IMF Working Paper, no. 31, February.

King, D. (1984) Fiscal Tiers,

Lauré, M. (1993), Science Fiscale, Paris, Presses Universitaires de France.

Leccisotti, M.-Marè, M. (1992), "On the Presumed Technical Superiority of VAT", Australian Tax Forum, vol. 9, n. 3.

Le Cacheux, J. (2005) Budget européèn: le poison du juste retour, Notre Europe, Etudes et Recherches n. 41,

Le Cacheux, J. (2007) Funding the EU Budget with a Genuine Own Resource: The Case for a European Tax, Notre Europe, Studies n. 57, May.

Lefebvre, M. (2005) (ed.) What Kind of European Budget for 2013?, CEES and IFRI, Paris

Lockwood, B. (1991), "Border Controls and Tax Competition in a Custom Union", Center for Economic Research, Discussion Paper, n. 9140, September.

Lockwood, B. (1993), "Commodity Tax Competition under Destination and Origin Principles", Journal of Public Economics, vol. 52, n. 2, September.

Lockwood, B.-De Meza, B.-Myles, G. (1994a), "When the Origin and Destination Regimes are Equivalent?", International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 1, n. 1, May.

Lockwood, B.-De Meza, B.-Myles, G. (1994b), "The Equivalence between Destination and Non- Reciprocal Restricted Origin Tax Regimes", Scandinavian Journal of Economics, vol. 96, n. 3.

Lockwood, B.-De Meza, B.-Myles, G. (1995), "On the European Union VAT Proposals: The Superiority of Origin over Destination Taxation", Fiscal Studies, vol. 16, n. 1.

Longobardi, E. (1990), "L'Iva verso il '92 e oltre: un tributo europeo tra esigenze nazionali e inziativa comunitaria" in A. Majocchi-G. Tremonti (a cura di) Le imposte del 1992, Milano, Angeli.

MacDougall D. (1977) Report of the Study Group on the Role of the Public Finance in European Integration, European Commission, Brussels.

McLure, C. (1993) “Economic, Administrative, and Political Factors in Choosing a general Consumption Tax”, National Tax Journal, vol. 46, n. 3, september.

McLure, C. (2000a) “Implementing Subnational Value Added Taxes on International Trade: The Compensating VAT (CVAT)”, International Tax and Public Finance, vol. 7, n. 3, July.

McLure, Charles E., Jr. (2000b). “Tax Assignment and Subnational Fiscal Autonomy” Bulletin for International Fiscal Documentation.

McLure, Charles. (2001) “The Tax Assignment Problem: Ruminations on How Theory and Practice Depend on History”, National Tax Journal, vol. 54, no. 2.

McLure, Charles (2005) “Coordinating State Sales Taxes with a Federal VAT: Opportunities, Risks, and Challenges” paper presented at the Symposium on Federal Tax Reform and the States, National Press Club, Washington, DC, May 18.

Marè, M.-Sarcinelli, M.(1991), "È l’Iva compatibile con il mercato unico del 1992?", Politica economica, n. 2, agosto.

Marè, M. (2002) La tassazione dei consumi nell’UE: prelievo statale o imposta federale?, mimeo, SECIT, Ministero dell’Economia e delle Finanze, Roma, 10 giugno.

Marè, M. (2003) “La tassazione nell’Unione Europea: quale coordinamento? Quanta concorrenza?”, CNEL Rapporto di ricerca, 3 July 2003.

Marè, M. (2006) “A New VAT for the European Union: Taxing Consumption and Financing the Budget”, in G. Brosio-G. Muraro (eds.) Il finanziamento del settore pubblico, Milano, F. Angeli.

Marè, M. (2014) Subnational Consumption Taxes, in Gandullia, L.-Marè, M.-Piacentino, D.,The Role of Taxes in Fiscal Decentralization, Oecd, Paris, forthcoming.

Marè, M.-Sarcinelli, M.(1991), "È l’Iva compatibile con il mercato unico del 1992?", Politica economica, no. 2, August.

Marè, M.-Sarcinelli, M. (1998), Europa: cosa ci attende? Roma, Laterza.

Marè, M-Vitaletti, G. (1996), "La tassazione dei consumi nell’Unione Europea: effetti economici e ipotesi di riforma", Il Fisco, n. 15, 15 April.

Marè, M.-Vitaletti, G. (2000), "A Solution to the Definitive VAT Regime of the European Union”, mimeo, December.

Messere, K. (1994) “Consumption Tax Rules”, Bulletin for International Fiscal Documentation, vol. 48, n. 12, December.

Metcalf, G. (1995), “Value Added Taxation: A Tax whose Time has come”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 9, n. 1, winter.

Mikesell, J. (1997) “The American Retail Sales Tax: Consideration on their Structure, Operations, and Potential as a Foundation for a Federal Sales Tax”, National Tax Journal, vol. 50, no. 1, March.

Mora, M-Varsano, R. (2001) Fiscal Decentralization and Subnational Fiscal Autonomy in Brazil: Some Facts of the Nineties”, Texto Para Discussao, n. 854, Rio de Janeiro, December.

Musgrave, R. (1959) The Theory of Public Finance, New York, McGraw Hill.

Musgrave, R. (1969) Fiscal Systems, New Haven, Yale University Press.

Musgrave, R. (1983) “Who Should Tax, Where and What?”, in Tax Assignment in Federal Countries, a cura di Charles McLure, Centre for Research on Federal Financial Relations, Australian National University, Canberra.

Musgrave, R.-Musgrave, P. (1973), Public Finance in Theory and Practice, New York, McGraw-Hill.

Musgrave, P. (1987) “Interjurisdictional Coordination of Taxes on Capital Incomes”, in S. Cnossen (a cura di) Tax Coordination in the European Community, Kluwer Dewenter.

Neumark, F. (1963) Report to the Fiscal and Monetary Committee (Neumark Report), CEE Commission, Bruxelles.

Oates, W. (1968) “The Theory of Public Finance in a Federal System”, Canadian Journal of Economics, vol. 1, n. 1 February.

Oates, W. (1972) Fiscal Federalism, New York, Harcourt Brace.

Oates, W. (1977a) “Fiscal Federalism in Theory and Practice: Application to the European Community”, in McDougall (1977).

Oates, W. (1977b) “An Economist’s Perspective on Fiscal Federalism” in W. Oates (ed.) The Political Economy of Fiscal Federalism.

Oates, W. (1999), “An Essay on Fiscal Federalism”, Journal of Economic Literature, vol. 37, September. 92

Oates, W. (2002) “Fiscal Federalism and European Union: Some Reflections”, mimeo, September, SIEP, Pavia.

Oecd (2005) Consumption Tax Trends, 2004 edition, Paris.

Oecd (2006) Consumption Tax Trends, 2006 edition, Paris.

Olson, M. (1969) “The Principle of Fiscal Equivalence: The Division of Responsibilities Among Different Levels of Governments”, American Economic Review,P&P, , vol. 59.

Poddar, S. (1988) “Issues in Integration of Federal and Provincial sales Taxes: A Canadian Perspective”, National Tax Journal, September, vol. 41, no. 3

Poddar, S. (1990) "Value-Added Tax at the State Level," in Malcolm Gillis, Carl S. Shoup, and Gerardo P. Sicat (eds.), Value Added Taxation in Developing Countries, Washington: The World Bank, 1990.

Quigley, D. (1995) “Enterprise in the Single Market: The Definitive VAT Regime”, EC Tax Review, n. 1.

Raponi, D. (1996) “A Programme for a new Common System of VAT”, EC Tax Review, n.3.

Rezk, E. (2000) “Federalism and Decentralization Under Convertibility: Lessons from the Argentine Experience”, IMF Seminar on Decentralization, Washington, D.C.

Sapir, A. (2003) An Agenda for a Growing Europe, Report of an Independent High-Level study Group established on the initiative of the President of the European Commission, European Commission, Brussels, July.

Sharma, C. K. (2004) Implementing VAT in India: Implications for Federal Polity, The Indian Journal of Political Science, vol. LXVI, No 4, December, pp. 915-934.

Shibata, H. (1967) “The Theory of Economic Unions; A Comparative Analysis of Custom Unions, Free Trade Areas, and Tax Unions” in C. Shoup (a cura di) Fiscal Harmonization in Common Markets, New York, Columbia University Press.

Shoup, C. (1969), Public Finance, Chicago, Aldline.

Shoup, C. (1973) “Factors Bearing on an Assumed Choice between a Federal Retail Sales Tax and a Federal Value Added Tax”, in R. Musgrave (ed.) Broad-Based Taxes. New Options and Sources, John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.

Shoup, C. (1990) “Choosing among Types of VATs”, in M. Gillis-C. Shoup-G. Sicat (a cura di) Value Added Taxation in Developing Countries, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Sinn, H. W. (1993) “How Much Europe? Subsidiarity, Centralization and Fiscal Competition”, CEPR Discussion Paper, n. 834, September.

Smith, S. (1997) The Definitive Regime for VAT, Institute for Fiscal Studies, Commentary 63, London.

Tabellini, G. (2002) “Principles of Policymaking in the European Union: an Economic Perspective, mimeo, Bocconi University, October.

Terra, B. (1996) “A Common System of VAT. A Programme for the Single Market”, VAT Monitor, vol. 7, n. 5, September-October.

Vanistendael, F. (1995) “A Proposal for a Definitive VAT System Taxation in the Country of Origin at the Rate of the Country of Destination, Without Clearing”, EC Tax Review, n. 1.

Varsano, R. (1995), “A Tributacao do Comercio Interstadual: ICMS versus ICMS partilhadp”, Texto para Discussao, n. 382, Istituto de Pesquisa Economica Aplicada, Brasilia.

Varsano, R. (1999) “Subnational Taxation and Treatment of Interstate Trade in Brazil: Problems and a Proposed Solution”, mimeo.

Whalley, J. (1979), "Uniform Domestic Tax Rates, Trade Distortions and Economic Integration", Journal of Public Economics, n. 11.