Munich Personal RePEc Archive

From degrees of belief to binary beliefs: Lessons from judgment-aggregation theory

Dietrich, Franz and List, Christian (2014): From degrees of belief to binary beliefs: Lessons from judgment-aggregation theory.

This is the latest version of this item.

[img]
Preview
PDF
MPRA_paper_80844.pdf

Download (730kB) | Preview

Abstract

What is the relationship between degrees of belief and binary beliefs? Can the latter be expressed as a function of the former – a so-called “belief-binarization rule” – without running into difficulties such as the lottery paradox? We show that this problem can be usefully analyzed from the perspective of judgment-aggregation theory. Although some formal similarities between belief binarization and judgment aggregation have been noted before, the connection between the two problems has not yet been studied in full generality. We seek to fill this gap. This paper is organized around a baseline impossibility theorem, which we use to map out the space of possible solutions to the belief-binarization problem. Our theorem shows that, except in limiting cases, there exists no belief-binarization rule satisfying four initially plausible desiderata. Surprisingly, this result is a direct corollary of the judgmentaggregation variant of Arrow’s classic impossibility theorem in social choice theory.

Available Versions of this Item

UB_LMU-Logo
MPRA is a RePEc service hosted by
the Munich University Library in Germany.