THE CONCEPT OF COMPARISON INCOME: AN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE

Drakopoulos, Stavros A. (2008): THE CONCEPT OF COMPARISON INCOME: AN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE.

Abstract

Theories of social comparison have a long presence in the social sciences and have provided many useful insights. In economics, the idea of comparison, aspiration or relative income belongs to this theoretical framework. The first systematic usages of this idea can be found in the works of Keynes and Duesenberry. After these works the concept was relatively ignored by orthodox theorists until its recent re-appearance mainly in the fields of labour and macroeconomics. To the contrary, however, income comparisons continued to play a role in much of Keynesian inspired and Behavioural economics literature. In the last few years it has made a strong comeback in the literature of job satisfaction and of the economics of happiness. This paper attempts to trace the development of the concept in the modern history of economic thought. It also discusses the main theoretical implications of adopting income comparisons and possible reasons for its relative disregard by orthodox economics.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Relative Income; History of Economic Thought; Wages
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B20 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J30 - General

References

Adams, J. (1963). Towards an Understanding of Inequity, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67, pp. 422-436.

Akerlof, G. (1980). A Theory of Social Custom, of which Unemployment May Be One Consequence, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 94, pp.749-75.

Akerlof, G and Yellen, J. (1990). The Fair Wage-Effort Hypothesis and Unemployment, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 105, pp.255-84.

Albanese, P. (1988b) The Formation And Change of Fertility Preferences, Journal of Behavioral Economics, 17, pp.35-55.

Alesina, A., Di Tella, R. and Mac Culloch, R. (2004) Inequality and Happiness, Journal of Public Economics, 88, pp.2009-42.

Ambrose, M. and Kulik, T. (1999), Old Friends, New Faces: Motivation Research in 1990s, Journal of Management, 25, pp.231-280.

Andrews, F. (1991) Stability and Change in Levels and Structure of Subjective well-being: USA 1972 and 1988, Social Indicators Research, 25, pp.1-30.

Altman, M. (2001) A Behavioural Model of Labour Supply: Casting Some Light into the Black Box of Income-Leisure Choice, Journal of Socio-Economics, 30, pp.199-219.

Arestis, P. and Biefang-Frisancho Mariscal, I (1998). Elements of Conflict in UK Wage Determination, in New Keynesian Economics/ Post Keynesian Alternatives (Ed. R. Rotheim), London: Routledge.

Baxter, J. (1988) Social and Psychological Foundations of Economic Analysis, London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

Baxter J. (1993) Behavioral Foundations of Economics, New York: St Martin’s Press.

Berry, C. (1994) The Idea of Luxury: a Conceptual and Historical Investigation, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Blanchflower, D. and Oswald, A. (2004) Well-being Over Time in Britain and the USA, Journal of Public Economics, 88, pp.1359-86.

Boskin. M. and E. Sheshinski, (1978). Optimal redistributiveTtaxation when Individual Welfare Depends upon Relative Income, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 92, pp.589-61.

Bruni L. and Porta P.L (eds), (2007) Handbook of the Economics of Happiness, Cheletenham, UK: Edward Elgar.

Cappelli. P. and P.D. Sherer, (1988) Satisfaction. Market Wages and Labour Relations: An Airline Study, Industrial Relations 27 pp.56-73.

Charness, G. and Grosskopf, B. (2001). Relative Payoffs and Happiness: An Experimental Study, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization , 45 pp. 301–328.

Clark, A. and Oswald, A. (1996). Satisfaction and Comparison Income, Journal of Public Economics, 61, pp.359-381.

Clark, A. and Oswald, A. (1998) Comparison-Concave Utility and Following Behaviour in Social and Economic Settings, Journal of Public Economics, 70, pp.133-55.

Clark, A.,Frijters, P. and Shields, M. (2007) Relative Income, Happiness and Utility: an Explanation for the Easterlin Paradox and Other Puzzles, IZA Discussion Paper, No 2840.

Danthime J-P. and Kurmann, A (2004) Fair Wages in a New-Keynesian Model of the Business Cycle, Review of Economic Dynamics, 7, pp. 107-42

Deci, E. and Ryan, R. (2000) The ‘What ‘ and ‘Why’ of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-determination of Behavior, Psychological Inquiry, 11, pp.227-268.

De la Croix, D. (1993) Wage Interdependence and Competitiveness, Recherches Economiques de Louvain, 59, pp.395-425.

De la Croix, D. (1994) Wage Interdependence through Decentralized Bargaining, Journal of Economic Surveys, 8, pp.371-403.

Drakopoulos, S. (1992) "Psychological Thresholds, Demand and Price Rigidity", Manchester School, LX, pp.152-68.

Drakopoulos, S. (forthcoming) The Paradox of Happiness: Towards an Alternative Explanation, Journal of Happiness Studies.

Drakopoulos, S. and Theodossiou, I. (1997). Job Satisfaction and Target Earnings, Journal of Economic Psychology, 18, pp.694-704.

Duesenberry, J S. (1949). Income, Saving and the Theory of Consumer Behaviour, Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Earl, P. (1988) Behavioural Economics (ed), Aldershot: Edward Elgar.

Earl, P. (1990). Economics and Psychology: a Survey, The Economic Journal, 100, pp.718-55.

Easterlin, R. (1974). Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical Evidence, in Nations and Households in Economic Growth (eds. P. David and M. Reder). New York: Academic Press.

Easterlin, R. (1995) Will Raising the Incomes of all Increase the Happiness of all?”, Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 27, pp.35-47.

Easterlin, R. (2001) Income and Happiness: Towards a Unified Theory, Economic Journal, 111, pp.465-484. Eckstein, O and Wilson, T. (1962) The Determination of Money Wages in American Industry, Quarterly Journal of Economics, 76, pp.379-414.

Ferrer-i-Carbonell, A. (2005) Income and Well-being: an Empirical Analysis of the Comparison Income Effect, Journal of Public Economics, 89, pp.997-1019.

Festinger, L. (1954) A Theory of Social Comparison Processes, Human Relations, 3, pp.117-140.

Flanagan, R. (1976). Wage Interdependence in Unionized Labor Markets, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 3, pp.635-73.

Flanagan, R., Moene, K. and Wallerstein, M. (1993). Trade Union Behaviour, Pay-Bargaining and Economic Performance, Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Frank, R. (1984) Interdependent Preferences and the Competitive Wage Structure, Rand Journal of Economics, 15, pp.510-520.

Frank, R. (1985) Choosing the Right Pond, New York: Oxford University Press.

Frank, R. (1997) The Frame of Reference as a Public Good, The Economic Journal, 107, pp.1832-47.

Frey, B. and Stutzer, A. (2002a) Happiness and Economics, Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Frey, B. and Stutzer A. (2002b) “What Can Economists Learn from Happiness Research?”, Journal of Economic Literature, 40, pp.402-435.

Greenberg, J. (1990). Organizational Justice: Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow, Journal of Management, 16, pp.399-432.

Gylfason, T. and Linbeck, A. (1984). Competing Wage Claims, Cost Inflation, and Capacity Utilization, European Economic Review, 24, pp.1-21.

Gylfason, T. and Linbeck, A. (1986). Endogenous Unions and Governments, European Economic Review, 30, pp.5-26.

Hamermesh, D. (1975) Interdependence in the Labour Market, Economica, 42, pp.421-29.

Hamermesh D. (1977),Economic Aspects of Job Satisfaction, in Essays in Labor Market Analysis, edited by Ashenfelter O. and Oates W., Toronto: John Wiley &Son.

Harbaugh, R. (1996) Falling Beyond the Joneses: Relative Consumption and the Growth-Savings Paradox, Economics Letters, 53, pp.297-304.

Hochman. H.M. and J.D. Rogers. (1969) Pareto optimal redistribution. American Economic Review 59, pp.542-557.

Holländer, H. (2001) On the Validity of Utility Statements: Standard Theory versus Duesenberry's, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization, 45 pp. 227-249.

Holmlund, B. and Skedinger, P. (1990) Wage Bargaining and Wage Drift: Evidence from the Swedish Wood Industry, in L. Calmfors (ed.) Wage Formation and Macroeconomic Policy in the Nordic Countries, Oxford : Oxford University Press.

Homans, G. (1961). Social Behaviour: Its Elementary Forms, New York: Harcourt Brace.

Jakobsson, L. and Lindbeck, A. (1971) On the Transmission Mechanism of Wage Change, Swedish Journal of Economics, 73, pp.273-293.

Jacoby S. and Mitchell, D. (1990) Sticky Stories: Economic Explanations of Employment and Wage Rigidity, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 80, pp.33-37.

Kapteyn, A, and F.G. Van Herwaarden (1980) Interdependent Welfare Functions and Optimal Income Distribution. Journal of Public Economics 14, pp.375-397.

Kapteyn, A. and Wansbeek, T. (1982) Empirical Evidence on Preference Formation, Journal of Economic Psychology, 2, pp.137-54. Kaufman, B.E., (1999) Expanding the Behavioral Foundations of Labor Economics Industrial and Labor Relations Review 52, pp. 361–392. Kenny, C. (1999) Does Growth cause Happiness or does Happiness cause Growth? Kyklos, 52, pp.3-26.

Keynes, J. (1936) The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money, London: Macmillan (1973 edition).

King, J. (1990) Labour Economics, London: Macmillan.

Lane, R. (2000) The Loss of Happiness in the Market Democracies, Yale: Yale University Press

Layard, R. (1980). Human Satisfactions and Public Policy, Economic Journal, 90, pp.737-750.

Layard, R. (2005) Happiness, New York: The Penguin Press.

Leibenstein, H. (1950) Bandwagon, snob, and Veblen Effects in the Theory of Consumers’ Demand Quarterly Journal of Economics 64, pp.183–117

Leibenstein, H. (1975) “The Economic Theory of Fertility Decline,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 89, pp.1-31.

Leibenstein, H. (1976) Beyond Economic Man: A New Foundation for Microeconomics, Cambridge, MA: Harvard Universities Press.

Levine, D. (1993). What do Wages Buy? Administrative Science Quarterly, 38, pp.462-483.

Lindbeck, A. (1997) Incentives and Social Norms in Household Behavior, American Economic Review Papers and Proceedings, 87, pp.370-77.

Lommerud, K. (1989) Educational Subsidies when Relative Income Matters, Oxford Economic Papers, 41, pp.640-652.

McBride, M. (2001) Relative-income Effects on Subjective Well-being in the Cross-section, Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization , 45, pp. 251-278.

McDonald, I.M. (2002) How Social Preferences can Improve our Understanding of the Inflation-Unemployment Relation University of Melbourne, Department of Economics, Mimeo.

Martin, J. (1981) Relative Deprivation: a Theory of Distributive Justice for an Era of Shrinking Resources, in L.Cummings and B. Staw (eds) Research in Organizational Behavior: an Annual Series of Analytical Essays and Critical Reviews, vol.3, Greenwich CT: JAI Press.

Oswald, A. (1979) Wage Determination in an Economy with Many Trade Unions, Oxford Economic Papers, 31, pp.369-85.

Oswald, A. (1983) Altruism, Jealousy and the Theory of Optimal Non-linear Taxation, Journal of Public Economics, 20, pp.77-87.

Oswald, A. (1986). Is Wage Rigidity Caused by 'Lay-offs by Seniority'?, in W. Beckerman (ed) Wage Rigidity and Employment, London: Duckworth.

Oswald, A. (1997) “Happiness and economic performance”, Economic Journal, 107, pp.1815-31.

Pencavel, J. (1991) Labor Markets under Trade Unionism, Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Phelps, C. (2001) A Clue to the Paradox of Happiness, Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 45, pp.293-300. Pollak R. A (1976) Interdependent Preferences, American Economic Review, vol.66 (3) pp.745-63. Ross, A. (1948) Trade Union Wage Policy in E. McCarthy, 1972, (ed), Trade Unions, Harmondsworth : Penguin.

Rotheim, R. (ed) (1998) New Keynesian Economics/ Post Keynesian Alternatives, London: Routledge.

Runciman, W. (1966) Relative Deprivation and Social Justice, Berkeley: University of California Press.

Schram A.and Sonnemans J. (1996) Why People Vote: Experimental Evidence, Journal of Economic Psychology 17 (4), pp. 417-442

Sen, A. (1983) Poor, Relatively Speaking. Oxford Economic Papers, vol. 35, pp. 153- 169.

Summers, L. (1988) Relative Wages, Efficiency Wages, and Keynesian Unemployment, American Economic Review, Papers and Proceedings, 78, pp.383-88.

Stark, O. and Taylor, J. (1991) Migration Incentives, Migration Types: The role of Relative Deprivation Economic Journal, 101, pp. 1163-1178

Stutzer, A. (2004) The Role of Income Aspirations in Individual Happiness, Journal of Economic Behaviour and Organization, 54, pp.89-109

Sweeny, P. (1990) Distributive Justice and Pay Satisfaction: A Field Test of an Equity Theory Prediction, Journal of Business and Psychology, 4, pp.329-341.

Teulings, C. and Hartog, J. (1997) Corporatism or Competition: An International Comparison of Labour Market Structures and their Impact on Wage Formation. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Tomes N. (1986) Income Distribution, Happiness and Satisfaction: A Direct Test of the Interdependent Preferences Model, Journal of Economic Psychology, 7, pp.425-446.

Trevithick. J.A.. (1976) Money Wage Inflexibility and the Keynesian Labour Supply Function Economic Journal, 86, pp.327-332.

Valenzi, E. and Andrews, R (1971).Effects of Hourly Overpay and Underpay Inequity when Tested with a new Induction Procedure, Journal of Applied Psychology, LV, pp.22-27.

Van de Stadt, H., Kapteyn, A. and Van de Geer, S. (1985) The Relativity of Utility: Evidence from Panel Data, Review of Economics and Statistics, 67, pp. 7-15.

Veblen, T. (1899) The Theory of the Leisure Class, Macmillan: New York.

Veenhoven, R. (1991) Is Happiness Relative? Social Indicators Research, 24, pp.1-34.

Wright, R. (2000) Nonzero: The Logic of Human Destiny, New York: Pantheon Books.