Do External Funding Sources Affect Research Productivity?: A Departmental-Level Analysis of Seven Former Imperial Japanese Universities

Miyaki, Miki and Okajima, Yuko (2018): Do External Funding Sources Affect Research Productivity?: A Departmental-Level Analysis of Seven Former Imperial Japanese Universities.

Abstract

This study examines the research productivity of departments in seven former imperial universities of Japan. We categorize the departments into five academic fields: engineering, health sciences (i.e., medicine, dentistry and pharmaceutical), economics, science, and agriculture. Then, the impact of fundamental and external research funds is examined to see whether they positively affect research productivity—measured by the number of papers accepted in peer-reviewed, international academic journals. Additionally, we investigate whether such external funding sources affect productivity in each of the five fields differently, noting any variation between them.

The estimation results reveal that, first, the increase of fundamental and external funds per faculty member is positively correlated with research productivity in the fields of engineering and health sciences. Second, considering the results of further investigation into the effects of external funding, research funding by the public sector can increase productivity in each of the five academic fields. Third, the results pertaining to private research funds show that research funding provided by firms can increase productivity in engineering and health sciences. However, for economics, the increase in external funding from firms is negatively correlated with research productivity. This result might be because the purpose of industry–university collaboration differs according to the academic field. Regarding economics, the output from the resulting collaboration might not result in the production of an academic paper, but rather make policy recommendations or provide consulting using quantitative analysis.

This study is the first attempt by any Japanese university to analyze research productivity across several departments. The empirical results show that depending on the discipline, the same resources of research funding impact research productivity differently. Nowadays, the Japanese central government has been about the business of reforming resource allocation systems of universities by evaluating their research performance, basing them more on the quantitative indicators such as the key performance indicators (KPI). However, a key result of this study implies that when a relative evaluation of universities is applied, each university’s situation must be more carefully considered, especially in terms of what kinds of academic departments it has, and which specialties or segments it features.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: financial sources, research productivity, departmental-level analysis, five academic fields
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I22 - Educational Finance ; Financial Aid; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I23 - Higher Education ; Research Institutions; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I28 - Government Policy

References

Akai, N., K. Suetomi, W. Senoh, and K. Mizuta　(2014)　“Analyses of Resource Allocation in Educational Finance (Governance of Educational Finance): From the perspective across all education stages”, RIETI Discussion Paper Series 14-J-009, The Research Institute of Economy, Trade and Industry, Japan [published in Japanese].

Aoki, S. and M. Kimura (2016) “Analysis of Research Productivity at Japanese National Universities”, Financial Review - Policy Research Institute, Ministry of Finance Japan, vol.128, pp. 55-66 [published in Japanese]

Fujimura, M. (2017) “Estimating Effects of the Basic Research Fund Reduction on the Competitive Fundraising Behavior and Continued Research：Negative Spiral”, International Joint Research Programs Discussion Paper Series, No.6, Research Institute for Higher Education, Hiroshima University [published in Japanese].

Fukuzawa, N. (2015) “An Empirical Analysis of the Research Efficiency and its Factors in Life and Medical Sciences Fields: Gender and Research Funding”, NISTEP Discussion Paper, No.124, National Institute of Science and Technology Policy, Japan [published in Japanese].

Fukuzawa, N. and T. Ida (2010)　“Academic Innovation Management 2: 21-Seiki COE Puroguramu No Kenkyuu Sokushin Kouka No Jisshou Bunseki [Empirical Analyses of the Research Promoting Effect of the 21st Century Center of Excellence Program]”, Annual Conference of The Japan Society for Science Policy and Research Management 2010, The Japan Society for Science Policy and Research Management, Japan, 25: 25-28 [published in Japanese].

Hayashi, T., M. Shirabe, Y. Yamashita, and H. Tomizawa　(2008)　“Effects of Institutional Research Management on Faculty Research Productivity”, Research on Academic Degrees and University Evaluation, No. 8, pp. 23-41 [published in Japanese].

Hayashi, T. and H. Tomizawa　(2007)　“Transition of Research Performance and Research Structure in Japan”, Research on Academic Degrees and University Evaluation, No. 5, pp.55-73 [published in Japanese].

Ida, T. and N. Fukuzawa (2011)　“21-Seiki COE Puroguramu No Kenkyuu Sokushin Kouka No Jisshou Bunseki [Empirical Analyses of the Research Promoting Effect of the 21st Century Center of Excellence Program]”, Annual Conference of The Japan Society for Science Policy and Research Management 2011, The Japan Society for Science Policy and Research Management, Japan, No. 26, pp. 590-593 [published in Japanese].

Ito, Y. (2011) “Research Activity of Faculties in Universities, etc. Characterized by Their Publication Productivity”, The Journal of Science Policy and Research Management, vol. 26(1_2), pp. 73-84 [published in Japanese].

Kanda, Y. and M. Igami (2017) “Inputs Structure of the University System in Japan – In-depth Analyses of the Survey of Research and Development (2002～2015) –,” NISTEP Research Material, No.257, National Institute of Science and Technology Policy, Japan [published in Japanese]. Ohtawa, Y. (1998)　“A study on the number of Japanese Engineering research field papers through analyzing ‘COMPENDEX PLUS’”, Journal of Information Processing and Management, vol.41, No.7, pp. 509-516 [published in Japanese].

Saka, A. and T. Kuwahara　(2013)　“Benchmarking Scientific Research 2012 - Bibliometric Analysis on Dynamic Alteration of Research Activity in the world and Japan”, NISTEP Research Material, No.218, National Institute of Science and Technology Policy, Japan [published in Japanese].

Yonetani, Y., K. Ikeuchi, and T. Kuwahara (2013) “An analysis on the relationship between input and output in the production of articles in universities - An approach using Web of Science and Survey of R&D”, NISTEP Discussion Paper, No.89, National Institute of Science and Technology Policy, Japan [published in Japanese].