Defined benefit pensions and homeownership in the post-Great Recession era

Murray, Tim (2019): Defined benefit pensions and homeownership in the post-Great Recession era.

Abstract

While housing equity accounts for a large portion of many retiree’s savings portfolios, they are not using their equity to increase consumption in retirement as suggested by the Life-Cycle Hypothesis. Defined benefit plans provide a guaranteed source of income in retirement where the household bears no risk, whereas households with a defined contribution plan are subject to potential risk depending on their asset allocation. This paper examines whether having a defined benefit plan mitigated some of the effects of the Great Recession. Using a difference-in-difference analysis, I examine the impact of the Great Recession on homeownership between households with a defined benefit plan compared to those with a defined contribution plan. I find that households with a defined contribution plan were 2.1-2.9 percent less likely to own a home after the Great Recession compared to households with a defined contribution plan. It is possible that households with defined contribution plans were willing to forgo homeownership to offset some of the losses experienced from the Great Recession. Future retirees face a potentially riskier housing market and are less likely to have a defined benefit plan. As a result, future retirees may be more willing to use their housing equity to increase consumption in retirement than was observed in past generations.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Great Recession, Housing Equity, Retirement, Pension
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics > D14 - Household Saving; Personal Finance; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J14 - Economics of the Elderly ; Economics of the Handicapped ; Non-Labor Market Discrimination; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J3 - Wages, Compensation, and Labor Costs > J32 - Nonwage Labor Costs and Benefits ; Retirement Plans ; Private Pensions

References

Ai, Chungron, Jonathan Feinstein, Daniel L. McFadden, and Henry Pollakowski. 1990. 'The Dynamics of Housing Demand by the Elderly: User Cost Effects.' in David A. Wise (ed.), Issues in the Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Altonji, Joseph G., Todd E. Elder, and Christopher R. Taber. 2005. 'An Evaluation of Instrumental Variable Stretegies for Estimating the Effects of Catholic Schooling', The Journal of Human Resources, 40: 791-821.

Bailey, Conner, Leif Jenson, and Elizabeth Ransom. 2014. Rural American in a Globalizing World: Problems and Prospects for the 2010s (West Virginia University Press: Morgantown, WV).

Baranov, Victoria, Daniel Bennett, and Hans-Peter Kohler. 2015. 'The indirect impact of antiretroviral therapy: Mortality risk, mental health, and HIV-negative labor supply', Journal of Health Economics, 44: 195-211.

Borsch-Supan, Axel, Vassilis Hajivassiliou, and Laurence Kotlikoff. 1992. 'Health, Children, and Elderly Living Arrangements: A Multiperiod-Probit Model with Unobserved Heterogeneity and Autocorreleated Errors.' in David A. Wise (ed.), Topics in the Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Buessing, Marric, and Mauricio Soto. 2006. The State of private pensions: Current 5500 data. (Center for Retirement Research at Boston College: Chesnut Hill, MA).

Burbidge, John B., Lonnie Magee, and A. Leslie Robb. 1988. 'Alternative Transformations to Handle Extreme Values of the Dependent Variable', Journal of the American Statistical Association, 83: 123-27.

Butrica, Barbara A., Howard M. Iams, Karen E. Smith, and Eric J. Toder. 2009. 'The Disappearing Defined Benefit Pension and its Potential Impact on the Retirement Incomes of Baby Boomers', Social Security Bulletin, 69.

Butrica, Barbara, and Stipica Mudrazija. 2016. 'Home Equity Patterns among Older American Households', Urban Institute Research Report.

Carstensen, Laura L. 2006. 'The Influence of a Sense of Time on Human Development', Science, 312: 1913-15.

Copeland, Craig. 2006. 'Retirement plan participation and retirees' perception of their standard of living', EBRI Issue Bried No. 289. Washington, DC: Employee Benefit Research Institute.

Davidoff, Thomas, Patrick Gerhard, and Thomas Post. 2017. 'Reverse mortgages: What homeowners (don't) know and how it matters', Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 133: 151-71.

Fagereng, Andreas, Charles Gottlieb, and Luigi Guiso. 2017. 'Asset Market Participation and Portfolio Choice over the Life-Cycle', The Journal of Finace, 72: 705-50.

Feinstein, Jonathan, and Daniel McFadden. 1989. 'The Dynamics of Housing Demand by the Elderly: Wealth, Cash Flow, and Demographic Effects.' in David A. Wise (ed.), The Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Fisher, Jonathan D., David S. Johnson, Joseph T. Marchand, Timotny M. Smeeding, and Barbara Boyle Torrey. 2007. 'No Place Like Home: Older Adults and Their Housing', Journal of Gerontology, 62B: 120-28.

Gunes, Pinar, and Magda Tsaneva. 2016. 'The Effects of Early Pregnancy on Education, Physical Health and Mental Distress: Evidence from Mexico', Working Papers 2016-14, University of Ablerta, Department of Economics.

Hoynes, Hilary, and Daniel McFadden. 1997. 'The Impact of Demographic on Housing and Non-Housing Wealth in the United States.' in Michael D. Hurd and Maohiro Yashiro (eds.), The Economic Effects of Aging in the United States and Japan (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

HRS Staff. 2008. HRS Sample Evolution: 1992-2008 (Survey Research Center, Institute for Social Research, University of Michigan. https://hrs.isr.umich.edu/publications/biblio/9047: Ann Arbor, MI).

Hurd, Michael D. 1992. 'Wealth Depletion and Life-Cycle Consumption by the Elderly.' in David A. Wise (ed.), Topics in the Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Hurd, Michael D., and Susann Rohwedder. 2010. 'The Effect of the Economic Crisis on the Older Population', University of Michigan Retirement Research Center Working Paper 2010-231.

Kaul, Karan, and Lauire Goodman. 2017. 'Seniors' Access to Home Equity: Identifying Existing Mechanisms and Impediments to Broader Application', Urban Institute Research Report.

Kutty, Nandinee K. 1998. 'The Scope for Poverty Alleviation among Elderly Home-Owners in the United States through Reverse Mortgages', Urban Studies, 35: 113-29.

Mattingly, Marybeth J., Kristin Smith, and Jessica A. Bean. 2011. 'Unemployment in the Great Recession: single parents and men hit hard', The Carsey Institute at the Scholars' Repository., Paper 144.

Modigliani, Franco, and Richard Brumberg. 1954. 'Utility Analysis and the Consumption Function: An Interpretation of Cross-Section Data.' in K. K. Kurihara (ed.), Post-Keynesian Economics (Rutgers University Press: New Brunswick, NJ).

Moulton, Stephanie, Donald Haurin, Samuel Dodini, and Maximilian D. Schmeiser. 2016. 'How Home Equity Extraction and Reverse Mortgages Affect the Credit Outcomes of Senior Households', Ann Arbor, MI. University of Michigan Retirement Research Center Working Paper, WP 2016-351.

Murray, Tim. 2018. 'Do Precautionary Savings Keep Older Americans from using Their Housing Equity?'

Nakajima, Makoto, and Irina A. Telyukova. 2017. 'Reverse Mortgage Loans: A Quantitative Analysis', The Journal of Finance, 72: 911-49.

National Retirement Risk Index. 2010. "The NRRI and the House." In. NRRI Fact Sheet No 1.

Oster, Emily. 2017. 'Unobservable Selection and Coefficient Stability: Theory and Evidence', Journal of Business & Economics.

Ozier, Owen. 2018. 'The Impact of Secondary Schooling in Kenya: A Regression Discontinuity Analysis', Journal of Human Resources, 53: 157-88.

Pence, Karen. 2006. 'The Role of Wealth Transformations: An Application to Estimating the Effect of Tax Incentives on Saving', Contributions to Economic Analysis & Policy, 5.

Poterba, James, Joshua Rauh, Steven F. Venti, and David A. Wise. 2006. 'Defined Contribution Plans, Defined Benefit Plans, and the Accumulation of Retirement Wealth', NBER Working Paper Series 12597.

Poterba, James, Steven Venti, and David Wise. 2011. 'The Composition and Drawdown of Wealth in Retirement', Journal of Economic Perspectives, 25: 95-118.

RAND HRS Data. 2016. 'Version P. Producecd by the RAND Center for the Study of Aging, with funding from the National Institute on Aging and the Socual Security Administration. Santa Monica, CA'.

S&P Dow Jones Indicies LLC. 'S&P/Case-Shiller U.S. National Home Price Index [CSUSHPINSA], retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis; https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CSUSHPINSA, Accessed 12/10/17'.

Slack, Tim. 2014. 'Work in rural America in the era of globalization.' in Conner Bailey, Leif Jenson and Elizabeth Ransom (eds.), Rural America in a Globalizing World: Problems and Prospects for the 2010s (West Virginia University Press: Morgantown, WV).

Thiede, Brian C., and Shannon M. Monnat. 2016. 'The Great Recession and America's Geography of Unemployment', Demographic Research, 35: 891-928.

Toosi, Mitra. 2015. 'Labor Force Projections to 2024: The Labor Force is Growing, but Slowly', Monthly Labor Review, 101: 1-33.

U.S Bureau of Economic Analysis. 'Personal Consumption Expenditures (Chain-Type Price Index) [PCEPI], retreived from FRED, Feseral Reserve Bank of St. Louis on 5/13/2017'. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PCEPI. U.S Bureau of Labor-Statistics. 'Civilian Unemployment Rate [UNRATE], retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis on 4/22/2019 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE'.

US Census Bureau. 2018. 'Quarterly Resiential Vacancies and Homeownership, Fourth Quarter 2017'. https://www.census.gov/housing/hvs/files/currenthvspress.pdf.

Venti, Steven F., and David A. Wise. 1989. 'Aging, Moving, and Housing Wealth.' in David A. Wise (ed.), The Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Venti, Steven F., and David A. Wise. 1990. 'But they don't want to Reduce Housing Equity.' in David A. Wise (ed.), Issues in the Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Venti, Steven F., and David A. Wise. 2001. 'Aging and Housing Equity.' in Olivia S. Mitchell, Zvi Bodie, P. Brett Hammond and Stephen Zeldes (eds.), Innovations for Financing Retirement (Pension Research Council Publications: Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press).

Venti, Steven F., and David A. Wise. 2004. 'Aging and Housing Equity: Another Look.' in David A. Wise (ed.), Perspectives on the Economics of Aging (University of Chicago Press: Chicago).

Wiatrowski, William J. 2004. 'Medical and retirement plan coverage: Exploring the decline in recent years', Monthly Labor Review, 127: 29-36.

Yahoo Finance. 'S&P 500 (^GSPC); retrieved from https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/%5EGSPC/history/'.