The Costs of Energy-related Linear Property on Local Governments in Canada and the Role of That Local Government Revenue Tool Can Play in Addressing these Costs

Tedds, Lindsay M. and Euper, Brock (2019): The Costs of Energy-related Linear Property on Local Governments in Canada and the Role of That Local Government Revenue Tool Can Play in Addressing these Costs. Forthcoming in: In Trevor Tombe and Jennifer Winter (Eds.), 2019, Measuring the Contribution of Energy Infrastructure: A Practical Guide. Calgary: University of Calgary Press

Abstract

This chapter focuses solely on the various costs that ERLP brings to local governments, the evidence regarding these costs, and the tools that a local government can employ to recover these costs. Given that local governments across Canada are generally constrained to raising revenues through property taxes and various user levies, including those associated with regulation, this paper will focus on the application of local property taxes on ERLP as well as discuss the likelihood of charges that can be levied pursuant to local government regulatory powers, via rights-of-way by-laws, and fees pursuant to local government powers to enter bilateral rights agreements. Overall, the chapter finds that there are options available to local governments to not only take actions to minimize the costs imposed by ERLP but also to recoup the identified costs. Each option not only to minimize costs but also to recoup costs has areas of strengths and weaknesses, suggesting that no only a multipronged approach will be necessary, conditional on the specific jurisdictional characteristics, but also that these tools may not be able to minimize or recoup all the specific costs incurred.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Energy related linear Property, Local Government Authorities, Local Government Revenue, Property Tax, User Fees, Regulatory Charges
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H24 - Personal Income and Other Nonbusiness Taxes and Subsidies; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H27 - Other Sources of Revenue; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H71 - State and Local Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Abramzon, Shmuel, Constantine Samaras, Aimee Curtright, Aviva Litovitz, and Nicholas Burger. 2014. "Estimating the Consumptive Use Costs of Shale Natural Gas Extraction on Pennsylvania Roadways." Journal of Infrastructure Systems 20 (3). doi: 10.1061/(ASCE)IS.1943-555X.0000203.

Alberta Association of Municipal Districts and Counties. 2016. Submission to the National Energy Board: Input on Proposed Amendments to Pipeline Damage Prevention Regulations.

Alberta Energy Regulator. 2018. "When a Setback is a Good Thing | Resource." Alberta Energy Regulator, Last Modified March 26, 2018, accessed July 1. https://resource.aer.ca/stories/when-a-setback-is-a-good-thing.

Alberta Energy Regulator. n.d.-a. "Sour Gas." Alberta Government, accessed July 1. https://www.aer.ca/providing-information/by-topic/sour-gas.

Alberta Energy Regulator. n.d.-b. "Working Around Oil and Gas Pipelines." accessed July 11. https://www.aer.ca/providing-information/by-topic/pipelines/working-around-oil-and-gas-pipelines.

Alberta Infastructure. 2004. Transporation/Utility Corridor (TUC) Program Policy.

Alberta Municipal Affairs. 2018. Guide to Property Assessment and Taxation in Alberta - guide-to-property-assessment-and-taxation-in-alberta.pdf.

Alberta Utilities Commission. 2017. Enmax Power Corporation: Tax Agreement with The City of Calgary.

Althaus, Catherine and Lindsay M. Tedds, User Levies in Canada: A Municipal Design and Implementation Guide (Toronto: Canadian Tax Foundation, 2016)

Anderson, Orell C., Jack Williamson, and Alexander Wohl. 2017. "The effect of high-voltage overhead transmission lines on property values: a review of the literature since 2010.(Peer-Reviewed Article)(Report)." Appraisal Journal 85 (3):179.

Associated Engineering Ltd. 2015. Cost Impacts of the TransMountain Expansion on Lower Mainland Municipalities. B.C. Assessment. 2019. "Understanding property classes and exemptions." accessed July 10. https://info.bcassessment.ca/Services-products/property-classes-and-exemptions/understanding-property-classes-and-exemptions.

BC Oil & Gas Commission. 2019. Oil and Gas Activity Operations Manual.

Becklumb, Penny, Jed Chong, and Tim Williams. 2015. Shale Gas in Canada: Environmental Risks and Regulation. Ottawa: Library of Parliament.

Bolton, David R. 1993. "Properties Near Power Lines and Valuation Issues: Condemnation or Inverse Condemnation?" Institute On PLanning, Zonning and Eminent Domain, Dallas, Texas, November 17-19.

Bond, Sandy, Sally Sims, and Peter Dent. 2013. Towers, Turbines and Transmission Lines.

Boxall, Peter C., Wing H. Chan, and Melville L. McMillan. 2005. "The impact of oil and natural gas facilities on rural residential property values: a spatial hedonic analysis." Resource and Energy Economics 27 (3):248-269. doi: 10.1016/j.reseneeco.2004.11.003.

C. T. V. News Regina. 2017. "Loss of grant-in-lieu funding leaves Sask. municipalities short | CTV News Regina." 2017-03-27. https://regina.ctvnews.ca/loss-of-grant-in-lieu-funding-leaves-sask-municipalities-short-1.3343290.

Canada. National Energy Board Pipeline Damage Prevention Regulations – Obligations of Pipeline Companies.

Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. 2017. Statistical Handbook - Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers. Canadian Energy Pipeline Association. 2013. About Pipelines: Our Energy Connections.

Canadian Standards Association. 2012. Land use planning for pipelines: A guideline for local authorities, developers, and pipeline operators.

Conger, Brian, and Beverly Dalby. 2015. "Policy Forum: Taxation of Machinery and Equipment and Linear Property in Alberta." Canadian Tax Journal 63 (2).

County of Grande Prairie No. 1. 2012. "Linear Assessment." accessed July 1. http://www.countygp.ab.ca/EN/main/government/linear-assessment.html.

Dent, Sally Sims, and Peter. 2016. "High-voltage Overhead Power Lines and Property Values: A Residential Study in the UK." http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00420980500060541. doi: 10.1080_00420980500060541.

Ecofiscal. 2018. Responsible Risk: How putting a price on environmental risk makes disasters less likely. Ernstoff, Alexi Sara, and Brian R. Ellis. 2013. "Clearing the Waters of the Fracking Debate." doi: 10.3998/mjs.12333712.0001.009.

Farish, Kelly and Lindsay M. Tedds, “User Levy Design by Canadian Municipalities: Considerations Arising from Case Law,” Canadian Tax Journal 62, 3 (2014)

Federal of Canadian Municipalities. 2008. "Highway Robbery: How Federal Telecom Rules Cost Taxpayers and Damage Public Roads."32.

Federal of Canadian Municipalities. 2009. Dealing with Telecom Companies: Protecting Municipal Rights-of-Way. Federation of Canadian Municipalities. 2017a. Response to Federal Environmental and Regulatory Reviews Discussion Paper.

Federation of Canadian Municipalities. 2017b. Submission to the National Energy Board Modernization Expert Panel. Gopalakrishnan, Sathya, and H. Allen Klaiber. 2019. "Is the Shale Boom a Bust for Nearby Residents? Evidence from Housing Values in Pennsylvania." doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2117932. Government of Alberta. n.d. Transportation/Utility Corridors.

Graham, Jove, Jennifer Irving, Xiaoqin Tang, Stephen Sellers, Joshua Crisp, Daniel Horwitz, Lucija Muehlenbachs, Alan Krupnick, and David Carey. 2015. "Increased traffic accident rates associated with shale gas drilling in Pennsylvania." Accident Analysis and Prevention 74:203-209. doi: 10.1016/j.aap.2014.11.003.

Henstra, Daniel. n.d. Municipal Emergency Management. Mountain View, California.

Hoffman, Barak, and Clark C. Gibson. 2006. Huo, Da. 2012. "The Global Sour Gas Problem." July 11. https://energyclub.stanford.edu/the-global-sour-gas-problem/.

Jackson, Thomas O., and Jennifer Pitts. 2010. "The Effects of Electric Transmission Lines on Property ValuesA Literature Review." Journal of Real Estate Literature 18 (2):239-260.

Kiessling, Friedrich, Peter Nefzger, Joao Felix Nolasco, and Ulf Kaintzyk. 2013. Overhead Power Lines: Planning, Design, Construction. Germany: Springer.

Kitchen, Harry. 2012. "Property Tax: A Situation Analysis and Overview | H. Kitchen." In A primer on property tax: administration and policy, edited by G. C. Cornia and L. C. Walters, 1-37. Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley.

Kitchen, Harry, and Enid Slack. 2012. Property Taxes and Competitiveness in British Columbia. of Property Taxes & PILs.

Leeds School Of Business. 2016. Colorado Oil and Gas Industry: Economic Assessment of 2,500-Foot Oil and Gas Setback Proposal. Boulder, Colorado. Manitoba Municipal Relations. n.d. "Property Assessment Frequently Asked Questions." https://www.gov.mb.ca/mr/assessment/faq.html#4.

McMorran, Jacqui. 2013. Safety Buffers Between Gas Wells and Pipelines and Public Schools. Metro Vancouver. 2012. Best Practices for the Intensive Use of Industrial Lands.

Muehlenbachs, Lucija, Elisheba Spiller, and Christopher Timmins. 2015. "The Housing Market Impacts of Shale Gas Development." American Economic Review 105 (12):3633-3659. doi: 10.1257/aer.20140079.

Municipal Property Assessment Corporation. 2019. "Property Assessment and Taxation." https://www.mpac.ca/HowAssessmentWorks/PropertyAssessmentandTaxation.

Murphy, Luke. 2018. "The Invisible Land: The Hidden Force Driving the UK's Unequal Economy and Broken Housing Market." The IPPR Comission on Economic Justice. https://www.ippr.org/files/2018-08/cej-land-tax-august18.pdf.

Natural Resources Canada. 2016. "Pipelines Across Canada | Natural Resources Canada."

Nicholls, Sarah. 2000. Measuring the impact of parks on property values: new research shows that green spaces increase the value of nearby housing.

Pearce, Scott, and Frederick Jones. 2015. Pipeline Safety - Municipal Concerns and Expectations - 2 June 2015 - Scott-Pearce-eng.pdf. MRC D’Argenteuil.

Pembina Institute. 2016. Landowners Guide Section 4 - section4-landowners-guide-2016.pdf.

Rhodes, Charles. 2019. "Natural Gas Pipeline Safety Setback: Calculation of Safety Setbacks from Large Diameter High Pressure Natural Gas Pipelines." http://www.xylenepower.com/Natural%20Gas%20Pipeline%20Safety%20Setback.htm.

Rioux, Sebastien, Jean-Pierre L. Savard, and Alyssa A. Gerick. 2013. "Avian mortalities due to transmission line collisions: a review of current estimates and field methods with an emphasis on applications to the Canadian electric network." Avian Conservation and Ecology 8 (2):7. doi: 10.5751/ACE-00614-080207.

Savaldi, Aldo. 2018. "Royalty owners claim wider well setbacks would cost them $26 billion." The Denver Post, 2018-06-13. https://www.denverpost.com/2018/06/12/royalty-owners-claim-wider-well-setbacks-would-cost-them-26-billion/.

Savaria Experts. 2015. Mise en service du projet Oleoduc Energie Est de Trans Canada: Impact fiscal du projetde l’oleduc pour les municipalites du territore de la Communaute metropolitaine de Montreal. Sainte-Julie, QC. Sjoquist, David L., and Mary Beth Walker. 1999. "Economies of Scale in Property Tax Assessment." National Tax Journal 52 (2):207-220.

Slack, Enid, and Richard M. Bird. 2014. The Political Economy of Property Tax Reform. In OECD Working Papers on Fiscal Federalism.

Somerville, Tsur, and Jake Wetzel. 2014. Pipeline and Property Values: A Review of the Academic Literature. Vancouver, B.C.: Anadlan Consulting.

Statistics Canada. 2018. Table 10-10-0020-01 Canadian government finance statistics for municipalities and other local public administrations (x 1,000,000). Ottawa, Ontario: Statistics Canada.

Stephenson, Michael. 2015. Shale Gas and Fracking: Elsevier. Summerville, Tracy, and Gary N. Wilson. 2013. "Pipelinesor Pipedreams? Municipal Reactions to the Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipeline in British Columbia." Canadian Political Science Association, Victoria, BC.

Tatos, Ted, Mark Glick, and Troy A. Lunt. 2016. "Property value impacts from transmission lines, subtransmission lines, and substations.(Peer-Reviewed Article)(Report)." Appraisal Journal 84 (3):205.

Tedds. 2017, Lindsay M. “Municipal User Levies in Western Canada,” in Enid Slack and Richard Bird, eds., Financing Municipal Infrastructure: Who Should Pay? (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2017)

Tedds, Lindsay M. 2019. "Non-tax Revenue for Funding Municipal Governments: User Levies—Adoption, Constraints, and Emerging Opportunities." In Funding the Canadian City, edited by Enid Slack, Lisa Phillips, Lindsay M. Tedds and Heather L. Evans. Toronto, Ontario: Canadian Tax Foundation.

The City of Edmonton. 2014. Municipal Franchise Fees White Paper. Edmonton.

Tipping Point Planner. n.d. "Use Utility Corridors as Greenways." http://tippingpointplanner.org/my-projects/action-strategies-1/community-practices/162-use-utility-corridors-as-greenways.

Transportation Association of Canada. 2008. Management of Utilities in and adjacent to the Public Right-of-Way: Survey of Practices. Transportation Association of Canada. Vlavianos, Nickie, and Chidinma Thompson. 2010. "Alberta's approach to local governance in oil and gas development." Alberta Law Review 48 (1):55-92.

Wherry, Aaron. 2012. "The quiet cuts." Macleans, 2012-06-27. Wyman, David, and Chris Mothorpe. 2018. "The Pricing of Power Lines: A Geospatial Approach to Measuring Residential Property Values." Journal of Real Estate Research 40 (1):121-153. doi: 10.5555/0896-5803.40.1.121.