How Forward-Looking Are Local Governments? Evidence from Indonesia

Cassidy, Traviss (2017): How Forward-Looking Are Local Governments? Evidence from Indonesia.

Abstract

Conventional wisdom in the policy community holds that volatile fiscal transfers to local governments will cause volatile local spending, due to policy myopia. I test the degree to which local governments are forward-looking by exploiting unusual variation in intergovernmental grants in Indonesia. A national reform permanently increased the general grant, and the increase was larger for less densely populated districts. Hydrocarbon-rich districts experienced transitory shocks to shared resource revenue. Districts responded to the permanent revenue shock by increasing investment in lumpy public goods. By contrast, districts smoothed their expenditure responses to the transitory revenue shocks, opting not to adjust lumpy public goods. The results suggest that local governments respond to changes in permanent public income over a time horizon of three to five years. I discuss implications for countercyclical fiscal policy and research on taxation and accountability.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Intergovernmental grants, public goods, flypaper effect
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H72 - State and Local Budget and Expenditures; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H75 - State and Local Government: Health ; Education ; Welfare ; Public Pensions; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O13 - Agriculture ; Natural Resources ; Energy ; Environment ; Other Primary Products; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q3 - Nonrenewable Resources and Conservation > Q38 - Government Policy

References

Agustina, C. D., E. Ahmad, D. Nugroho, and H. Siagian (2012): “Political Economy of Natural Resource Revenue Sharing in Indonesia,” Working Paper 55, Asia Research Centre.

Albouy, D. (2012): “Evaluating the E�ciency and Equity of Federal Fiscal Equalization,” Journal of Public Economics, 96, 824–839.

Arellano, M. and S. Bond (1991): “Some Tests of Speci�cation for Panel Data: Monte Carlo Evidence and an Application to Employment Equations,” Review of Economic Studies, 58, 277–297.

Arellano, M. and O. Bover (1995): “Another Look at the Instrumental Variable Estimation of Error-Components Models,” Journal of Econometrics, 68, 29–51.

Arezki, R., F. van der Ploeg, and F. Toscani (2019): “�e Shi�ing Natural Wealth of Nations: Th�e Role of Market Orientation,” Journal of Development Economics, 138, 228–245.

Auten, G. (1999): “Capital Gains Taxation,” in �e Encyclopedia of Taxation and Tax Policy, ed. by J. J. Cordes, R. D. Ebel, and J. Gravelle, Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press, 58–61, �first ed.

Baicker, K. (2005): “Extensive or Intensive Generosity? �e Price and Income E�ects of Federal Grants,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 87, 371–384.

Bazzi, S. and M. A. Clemens (2013): “Blunt Instruments: Avoiding Common Pitfalls in Identifying the Causes of Economic Growth,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 5, 152–186.

Bazzi, S. and M. Gudgeon (2018): “�e Political Boundaries of Ethnic Divisions,” Working paper, Boston University.

Besfamille, M., D. Jorrat, O. Manzano, and P. Sanguinetti (2019): “How Do Subnational Governments React to Shocks to Revenue Sources? Evidence from Argentina,” Working Paper 522, IE-PUC.

Bl¨ondal, J. R., I. Hawkesworth, and H.-D. Choi (2009): “Budgeting in Indonesia,” OECD Journal on Budgeting, 9, 49–79.

Blundell, R. and S. Bond (1998): “Initial Conditions and Moment Restrictions in Dynamic Panel Data Models,” Journal of Econometrics, 87, 115–143.

Boehm, C. E. (2019): “Government Consumption and Investment: Does the Composition of Purchases A�ect the Multiplier?” Journal of Monetary Economics, Forthcoming.

Bond, S. (2002): “Dynamic Panel Data Models: A Guide to Micro Data Methods and Practice,” Working Paper CWP09/02, Cemmap, Institute for Fiscal Studies.

Borge, L.-E., P. Parmer, and R. Torvik (2015): “Local Natural Resource Curse?” Journal of Public Economics, 131, 101–114.

Brollo, F., T. Nannicini, R. Perotti, and G. Tabellini (2013): “�e Political Resource Curse,” American Economic Review, 103, 1759–1796.

Buettner, T. and D. E. Wildasin (2006): “�e Dynamics of Municipal Fiscal Adjustment,” Journal of Public Economics, 90, 1115–1132.

Burgess, R., M. Hansen, B. A. Olken, P. Potapov, and S. Sieber (2012): “�e Political Economy of Deforestation in the Tropics,” �arterly Journal of Economics, 127, 1707–1754.

Cameron, A. C., J. B. Gelbach, and D. L. Miller (2011): “Robust Inference With Multiway Clustering,” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, 29, 238–249.

Caselli, F. and G. Michaels (2013): “Do Oil Windfalls Improve Living Standards? Evidence from Brazil,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5, 208–238.

Cassidy, T. (2018): “�e Long-Run E�ects of Oil Wealth on Development: Evidence from Petroleum Geology,” Economic Journal, forthcoming.

Christelis, D., D. Georgarakos, T. Jappelli, L. Pistaferri, and M. van Rooij (2019): “Asymmetric Consumption Eff�ects of Transitory Income Shocks,” Economic Journal, Forthcoming.

Cust, J. and T. Harding (2017): “Institutions and the Location of Oil Exploration,” Working paper, NHH Norwegian School of Economics.

Cust, J. and C. Viale (2016): “Is �ere Evidence for a Subnational Resource Curse?” Policy paper, Natural Resource Governance Institute.

Dahlberg, M. and T. Lindstr¨om (1998): “Are Local Governments Governed by Forward Looking Decision Makers? An Investigation of Spending Pa�erns in Swedish Municipalities,” Journal of Urban Economics, 44, 254–271.

Dahlberg, M., E. M¨ork, J. Rattso, and H. °Agren (2008): “Using a Discontinuous Grant Rule to Identify the E�ect of Grants on Local Taxes and Spending,” Journal of Public Economics, 92, 2320–2335.

Dahlby, B. and E. Ferede (2016): “�e Stimulative E�ects of Intergovernmental Grants and the Marginal Cost of Public Funds,” International Tax and Public Finance, 23, 114–139.

Fitrani, F., B. Hofman, and K. Kaiser (2005): “Unity in Diversity? �e Creation of New Local Governments in a Decentralising Indonesia,” Bulletin of Indonesian Economic Studies, 41, 57–79.

Flavin, M. A. (1981): “�e Adjustment of Consumption to Changing Expectations About Future Income,” Journal of Political Economy, 89, 974–1009.

Gadenne, L. (2017): “Tax Me, But Spend Wisely? Sources of Public Finance and Government Accountability,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 9, 274–314.

Gadenne, L. and M. Singhal (2014): “Decentralization in Developing Economies,” Annual Review of Economics, 6, 581–604.

Gennari, E. and G. Messina (2014): “How Sticky are Local Expenditures in Italy? Assessing the Relevance of the Flypaper E�ect through Municipal Data,” International Tax and Public Finance, 21, 324–344.

Gordon, N. (2004): “Do Federal Grants Boost School Spending? Evidence from Title I,” Journal of Public Economics, 88, 1771–1792.

Harris, R. D. F. and E. Tzavalis (1999): “Inference for Unit Roots in Dynamic Panels where the Time Dimension is Fixed,” Journal of Econometrics, 91, 201–226.

Hines, J. R. and R. H. Thaler (1995): “�e Flypaper E�ect,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9, 217–226.

Hofman, B., Kadjatmiko, K. Kaiser, and B. S. Sjahrir (2006): “Evaluating Fiscal Equalization in Indonesia,” Policy Research Working Paper 3911, World Bank.

Holtz-Eakin, D., W. Newey, and H. S. Rosen (1988): “Estimating Vector Autoregressions with Panel Data,” Econometrica, 56, 1371–1395.

Holtz-Eakin, D. and H. S. Rosen (1991): “Municipal Labor Demand in the Presence of Uncertainty: An Econometric Approach,” Journal of Labor Economics, 9, 276–293. ——— (1993): “Municipal Construction Spending: An Empirical Examination,” Economics and Politics, 5, 61–84.

Holtz-Eakin, D., H. S. Rosen, and S. Tilly (1994): “Intertemporal Analysis of State and Local Government Spending: Th�eory and Tests,” Journal of Urban Economics, 35, 159–174.

Inman, R. P. (2008): “�e Flypaper E�ect,” Working Paper 14579, NBER.

James, A. (2015): “U.S. State Fiscal Policy and Natural Resources,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 7, 238–257.

Knight, B. (2002): “Endogenous Federal Grants and Crowd-Out of State Government Spending: �Theory and Evidence from the Federal Highway Aid Program,” American Economic Review, 92, 71–92.

Ladd, H. F. (1993): “State Responses to the TRA86 Revenue Windfalls: A New Test of the Flypaper E�ect,” Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 12, 82–103.

Leland, H. E. (1968): “Saving and Uncertainty: �e Precautionary Demand for Saving,” �arterly Journal of Economics, 82, 465–473.

Lewis, B. D. and A. Oosterman (2009): “�e Impact of Decentralization on Subnational Government Fiscal Slack in Indonesia,” Public Budgeting and Finance, 29, 27–47.

Litschig, S. and K. M. Morrison (2013): “�e Impact of Intergovernmental Transfers on Education Outcomes and Poverty Reduction,” American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 5, 206–240.

Liu, C. and G. Ma (2016): “Taxation without Representation: Local Fiscal Response to Intergovernmental Transfers in China,” International Tax and Public Finance, 23, 854–874.

Lundqvist, H. (2015): “Granting Public or Private Consumption? E�ects of Grants on Local Public Spending and Income Taxes,” International Tax and Public Finance, 22, 41–72.

Lutz, B. (2010): “Taxation with Representation: Intergovernmental Grants in a Plebiscite Democracy,” Review of Economics and Statistics, 92, 316–332.

Martinez, L. R. (2017): “Sources of Revenue and Government Performance: Evidence from Colombia,” Working paper, University of Chicago.

Michaillat, P. (2014): “A �eory of Countercyclical Government Multiplier,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 6, 190–217.

Monteiro, J. and C. Ferraz (2012): “Does Oil Make Leaders Unaccountable? Evidence from Brazil’s O�shore Oil Boom,” Working paper, PUC-Rio.

Natural Resource Governance Institute (2016): “Natural Resource Revenue Sharing,” Technical report, Natural Resource Governance Institute.

Nickell, S. (1981): “Biases in Dynamic Models with Fixed E�ects,” Econometrica, 49, 1417–1426.

Obstfeld, M. and K. Rogoff (1996): Foundations of International Macroeconomics, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, �rst ed.

Reinikka, R. and J. Svensson (2004): “Local Capture: Evidence from a Central Government Transfer Program in Uganda,” �arterly Journal of Economics, 119, 679–705.

Roodman, D. (2009): “A Note on the �eme of Too Many Instruments,” Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 71, 135–158.

Rystad Energy (2016): “UCube Database,” h�ps://www.rystadenergy.com/Products/ EnP-Solutions/UCube, accessed September 18, 2016.

Sanderson, E. and F. Windmeijer (2016): “A Weak Instrument F-test in Linear IV Models with Multiple Endogenous Variables,” Journal of Econometrics, 190, 212–221.

Shah, A., R. Qibthiyyah, and A. Dita (2012): “General Purpose Central-Provincial-Local Transfers (DAU) in Indonesia: From Gap Filling to Ensuring Fair Access to Essential Public Services for All,” Working paper, World Bank.

Skoufias, E., A. Narayan, B. Dasgupta, and K. Kaiser (2014): “Electoral Accountability and Local Government Spending in Indonesia,” Policy Research Working Paper 6782, World Bank.

UNFPA Indonesia (2014): “Midwifery Consultancy Report,” Technical report, United Nations Population Fund.

van der Ploeg, F. (2011): “Natural Resources: Curse or Blessing?” Journal of Economic Literature, 49, 366–420.

van der Ploeg, F. and A. J. Venables (2013): “Absorbing a Windfall of Foreign Exchange: Dutch Disease Dynamics,” Journal of Development Economics, 103, 229–243.

Vegh, C. A. and G. Vuletin (2015): “Unsticking the Flypaper E�ect in an Uncertain World,” Journal of Public Economics, 131, 142–155.

World Bank (2003): “Decentralizing Indonesia: A Regional Public Expenditure Review Overview Report,” Technical report, World Bank, Jakarta.

——— (2007): “Spending for Development: Making the Most of Indonesia’s Opportunities,” Technical report, World Bank, Jakarta.

——— (2010): “Village Capacity in Maintaining Infrastructure: Evidence from Rural Indonesia,” Technical report, World Bank, Jakarta.

Zeldes, S. P. (1989): “Consumption and Liquidity Constraints: An Empirical Investigation,” Journal of Political Economy, 97, 305–346.

Zou, H. (1994): “Dynamic E�ects of Federal Grants on Local Spending,” Journal of Urban Economics, 36, 98–115.