Efficiency of Healthcare Systems in the first wave of COVID-19 - a technical efficiency analysis

Breitenbach, Marthinus C and Ngobeni, Victor and Aye, Goodness (2020): Efficiency of Healthcare Systems in the first wave of COVID-19 - a technical efficiency analysis.

Abstract

In this novel paper, we make use of a non-parametric method known as Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) to analyse the 31 most infected countries during the first 100 days since the outbreak of the COVID-19 coronavirus for the efficiency in containing the spread of the virus – a question yet to be answered in the literature. Our model showed 12 of the 31 countries in our sample were efficient and 19 inefficient in the use of resources to manage the flattening of their COVID-19 contagion curves. Among the worst performers were some of the richest countries in the world, Germany, Canada, the USA and Austria, with efficiency between 50 and 60 per cent - more inefficient than Italy, France and Belgium, who were some of those hardest hit by the spread of the virus.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Pandemic, COVID-19, Flattening the Curve, Data Envelopment Analysis, Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions, Healthcare, Technical Efficiency, Healthcare system efficiency barometer.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C6 - Mathematical Methods ; Programming Models ; Mathematical and Simulation Modeling > C61 - Optimization Techniques ; Programming Models ; Dynamic Analysis; D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D24 - Production ; Cost ; Capital ; Capital, Total Factor, and Multifactor Productivity ; Capacity; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I10 - General

References

Afonso, A. and St. Aubyn, M. (2006). Relative Efficiency of Health Provision: A DEA Approach with Non-Discretionary Inputs.

Akazili, J. Adjuik, M. Jehu-Appiah, C. and Zere, E. (2008). Using Data Envelopment Analysis to Measure the Extent of Technical Efficiency of Public Health Centres in Ghana. BMC International Health and Human Rights, 8(1), p.11.

Alhassan, R.K. Nketiah-Amponsah, E. Akazili, J. Spieker, N. Arhinful, D.K. and De Wit, T.F.R. (2015). Efficiency of Private and Public Primary Health Facilities Accredited by the National Health Insurance Authority in Ghana. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation, 13(1), p.23.

Anton, S.G. (2013). Technical Efficiency in the Use of Health Care Resources: A Cross-Country Analysis. Annals of the Alexandru Ioan Cuza University-Economics, 60(1), pp.1-12.

Aristovnik, A. (2012). The Impact of ICT on Educational Performance and its Efficiency in Selected EU and OECD Countries: A Non-Parametric Analysis.

Avkiran, N.K. (2001). Investigating Technical and Scale Efficiencies of Australian Universities through Data Envelopment Analysis. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences, 35(1), pp.57-80.

Barro, R. J., Ursúa, J. F. and Weng J. (2020). The coronavirus and the great influenza pandemic: Lessons from the “Spanish flu” for the coronavirus’s potential effects on mortality and economic activity. Working Paper 26866, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Bhat, V. N. (2005). Institutional arrangements and efficiency of health care delivery systems. European Journal of Health Economics, 50, 215-222.

Bootsma, M. C. J. and N. M. Ferguson. (2007). The effect of public health measures on the 1918 influenza pandemic in U.S. cities. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(18), 7588–7593.

Campanella, P. Azzolini, E. Izzi, A. Pelone, F. De Meo, C. La Milia, C.D. Specchia, M.L and Ricciardi, W. (2017). Hospital Efficiency: How to Spend Less Maintaining Quality. Ann Ist Super Sanita, 53(1), pp.46-53.

Chowdhury, H. Zelenyuk, V. Wodchis, W. and Laporte, A. (2010). Efficiency and Technological Change in Health Care Services in Ontario (No. WP082010). School of Economics, University of Queensland, Australia.

Coelli, T.J. Rao, D.S.P. O’Donnell, C.J. and Battese, G.E. (2005). An Introduction to Efficiency and Productivity Analysis. Springer Science & Business Media.

Cooper, W.W. Seiford. L.M. and Tone, K. (2007). Data Envelopment Analysis: A Comprehensive Text with Models, Applications, References and DEA-Solver Software. Springer, New York, USA.

Correia, S., Luck, S. and Verner, E. (2020). Pandemics Depress the Economy, Public Health Interventions Do Not: Evidence from the 1918 Flu. Draft Paper. This preprint research paper has not been peer reviewed. Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3561560

de Cos, P. H., Moral-Benito, E. (2014). Determinants of health-system efficiency: evidence from OECD countries. International Journal of Health Care Finance Economics, 14, 69-93. (16) (PDF) Efficiency vs Effectiveness: a Benchmarking Study on European Healthcare Systems.

Eichenbaum, M. S., S. Rebelo, and M. Trabandt. (2020). The macroeconomics of epidemics. Working Paper 26882, National Bureau of Economic Research.

Frogner, B. K., Frech, H. E., Parente, S. T. (2015). Comparing efficiency of health systems across industrialized countries: a panel analysis. BMC Health Services Research, 15, 415-426. (16) (PDF) Efficiency vs Effectiveness: a Benchmarking Study on European Healthcare Systems.

Gannon, B. (2005). Testing for Variation in Technical Efficiency of Hospitals in Ireland. The Economic and Social Review, Vol. 36 (3), pp. 273-294.

Garrett, T. A. (2008). Pandemic economics: the 1918 influenza and its modern-day implications. Review 90 (Mar), 74–94.

Gavurova, B. Kocisova, K. Belas, L. and Krajcik, V. (2017). Relative Efficiency of Government Expenditure on Secondary Education. Journal of International Studies 10(2), pp. 329-343.

Giuffrida, A., Gravelle, H. (2001). Measuring performance in primary care: econometric analysis and DEA. Applied Economics, 33, 163-175.

González, E., Cárcaba, A., Ventura, J. (2010). Value efficiency analysis of health systems: does public financing play a role? Journal of Public Health, 18(4), 337-350. (16) (PDF) Efficiency vs Effectiveness: a Benchmarking Study on European Healthcare Systems.

Gourinchas, P. O. (2020). Flattening pandemic and recession curves. Working Paper.

Hatchett, R. J., C. E. Mecher, and M. Lipsitch. (2007). Public health interventions and epidemic intensity during the 1918 influenza pandemic. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 104(18), 7582–7587.

Hadad, S., Hadad, Y., Simon-Tuval, T. (2013). Determinants of healthcare system’s efficiency in OECD countries. European Journal of Health Economics, 14, 253-265. (16) (PDF) Efficiency vs Effectiveness: a Benchmarking Study on European Healthcare Systems.

Hollingsworth, B. (2003). Non-parametric and parametric applications measuring efficiency in health care. Health Care Management Science, 6, 203-218.

International Monetary Fund. (2020). Policy Responses to COVID-19. International Monetary Fund. Accessed, 30 April 2020. https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/imf-and-covid19/Policy-Responses-to-COVID-19

Jarjue, G. Nor, N.M. Ghani, J.A. and Jalil, S.H. (2015). Technical Efficiency of Secondary Health Care Service Delivery in the Gambia. International Journal of Economics & Management, 9(1).

Johns Hopkins University and Medicine. (2020). Coronavirus Resource Centre. Johns Hopkins University and Medicine. Accessed, 30 April 2020. https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/map.html

Jouzdani, J. (2020). Fight against COVID-19: A global outbreak response management performance view. Journal of Project Management. Vol 5. homepage: www.GrowingScience.com.

Kim, Y. and Kang, M. (2014). The Measurement of Health Care System Efficiency: Cross-country Comparison by Geographical Region. Accessed, 01 January 2019. http://s-space.snu.ac.kr/bitstream/10371/91911/1/02_Younhee_Kim.pdf

Kim, Y. Oh. D., Kang, M. (2016). Productivity changes in OECD healthcare systems: bias-corrected Malmquist productivity approach. International Journal of Health Planning Management, 31,537-553.

Kirigia, J.M. Sambo, L.G. and Scheel, H. (2001). Technical Efficiency of Public Clinics in Kwazulu-Natal Province of South Africa. East African Medical Journal, 78(3), pp.1-14.

Kirigia, J.M. Lambo, E. and Sambo, L.G. (2000). Are Public Hospitals in KwaZulu-Natal Province of South Africa Technically Efficient? African Journal of Health Sciences, 7(3-4), p.25.

Lauro, A., Dos Santos Figueiredo, O.H. and Wanke, P.F. (2016). Efficiency of Municipal Schools in Rio de Janeiro: Evidence from Two-Stage DEA. Journal of Economics and Economic Education Research, 17(3), p.147.

Lo Storto, C. and Goncharuk, A.G. (2017). Efficiency vs Effectiveness: A Benchmarking Study on European Healthcare Systems. Economics and Sociology, 10(3), 102-115. Accessed, 28 January 2019.

Lubrano, A. (2020). The world has suffered through other deadly pandemics. But the response to coronavirus is unprecedented. The Philadelphia Inquirer. 28 April 2020. Accessed online on 28 April 2020 at https://www.inquirer.com/health/coronavirus/coronavirus-philadelphia-spanish-flu-world-war-two-civil-war-pandemic-aids-20200322.html

Markel, H., Lipman, H. B. Navarro, J. A., Sloan, A., Michalsen, J. R., Stern A. M., and Cetron M. S. (2007). Non-pharmaceutical Interventions Implemented by US Cities During the 1918-1919 Influenza Pandemic. JAMA 298(6), 644–654.

Marschall, P. and Flessa, S. (2009). Assessing the Efficiency of Rural Health Centres in Burkina Faso: An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis. Journal of Public Health, 17(2), p.87.

Martić, M. Novaković, M and Baggia, A. (2009). Data Envelopment Analysis-Basic Models and their Utilization. Organizacija, 42(2), pp.37-43. Accessed, 24 January 2019. https://www.degruyter.com/downloadpdf/j/orga.2009.42.issue-2/v10051-009-0001-6/v10051-009-0001-6.xml

Masiye, F. (2007). Investigating Health System Performance: An Application of Data Envelopment Analysis to Zambian Hospitals. BMC Health Services Research, 7(1), p.58. https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1472-6963-7-58

Mbuvha, R. and Marwala, T. (2020). On Data-Driven Management of the COVID-19 Outbreak in South Africa. MedRxiv. https://doi.org/10.1101/2020.04.07.20057133.

McWilliams, A. Siegel, D. and Van Fleet, D. D. (2005). Scholarly Journals as Producers of Knowledge: Theory and Empirical Evidence Based on Data Envelopment Analysis. Organisational Research Methods, 8(2), pp.185-201.

Newey S. and Gulland A. (2020). What is coronavirus, how did it start and how big could it get? The Telegraph. 28 April 2020. Available online at https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2020/04/28/what-is-coronavirus-covid-19-virus-pandemic/ Date accessed: 28 April.

Ngobeni, V. Breitenbach, M.C. & Aye, G. (2020). Technical Efficiency of Provincial Public Healthcare in South Africa. Cost Effectiveness & Resource Allocation, Vol 18:3. BMC Springer Nature.

Nolte, E. Wait, S. McKee, M. (2006). Investing in Health: Benchmarking Health Systems. Technical report published by. The Nuffield Trust, London. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320508371_Efficiency_vs_Effectiveness_a_Benchmarking_Study_on_European_Healthcare_Systems [accessed May 08 2020].

Ramírez Hassan A. (2008). Consequences of Omitting Relevant Inputs on the Quality of the Data Envelopment Analysis Under Different Input Correlation Structures.

Shirouyehzad, H. Jouzdani, J. and Khodadadi-Karimvand, M. (2020). Fight Against COVID-19: A Global Efficiency Evaluation based on Contagion Control and Medical Treatment. Journal of Applied Research on Industrial Engineering. Vol.7, No.2 (2020) 109-120.

Taylor, B. and Harris, G. (2004). Relative Efficiency among South African Universities: A Data Envelopment Analysis. Higher Education, 47(1), pp.73-89.

The World Bank. (2020a). Current Health Expenditure (% of GDP). The World Bank. Accessed, 15 April 2020. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.XPD.CHEX.GD.ZS

The World Bank. (2020b). Physicians per 1 000 population. The World Bank. Accessed, 15 April 2020. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.MED.PHYS.ZS

Varabyova, Y. and Schreyögg, J. (2013). International Comparisons of the Technical Efficiency of the Hospital Sector: Panel Data Analysis of OECD Countries using Parametric and Non-Parametric Approaches. Health Policy, 112(1-2), pp.70-79. Accessed, 15 January 2019 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168851013000675

Wang, E.C. and Alvi, E. (2011). Relative Efficiency of Government Spending and its Determinants: Evidence from East Asian Countries. Eurasian Economic Review, 1(1), pp.3-28.

Worldometer. (2020). COVID-19 Coronavirus Pandemic. Worldometer. Accessed, 30 April 2020. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/

Yawe, B.L. (2014). Technical efficiency and Productivity of Primary Schools in Uganda. Accessed, 31 January 2019. https://www.africaportal.org/documents/17554/RP277.pdf

Yuan, Y. and Shan, M. (2016). The Educational Efficiency Evaluation Framework: By Using DEA Model and CA Method. International Journal of Information and Education Technology. 6(12), p. 923.

Zere, E. Mbeeli, T. Shangula, K. Mandlhate, C. Mutirua, K. Tjivambi, B. and Kapenambili, W. (2006). Technical Efficiency of District Hospitals: Evidence from Namibia Using Data Envelopment Analysis. Cost Effectiveness and Resource Allocation, 4(1), p.1.