A Cointegration and Causality Test on Government Expenditure –Economic Growth Nexus: Empirical Evidence from a South African Province

Omoshoro-Jones, Oyeyinka Sunday (2016): A Cointegration and Causality Test on Government Expenditure –Economic Growth Nexus: Empirical Evidence from a South African Province.

Abstract

This paper examines the longstanding debate on government expenditure–economic growth nexus based on two opposing theories (i.e., Wagner’s Law and Keynesian theory) focusing on the Free State (FS) province in South Africa using both bivariate and trivariate models estimated for the period 2001:Q1 to 2014:Q4. Time-series on population per capita is used as a third variable in the multivariate to obviate the ‘omitted variable’ problem and erroneous conclusion on the existing causative links among variables. The long-run relations and causal links were tested employing the Autoregressive Distributed Lag (ARDL)–bounds testing approach and Toda-Yamamoto causality test. Our results show a bi-directional causal link between total provincial government expenditure (PGE) and economic growth (real GDP) in the short run, while the real GDP Granger-causes PGE in the long-run. We also find a unidirectional causal flow from population growth to both GDP and PGE in the short-run, suggesting that demographic factor plays a key role in explaining a rise in total PGE. Other evidence reveals a long-run income elasticity ranging from 0.99 to 1.2% suggesting that a 1% rise in real GDP in the FS province can cause PGE to rise by 0.99 – 1.2%. The result on ‘voracity effect’ shows that external shock could lead to an increase of about 0.49 – 2.12% in total PGE, in the short-run. These findings provide concrete support for the adopted stringent fiscal consolidation stance by the provincial government to ensure efficient allocation of limited available fiscal resources, curb wasteful expenditure and reduce government size. Albeit, the bi-directional causal link between real GDP and PGE requires policymakers to prudently balance both current and future public expenditures in order not to crowd-out output and labour productivity.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: ARDL, Toda-Yamamoto causality test, Wagner’s Law, Keynesian theory, Free State province.
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C51 - Model Construction and Estimation; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C54 - Quantitative Policy Modeling; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook > E62 - Fiscal Policy; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O2 - Development Planning and Policy > O23 - Fiscal and Monetary Policy in Development

References

Abdullah, H., Habibullah, M., Baharumshah, A. Z., & Hui, T. B. (2007). Long-Run Relationship between Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth in Asia: Evidence Using Pedroni’s Cointegration Approach. Malaysian Management Journal, 11(1&2), 49-67.

Abedian, I., & Standish, B. (1984). An Analysis of the Sources of Growth in State Expenditure in South Africa, 1920-1982. South African Journal of Economics, 4, 392-410.

Abizadeh, S., & Yousefi, M. (1988). An Empirical Examination of Wagner's Law. Economics Letters, 26, 169-173.

Abu–Eideh, O. (2015). Causality between Public Expenditure and GDP Growth in Palestine: An Econometric Analysis of Wagner’s Law. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, 6(2), 189-199.

Afxentiou, P., & Serletis, A. (1996). Government Expenditures in the European Union: Do They Converge or Follow Wagner's Law? International Economic Journal, 10(3), 33-47.

Ahmad U, G., & Loganathan, N. (2016). The Causal Nexus between Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in Nigeria: Evidence from a Bootstrap Rolling Window Approach. The American Journal of Innovative Research and Applied Sciences, 2(1), 16-24.

Ahsan, S. M., Kwan, A. C., & Sahni, B. (1992). Public Expenditure and National Income Causality: Further Evidence on the Role of Omitted Variables. Southern Economic Journal, 58(3), 623-634.

Ahsan, S. M., Kwan, A., & Sahni, B. (1996). Cointegration and Wagner’s Hypothesis: Time Series Evidence for Canada. Applied Economics, 28, 1055-1058.

Ahsan, S. M., Kwan, A. C., & Sahni, B. (1992). Public Expenditure and National Income Causality: Further Evidence on the Role of Omitted Variables. Southern Economic Journal, 58(3), 623-634.

Akitoby, B., Clements, B., Gupta, S., & Inchaust, G. (2006). Public Spending, Voracity, and Wagner’s Law in Developing Countries. European Journal of Political Economy, 22, 908-924.

Algan, Y., Cahuc, P., & Zylberberg, A. (2002). Public Employment and Labour Market Performance. Economic Policy, 34, 7-65.

Alimi, S. R. (2013). Testing Augmented Wagner's Law for Nigeria Based on Cointegration and Error-Correction Modelling Techniques. MPRA Paper No. 52319. Retrieved from https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/52319/

Alm, J., & Embaye, A. (2010). Explaining the Growth of Government Spending in South Africa. South African Journal of Economics, 78(2), 152-159.

Alshahrani, S. A., & Alsadiq, A. (2014). Economic Growth and Government Spending in Saudi Arabia: An Empirical Investigation. IMF Working Paper, WP/14/3.

Al-Shatti, A. (2014). The Impact of Public Expenditures on Economic Growth in Jordan. International Journal of Economics and Finance, 6(10), 157-166.

Al-Zeuod, H. (2013). The Causal Relationship between Government Expenditures and Economic Growth: Evidence form Jordan. Al-Manara, 19(4), 43-56.

Amin, S-B. (2011). Causal Relationship between Consumption Expenditure and Economic Growth in Bangladesh. World Journal of Social Sciences, 1(2), 158-169.

Ansari, M. I., Grdon, D. V., & Akuamoah, C. (1997). Keynes versus Wagner: Public Expenditure and National Income for Three African Countries. Applied Economics, 29(4), 545-550.

Arpaia, A., & Turrini, A. (2008). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in the EU: Long-Run Tendencies and Short-Term Adjustment. European Commission. doi:10.2765/22776

Aschauer, D. A. (1988). Is Public Expenditure Productive? Journal of Monetary Economics, 23, 177-200. Asghar, N., Azim, P., & Hafeez, R. U. (2011). Impact of Government Spending in Social Sectors on Economic Growth: A Case Study of Pakistan. Journal of Business and Economics, 3(2), 214-234.

Atasoy, B., & Gür, T. H. (2016). Does the Wagner’s Hypothesis Hold for China? Evidence from Static and Dynamic Analyses. Panoeconomicus, 63(1), 45-60.

Atkinson, A. B. and Stiglitz, J. E. (1980) Lectures on Public Economics, McGraw-Hill, New York.

Babatunde, M. A. (2011). A Bound Testing Analysis of Wagner's Law in Nigeria: 1970–2006. Applied Economics, 43(21), 2843-2850.

Barro, R. J. (1990). Government Spending in a Simple Model of Endogenous Growth. Journal of Political Economy, 98(5), 108-125.

Barth, J., & Brady, M. (1987). The Impact of Government spending on Economic Activity. Manuscript. George Washington University, Washington, DC.

Bird, R. (1971). Wagner's Law of Expanding State Activity. Public Finance, 26, 1-26.

Bojanic, A. (2013). Testing the Validity of Wagner’s Law in Bolivia: A Cointegration and Causality Analysis with Disaggregated Data. Revista de Aálisis Ecónomico, 28(1), 25-45.

Brown, R. L., Durbin, J., & Evans, J. M. (1975). Techniques for Testing the Constancy of Regression relations over time. Journal of the Royal Statistical, 37, 149-192.

Çakerri, L., Petanaj, M., & Muharremi, O. (2014). The Effect of Government Expenditures on Economic Growth: The Case of Albania. European Journal of Social Sciences Education and Research, 2(1), 242-253.

Chang, T. (2002). An Econometric Test of Wagner’s Law for Six Countries Based on Cointegration and Error-Correction Modelling Techniques. Applied Economics, 34, 1157-1169.

Chang, T., Liu, W., & Caudill, S. (2004). A re-examination of Wagner’s Law for Ten Countries Based on Cointegration and Error-Correction Modelling Techniques. Applied Financial Economics, 14, 577-589.

Cheng, Benjamin, S., & Lai, T. W. (1997). Government Expenditures and Economic Growth in South Korea: A VAR Approach. Journal of Economic Development, 22(1), 11-24.

Chimobi, O. (2009). Government Expenditure and National income: A Causality Test for Nigeria. European Journal of Economic and Political Studies, 1-11.

Christie, T. (2014). The Effect of Government Spending on Economic Growth: Testing the Non-Linear Hypothesis. Bulletin of Economic Research, 66(2), 183-204.

Chude, N. P., & Chude, D. I. (2013). Impact of Government Expenditure on Economic Growth in Nigeria. International Journal of Business and Management Review, 1(4), 64-71.

Constantinos, A. (2009). Government Spending and Economic Growth: Econometric Evidence from the South Eastern Europe (SEE). Journal of Economic and Social Research, 11(1), 1-16.

Cotsomitis, J., Harnhirun, S., & Kwan, A. (1996). Co-integration Analysis and the Long Run Validity of Wagner’s Hypothesis: Evidence from the People’s Republic of China. Journal of Economic Development, 21, 1-10.

Dada, A. M. (2013). Empirical Investigation of Government Expenditure and Revenue Nexus: Implication for Fiscal Sustainability in Nigeria. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, 4(9), 135-145.

Dada, M., & Adewale, O. (2013). Is Wagner’s Law a Myth or a Reality? Empirical Evidence from Nigeria. International Journal of Development and Economic Sustainability, 1(1), 123-137.

Danladi, J., Komolafe, K. J., Olarinde, O., & Anyadiegwu, N. (2015). Government Expenditure and Its Implication for Economic Growth: Evidence from Nigeria. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, 6(18).

Devarajan, S., Swaroop, V., & Zou, H-F. (1996). The Composition of Public Expenditure and Economic Growth. Journal of Monetary Economics, 37, 3 1 3- 344.

Diamond, J. (1989). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth: An Empirical Investigation. IMF Working Paper. WP/89/45.

Dickey, D., & Fuller, W. A. (1979). Distribution of the Estimates for Autoregressive Time-Series with a Unit Root. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 74, 427-431.

Dilrukshini, W. (2009). Public Expenditure and Economic Growth in Sri Lanka: Cointegration Analysis and Causality Testing. Central Bank of Sri Lanka, Staff Studies, 34(1-2), 51-68. Retrieved from http://doi.org/10.4038/ss.v34i1.1239

Dogan, E., & Tang, T. (2006). Government Expenditure and National Income: Causality Tests for Five South East Asian Countries. International Business & Economics Research Journal, 5(10), 49-56.

Dritsakis, N., & Adamopoulos, A. (2004). A Causal Relationship between Government Spending and Economic Development: An Empirical Examination of the Greek Economy. Applied Economics, 36, 457-464.

Durevall, D., & Henrekson, M. (2011). The Futile Quest for Grand Explanation of Long-run Government Expenditure. Journal of Public Economics, 95, 708-722.

Edward, H., & Kon, S. (1994). Government Spending And Economic Growth: the G-7 experience. Applied Economics, 26, 535-542.

Elliot, G., Rothenberg, T., & Stock, J. (1996). Efficient Tests for an Autoregressive Unit root. Econometrica, 64, 813-816.

Engle, R. F., & Granger, C. W. (1987). Co-integration and Error-Correction: Representation, Estimation and Testing. Econometrica, 55, 251-276.

Free State Provincial Treasury. (2016). 2016 Provincial Budget Speech. Bloemfontein, Free State.

Gadinabokao, L., & Daw, D. (2013). An Empirical Examination of the Relationship between Government Spending and Economic Growth in South Africa, from 1980 to 2011. Mediterranean Journal of Social Sciences, 4(3), 235-242.

Garba, T., & Abdullahi, S. Y. (2013). Public Expenditure and Economic Growth: An Application of Cointegration and Granger Causality Tests on Nigeria. Journal of Economic and Social Research, 15(1), 1-30.

Gemmell, N., Kneller, R., & Sanz, I. (2015). Does the Composition of Government Expenditure Matter for Long-Run GDP Levels? Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 0305–9049, 1-25.

Ghali, H. (1997). Government Spending and Economic Growth in Saudi Arabia. Journal of Economic Development, 22(2), 165-172.

Govindaraju, V., Rao, R., & Anwar, S. (2011). Economic growth and government spending in Malaysia: a re-examination of Wagner and Keynesian views. Econ Change Restruc, 44, 203-219.

Granger, C. J. (1969). Investigation causal relationship by Econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica, 37, 424-438.

Granger, C. J. (1986). Developments in the Study of Cointegrated Economic Variables. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 213-228.

Granger, C. J., & Newbold, P. (1974). Spurious Regressions in Econometrics. Journal of Econometrics, 111-120.

Grenade, K., & Wright, A. (2014). Public Spending in Selected Caribbean Countries: Testing Wagner’s Law and the Ratchet Hypothesis. Public Finance Review, 42, 487-510.

Gupta, S. P. (1967). Public Expenditure and Economic Growth: A Time Series Analysis. Public Finance, 22, 423-466.

Gupta, S. P. (1968). Public Expenditure and Economic Development: A Cross-Section Analysis. Finanzarchiv, 27, 26-41.

Gürgül, H., Lukasz, L., & Mestel, R. (2012). The Relationship between Budgetary Expenditure and Economic Growth in Poland. Central European Journal of Operations Research, 20(1), 161-182.

Halicioglu, F. (2003). Testing Wagner’s Law for Turkey, 1960–2000. Review Middle East Economic and Finance, 1(2), 129-140.

Hendry, D. (1986). Econometric Modelling with Co-integrated Variables: An Overview. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 201-212.

Henrekson, M. (1993). Wagner's Law - A Spurious Relationship. Public Finance, 48, 406-415.

Ho, T. W. (2004). Cointegration, Government Spending and Private Consumption: Evidence from Japan. The Japanese Economic Review, 55(2), 163-174.

Holmes, J. M., & Hutton, P. A. (1990). On the Casual Relationship between Government Expenditures and National Income. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 72(1), 87-95.

Huang, C. J. (2006). Government Expenditures in China and Taiwan: Do they follow Wagner’s Law? Journal of Economic Development, 31(2), 139-148.

Ibok, O. W., & Bassey, N. E. (2013). Wagner's Law Revisited: The Case of Nigerian Agricultural Sector (1961 – 2012). International Journal of Food and Agricultural Economics, 2(3), 19-32.

Ighodaro, C. A., & Oriakhi, D. (2010). Does The Relationship Between Government Expenditure and Economic Growth Follow? Annals of the University of Petroşani, Economics, 10(2), 185-198.

Islam, A. M. (2001). Wagner's Law Revisited: Cointegration and Exogeneity Tests for the USA. Applied Economics Letters, 8(8), 509-515.

Iyare, S. O., & Lorde, T. (2006). Co-integration, Causality and Wagner's Law: Tests for Selected Caribbean Countries. Applied Economics Letters, 11(13), 815-825.

Johansen, S., & Juselius, K. (1990). Maximum Likelihood Estimation and Inference on Cointegration with Applications to the Demand for Money. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 52, 169-210.

Johansen, S., & Juselius, K. (1992). Testing Structural Hypothesis in a Multivariate Cointegration Analysis of the PPP and the UIP for UK. Journal of Econometrics, 53, 211-244.

Kalam, M., & Aziz, N. (2009). Growth of Government Expenditure in Bangladesh: An Empirical Enquiry into the Validity of Wagner’s Law. Global Economy Journal. 9(2), 1-18.

Kamasa, K., & Ofori-Abebrese, G. (2015). Wagner or Keynes for Ghana? Government Expenditure and Economic Growth Dynamics:A VAR Approach. Journal of Reviews on Global Economics, 4, 177-183.

Karagianni, S., & Pempetzoglou, M. (2009). Evidence for Non-Linear Causality between Public Spending and Income in the European Union Countries. The Journal of Applied Business Research, 25(1), 69-82.

Karagianni, S., Pempetzoglou, M., & Strikou, S. (2011). Testing Wagner's Law for the European Union Economies. The Journal of Applied Business Research, 18(4), 107-114.

Kesavarajah, M. (2012). Wagner’s Law in Sri Lanka: An Econometric Analysis. International Scholarly Research Network Economics, 1-8.

Keynes, J. (1936). The General Theory of Employment Interest and Money. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World Inc.

Khan, H., & Bashar, O. K. (2015). Social Expenditure and Economic Growth: Evidence from Australia and New Zealand Using Cointegration and Causality Tests. The Journal of Developing Areas, 49(4), 285-300.

Klingman, D., & Peters, B. (1980). Economic Development and the Growth of Public Expenditures in Scandinavia, 1875-1965. Political Studies, XXVIII (1), 20-42.

Kolluri, B., Panik, M., & Wahab, M. S. (2000). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth: Evidence from G7 Countries. Applied Economics, 32, 1059–1068.

Kormendi, R., & Meguire, P. G. (1985). Macroeconomic determinants. Journal of Monetary Economics, 16, 141-163.

Kumar, & Saten. (2009). Further Evidence on Public Spending and Economic Growth in East Asian Countries. MPRA Paper No. 19298, 297-307. Retrieved from http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/19298/

Kumar, S., Webber, D., & Fargher, S. (2012). Wagner’s Law Revisited: Cointegration and Causality tests for New Zealand. Applied Economics, 44(5), 607-616.

Künü, S., & Başa, S. (2015). The Effects of Public Expenditures on Economic Growth: An Empirical Analysis for Turkey. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 6(4), 151-161.

Künü, S., & Hopoğlu, S. (2015). The Relationship Between Sub-Categories of Public Spending and Economic Growth In Turkey: A Causality Analysis. International Journal of Economics and Resources, 6(04), 25-38.

Lahirushan, K. K., & Gunasekara, W. V. (2015). The Impact of Government Expenditure on Economic Growth: A Study of Asian Countries. International Journal of Social, Behavioral, Educational, Economic, Business and Industrial Engineering, 9(9), 3058 - 3066.

Lamartina, S., & Zaghini, A. (2010). Increasing Public Expenditure: Wagner’s Law in OECD Countries. German Economic Review, 12(2), 149-164.

Landau, D. (1983). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth. Southern Economic Journal, 49, 783-792.

Landau, D. (1986). Government and Economic Growth in the Less Developed Countries: An Empirical Study for 1960-1980. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 35(1), 35-75.

Lawal, A., Raphael, N., & Jacob, H. (2015). The Granger Causality Tests on the Impact of Government Expenditure on Economic Growth in Nigeria. International Journal of Research in Science and Technology, 5(IV), 126-134.

Lin, Y. (1994). Government Spending and Economic Growth. Applied Economics, 26(1), 86-94.

Lindauer, D., & Velenchik, A. (1992). Government Spending in Developing Countries: Trends, Causes, and Consequences. The World Bank Research Observer, 7(1), 59-78.

Loizides, J., & Vamvoukas, G. (2004). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth: Evidence from Trivariate Causality Testing. Journal of Applied Economics, VIII (1), 125-152.

Lütkepohl, H. (1982). Non-causality due to Omitted Variables. Journal of Econometrics, 19, 367-378.

Magazzino, C. (2010). Wagner’s Law in Italy: Empirical Evidence from 1960 to 2008. G. & L. E. R., 14(1), 91-115.

Magazzino, C. (2012a). The Nexus between Disagregated Public Spending and GDP in the Euro-Area. Economic Bulletin, 32(3), 2560-2579.

Magazzino, C. (2012b). Wagner’s Law and Augmented Wagner’s Law in EU-27: A Time-Series Analysis on Stationarity, Cointegration and Causality. International Research Journal of Finance and Economics, 89, 205-220.

Mah, J. (2000). An Empirical Examination of the Disaggregated Import Demand of Korea: The Case of Information. Journal of Asian Economics, 11, 237-244.

Mahmoodi, M., & Mahmoodi, E. (2014). Government Expenditure-GDP Nexus: Panel Causality Evidence. International Journal of Economy, Management and Social Sciences, 3(1), 37-42.

Maku, O., & Ajike, E. (2014). Government Spending and Economic Growth Dynamics in Nigeria: A Time series Analysis. EPRA International Journal of Economic and Business Review, 2(12), 169-175.

Mann, A. (1980). Wagner’s law: An Econometric test for Mexico, 1925 - 1976. National Tax Journal, 33, 189- 201.

Mekdad, Y., Dahmani, A., & Louaj, M. (2014). Public spending on education and Economic Growth in Algeria: Causality Test. International Journal of Business and Management, II (3), 55-70.

Menyah, K., & Wolde-Rufael, Y. (2012). Wagner’s Law Revisited: A Note from South Africa. South African Journal of Economics, 80(2), 200-208.

Menyah, K., & Wolde-Rufael, Y. (2013). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth: Ethiopian Experience, 1950-2007. The Journal of Developing Areas. 47(1), 263-280.

Muhammad, F., Xu, T., & Karim, R. (2015). Impact of Expenditure on Economic Growth in Pakistan. International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences. 5(2), 231-236.

Musgrave, R. A. (1969) Fiscal Systems, Yale University Press, New Haven and London.

Narayan, P., Nielsen, I., & Smyth, R. (2008). Panel Data, Cointegration, Causality and Wagner's Law: Empirical Evidence from Chinese Provinces. China Economic Review, 19, 297-307.

National Treasury. (2016). 2016 Budget Speech. Pretoria, South Africa. Retrieved from www.nationaltreasury.gov.za

Ocran, M. K. (2011). Fiscal Policy and Economic Growth in South Africa. Journal of Economic Studies, 38(5), 604-618.

Odhiambo, N. (2015). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in South Africa: An Empirical Investigation. Atlantic Economic Journal, 43, 393-406.

Ogbuagu, M., & Ekpenyong, U. I. (2015). Estimating the Impact of the Components of Public Expenditure on Economic Growth in Nigeria (A Bound Testing Approach). International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management, III (3), 1-8.

Ogundipe, A. A., & Oluwatobi, S. (2013). Government Spending and Economic Growth in Nigeria: Evidence from Disaggregated Analysis. Journal of Business Management and Applied Economics, II (4), 1-10.

Ogunlana, O. F. (2015). Government Expenditure Efficacy and the Question of Growth: Evidence from Nigeria. European Scientific Journal, 11(28), 423-434.

Ojong, C. M., Ekpo, N. S., & Anthony, O. (2016). Government Expenditure and Its Implications on Nigerian Economy. IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 21(1), 50-55. Omoshoro-Jones, O. S. (2016). Exploring the Impact of Provincial Expenditure on EPWP on Economic Growth and Labour Dynamics: ARIMA & VAR Modelling Approach. EAD Staff Working paper series, Economic Analysis Directorate, Free State Provincial Treasury.

Oteng-Abayie, E. (2011). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in 5 ECOWAS Countries: A Panel econometric Estimates. Journal of Economic Theory, 5(1), 11-14.

Oxley, L. (1994). Cointegration, Causality and Wagner’s Law: A Test for Britain, 1870–1913. Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 41, 286-297.

Oyinlola, M. A., & Akinnibosun, O. (2013). Public Expenditure and Economic Growth Nexus: Further evidence from Nigeria. Journal of Economics and International Finance, 5(4), 146-154.

Pahlavani, M., Abed, D., & Pourshabi, F. (2011). Investigating the Keynesian View and Wagner’s Law on the Size of Government and Economic Growth in Iran. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 2(13), 170-175.

Paleologou, S.-M. (2015). The Long-Run Tendency of Government Expenditure: A Semi-Parametric Modelling Approach. Empirical Economics. doi:10.1007/s00181-015-0959-2

Pattichis, C. A. (1999). Price and Income Elasticities of Disaggregated Import Demand: Results from UECMs and an Application. Applied Economics, 31, 1061-1071.

Peacock, A., & Scott, A. (2000). The Curious Attraction of Wagner's Law. Public Choice, 102, 1-17.

Peacock, A., & Wiseman, J. (1979). Approaches to the Analysis of Government Expenditure Growth. Public Finance Quarterly, 7, 3-23.

Permana, Y., & Wika, G.S.M.(2014). Testing the Existence of Wagner Law and Government Expenditure Volatility in Indonesia Post-Reformation Era. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, 5(10), 130-139.

Perron, P. (1997). Further Evidence on Breaking Trend Functions in Macroeconomic variables. Journal of Econometrics, 80, 355-385.

Pesaran, M., Shin, Y., & Smith, J. (2001). Bounds Testing Approaches to the Analysis of Level Relationships. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 16(3), 289-326.

Phillips, P. C., & Perron, P. (1988). Testing for Unit Root in Time Series Regression. Biometrica, 75, 335-346.

Pryor, F. (1969). Public Expenditures in Communist and Capitalist Nations. London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd.

Ram, R. (1986). Government Size and Economic Growth: A New Framework and Some Evidence from Cross-Section and Time-Series Data. American Economic Review, 76, 191-203.

Rambaldi, A. N., & Doran, H. (1996). Testing for Granger Non-causality in Cointegrated System Made Easy. Working Papers in Econometrics and Applied Statistics, No.88. Department of Econometrics, University of New England.

Rana, R. (2014). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in Bangladesh: An Empirical Study. The International Journal of Business & Management, 2(10), 271-278.

Rao, B. V. (1989). Government Size and Economic Growth: A New Framework and Some Evidence from Cross-Section and Time-Series Data: Comment. The American Economic Review, 79(1), 272-280.

Richter, C., & Dimitrios, P. (2012). The Validity of Wagner’s Law in the United Kingdom. Working Paper 2012.9, International Network for Economic Research.

Sabir, Yustika, A., Susilo, & Maskie, G. (2015). Local Government Expenditure, Economic Growth and Income Inequality in South Sulawesi Province. Journal of Applied Economics and Business, 3(2), 61-73.

Safdar, M., Mahmoodi, M., & Mahmoodi, E. (2012). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth: Panel Evidence from Asian Countries. Life Science Journal, 9(2), 553-558.

Salih, M. A. (2012). The Relationship between Economic Growth and Government Expenditure: Evidence from Sudan. International Business Research, 5(8), 40-46.

Salwindi, N., & Seshamani, V. (2016). The Relevance of Wagner’s Law to Zambia. International Review of Research in Emerging Markets and the Global Economy, 2(2), 808-822.

Seeber, A., & Dockel, J. (1978). The behaviour of Government Expenditure in South Africa. South African Journal of Economics, 46(4), 337-351.

Sevitenyi, L. N. (2012). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in Nigeria: An Empirical. The Journal of Economic Analysis Investigation (1961-2009), III (I), 38-51.

Sideris, D. (2007). Wagner’s Law in 19th century Greece: A Cointegration and Causality Analysis. Working Papers, 64, Bank of Greece.

Singh, B., & Sahni, B. S. (1984). Causality between Public Expenditure and National Income. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 66(4), 630-644.

Sinha, D. (2007). Does the Wagner’s Law hold for Thailand? A Time Series Study. MPRA Paper, No.2560.

Srinivasan, P. (2013). Causality between Public Expenditure and Economic Growth: The Indian Case. International Journal of Economics and Management, 7(2), 335-347.

Statistics South Africa. (2016). Quarterly Labour Market Review, 2016:Q1-Q4. Pretoria: South Africa: Statistics South Africa. Retrieved from http://www.statssa.gov.za

Szarowská, I. (2011). Relationship between Government Spending and Economic Growth in the Czech Republic. Acta Universitatis Agriculturae Et Silviculturae Mendelianae Brunensis, LIX (44), 415-421.

Tasseven, Ö. (2011). The Wagner’s Law: Time Series Evidence for Turkey. Doğuş Üniversitesi Dergisi, 12(2), 304-316.

Thabane, K., & Lebina, S. (2016). Economic Growth and Government Spending Nexus: Empirical Evidence from Lesotho. African Journal of Economic Review, IV (1).

Toda, H. Y., & Yamamoto, T. (1995). Statistical Inference in Vector Autoregressions with Possibly Integrated Processes. Journal of Econometrics, 66, 225–250.

Tsauri, K., & Odhiambo, N. M. (2013). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in Zimbabwe: An ARDL-Bounds Testing Approach. International Journal of Economic Policy in Emerging Economies, 6(1), 78-90.

Tulsidharan, S. (2006). Government Expenditure and Economic Growth in India (1960 to 2002). Finance India, XX (1), 169-179.

VamsiKrushna, A. (2015). Empirical Estimation of Wagner’s Law: A Case Study of India. International Journal of Research in Engineering, IT and Social Sciences, 5(12), 18-27.

Wagner, A. (1883). Three Extracts on Public Finance. (R. Musgrave, & A. Peacock (1958), Eds.) Classics in the Theory of Public Finance.

Wagner, A. (1893). Grundlegung der Politischen Okonomie. 3rd edn, Leipzig.