Complementarities and Intergenerational Educational Mobility: Theory and Evidence from Indonesia

Ahsan, Nazmul and Emran, M. Shahe and Shilpi, Forhad (2021): Complementarities and Intergenerational Educational Mobility: Theory and Evidence from Indonesia.

Abstract

We provide a theory based empirical analysis of the role of two types of complementarities in intergenerational educational mobility. We develop a model where parental financial investment in children’s schooling can be complementary to or a substitute of school quality and parent’s education level. Such complementarities can make the mobility equation convex with starkly different mobility patterns compared to the workhorse linear model. Mobility and investment equations derived from the model are estimated for Indonesia, using exceptional data that allow us to tackle two major sources of bias: coresidency and cognitive ability heterogeneity. We find that the mobility equation is convex in rural but linear in urban areas. The children of low educated fathers enjoy higher relative mobility in rural areas, while the urban children fare better in highly educated households. The standard linear model in rural areas incorrectly suggests no rural-urban gap in relative mobility. Theoretical insights help interpret the evidence, suggesting complementarity between financial investment and parental education in both rural and urban areas even though the mobility curve is linear in urban areas. We develop an approach to recover the parameters determining the interaction between school quality and parental investment. School quality is complementary to financial investment in rural areas, with stronger effect in more educated households. In urban areas, school quality is a substitute in low educated households, but complementary in the highly educated households. These results imply that public investment in school quality would lower relative mobility in Indonesia

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Intergenerational Educational Mobility, Complementarity, Convex Mobility Curve, School Quality, Rural-Urban Divide, Returns to Education, Coresidency, Sample Truncation, Ability Heterogeneity, Developing Countries, Indonesia
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J62 - Job, Occupational, and Intergenerational Mobility; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O12 - Microeconomic Analyses of Economic Development

References

Abadie, A., Athey, S., Imbens, G., and Wooldridge, J. (2017). When Should You Adjust Standard Errors for Clustering? NBER Working Papers 24003, National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.

Akresh, R., Halim, D., and Kleemans, M. (2018). Long-term and Intergenerational Effects of Education: Evidence from School Construction in Indonesia. NBER Working Papers 25265, National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.

Atkinson, A. B., Piketty, T., and Saez, E. (2011). "Top incomes in the long run of history." Journal of Economic Literature, 49(1):3{71.

Autor, D. H. (2014). "Skills, education, and the rise of earnings inequality among the other 99 percent". Science, 344(6186):843-851.

Azam, M. and Bhatt, V. (2015). "Like Father, Like Son? Intergenerational Educational Mobility in India." Demography, 52(6):1929-1959.

Becker, G., Kominers, S. D., Murphy, K. M., and Spenkuch, J. L. (2015). "A Theory of Intergenerational Mobility." MPRA Paper 66334, University Library of Munich, Germany.

Black, S. E. and Devereux, P. J. (2011). Recent Developments in Intergenerational Mobility. In Handbook of Labor Economics, volume 4, chapter 16, pages 1487-1541. Elsevier.

Booth, A. (1998). The Indonesian Economy in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries: A History of Missed Opportunities. Macmillan Press Limited.

Bossuroy, T. and Cogneau, D. (2013). "Social Mobility in Five African Countries." Review of Income and Wealth, 59:84{110.

Card, D., Domnisoru, C., and Taylor, L. (2018). The Intergenerational Transmission of Human Capital: Evidence from the Golden Age of Upward Mobility. NBER Working Papers 25000, National Bureau of Economic Research, Inc.

Chapman, B. and Suryadarma, D. (2013). "Financing higher education: The viability of a commercial student loan scheme in Indonesia.", Education in Indonesia, pages 203-215.

Chetty, R., Hendren, N., Kline, P., and Saez, E. (2014). "Where is the land of Opportunity? The Geography of Intergenerational Mobility in the United States". The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 129(4):1553-1623.

Corak, M. (2013). "Income Inequality, Equality of Opportunity, and Intergenerational Mobility." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 27(3):79-102.

Dahl, M. W. and DeLeire, T. (2008). The Association between Childrens Earnings and Fathers Lifetime Earnings: Estimates Using Administrative Data. Working paper, institute for research on poverty, University of Wisconsin Madison.

Echazarra, A. and Readinger, T. (2019). Learning in Rural Schools: Insights from PISA, TALIS, and the Literature. OECD Education Working Paper Series 196, OECD.

Emran, M. S., Greene, W., and Shilpi, F. (2018). "When Measure Matters: Coresidency, Truncation Bias, and Intergenerational Mobility in Developing Countries." Journal of Human Resources, 53(3):589-607.

Emran, M. S., Islam, A., and Shilpi, F. (2020a). "Distributional Effects of Corruption When Enforcement is Biased: Theory and Evidence from Bribery in Schools in Bangladesh." Economica, 87(348):985-1015.

Emran, M. S., Jiang, H., and Shilpi, F. (2021). Is Gender Destiny? Gender Bias and Intergenerational Educational Mobility in India. GLO Discussion Paper Series 807, Global Labor Organization (GLO).

Emran, M. S., Jiang, H., and Shilpi, F. J. (2020b). Gender Bias and Intergenerational Educational Mobility: Theory and Evidence from China and India. Policy Research Working Paper Series 9250, The World Bank.

Emran, M. S. and Shilpi, F. (2011). "Intergenerational Occupational Mobility in Rural Economy: Evidence from Nepal and Vietnam." Journal of Human Resources, 46(2):427-458.

Emran, M. S. and Shilpi, F. (2015). "Gender, Geography, and Generations: Intergenerational Educational Mobility in Post-Reform India." World Development, 72:362-380.

Emran, M. S. and Shilpi, F. (2021). Economic approach to intergenerational mobility: Measures, methods, and challenges in developing countries. In Iversen, V., Krishna, A., and Sen, K., editors, Social Mobility in Developing Countries: Concepts, Methods, and Determinants. Oxford University Press.

Emran, M. S. and Shilpi, F. J. (2019). "Economic approach to intergenerational mobility: Measures, Methods, and Challenges in Developing Countries." Working Paper Series 98, UNU-WIDER.

Emran, M. S. and Sun, Y. (2015). "Magical transition intergenerational educational and occupational mobility in rural China: 1988-2002." Policy Research Working Paper Series 7316, The World Bank.

Fan, Y., Yi, J., and Zhang, J. (2020). "Rising Intergenerational Income Persistence in China." American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 2021.

Febriana, M., Nurkamto, J., Rochsantiningsih, D., and Muhtia, A. (2018). "Teaching in Rural Indonesian Schools: Teachers Challenges." International Journal of Multicultural and Multireligious Understanding, 5:11-20.

Frankema, E. (2014). Why was the Dutch legacy so poor? Educational development in the Netherlands Indies, 1871-1942. CGEH Working Paper Series 54, Universiteit Utrecht.

Frankenberg, E., Karoly, L. A., Gertler, P., Achmad, S., Agung, I., Hatmadji, S. H., and Sudharto, P. (1995). The 1993 Indonesian family life survey: Overview and field report.

Friedman, J. (2005). How Responsive is Poverty to Growth? A Regional Analysis of Poverty, Inequality, and Growth in Indonesia, 1984-1999. In Kanbur, R. and Venables, A., editors, Spatial Inequality and Development. Oxford University Press.

Furnivall, J, S. (1943). Educational Progress in Southeast Asia. Working paper series, New York: Institute of Pacific Relations.

Goldin, C. and Katz, L. (2008). The Race Between Education and Technology. Belknap Press.

Heckman, J. and Corbin, C. (2016). Capabilities and Skills. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 17(3):342-359.

Heckman, J. and Mosso, S. (2014). "The Economics of Human Development and Social Mobility." Annual Review of Economics, 6(1):689-733.

Hertz, T. and Jayasundera, T. (2007). School Construction and Intergenerational Mobility in Indonesia. Working Papers 2007-18, American University, Department of Economics.

Hertz, T., Jayasundera, T., Piraino, P., Selcuk, S., Smith, N., and Verashchagina, A. (2008). "The Inheritance of Educational Inequality: International Comparisons and Fifty-Year Trends." The B.E. Journal of Economic Analysis & Policy, 7(2):1-48.

Iversen, V., Krishna, A., and Sen, K. (2019). Beyond poverty escapes − social mobility in developing countries: A review article. World Bank Research Observer, 34(2):239-273.

Kanbur, R. and Jhuang, J. (2014). Urbaization and Inequality in Asia. In Kanbur, R., Rhee, C., and Jhuang, J., editors, Inequality in the Asia and Pacific, pages 288-302. Rutledge and ADB.

Kiviet, J. F. (2013). "Identification and inference in a simultaneous equation under alternative information sets and sampling schemes." Econometrics Journal, 16(1):24-59.

Kiviet, J. F. (2020a). Instrument-free inference under confined regressor endogeneity; derivations and applications. Working Papers 09/2020, Stellenbosch University, Department of Economics.

Kiviet, J. F. (2020b). "Testing the impossible: Identifying exclusion restrictions." Journal of Econometrics, 218(2):294{316.

Kurosaki, T. and Khan, H. (2006). "Human Capital, Productivity, and Stratification in Rural Pakistan." Review of Development Economics, 10:116-134.

Mazumder, B. (2005). "Fortunate Sons: New Estimates of Intergenerational Mobility in the United States Using Social Security Earnings Data." The Review of Economics and Statistics, 87(2):235-255.

Mazumder, B., Rosales-Rueda, M., and Triyana, M. (2019). "Intergenerational Human Capital Spillovers: Indonesia’s School Construction and Its Effects on the Next Generation." AEA Papers and Proceedings, 109:243-249.

Neidhofer, G., Serrano, J., and Gasparini, L. (2018). "Educational inequality and intergenerational mobility in Latin America: A new database." Journal of Development Economics, 134(C):329-349.

Nishiyama, S. (2000). Measuring Time Preference and Parental Altruism. Working Papers 13333, Congressional Budget Office.

Phillips, J. M. (1994). "Farmer education and farmer efficiency: A meta-analysis." Economic Development and Cultural Change, 43(1):149-65.

Schrader, H. (1997). Changing Financial Landscapes in India and Indonesia: Sociological Aspects of Monetization and Market Integration. LIT Verlag Münster.

Sen, S. (2013). Model of Childbearing with 2-sided Altruism in Developing Countries: A Calibration Exercise. Working paper, Pennsylvania State University.

Solon, G. (1992). "Intergenerational Income Mobility in the United States. American Economic Review," 82(3):393-408.

Solon, G. (1999). Intergenerational mobility in the labor market. In Ashenfelter, O. and Card, D., editors, Handbook of Labor Economics, volume 3 of Handbook of Labor Economics, pages 1761{1800. Elsevier.

Stiglitz, J. (2012). The Price of Inequality. W. W. Norton Company.

Thomas, D. (1996). "Education across Generations in South Africa." American Economic Review, 86(2):330-334.

Torche, F. (2019). Educational mobility in developing countries. WIDER Working Paper Series 2019-88.