The Theory of the Emission Economy Bolshevik roots of "Modern Monetary Theory"

Nenovsky, Nikolay (2020): The Theory of the Emission Economy Bolshevik roots of "Modern Monetary Theory".

Abstract

In this article we present the monetary theory, called the "Theory of Emission Economy (TEE)", most fully formulated by the Russian economist S. Falkner (1890-1938). Formulated exactly a century ago, it is strikingly reminiscent of modern "Modern Monetary Theory, MMT." Like MMT, TEE has had both supporters and serious critics. More importantly, in a certain period of time, 1918–1920, the TEE was put into practice, and the MMT's "consolidation hypothesis", that of merging the central bank with the treasury (government), became a reality (January 1920). The Bolsheviks' brief experience with MMT ended in disaster. Lenin himself, who at first shared its basic ideas, was forced to undertake monetary stabilization based on the parallel introduction of gold coins, chervonets. The purpose of this article is to present the theoretical discussions about TEE, as well as the monetary policies of Bolshevik Russia in order to derive some useful patterns for the state of monetary theory and practice today.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Monetary theory, MMT, Bolshevik monetary economy, Theory of Emission Economy, S. Falkner, V. Lenin
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B2 - History of Economic Thought since 1925 > B24 - Socialist ; Marxist ; Sraffian; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E6 - Macroeconomic Policy, Macroeconomic Aspects of Public Finance, and General Outlook

References

Bibliography in Cyrillic (original titles)

Атлас, З. (1969) Социалистическая денежная система, Изд. „Финансы“, Москва.

Базаров, В. (1925) О „восстановительных процессах“ вообще и об „эмиссионных возможностях“ в частности, В: Базаров, В., Избранные произведения, Том 1, с. 356–383, Издательский дом „Дело“, Москва.

Боголепов, М. (1922) Бумажные деньги, Изд. „Кооперативное товарищество“, Москва.

Богомазов, Г. (1974). Марксизм – ленинизм и проблемы товарно-денежных отношений в период строительства социализма в СССР (историко-теоретический очерк), изд. Ленинградского университета, Ленинград.

Бруцкус, Б. (1922) Проблемы народного хозяйства при социалистическом строе, Изд. „Экономист“, 1 (I–IV), 2 (V–VI), 3 (VII–X).

Бухарин, Н., Е. Преображенский (2018 [1919]) Азбука коммунизма, Изд. „Алгоритм“, Москва.

Варга, Е. (1922 [1921]) Проблемы экономической политики при пролетарской диктатуре, Государственное издательство, Москва

Вельов, М. (1952) Функции и роля на парите у нас, Изд. на БКП, София.

Голанд, Ю. Дискусии об экономической политике в годы денежной реформы 1921–1924, Изд. „Экономика“, Москва.

Катцеленбаум, З. (1924) Денежное обращение России, 1914–1924, Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва – Ленинград.

Ковалев, А. (2014) Идеи австрийской школы в советской экономической литературе 1920-х годов, В: Капитализм и свобода, СПб, с. 88–105.

Корнай, Я. (1996 [1992]) Социалистическата система. Политическа икономия на комунизма, изд. „Проф. Марин Дринов“, София.

Корнай, Я. (1998) Трансформация след социализма. Опитът на Унгария, Изд. Агенция за икономическо програмиране и развитие, София.

Коцев, Ц. (1989) Организация и планиране на паричния оборот и паричното обръщение при социализма, и Система и организация на безналичните плащания, в: Финанси и кредит при социализма, Изд. „Г. Бакалов“, Варна, гл. 2 и гл. 3, с. 26–73.

Коцев, Ц., Г. Николова (1983). Организация и планиране на паричното обра­щение при социализма, и Система и организация на безналичните плащания, гл. 10 и гл. 11, в: Ц. Коцев и Г. Петров, под. ред. Финанси и кредит на социализма, Изд. „Наука и изкуство“, София, с. 254–305.

Коцев, Ц., Г. Николова, Р. Радков (1975) Организация и планиране на паричното обращение при социализма; Същност и организация на безналичните плащания, гл. 10 и гл. 11, Русенов, в: М., под. ред., Финанси и кредит на социалистическата държава, Изд. „Г. Бакалов“, Варна, с. 239–270.

Кузовков, Д. (1925). Основные моменты распада и восстановления денежной системы, Коммунистическая Академия, секция Экономика, Москва

Кутлер, Н. (1922) О денежной реформе. Доклад Н. Н. Кутлера, с.112–120 (Российский государственный архив экономики, ф. 2324, оп. 26, д. 103, л. 46–48 гр.), в: Денежная реформа 1921–1924 гг.: Создание твердой валюты. Документы и материалы (2008), РОССПЭН, Москва.

Кутлер, Н. (1923) К вопросу о росте товарных цен, Экономическая жизнь, 29 августа, с. 2, в: Николаев, М. Г. (2018) Николай Кутлер. Жизнь в двух эпохах. Страницы биографии одного из руководителей Госбанка периода НЭПа, Изд. Банка России, Москва, с. 349–353.

Ларин, Ю. (1918) У колыбели, НХ(4): с. 16–28.

Ленин, В. (1967 [1921]). VII Московская Губпартконференция, В: В. И. Ленин (1967), Полное собрание сочинений, Т. 44, с. 207–208 (http://leninvi.com/).

Лившиц, Б. (1924) К постановке денежной проблемы с точки зрения закона равновесия, Под знаменем марксизма, (8–9): с. 224–245.

Ломейeр, А. Э., под ред. (1918) Вопросы денежного обращения, Изд. „Центральный народно-промышленный комитет“, Петроград.

Маневич, В. (1986) Развитие теории денежного обращения в советской экономической литературе, Изд. „Наука“, Москва.

Народное хозяйство (1918) Отдел экономических исследований, № 10.

Неновски, Н. (2020) Рассчитываться без денег: натуральные модели социального бухучета по О. Нейрату и А. Чаянову, в: Автономова, В. С., А. Я. Рубинштейн, под. ред., Экономическая наука: забытые и отвергнутые теории, Изд. „Институт экономики РАН и ГУ ВШЭ“, Москва, с. 234–250.

Неновски, Н. (2020а) Паричен национализъм, потисната и открита инфлация, в-к „Банкеръ“, 14 август 2020, с. 6–7.

Неновски, Н. (2007). Паричнит ред. Критика на теорията на парите, изд. Сиела, София.

Николаев, М. Г. (2018) Николай Кутлер. Жизнь в двух эпохах. Страницы биографии одного из руководителей Госбанка периода НЭПа, Изд. Банка России, Москва.

Новожилов, В. (1924) Пределы инфляции, В: Штейн, В., под ред., Финансы и денежное обращение в современной России, с. 83–121, Изд. „Петгорград“, Ленинград – Москва.

Новожилов, В. (1926) Недостаток товаров, Вестник Финансов, (2): с. 71–86.

Панчев, С. (2021) Банките сигурно са полудели, в: 2020: Отвътре и отвъд, Изд. Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, София.

Погребецкий, А. (1924) Денежное обращение и денежные знаки Дальнего Вос­тока за период войны и революции (1914–1924), Общество изучения Маньчжурского края, Харбин.

Преображенский, Е. (1922) Русский рубль за время войны и революции, Красная новь, (2): с. 242—257

Преображенский, Е. (1920) Бумажные деньги в эпоху пролетарской диктатуры, Государственное издательство, Москва.

Сокольников, Г. (2006 [1918]) Основные положения финансовой политики, В: Сокольников, Г. (2006) Финансовая политика революции, Изд. „Общест­во купцов и промышленников“, Москва, 19–45.

Сокольников, Г. (1922) Письмо Г. Я. Сокольникова В. И. Ленину, 28 января 1922 г., с. 93 (Российский государственный архив социально-политической истории, ф. 5, оп. 1, д. 1372, л. 1–1 гр.), в: Денежная реформа 1921–1924 гг., Создание твердой валюты. Документы и материалы (2008), Изд. РОССПЭН, Москва.

Шарапов (Талицкий), С. (1895) Бумажный рубль (его теория и практика), типо­графия „Общественная польза“, С. Петербург.

Шухов, Н. (1991) Политическая экономия социализма в 20-е годы, Изд. „Наука“, Москва.

Струмилин, С. (1925) Проблемы экономики труда, „Вопросы труда“, Москва.

Трахтенберг, И. А. (1922) Бумажные деньги, Кооперативное издательство „Московский рабочий“, Москва.

Трифонов, Д., Л. Широкорад, под. ред. (1983) История политической экономии социализма, Изд. Ленинградского Университета, Ленинград.

Шмидт, О. (1923) Математические законы денежной эмиссии, Государственное издательство, Москва, Петгроград.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1918) Проблема нормирования цен в системе эмиссионного хозяства, В: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 69–78.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1918/1919) Будущее нашей валюты, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 27–34.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1919) Бумажные деньги французской революции (1789–1797), Изд. Высший Совет народного хозяйства, Москва.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1919а) Экономические функции обесценения денег, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 44–47.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1919б) Эмиссия как финансовая система, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 35–43.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1919в) Принципы построения системы твердых цен, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 98–109.

Фалькнер, С Я. (1920) Эмисионное хозяйство как экономическая категория, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 13–26.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1920а) Методы определения ценности бумажных денег, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 123–128.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1920б) Напряжённость эмиссии и темп обесценения в 1914–1918 гг., в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 129–141.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1920в) Прошлое и будущее русской эмиссионной системы, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 176–201.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1921) Цели и средства денежной реформы, в: Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства. Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва, с. 60–66.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1922) Изказване В: Журнал совещания по вопросам денежного обращения, происходивщего в Наркомфине 26 января 1922 г., с. 67, 76–78, 87 (Шмелев), 88–89 (Российский государственный архив экономики, ф. 7733, оп. 1, д. 6898, л. 146–188), в: Денежная реформа 1921–1924 гг.: Создание твердой валюты. Документы и материалы (2008). Изд. РОССПЭН, Москва.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924) Проблема теории и практики эмиссионного хозяйства, Изд. „Экономическая жизнь“, Москва.

Фалькнер, С. Я. (1924а) Изказвания В: Работы Института экономики I Московского Государственного Университета, Факультета общественных наук, СХ (1): с. 416–417, 421; СХ (2): с. 377–378.

Хензел, П. (1935) Финансово и данъчно устройство на Съюза на съветските социалистически републики, кооперативна печатница „Напред“, София.

Ходяков, М. (2018) Деньги революции и гражданской войны, Изд. Санкт-петер­бургского Государственного Университета, Санкт-Петербург.

Царевски, Н. (1975) Валутни и кредитни отношения на НР България, Изд. „Наука и изкуство“, София.

Чуднов, И. (2018) Денежная реформа 1947 года, Изд. РОССПЭН, Москва.

Чучин, Ф. (1927) Каталог бон и дензнаков России, РСФСР, СССР, окраин и образований (1769–1927), Издание Советской филателистической ассоциации при комиссии Всероссийского центрального исполнительного комитета фонда имени В. И. Ленина помощи беспризорным детям, Москва.

Юровский, Л. (под ред.), (1926) Наше денежное обращение. Сборник материалов по истории денежного обращения в 1914–1925 гг., Финансовое издательство Народного комиссариата финансов СССР, Москва.

Юровский, Л. (2008) Денежная политика Советской власти (1917–1927). Избранные статьи, под. ред. Ю. Голанда, Изд. „Экономика“, Москва.

Bibliography In Cyrillic translated into English (the same order as above)

Atlas, Z. (1969) The Socialist Monetary System, ed. "Finance”, Moscow. (In Russian)

Bazarov, V. (1925) On "recovery processes" in general and on "emission possibilities" in particular, In: Bazarov, V., Selected Works, Vol. 1, pp. 356-383, Publishing House "Delo", Moscow. (In Russian)

Bogolepov, M. (1922) Paper Currency, Ed. "Cooperative Society”, Moscow. (In Russian)

Bogomazov, G. (1974). Marxism - Leninism and the Problems of Commodity-Money Relations during the Construction of Socialism in the USSR (Historical-Theoretical Essay), ed. Leningrad University, Leningrad. (In Russian)

Brutskus, B. (1922) Problems of the National Economy under the Socialist System, Ekonomist, 1 (I-IV), 2 (V-VI), 3 (VII-X). (In Russian)

Bukharin, N., E. Preobrazhensky (2018 [1919]) The ABC of Communism, ed. "Algorithm”, Moscow. (In Russian)

Varga, E. (1922 [1921]) Problems of Economic Policy under the Proletarian Dictatorship, State Publishing House, Moscow (In Russian)

Velyov, M. (1952) Functions and role of money in our country, Bulgarian Communist Party Publishing House, Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Goland, Y. (2006). Discussions on Economic Policy in the Years of Monetary Reform 1921-1924, Ed. "Ekonomika”, Moscow. (In Russian)

Katzenbaum, Z. (1924) Monetary Circulation of Russia, 1914-1924, Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow - Leningrad. (In Russian)

Kovalev, A. (2014) Ideas of the Austrian School in Soviet Economic Literature of the 1920s, In: Capitalism and Freedom, Sant Petersburg, pp. 88-105. (In Russian)

Kornai, J. (1996 [1992]) The Socialist System. A political economy of communism, ed. "Prof. Marin Drinov”, Sofia.

Kornai, J. (1998) Transformation after Socialism. The Hungarian Experience, Ed. Economic Programming and Development Agency, Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Kotsev, T. (1989) Organization and Planning of Money Turnover and Monetary Circulation under Socialism, and System and Organization of Cashless Payments, in: T. Kotsev and G. Petrov, eds. Finance and Credit under Socialism, ed. "Science and Art, Sofia, chap. 3, с. 26-73. (In Bulgarian)

Kotsev, T., G. Nikolova (1983). Organization and Planning of Money Circulation under Socialism, and System and Organization of Cashless Payments, chap. 10 and chap. 11, in: T. Kotsev and G. Petrov, eds. Finance and Credit under Socialism, ed. "Science and Art, Sofia, pp. 254-305. (In Bulgarian)

Kotsev, T., G. Nikolova, R. Radkov (1975) Organization and Planning of Monetary Circulation under Socialism; Nature and Organization of Cashless Payments, chap. 10 and chap. 11, Rusenov, V., M., ed. Finance and Credit of the Socialist State, in: T. Kotsev and G. Petrov, eds. Finance and Credit under Socialism, ed. "Science and Art, Sofia, pp. 239-270. (In Bulgarian)

Kuzovkov, D. (1925). Highlights of the collapse and restoration of the monetary system, Communist Academy, Economics section, Moscow (In Russian)

Kutler, N. (1922) On Monetary Reform. Report of N. Н. Kutler, pp. 112-120 (Russian State Archive of Economics, f. 2324, op. 26, d. 103, pp. 46-48), In: Monetary Reform 1921-1924: Creation of a Hard Currency. Documents and Materials (2008), ROSSPEN, Moscow. (In Russian)

Kutler, N. (1923) On the growth of commodity prices, Economic Life, August 29, p. 2, In: Nikolaev, M. Г. (2018) Nikolai Kutler. Life in two epochs. Pages of the biography of one of the heads of the State Bank of the NEP period, Ed. Bank of Russia, Moscow, pp. 349-353.

Larin, Y. (1918) At the Cradle, Narodnoe hozyastvo (4): pp. 16-28. (In Russian)

Lenin, V. (1967 [1921]). VII Moscow Gubpartkonferentsiya, In. V. Lenin (1967), Complete Works, Vol. 44, pp. 207-208 (http://leninvi.com/). (In Russian)

Livshits, B. (1924) Towards a statement of the monetary problem from the point of view of the law of equilibrium, Under the Banner of Marxism, (8-9): pp. 224-245. (In Russian)

Lomeyer, A., ed. (1918) Questions of Currency Circulation, ed. "Central People's Industrial Committee", Petrograd. (In Russian)

Manevich, V. (1986) The Development of the Theory of Money Circulation in Soviet Economic Literature, Ed. "Nauka, Moscow. (In Russian)

NKh/National Economy (1918) Economic Research Division, No. 10, Supreme Board of the National Economy (in Russian)

Nenovsky, N. (2020) Counting without money: natural models of social accounting in O. Neurath and A. Chayanov, In: Autonomov, V., A. Rubinstein, eds., Economic Science: Forgotten and Rejected Theories, ed. Institute of Economics RAS and SU HSE, Moscow, pp. 234-250. (In Russian)

Nenovsky, N. (2020a) Monetary nationalism, suppressed and open inflation, Banker's Weekly, 14 August 2020, pp. 6-7. (In Bulgarian)

Nenovsky, N. (2007). Money Order. Critique of the theory of money, ed. “Siela”, Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Nikolaev, M. (2018) Nikolai Kutler. Life in two epochs. Pages of the biography of one of the heads of the State Bank of the NEP period, Ed. Bank of Russia, Moscow. (In Russian)

Novozhilov, V. (1924) The Limits of Inflation, In: Stein, V., ed., Finance and Monetary Circulation in Modern Russia, pp. 83-121, Ed. "Petgorgrad", Leningrad - Moscow. (In Russian)

Novozhilov, V. (1926) Shortage of goods, Vestnik Finansov, (2): pp. 71-86. (In Russian)

Panchev, S. (2021) Banks must be crazy, In. 2020 and beyond, Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Pogrebetsky, A. (1924) Monetary circulation and currency of the Far East during the war and revolution (1914-1924), Society for the Study of the Manchurian Region, Harbin. (In Russian)

Preobrazhensky, E. (1922) The Russian ruble during the war and the revolution, Krasnaya Nov, (2): pp. 242-257(In Russian)

Preobrazhensky, E. (1920) Paper Money in the Era of Proletarian Dictatorship, State Publishing House, Moscow. (In Russian)

Sokolnikov, G. (2006 [1918]) Basic Principles of Financial Policy, In: Sokolnikov, G. (2006) Financial Policy of the Revolution, ed. "Society of Merchants and Industrialists”, Moscow, 19-45. (In Russian)

Sokolnikov, G. (1922) Letter of G. Sokolnikov to V. Lenin, January 28, 1922, p. 93 (Russian State Archive of Social and Political History, f. 5, op. 1, d. 1372, л. 1-1), In: Monetary Reform 1921-1924, Creation of a Hard Currency. Documents and Materials (2008), Ed. ROSSPEN, Moscow. (In Russian)

Sharapov (Talitsky), S. (1895) The paper ruble (its theory and practice), printing house "Public utility", S. Petersburg. (In Russian)

Shukhov, N. (1991) The Political Economy of Socialism in the 1920s, ed. "Nauka”, Moscow. (In Russian)

Strumilin, S. (1925) Problems of Labour Economics, Questions of Labour, Moscow. (In Russian)

Trachtenberg, I. (1922) Paper Currency, Cooperative Publishing House "Moskovskii Rabochiy", Moscow. (In Russian)

Trifonov, D., L. Shirokorad, eds. (1983) History of Political Economy of Socialism, ed. Leningrad University, Leningrad. (In Russian)

Schmidt, O. (1923) Mathematical laws of monetary emission, State Publishing House, Moscow, Petrograd. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1918) The problem of price rationing in the system of the emission economy, In S. Falkner (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn, Moscow, pp. 69-78. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1918/1919) The future of our currency, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn, Moscow, pp. 27-34. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1919) Paper Currency of the French Revolution (1789-1797), Ed. Supreme Council of National Economy, Moscow. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1919a) Economic functions of money depreciation, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn, Moscow, pp. 44-47. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1919b) Emission as a Financial System, In: Faulkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn, Moscow, pp. 35-43. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1919c) Principles of the construction of a system of firm prices, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow, pp. 98-109. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1920) Emission economy as an economic category, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn, Moscow, pp. 13-26. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1920a) Methods of determining the value of paper currency, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow, pp. 123-128. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1920b) Emission tensions and the rate of depreciation in 1914-1918, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow, pp. 129-141. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1920c) The past and future of the Russian emission system, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Emission Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow, pp. 176-201. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1921) The ends and means of monetary reform, In: Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Issue Economy. Ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow, pp. 60-66. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1922) Speech in: Notes of the meeting on monetary circulation, held in the Narcomfin on 26 January 1922, pp. 67, 76-78, 87 (Shmelev), 88-89 (Russian State Archive of Economics, ff. 7733, op. 1, d. 6898, l. 146-188), In: Monetary Reform 1921-1924: Creation of a Hard Currency. Documents and Materials (2008). Ed. ROSSPEN, Moscow. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1924) The Problem of the Theory and Practice of the Issue Economy, ed. "Ekonomicheskaya zhizn", Moscow. (In Russian)

Falkner, S. (1924a) Speeches In: Works of the Institute of Economics I of Moscow State University, Faculty of Social Sciences, Narodnoe Hozyaistvo (1): pp. 416-417, 421; SX (2): pp. 377-378. (In Russian)

Hensel, P. (1935) Financial and Tax Structure of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, Cooperative Printing House "Napredak", Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Khodiakov, M. (2018) The Money of Revolution and Civil War, Ed. St. Petersburg State University, St. Petersburg. (In Russian)

Tsarevsky, N. (1975) Currency and Credit Relations of the People's Republic of Bulgaria, Ed. "Hauka I Izkustvo”, Sofia. (In Bulgarian)

Chudnov, I. (2018) Monetary Reform of 1947, Ed. ROSSPEN, Moscow. (In Russian)

Chuchin, F. (1927) Catalogue of Bonds and Denominations of Russia, RSFSR, USSR, Suburbs and Entities (1769-1927), Edition of the Soviet Philatelic Association under the Commission of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee of the V. Chuchin Foundation. И. Lenin's aid to street children, Moscow. (In Russian)

Yurovsky, L. (ed.), (1926) Our Monetary Circulation. Collection of materials on the history of money circulation in 1914-1925, Financial Publishing House of the People's Commissariat of Finance of the USSR, Moscow. (In Russian)

Yurovsky, L. (2008) Monetary Policy of the Soviet Power (1917-1927). Selected Articles, ed. Y. Goland, ed. "Ekonomika, Moscow. (In Russian)

* * * Bibliography in Latin

Allisson, F. (2015) Value and Prices in Russian Economic Thought. A Journey inside the Russian Synthesis, 1890-1920, Routledge, London.

Aftalion, F. (2007) L'économie de la Révolution française, Les Belles Lettres, Paris.

Arnold, A. (1937) Banks, Credit and Money in Soviet Russia, Cambridge University Press, New York.

Artus, P. (2020) La création monétaire n'annulera pas les effets de la crise, Les Echos, 14 décembre 2020.

Birman, I. (1980) The Financial Crisis in the USSR, Soviet Studies, 32(1): pp. 84-105.

Birman, I. (1980) A Reply to Professor Pickersgill, Soviet Studies, 32(1): pp. 586-591.

Boettke, P. J. (1999 [1990]) The Political Economy of Soviet Socialism. The Formative Years, 1918-1928, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Boston, Dordrecht, London.

Caballero, R., E. Farhi (2017). The Safety Trap, Review of Economic Studies, 85 (1): pp. 223-274.

Cagan, Ph. (1956) The Monetary Dynamics of Hyperinflation, in: Friedman, M., (ed.), (1956), Studies in the Quantity Theory of Money, pp. 25-117, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London.

CRBRP (Comité des Représentants des Banques Russes à Paris) (1922) Mémoires élaborées à l'occasion de la Conférence de Gênes, Imprimerie I. Rirachovsky, Paris.

Coats, W. (2019) Modern Monetary Theory: A Critique, Cato Journal, 39(3): pp. 563-576.

Congdon, T. (2020) Will the Current Money Growth Acceleration Increase Inflation? Wolrd Economics, 21(2): pp. 1-24.

Davies, R. (1958) The Development of the Soviet Budgetary System, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

De Grauwe, P., Y. Ji (2018) Financial engineering will not stabilise an unstable euro area, VoxEU CEPR, 19 March 2018.

Dembinski, P. (1988) Les économies planifiées. La logique du système, Editions du Seuil, Paris.

De Soto, J-H. (2010 [2001/1992]) Socialism, Economic Calculation and Entrepreneurship, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

Edwards, S. (2019) Modern Monetary Theory: Cautionary Tales from Latin America, Cato Journal, 39(3): pp. 529-561.

Fry, M. (1995[1988]) Money, Interest, and Banking in Economic Development, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore and London.

Garvy, G. (1977) Money, Financial Flows, and Credit in the Soviet Union, NBER, Ballanger Publishing Company, Cambridge.

Hanke, S. (2012) Bulgaria: Fifteen Years Later. Currency Board, Studies in Applied Economics No. 2.

Hayek, F. (2015 [1937]) Collectivist Economic Planning, edited with an Introduction and Collected Essays by F. A. Hayek, L. v. Mises Institute.

Hayek, F. (2012 [1929]) Monetary theory and the trade cycle, in. A. Hayek, Business cycles, part I, Routledge, Abingdon, New York.

Jaconis, S. (2017) Currency substitution and instability in the economy: the soviet experiment of the 'chervonets' in the twenties, Rivista di Storia Economica, 33(1): pp. 89-112.

Keynes, J. M. (2000 [1923]) A Tract on Monetary Reform, Prometheus Books, New York

Kim, B. (2002) Causes of repressed inflation in the consumer goods market, 1965-1989: retails price subsidies, the siphoning effect, and the budget deficit, Economic History Review, 55(1): pp. 105-127.

Kornai, J. (1980) Economics of Shortage (vols. A and B), North-Holland Pub. Co, Amsterdam, New York.

Kremer, G., A. Bouhaili (1992) Modèles monétaires de l'hyperinflation, Revue Tiers Monde, 33 (129): pp. 113-136.

Lavoie, D. (2015 [1985]) Rivalry and central planning: the socialist calculation debate reconsidered, Mercatus Center, George Mason University, Arlington.

Lavoie, M. (2013) The Monetary and Fiscal Nexus of Neo-Chartalism: A Friendly Critique, Journal of Economic Issues, 47(1): 1-32.

Lerner, A. (1947 [1944/1943]) Interest, Investment, and Employment III (Functional Finance), in. (1947 [1944]) The Economics of Control. Principles of Welfare Economics, The Macmillan Company, New York, pp. 302-321.

Lindbeck, A. (2007) János Kornai's Contributions to Economic Analysis, IFN Working Paper No. 724.

Malle, S. (1985) The Economic Organization of War Communism, 1918-1921, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Magnin, E., N. Nenovsky (2020) Calculating Without Money. Theories of In-Kind Accounting of Alexander Chayanov, Otto Neurath and the Early Soviet Experiences, European Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 28(3).

Mankiw, G. (2020) A Skeptic's Guide to Modern Monetary Theory, AEA Papers and Proceedings, (110): pp. 141-144.

Maskin, E. (2000) Planning, Shortage, and Transformation: Essays in Honor of János Kornai, MIT Press.

Mises, L. (1980 [1952/53]). The Theory of Money and Credit, Liberty Fund, Indianapolis.

Mitchell, W., R. Wray, M. Watts (2019) Macroeconomics, London, Red Globe Press.

Nenovsky, N. (2020) Discussion on paper currency among Russian economist during the Great War (1914-1917) with special emphasis on Tugan-Baranovsky's contributions, Revue d'histoire de la pensée économique, 2(10): pp. 103-140.

Nenovsky, N. (2019) Money as a coordinating device of a commodity economy: Old and new, Russian and French readings of Marx, Part 1. Monetary theory of value, Revue de la Régulation, 26 (2), online: https://journals.openedition.org/regulation/15916.

Nenovsky, N. (2019a) Money as a coordinating device of a commodity economy: Old and new, Russian and French readings of Marx, Part 2: The theory of money without the theory of value, Revue de la Régulation, 26 (2), online: https://journals.openedition.org/regulation/15991.

Nenovsky, N. (2010) The Soviets monetary experience (1917-1924) through the perspective of the discussion on unity and diversity of money, MPRA Paper No. 79864.

Nenovsky, N., K. Hristov (2002) New Currency Boards and Discretion. The Empirical Evidence from Bulgaria, (with K. Hristov), Economic Systems, 26 (1): pp. 55-72.

Nuti, D. (1986). Hidden and repressed inflation in soviet-type economies: definitions, measurements and stabilisation, Contributions in Political Economies, (5): pp. 37-82.

Pasvolsky, L. (1921) The Economics of Communism (with special reference to Russia's experiment), The Macmillan Company, New York.

Seurot, F. (1983) Inflation et emploi dans les pays socialistes, PUF, Paris.

Sinn, H-W. (2020) The Economics if Target Balances. From Lehman to Corona, Palgrave, Macmillan, Cham.

Shmelev, K. (1931) Public finances during the civil war, 1917-1921, in. and Associates (1931). Edited by L. Hutchinson and C. Plehn, Soviet Policy in Public Finance, 1917-1928, Stanford University Press, California, pp. 74-137.

Tymoigne, E., R. Wray (2013) Modern Money Theory 101: A Reply to Critics, Levy Institute Working Paper No. 778

Willes, P. (1962). The Political Economy of Communism, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.

Wray, R. (1998) Understanding Modern Money. The Key to Full Employment and Price Stability, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

Wray, R. (2015) Modern Money Theory: A Primer on Macroeconomics for Sovereign Monetary Systems, Palgrave Macmillan, London.