High-zinc rice and randomized nutrition training among women farmers: a panel data analysis of long-term adoption in Bangladesh

Valera, Harold Glenn and Antonio, Ronald Jeremy and Habib, Muhammad Ashraful and Puskur, Ranjitha and Pede, Valerien and Yamano, Takashi (2024): High-zinc rice and randomized nutrition training among women farmers: a panel data analysis of long-term adoption in Bangladesh. Published in: Q Open , Vol. 5, No. 1 (14 January 2025)

Abstract

This paper aims to examine the effect of nutrition training on the adoption of high-zinc rice among female farmers with young children in Bangladesh. The authors first conducted a randomized control trial by providing female farmers with micronutrient training in randomly selected villages in May-June 2017, followed by a phone-based survey on high-zinc rice seeds among farmer trainees and counterparts in control villages. We conducted a three-visit panel survey in 2018–2020 to measure the effect of nutrition training on high-zinc rice adoption. We found that the adoption of high-zinc rice in the Aman or rainy season during July-August declined from 59% in 2018 to 8% in 2020 among treated farmers and from 13% to 2% among control farmers. The regression analysis indicated that nutrition training had a significant but diminishing effect on the adoption of high-zinc rice. Unavailability of seeds and low yields were cited as the major reasons for not using high-zinc rice, while lack of knowledge about high-zinc rice was the dominant reason among the control farmers. The results have shown that continuous training, public messaging, and improving seed systems are required to sustain zinc rice adoption. The trainings should tackle the nutritional advantages of biofortified crops to ensure knowledge retention and farm practices and management techniques to achieve optimal production.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Biofortification, Zinc-enhanced rice, Adoption, Bangladesh
• Subjects: I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I12 - Health Behavior; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O33 - Technological Change: Choices and Consequences ; Diffusion Processes; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q16 - R&D ; Agricultural Technology ; Biofuels ; Agricultural Extension Services

References

Abolurin, O.O., Oyelami, O.A. and Oseni, S.B. 2020. A comparative study of the prevalence of zinc deficiency among children with acute diarrhoea in SouthWestern Nigeria. African Health Sciences, 20(1), pp.406-412.

Ahmed, T., S. Roy, N. Alam, and M. I. Hossain. 2012. Determinants of Undernutrition in Children under 2 Years of Age from Rural Bangladesh. Indian Pediatrics. 49 (10). pp. 821–824.

Ainembabazi, J., P. van Asten, B. Vanlauwe, E. Ouma, G. Blomme, E. A. Birachi, P. Nuezet, D. Mignouna, and V. Manyong. 2016. Improving Seed Adoption of Agricultural Technologies and Farm Performance through Farmer Groups: Evidence from Great Lakes Region of Africa. Agricultural Economics. 42. pp. 241–259.

Areal, F.J., Clarkson, G., Garforth, C., Barahona, C., Dove, M. and Dorward, P. 2020. Does TV edutainment lead to farmers changing their agricultural practices aiming at increasing productivity?. Journal of Rural Studies, 76, pp.213-229.

Arsenault, J., E. Yakes, M. Hossain, M. Islam, T. Ahmed, C. Hotz, B. Lewis, A. Rahman, K. Jamil, and K. Brown. 2010. The Current High Prevalence of Dietary Zinc Inadequacy among Children and Women in Rural Bangladesh Could Be Substantially Ameliorated by Zinc Biofortification of Rice. The Journal of Nutrition. 140 (9). pp. 1683–1690.

Bannor, R. K., G. A. K. Kumar, H. Oppong-Kyeremeh, and C. A. Wongnaa. 2020. Adoption and Impact of Modern Rice Varieties on Poverty in Eastern India. Rice Science. 27 (1). pp. 56–66.

Birol, E., Asare-Marfo, D., Karandikar, B., Roy, D. and Diressie, M.T. 2015. Investigating demand for biofortified seeds in developing countries: high-iron pearl millet in India. Journal of Agribusiness in Developing and Emerging Economies, 5(1), pp.24-43.

Caeiro, R. M. and P. C. Vicente. 2020. Knowledge of Vitamin A Deficiency and Crop Adoption: Evidence from a Field Experiment in Mozambique. Agricultural Economics. 51 (2). pp. 175–190.

Clarkson, G., Garforth, C., Dorward, P., Mose, G., Barahona, C., Areal, F. and Dove, M. 2018. Can the TV makeover format of edutainment lead to widespread changes in farmer behaviour and influence innovation systems? Shamba Shape Up in Kenya. Land Use Policy, 76, pp.338-351.

Conley, T. G. and C. R. Udry. 2010. Learning About a New Technology: Pineapple in Ghana. American Economic Review. 100 (1). pp. 35–69.

De Brauw, A., P. Eozenou, D. O. Gilligan, C. Hotz, N. Kumar, and J. V. Meenakshi. 2018. Biofortification, Crop Adoption and Health Information: Impact Pathways in Mozambique and Uganda. American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 100 (3). pp. 906–930.

De Groote, H., N. S. Gunaratna, M. Fisher, E. G. Kebebe, F. Mmbando, and D. Friesen. 2016. The Effectiveness of Extension Strategies for Increasing the Adoption of Biofortified Crops: The Case of Quality Protein Maize in East Africa. Food Security. 8 (6). pp. 1101–1121.

Dimara, E. and D. Skuras. 2003. Adoption of Agricultural Innovations as a Two‐Stage Partial Observability Process. Agricultural Economics. 28 (3). pp. 187–196.

Doss, C. R. 2006. Analyzing Technology Adoption using Microstudies: Limitations, Challenges, and Opportunities for Improvement. Agricultural Economics. 34 (3). pp. 207–219.

Foster, A.D. and Rosenzweig, M.R. 1995. Learning by doing and learning from others: Human capital and technical change in agriculture. Journal of political Economy, 103(6), pp.1176-1209.

Ghosh, M. K., S. S. Hasan, R. Fariha, M. O. Bari, and M. A. Parvin. 2021. Women Empowerment through Agriculture in Chapainawabganj, Bangladesh. European Journal of Agriculture and Food Sciences. 3(1). pp. 153‒160.

Gilligan, D. O. 2012. Biofortification, Agricultural Technology Adoption, and Nutrition Policy: Some Lessons and Emerging Challenges. CESifo Economic Studies. 58 (2). pp. 405–421.

Gilligan, D. O., N. Kumar, S. McNiven, J. V. Meenakshi, and A. Quisumbing. 2020. Bargaining Power, Decision Making, and Biofortification: The Role of Gender in Adoption of Orange Sweet Potato in Uganda. Food Policy. 95. p. 101909.

HarvestPlus. 2015. Bangladesh Releases New, Improved Zinc Rice Variety.

Hassanein, M.S., Zaki, N.M. and Ahmed, A.G. 2019. Effect of Zn foliar application on growth and yield characteristics of two wheat cultivars. Current Science International, 8(3), pp.491-498.

Hossain, M., Bose, M.L. and Mustafi, B.A., 2006. Adoption and productivity impact of modern rice varieties in Bangladesh. The Developing Economies, 44(2), pp.149-166.

Hossain, S. D. and A. Hossen. 2020. Poverty Maps of Bangladesh 2016: Key Findings. Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics and World Food Programme.

Iqbal, K. and K. A. Toufique. 2016. Formal vs. Informal Seeds: Adoption and Productivity Differences. The Bangladesh Development Studies. 39 (1-2). pp. 59–81.

IZiNCG (International Zinc Nutrition Consultative Group). 2004. Assessment of the Risk of Zinc Deficiency in Populations and Options for Its Control. Food and Nutrition Bulletin. 25 (supplement 2). pp. S91–S204.

Jack, K. 2011. Constraints on the Adoption of Agricultural Technologies in Developing Countries. White Paper. Berkeley, CA: Agricultural Technology Adoption Initiative (ATAI), Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL), and Center for Effective Global Action (UC Berkeley).

Khan, Z. and Ali, A. 2023. Global Food Insecurity and Its Association with Malnutrition. Emerging Challenges in Agriculture and Food Science, p.2.

Krishnan, P. and M. Patnam. 2014. Neighbors and Extension Agents in Ethiopia: Who Matters More for Technology Adoption? American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 96 (1). pp. 308–327.

Global Data Lab. 2019. Area Database [Data set]. Global Data Lab.

Malapit, H. J. L. and A. R. Quisumbing. 2015. What Dimensions of Women’s Empowerment in Agriculture Matter for Nutrition in Ghana? Food Policy. 52. pp. 54–63.

Malapit, H. J. L., S. Kadiyala, A. R. Quisumbing, K. Cunningham, and P. Tyagi. 2015. Women’s Empowerment Mitigates the Negative Effects of Low Production Diversity on Maternal and Child Nutrition in Nepal. The Journal of Development Studies. 51 (8). pp. 1097–1123.

McNiven, S. and Gilligan, D.O. 2012. Networks and constraints on the diffusion of a biofortified agricultural technology: Evidence from a partial population experiment. Unpublished, University of California, Davis.

Meier, C., El Benni, N., Sakamma, S., Moakes, S., Grovermann, C., Quiédeville, S., Stolz, H., Stolze, M. and Umesh, K.B. 2020. Are non-farming consumers willing to pay “a good market price” for iron-biofortified finger millet? Evidence from experimental auctions in Karnataka, India. Journal of Agribusiness in Developing and Emerging Economies, 10(5), pp.751-779.

Monfared, V., Salehian, A., Nikniaz, Z., Ebrahimpour-Koujan, S. and Faghfoori, Z. 2023. The effect of zinc supplementation on anthropometric measurements in healthy children over two years: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC pediatrics, 23(1), p.414.

Ogutu, S.O., 2018. Agriculture-Nutrition Linkages in the Kenyan Small Farm Sector: The Role of Commercialization, Technology Adoption, and Extension (Doctoral dissertation, Dissertation, Göttingen, Georg-August Universität, 2018). Ogutu, S.O., Fongar, A., Gödecke, T., Jäckering, L., Mwololo, H., Njuguna, M., Wollni, M. and Qaim, M. 2020. How to make farming and agricultural extension more nutrition-sensitive: evidence from a randomised controlled trial in Kenya. European Review of Agricultural Economics, 47(1), pp.95-118.

Okello, J.J., Kwikiriza, N., Muoki, P., Wambaya, J. and Heck, S., 2019. Effect of intensive agriculture-nutrition education and extension program adoption and diffusion of biofortified crops. Journal of Agricultural & Food Information, 20(3), pp.254-276.

Osmani, A. G. and E. Hossain. 2015. Market Participation Decision of Smallholder Farmers and Its Determinants in Bangladesh. Еconomics of Agriculture. 62 (1). pp. 163–179.

Rahman, S., T. Ahmed, A. S. Rahman, N. Alam, A. M. S. Ahmed, S. Ireen, I. A. Chowdhury, F. P. Chowdhury, and S. M. M. Rahman. 2016. Status of Zinc Nutrition in Bangladesh: The Underlying Associations. Journal of Nutritional Science. 5.

Rerksuppaphol, L. and Rerksuppaphol, S., 2019. Zinc deficiency in children with Dengue viral infection. Pediatric reports, 11(1), p.7386.

Sanjeeva Rao, D., C. N. Neeraja, P. Madhu Babu, B. Nirmala, K. Suman, L. V. Rao, and S. R. Voleti. 2020. Zinc Biofortified Rice Varieties: Challenges, Possibilities, and Progress in India. Frontiers in Nutrition. 7. p. 26.

Shiferaw, B., T. Kebede, M. Kassie, and M. Fisher. 2015. Market Imperfections, Access to Information and Technology Adoption in Uganda: Challenges of Overcoming Multiple Constraints. Agricultural Economics. 46 (4). pp. 475–488.

Shiferaw, B. A., T. A. Kebede, and L. You. 2008. Technology Adoption under Seed Access Constraints and the Economic Impacts of Improved Pigeonpea Varieties in Tanzania. Agricultural Economics. 39 (3). pp. 309–323.

Shivalingaiah, M. and Ramaraj, S.M. 2019. Serum zinc levels in children hospitalized with pneumonia–A cross-sectional study. Indian Journal of Child Health, pp.545-547.

Simtowe, F., P. Marenya, E. Amondo, M. Worku, and O. Erenstein. 2019. Heterogeneous Seed Access and Information Exposure: Implications for the Adoption of Drought-Tolerant Maize Varieties in Uganda. Agricultural and Food Economics. 7 (1). pp. 1–23.

Singh, S.P. and N. Kumar. 2014. Rice Seeds Availability in India and Bangladesh. CUTS International Briefing Paper No. 4.

Suri, T., 2011. Selection and comparative advantage in technology adoption. Econometrica, 79 (1), pp.159-209.

Swamy, B., P. Rahman, M. Inabangan-Asilo, M. Amparado, A. Manito, M. Chadha-Mohanty, A. Reinke, and A. Slamet-Loedin. 2016. Advances in Breeding for High Grain Zinc in Rice. Rice. 9 (1). p. 49.

Talsma, E. F., Melse-Boonstra, A., and Brouwer, I. D. (2017). Acceptance and adoption of biofortified crops in low-and middle-income countries: a systematic review. Nutrition reviews, 75(10), 798-829.

Tibamanya, F.Y., Henningsen, A. and Milanzi, M.A., 2022. Drivers of and barriers to adoption of improved sunflower varieties amongst smallholder farmers in Singida, Tanzania: A double-hurdle approach. Q Open, 2(1), p.qoac008.

Vaiknoras, K., C. Larochelle, E. Birol, D. Asare-Marfo, and C. Herrington. 2019. Promoting Rapid and Sustained Adoption of Biofortified Crops: What We Learned from Iron-Biofortified Bean Delivery Approaches in Rwanda. Food Policy. 83. pp. 271–284.

Ward, P. S. and V. O. Pede. 2014. Capturing Social Network Effects in Technology Adoption: The Spatial Diffusion of Hybrid Rice in Bangladesh. Australian Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics. 58. pp. 1–17.