Marshall Meets Lewis: Efficiency of Sharecropping in the Presence of Surplus Labor

Ahmed, Shakil and Mallick, Debdulal and Roy Chowdhury, Prabal (2025): Marshall Meets Lewis: Efficiency of Sharecropping in the Presence of Surplus Labor.

Abstract

Our paper revisits the Marshallian inefficiency but from a different perspective in the presence of surplus labor in the farm household. We investigate the (in)efficiency of sharecropping relative to owner cultivation and fixed-rent cultivation in terms of total factor productivity (TFP), which is another important departure from the existing literature. We use an unbalanced panel dataset at the farm household level consisting of 4,206 rice cultivating plots for two major rice cropping seasons in Bangladesh. Our main identification strategy is based on a controlled experiment in which we take two plots cultivated by each farm household—one owned and another rented-in, either under a sharecropping or a fixed-rent contract. After controlling for time-varying household fixed effects, season fixed effects, plot-level characteristics such as soil quality, land elevation and provision for irrigation, and shocks that might damage crops, we find that TFP is about 4.2 percent lower in sharecropping than in owner cultivation, while there is no difference between fixed-rent and owner cultivation. It is labor than capital and material inputs per unit of land that is less intensively used in sharecropping plots. The important result is that the difference in TFP and labor use between sharecropping and owner cultivation decreases with the endowment of (male) working-age members at the household and ceases to exist after a threshold (3 or more working-age male members). Explanations of the results are discussed.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Marshallian inefficiency, Surplus labor, Total factor productivity, Sharecropping, Tenancy.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D2 - Production and Organizations > D24 - Production ; Cost ; Capital ; Capital, Total Factor, and Multifactor Productivity ; Capacity; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J4 - Particular Labor Markets > J43 - Agricultural Labor Markets; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q12 - Micro Analysis of Farm Firms, Farm Households, and Farm Input Markets; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q1 - Agriculture > Q15 - Land Ownership and Tenure ; Land Reform ; Land Use ; Irrigation ; Agriculture and Environment

References

Acharya, R.N. and Ekelund, R.B. (1998), "Mixed and Pure Sharecropping in Nepal: Empirical Evidence Supporting the Traditional Hypothesis", Applied Economics, 30, 37-50.

Adamopoulos, Tasso and Diego Restuccia (2014), “The Size Distribution of Farms and International Productivity Differences,” American Economic Review, Vol. 104 (6), pp. 1667–1697.

Adamopoulos, Tasso and Diego Restuccia (2020), “Land Reform and Productivity: A Quantitative Analysis with Micro Data,” American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, Vol. 12 (3), pp. 1–39.

Aragón, Fernando M., Diego Restuccia, Juan Pablo Rud (2022), “Are Small Farms Really More Productive than Large Farms?” Food Policy, Vol. 106 (Article 102168), pp. 1-11.

Arcand, J-L, C Ai and F Ethier (2007), “Moral hazard and Marshallian inefficiency: Evidence from Tunisia”, Journal of Development Economics, 83 (2), pp. 411–445.

Bandiera, Oriana (2007), “Land Tenure, Investment Incentives, and the Choice of Techniques: Evidence from Nicaragua,” World Bank Economic Review, Vol. 21 (3), pp. 487–508.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2016), “Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics- 2014,” Statistics and Informatics Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2022), “Agriculture Census 2019,” Vol. 1: Structure of Agricultural Holdings and Livestock & Fisheries, Statistics and Informatics Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.

Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (2024), “Yearbook of Agricultural Statistics- 2023,” Statistics and Informatics Division, Ministry of Planning, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.

Bardhan, Pranab (1984), “Land, Labor, and Rural Poverty,” Columbia University Press, New York.

Basu, Susanto and John G. Fernald (1997), “Returns to Scale in U.S. Production: Estimates and Implications,” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 105 (2, April), pp. 249-283.

Bell, Clive (1977), “Alternative Theories of Sharecropping: Some Tests Using Evidence from Northeast India,” Journal of Development Studies, 13 (4), 317–346.

Bhuiyan, M. S. R. (1987), “Effect of Farm Size and Tenurial Status of Land on Production Efficiency in an Area of Bangladesh,” Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 10 (1), pp. 1-31.

Bidisha, Sayema Haque, Md. Amzad Hossain, Rubaiyat Alam, Mehedi Hasan (2018), “Credit, Tenancy Choice and Agricultural Efficiency: Evidence from the Northern Region of Bangladesh,” Economic Analysis and Policy, Vol. 57 (March), pp. 22-32.

Braido, Luis H. B. (2006), “Insurance and Incentives in Sharecropping,” in Competitive Failures in Insurance Markets: Theory and Policy Implications, edited by Pierre-André Chiappori and Christian Gollier, CESifo Seminar Series, MIT Press.

Braido, Luis H. B. (2008), “Evidence on the Incentive Properties of Share Contracts,” Journal of Law & Economics, Vol. 51 (2), pp. 327-349.

Brandt, Loren, Stephen Ayerst and Diego Restuccia (2018), “Market Constraints, Misallocation, and Productivity in Vietnam Agriculture,” WIDER Working Paper 114, UNU-WIDER.

Burchardi, Konrad, Selim Gulesci, Benedetta Lerva and Munshi Sulaiman (2019), “Moral Hazard: Experimental Evidence from Tenancy Contracts,” Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 134 (1), pp. 281–347.

Chay, Kenneth and Kaivan Munshi (2015), “Black Networks After Emancipation: Evidence from Reconstruction and the Great Migration,” mimeo.

Cheung, Steven N. S. (1968), “Private Property Rights and Sharecropping,” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 76 (6), pp. 1107-1122.

Cheung, Steven N. S. (1969), “The Theory of Share Tenancy,” University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Deininger, Klaus and Gershon Feder (2001), “Land Institutions and Land Markets,” in Handbook of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 1A (Agricultural Production), Edited by Bruce L. Gardner, Gordon C. Rausser, Elsevier, New York, Chapter 6, pp. 287-331.

Chen, Chaoran, Diego Restuccia and Raúl Santaeulàlia-Llopis (2021), “The Effects of Land Markets on Resource Allocation and Agricultural Productivity,” Review of Economic Dynamics, Vol, 45 (July), pp. 41-54.

Chen, Chaoran, Diego Restuccia and Raül Santaeulàlia-Llopis (2023), “Land Misallocation and Productivity, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, Vol. 15 (2), pp. 441–465.

Dubois, Pierre (2002), “Moral Hazard, Land Fertility and Sharecropping in a Rural Area of the Philippines,” Journal of Development Economics, Vol. 68 (1), pp. 35-64.

Georgescu-Roegen, Nicholas (1960), “Economic Theory and Agrarian Reforms,” Oxford Economic Papers, Vol. X12 (1, February), pp. 1-40.

Hayami, Yujiro and Keijiro Otsuka (1993), “The Economics of Contract Choice: An Agrarian Perspective,” Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK.

Helfand, Steven M. and Matthew P. H. Taylor (2021), “The Inverse Relationship between Farm Size and Productivity: Refocusing the Debate,” Food Policy, Vol. 99 (Article 101977), pp. 1-12.

Hossain, Mahabub (1977), “Farm Size, Tenancy and Land Productivity: An Analysis of Farm Level Data in Bangladesh Agriculture,” Bangladesh Development Studies, Vol. 5 (3), pp. 285-348.

Hossain, Mahabub and Abdul Bayes (2009), “Rural Economy and Livelihoods: Insights from Bangladesh,” A H Development Publishing House, Dhaka, Bangladesh.

Hossain, Mahabub, Mohammad A. Malek and Narayan C. Das (2014), “Tenant Farmers’ Access to Credit and Extension Services: BRAC Tenant Farmer Development Project in Bangladesh,” Working Paper No. 40, Research and Evaluation Division, BRAC, Bangladesh.

Hossen M. A. (2019), “Mechanization in Bangladesh: Way of Modernization in Agriculture,” International Journal of Engineering Trends and Technology, Vol. 67 (9), pp. 69-77.

Jacoby, Hanan G. and Ghazala Mansuri (2008), “Land Tenancy and Non-Contractible Investment in Rural Pakistan,” Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 75 (3), pp. 763–788.

Jacoby, Hanan G. and Ghazala Mansuri (2009), “Incentives, supervision and sharecropper productivity”, Journal of Development Economics, Vol. 88 (2), pp. 232–241.

Jaim, W. M. H. and Mahabub Hossain (2011), “Women’s Participation in Agriculture in Bangladesh: Trends, Determinants and Impact on Livelihoods,” 2011 ASAE 7th International Conference, October 13-15, Hanoi, Vietnam, Asian Society of Agricultural Economists.

Kmenta, Jan (1967), “On Estimation of the CES Production Function,” International Economic Review, Vol. 8 (2), pp. 180-189.

Laffont, Jean-Jacques and Mohamed S. Matoussi (1995), “Moral Hazard, Financial Constraints and Sharecropping in El Oulja,” Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 62 (3), pp. 381-399.

Lewis, W. Arthur. (1954), “Economic Development with Unlimited Supplies of Labour,” Manchester School, Vol. 22 (2, May), pp. 139-191.

Mandal, M. A. S. (1980), “Farm Size, Tenure, and Productivity in an Area of Bangladesh,” Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 3 (2), pp. 21-42.

Marshall, Alfred (1890), “Principles of Economics,” Edition with annotations by C. W. Guillebaud, Macmillan and Co Limited, Ninth Edition, London (1961).

Mazumdar, Dipak (1975), “The Theory of Share-Cropping with Labour Market Dualism,” Economica, Vol. 42, No. 167 (August), pp. 261-271.

Newbery, David M. G. and Joseph E. Stiglitz (1979), “Sharecropping, Risk-sharing, and the Importance of Imperfect Information,” In Risk, Uncertainty, and Agricultural Development, edited by Roumasset James A., Jean-Marc Boussard and Inderjit Singh, Southeast Asian Regional Center for Graduate Study and Research in Agriculture, Agricultural Development Council, New York.

Otsuka, Keijiro and Yujiro Hayami (1988), “Theories of Share Tenancy: A Critical Survey,” Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 37 (1), pp. 31-68.

Otsuka, Keijiro, Hiroyuki Chuma and Yujiro Hayami (1992), “Land and Labor Contracts in Agrarian Economies: Theories and Facts,” Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 30 (4), pp. 1965-2018.

Otsuka, Keijiro (2007), “Efficiency and Equity Effects of Land Markets,” in Handbook of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 3 (Agricultural Development: Farmers, Farm Production and Farm Markets), Edited by Robert Evenson and Prabhu Pingali, Elsevier, New York, Chapter 51, pp. 2672-2703.

Quibria, M. G. and Salim Rashid (1984), “The Puzzle of Sharecropping: A Survey of Theories,” World Development, Vol. 12 (2), pp. 103-114.

Rahman, Sanzidur (2000), “Women's Employment in Bangladesh Agriculture: Composition, Determinants and Scope,” Journal of Rural Studies, Vol. 16 (4), pp. 497-507.

Rahman, Sanzidur (2010), “Determinants of Agricultural Land Rental Market Transactions in Bangladesh,” Land Use Policy, Vol. 27 (3), pp. 957-964.

Rahman, Sanzidur and Mizanur Rahman (2009), “Impact of Land Fragmentation and Resource Ownership on Productivity and Efficiency: The Case of Rice Producers in Bangladesh,” Land Use Policy, Vol. 26 (1), pp. 95-103.

Rahman, Mohammad M. and Jeffery D. Connor (2022), “The Effect of High-Yielding Variety on Rice Yield, Farm Income and Household Nutrition: Evidence from Rural Bangladesh,” Agriculture & Food Security, Vol. 11 (Article No. 35), pp. 1-11.

Roumasset, James and Sang-Hyop Lee (2007), “Labor: Decisions, Contracts and Organization,” in Handbook of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 3 (Agricultural Development: Farmers, Farm Production and Farm Markets), Edited by Robert Evenson and Prabhu Pingali, Elsevier, New York, Chapter 52, pp. 2705-2740.

Shahid, A. and Robert W. Herdt (1982), “Land Tenure and Rice Production in Four Villages of Dhaka District, Bangladesh,” Bangladesh Development Studies, Vol. 10 (4), pp. 113-124.

Sen, Amartya K. (1966), “Peasants and Dualism with or without Surplus Labor,” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 74 (5), pp. 425-450.

Sen, Amartya, K. (1962), “An Aspect of Indian Agriculture,” Economic Weekly, Vol. 14 (4-6), pp. 243-246.

Sen, Debapriya (2016), “Sharecropping in theory and practice: a selective review,” in: S. Banerjee, V. Mukherjee, S.K. Haldar (eds.) Understanding Development: An Indian Perspective on Legal and Economic Policy, pp. 53-72, 2016, Springer.

Sen, Binayak, Tajnoore Samina Khanam, Shishir Kumar Munshi, Sk. Masudur Rahman and Muntasir Murshed (2023), “Choice of Tenancy in Rural Bangladesh: Evidence from the 62-Village, HIES, and BIDS-BARD 6-Village Surveys,” Paper presented at the ABCD 2023 (7-9 December), Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies, Dhaka, Bangladesh. https://bids.org.bd/public/bids-org/uploads/events/ABCD2023/Day_3/Session%208_paper_2.pdf (accessed on December 10, 2024).

Shaban, Radwan Ali (1987), “Testing between Competing Models of Sharecropping,” Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 95 (5), pp. 893-920.

Singh, Nirvikar (1989), “Theories of Sharecropping,” in The Economic Theory of Agrarian Institutions, edited by Pranab Bardhan, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Stiglitz, Joseph E. (1974), ‘Incentives and Risk Sharing in Sharecropping,” Review of Economic Studies, Vol. 41 (2), pp. 219-255.

Talukdar, R. K. (1980), “Land Tenure and Efficiency in Boro Rice Production in an Area of Mymensingh,” Bangladesh Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol. 3 (2), pp. 43-45.

Tenriawaru, Nixia, Muslim Salam, Muhammad Ridwan, Sitti Nurani Sirajuddin, Abdel Razzaq M. Al-Tawaha, Siti Hardiyanti Syam (2023), “Comparison of the Application of Local and Superior Rice Varieties in Terraced Rice Fields and their Implications for Farmers’ Income,” Universal Journal of Agricultural Research, Vol. 11 (3), pp. 537-546.

Townsend, Robert F., J. Kirsten and N. Vink (1998), “Farm Size, Productivity and Returns to Scale in Agriculture Revisited: A Case Study of Wine Producers in South Africa,” Agricultural Economics, Vol. 19 (1-2), pp. 175-180.

Wood, Geof (2022), ‘Rentiers and Contractors: The Future of Agrarian Bangladesh, Part 1: The Agrarian Transition since Liberation,” Review of Agrarian Studies, Vol. 12 (1), pp. 9-30.

Wood, Geof and M. A. Sattar Mandal (2022), “Rentiers and Contractors: The Future of Agrarian Bangladesh, Part 2: The Disappearance of the Bangladeshi Farm?” Review of Agrarian Studies, Vol. 12 (2), pp. 98-129.

Young, H. Peyton, (1996), “The Economics of Convention,” Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 10 (2), pp. 105–122.

Zaman, M. Raquibuz (1973), ‘Sharecropping and Economic Efficiency in Bangladesh,” Bangladesh Economic Review, Vol. 1 (2), pp. 149-172.