Do High Power Prices Slow Electrification? Some Panel Data Evidence

Huntington, Hillard (2025): Do High Power Prices Slow Electrification? Some Panel Data Evidence. Forthcoming in: Energy Policy

Abstract

Electrifying household and economic activity remain a cornerstone of the transition towards deep decarbonization. This analysis conducts a cross-country evaluation through a pooled mean-group model based upon 33 OECD nations since 1980. Electrification is defined as electricity’s share of the total energy system. The results show that electrification would have decreased by approximately 13 to 31 percent below other countries if the electricity price level had increased above other countries by 100 percent. Additional sensitivities show that symmetry between this response between price increases and price decreases depends upon whether GDP is exogenous. These estimates highlight the critical importance of finding new generation, transmission and distribution technologies that both reduce emissions and remain cost competitive. They also emphasize that any successful transition pathway must price electric power competitively based upon the opportunity costs of providing power. Efforts to bundle costly social programs and other expenses into power prices should be avoided.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: OECD electrification; electricity prices; cross-country panel analysis
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C2 - Single Equation Models ; Single Variables > C23 - Panel Data Models ; Spatio-temporal Models; L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L94 - Electric Utilities; L - Industrial Organization > L9 - Industry Studies: Transportation and Utilities > L98 - Government Policy; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q41 - Demand and Supply ; Prices; Q - Agricultural and Natural Resource Economics ; Environmental and Ecological Economics > Q4 - Energy > Q48 - Government Policy

References

Aklin, M., Harish, S.P. and Urpelainen, J., 2018. A global analysis of progress in household electrification. Energy Policy, 122, pp.421-428.

Adeyemi, O.I. and Hunt, L.C., 2014. Accounting for asymmetric price responses and underlying energy demand trends in OECD industrial energy demand. Energy Economics, 45, pp.435-444.

Adeyemi, O.I., Broadstock, D.C., Chitnis, M., Hunt, L.C. and Judge, G., 2010. Asymmetric price responses and the underlying energy demand trend: Are they substitutes or complements? Evidence from modelling OECD aggregate energy demand. Energy Economics, 32(5), pp.1157-1164.

Aydin, M., 2019. Renewable and non-renewable electricity consumption–economic growth nexus: evidence from OECD countries. Renewable energy, 136, pp.599-606.

Baek, J., 2016. A new look at the FDI–income–energy–environment nexus: dynamic panel data analysis of ASEAN. Energy Policy, 91, pp.22-27.

Barron, A.R., Fawcett, A.A., Hafstead, M.A., McFarland, J.R. and Morris, A.C., 2018. Policy insights from the EMF 32 study on US carbon tax scenarios. Climate change economics, 9(01), p.1840003.

Bhatia, M., & N. Angelou. (2015). Beyond Connections: Energy Access Redefined. ESMAP Technical Report 008/15, The World Bank.

Bistline, J.E. and Blanford, G.J., 2021. The role of the power sector in net-zero energy systems. Energy and Climate Change, 2, p.100045.

Bistline, J.E., Blanford, G., Grant, J., Knipping, E., McCollum, D.L., Nopmongcol, U., Scarth, H., Shah, T. and Yarwood, G., 2022. Economy-wide evaluation of CO2 and air quality impacts of electrification in the United States. Nature Communications, 13(1), p.6693.

Bistline, J.E., Brown, M., Siddiqui, S.A. and Vaillancourt, K., 2020. Electric sector impacts of renewable policy coordination: A multi-model study of the North American energy system. Energy Policy, 145, p.111707.

Blackburne III, E.F. and Frank, M.W., 2007. Estimation of nonstationary heterogeneous panels. The Stata Journal, 7(2), pp.197-208.

Borenstein, S. and Bushnell, J.B., 2022a. Do two electricity pricing wrongs make a right? Cost recovery, externalities, and efficiency. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 14(4), pp.80-110.

Borenstein, S. and Bushnell, J.B., 2022b. Headwinds and tailwinds: Implications of inefficient retail energy pricing for energy substitution. Environmental and energy policy and the economy, 3(1), pp.37-70.

Browning, M., McFarland, J., Bistline, J., Boyd, G., Muratori, M., Binsted, M., Harris, C., Mai, T., Blanford, G., Edmonds, J. and Fawcett, A.A., 2023. Net-zero CO2 by 2050 scenarios for the United States in the Energy Modeling Forum 37 study. Energy and Climate Change, 4, p.100104.

Burke, P.J., Stern, D.I. and Bruns, S.B., 2018. The impact of electricity on economic development: A macroeconomic perspective. International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics, 12(1), pp.85-127.

Carl, J. and Fedor, D., 2016. Tracking global carbon revenues: A survey of carbon taxes versus cap-and-trade in the real world. Energy Policy, 96, pp.50-77.

Carrion-i-Silvestre, J.L., del Barrio-Castro, T. and Lopez-Bazo, E., 2005. Breaking the panels: an application to the GDP per capita. The Econometrics Journal, pp.159-175.

Chao, H.P. and Huntington, H.G. eds., 2013. Designing competitive electricity markets (Vol. 13). Springer Science & Business Media.

Chudik, A. and Pesaran, M.H., 2015. Common correlated effects estimation of heterogeneous dynamic panel data models with weakly exogenous regressors. Journal of econometrics, 188(2), pp.393-420.

Chuliá, H., Klein, T., Mendoza, J.A.M. and Uribe, J.M., 2024. Vulnerability of European electricity markets: A quantile connectedness approach. Energy Policy, 184, p.113862.

David, P.A., 1990. The dynamo and the computer: an historical perspective on the modern productivity paradox. The American economic review, 80(2), pp.355-361.

Davis, L.W., 2023. What matters for electrification? Evidence from 70 years of US home heating choices. Review of Economics and Statistics, pp.1-46.

Davis, L.W., Hausman, C. and Rose, N.L., 2023. Transmission impossible? Prospects for decarbonizing the US grid. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 37(4), pp.155-180.

Fabra, N., 2023. Reforming European electricity markets: Lessons from the energy crisis. Energy Economics, 126, p.106963.

Feldstein, M.S., 1972. Equity and efficiency in public sector pricing: the optimal two-part tariff. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 86(2), pp.175-187.

Fiszbein, M., Lafortune, J., Lewis, E.G. and Tessada, J., 2020. Powering Up Productivity: The Effects of Electrification on US Manufacturing. NBER Working Paper, (w28076).

Gately, D. and Huntington, H.G., 2002. The asymmetric effects of changes in price and income on energy and oil demand. The Energy Journal, 23(1).

Gordon, R.J., 2016. The Rise and Fall of American Growth: The U. S. Standard of Living Since the Civil War. Princeton University Press.

Hegwood, N. and Papell, D.H., 2007. Are real GDP levels trend, difference, or regime‐wise trend stationary? Evidence from panel data tests incorporating structural change. Southern Economic Journal, 74(1), pp.104-113.

Im, K. S., M. H. Pesaran, and Y. Shin. 2003. Testing for unit roots in heterogeneous panels. Journal of Econometrics 115: 53-74. International Energy Agency (2024), World Energy Outlook 2024, IEA, Paris https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2024, Licence: CC BY 4.0 (report); CC BY NC SA 4.0 (Annex A).

International Energy Agency, n.d., Tracking electrification, https://www.iea.org/energy-system/electricity/electrification.

Joskow, P.L., 2020. Transmission capacity expansion is needed to decarbonize the electricity sector efficiently. Joule, 4(1), pp.1-3.

Labandeira, X., Labeaga, J.M. and López-Otero, X., 2017. A meta-analysis on the price elasticity of energy demand. Energy policy, 102, pp.549-568.

Lee, K., Miguel, E. and Wolfram, C., 2020. Does household electrification supercharge economic development?. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 34(1), pp.122-144.

Levin, T., Botterud, A., Mann, W.N., Kwon, J. and Zhou, Z., 2022. Extreme weather and electricity markets: Key lessons from the February 2021 Texas crisis. Joule, 6(1), pp.1-7.

Lewis, J. and Severnini, E., 2020. Short-and long-run impacts of rural electrification: Evidence from the historical rollout of the US power grid. Journal of Development Economics, 143, p.102412.

Liddle, B. and Huntington, H., 2020. Data for: leap-frogging and energy consumption: a country panel analysis. Mendeley Data, V1, doi: 10.17632/3nmbz2jyd2.1.

Liddle, B., 2022. Introducing a large panel dataset of economy-wide real electricity prices and estimating long-run GDP and price elasticities of electricity demand for high-and middle-income panels. Journal of Energy History/Revue d'Histoire de l'Énergie [Online], (7).

Liddle, B., 2023. Is timing everything? Assessing the evidence on whether energy/electricity demand elasticities are time-varying. Energy Economics, p.106872.

Luderer, G., Madeddu, S., Merfort, L., Ueckerdt, F., Pehl, M., Pietzcker, R., Rottoli, M., Schreyer, F., Bauer, N., Baumstark, L. and Bertram, C., 2022. Impact of declining renewable energy costs on electrification in low-emission scenarios. Nature Energy, 7(1), pp.32-42.

Miller, M. and Alberini, A., 2016. Sensitivity of price elasticity of demand to aggregation, unobserved heterogeneity, price trends, and price endogeneity: Evidence from US Data. Energy Policy, 97, pp.235-249.

Opoku, E.E.O. and Boachie, M.K., 2020. The environmental impact of industrialization and foreign direct investment. Energy Policy, 137, p.111178.

Pesaran, M. H. 2007. A simple panel unit root test in the presence of cross section dependence, Journal of Applied Econometrics 22(2): 265-312.

Pesaran, M. H. 2015. Testing weak cross-sectional dependence in large panels. Econometric Reviews 34(6-10): 1089-1117.

Pesaran, M. H., Y. Shin, and R. P. Smith. 1999. Pooled mean group estimation of dynamic heterogeneous panels. Journal of the American Statistical Association 94: 621-634.

Pesaran, M.H., Shin, Y. and Smith, R.J., 2001. Bounds testing approaches to the analysis of level relationships. Journal of Applied Econometrics, 16(3), pp.289-326.

Pollitt, M.G., 2023. Energy Markets Under Stress: Some Reflections on Lessons From the Energy Crisis in Europe (No. 2350). Faculty of Economics, University of Cambridge.

Pollitt, M.G., von der Fehr, N.H.M., Willems, B., Banet, C., Le Coq, C. and Chyong, C.K., 2024. Recommendations for a future-proof electricity market design in Europe in light of the 2021-23 energy crisis. Energy Policy, 188, p.114051.

Raouf, E., 2023. Green hydrogen production and public health expenditure in hydrogen-exporting countries. International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy, 13(6), pp.36-44.

Rule, T.A., 2024. Electricity Affordability in Context. Arizona State University Sandra Day O'Connor College of Law Paper, San Diego Journal of Climate & Energy Law (forthcoming 2025).

Sahari, A., 2019. Electricity prices and consumers’ long-term technology choices: Evidence from heating investments. European Economic Review, 114, pp.19-53.

Schittekatte, T., Mallapragada, D., Joskow, P.L. and Schmalensee, R., 2023. Reforming retail electricity rates to facilitate economy-wide decarbonization. Joule, 7(5), pp.831-836.

Shin, Y., Yu, B. and Greenwood-Nimmo, M., 2014. Modelling asymmetric cointegration and dynamic multipliers in a nonlinear ARDL framework. Festschrift in honor of Peter Schmidt: Econometric methods and applications, pp.281-314.

Singh, M., Ong, A. and Sud, R., 2024. Trends and drivers of utility costs in California. Available at SSRN.

Tran, B.L., Chen, C.C. and Tseng, W.C., 2022. Causality between energy consumption and economic growth in the presence of GDP threshold effect: Evidence from OECD countries. Energy, 251, p.123902.

US Department of Energy, n.d. What is electrification?, https://www.energy.gov/electricity-insights/what-electrification

Williams, J.H., DeBenedictis, A., Ghanadan, R., Mahone, A., Moore, J., Morrow III, W.R., Price, S. and Torn, M.S., 2012. The technology path to deep greenhouse gas emissions cuts by 2050: the pivotal role of electricity. Science, 335(6064), pp.53-59.

Zhu, X., Li, L., Zhou, K., Zhang, X. and Yang, S., 2018. A meta-analysis on the price elasticity and income elasticity of residential electricity demand. Journal of Cleaner Production, 201, pp.169-177.