Improved estimates of the benefits of breastfeeding using sibling comparisons to reduce selection bias

Reilly, Siobhan and Evenhouse, Eirik (2005): Improved estimates of the benefits of breastfeeding using sibling comparisons to reduce selection bias. Published in: Health Services Research , Vol. 40, No. 6 (December 2005): pp. 1781-1802.

Abstract

Objective Better measurement of the health and cognitive benefits of breastfeeding by using sibling comparisons to reduce sample selection bias.

Data We use data on the breastfeeding history, physical and emotional health, academic performance, cognitive ability, and demographic characteristics of 16,903 adolescents from the first (1994) wave of the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. The sample includes 2,734 sibling pairs.

Study Design We examine the relationship between breastfeeding history and 15 indicators of physical health, emotional health, and cognitive ability, using ordinary least squares and logit regression. For each indicator, we estimate, in addition to the usual between-family model, a within-family model to see whether differences in siblings' outcomes are associated with differences in the siblings' breastfeeding histories.

Principal Findings. Nearly all of the correlations found in the between-family model become statistically insignificant in the within-family model. The notable exception is a persistent positive correlation between breastfeeding and cognitive ability. These findings hold whether breastfeeding is measured in terms of duration or as a Yes/No variable.

Conclusions This study provides persuasive evidence of a causal connection between breastfeeding and intelligence. However, it also suggests that nonexperimental studies of breastfeeding overstate some of its other long-term benefits, even if controls are included for race, ethnicity, income, and education.

The definitive version is available at www.blackwell-synergy.com

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Breast feeding; siblings; adolescents; intelligence; obesity; BMI; selection bias; breastfeeding; academic performance; allergy; PVT; Add Health; National Longitudinal Survey of Adolescent Health; bonding; overweight; diabetes; IQ; asthma; depression; human capital; parental investment; school failure
• Subjects: J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J13 - Fertility ; Family Planning ; Child Care ; Children ; Youth; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I1 - Health > I12 - Health Behavior; D - Microeconomics > D1 - Household Behavior and Family Economics

References

Alm, B., G. Wennergren, S. G. Norvenius, R. Skjaerven, H. Lagercrantz, K. Helweg-Larsen, and L. M. Irgens. 2002. ‘‘Breast Feeding and Sudden Infant Death Syndrome in Scandinavia, 1992–95.’’ Archives of Disease in Childhood 86 (6): 400–2.

Anderson, J. W., B. M. Johnstone, and D. T. Remley. 1999. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Cognitive Development: A Meta-Analysis.’’ The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 70: 525–35.

Anderson, P. M., K. F. Butcher, and P. B. Levine. 2003. ‘‘Maternal Employment and Overweight Children.’’ Journal of Health Economics 22 (3): 477–504.

Armstrong, J., J. J. Reilly, and Child Health Information Team. 2002. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Lowering the Risk of Childhood Obesity.’’ Lancet 359 (9322): 1249–50.

Baumslag, N., and D. L. Michels. 1995. Milk, Money & Madness: The Culture and Politics of Breastfeeding. Westport: Bergin & Garvey.

Beaudry, M., R. Dufour, and S. Marcoux. 1995. ‘‘Relationship between Infant Feeding and Infections during the First Six Months of Life.’’ Journal of Pediatrics 126: 191–7.

Behrman, J. R., M. R. Rosenzweig, and P. Taubman. 1994. ‘‘Endowments and the Allocation of Schooling in the Family and the Marriage Market: The Twins Experiment.’’ Journal of Political Economy 102: 1131–74.

Behrman, J. R., R. Pollack, and P. Taubman. 1982. ‘‘Parental Preferences and the Provision of Progeny.’’ Journal of Political Economy 90: 52–73.

British Childhood Cancer Study Investigators. 2001. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Childhood Cancer.’’ British Journal of Cancer 85 (11): 1685–94.

Card, D. 1999. ‘‘The Causal Effect of Education on Earnings.’’ In Handbook of Labor Economics, Vol. 3A, edited by O. Ashenfelter and D. Card. Amsterdam: North- Holland.

Chen, A., and W. Rogan. 2004. ‘‘Breastfeeding and the Risk of Postneonatal Death in the United States.’’ Pediatrics 113 (5): e435–9.

Chen, Y., S. Z. Yu, and W. X. Li. 1988. ‘‘Artificial Feeding and Hospitalization in the First 18 Months of Life.’’ Pediatrics 81 (1): 58–62.

CollaborativeGroup on Hormonal Factors in Breast Cancer. 2002. ‘‘Breast Cancer and Breastfeeding: Collaborative Reanalysis of Individual Data from 47 Epidemiological Studies in 30 Countries, Including 50302 Women with Breast Cancer and 96973 Women without the Disease.’’ Lancet 360 (9328): 187–95.

Davis,M. K. 1998. ‘‘Review of the Evidence for an Association between Infant Feeding and Childhood Cancer.’’ International Journal of Cancer 11 (suppl): 29–33.

Davis, M. K., D. A. Savitz, and B. I. Graubard. 1988. ‘‘Infant Feeding and Childhood Cancer.’’ Lancet 2 (8607): 365–8.

Dell, S., and T. To. 2001. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Asthma in Young Children: Findings from a Population-Based Study.’’ Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine 155 (11): 1261–5.

Dewey, K. G., M. J. Heinig, and L. A. Nommsen-Rivers. 1995. ‘‘Differences in Morbidity between Breast-Fed and Formula-Fed Infants.’’ Journal of Pediatrics 126: 696–702.

Gilman, M., S. L. Rifas-Shiman, C. A. Camargo Jr., C. S. Berkey, A. L. Frazier, H. R. Rockett, A. E. Field, and G. A. Colditz. 2001. ‘‘Risk of Overweight among Adolescents Who Were Breastfed as Infants.’’ Journal of the American Medical Association 285 (19): 2461–7.

Griliches, Z. 1979. ‘‘Sibling Models and Data in Economics: Beginnings of a Survey.’’ Journal of Political Economy 87 (5, Part 2): S37–64.

Hediger, M., M. D. Overpeck, R. J. Kuczmarski, and W. J. Ruan. 2001. ‘‘Association between Infant Breastfeeding and Overweight in Young Children.’’ Journal of the American Medical Association 284: 2453–60.

Heinig, M. J., and K. G. Dewey. 1997. ‘‘Health Effects of Breastfeeding for Mothers: A Critical Review.’’ Nutrition Research Reviews 10: 35–56.

Horwood, L. J., B. A. Darlow, and N. Mogridge. 2001. ‘‘Breast Milk Feeding and Cognitive Ability at 7–8 Years.’’ Archives of Disease in Childhood, Fetal Neonatal Edition 84 (1): F23–7.

Huttly, S. R., F. C. Barros, C. G. Victora, J. U. Beria, and J. P. Vaughan. 1990. ‘‘Do Mothers Overestimate Breast Feeding Duration? An Example of Recall Bias from a Study in Southern Brazil.’’ American Journal of Epidemiology 132 (3): 572–5.

Kull, I., M. Wickman, G. Lilja, S. L. Nordvall, and G. Pershagen. 2002. ‘‘Breast Feeding and Allergic Diseases in Infants——A Prospective Birth Cohort Study.’’ Archives of Disease in Childhood 87 (6): 478–81.

Lawrence, R. A., and R. M. Lawrence. 1998. Breastfeeding: A Guide for the Medical Profession, 5th Edition. London: Mosby-Year Book Inc.

Lucas, A., and T. J. Cole. 1990. ‘‘Breast Milk and Neonatal Necrotising Enterocolitis.’’ Lancet 336 (8730): 1519–23.

McVea, K. L., P. D. Turner, and D. K. Peppler. 2000. ‘‘The Role of Breastfeeding in Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.’’ Journal of Human Lactation 16 (1): 13–20.

Michael, R. T. 2002. ‘‘Family Influences on a Child’s Verbal Ability.’’ Unpublished Paper, University of Chicago (September).

Milligan, R. A., L. C. Pugh, Y. L. Bronner, D. L. Spatz, and L. P. Brown. 2000. ‘‘Breastfeeding Duration among Low IncomeWomen.’’ Journal of Midwifery and Women’s Health 45 (3): 246–52.

Mitchell, E. A., R. Scragg, A. W. Stewart, D. M. Becroft, B. J. Taylor, R. P. Ford, I. B. Hassall, D. M. Barry, E. M. Allen, and A. P. Roberts. 1991. ‘‘Results from the First Year of the New Zealand Cot Death Study.’’ New Zealand Medical Journal 104: 71–6.

Mortensen, E. L., K. F. Michaelsen, S. A. Sanders, and J. M. Reinisch. 2002. ‘‘The Association between Duration of Breastfeeding and Adult Intelligence.’’ Journal of the American Medical Association 287 (18): 2365–71.

Nelson, M., P. Gordon-Larsen, and L. Adair. 2003. ‘‘The Protective Effect of Breastfeeding on Adolescent Overweight Disappears with Use of Sibling Controls.’’ Presentation at the 2003 Add Health Users Workshop, Bethesda, MD.

Northwest Environment Watch. 2004. ‘‘Flame Retardants in the Bodies of Pacific Northwest Residents: A Study on Toxic Body Burdens (September 29).’’ Seattle, WA.

Oddy, W. H., M. Halonen, F. D. Martinez, I. C. Lohman, D. A. Stern, M. Kurzius-Spencer, S. Guerra, and A. L. Wright. 2003. ‘‘TGF-Beta in Human Milk Is Associated with Wheeze in Infancy.’’ Journal of Allergy Clinical Immunology 112 (4): 723–8.

Oliveira, V., E. Racine, J. Olmstead, and L. M. Ghelfi. 2002. The WIC Program: Background, Trends, and Issues. Washington, DC: Food Assistance and Nutrition Research Report #5.

Owen, C. G., P. H. Whincup, K. Odoki, J. A. Gilg, and D. G. Cook. 2002. ‘‘Infant Feeding and Blood Cholesterol: A Study in Adolescents and a Systematic Review.’’ Pediatrics 110 (3): 597–608.

Pettitt, D. J., M. R. Forman, R. L. Hanson, W. C. Knowler, and P. H. Bennett. 1997. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Incidence of Non-Insulin-Dependent Diabetes Mellitus in Pima Indians.’’ Lancet 350 (9072): 166–8.

PROBIT Study Group, Kramer,M. S., B. Chalmers, E. D., Hodnett, Z. Sevkovskaya, I. Dzikovich, S. Shapiro, J. P. Collet, I. Vanilovich, I. Mezen, T. Ducruet, G. Shishko, V. Zubovich, D. Mknuik, E. Gluchanina, V. Dombrovskiy, A. Ustinovitch, T. Kot, N. Bogdanovich, L. Ovchinikova, and E. Helsing. 2001. ‘‘Promotion of Breastfeeding Intervention Trial (PROBIT): A Randomized Trial in the Republic of Belarus.’’ Journal of the American Medical Association 285: 413–20.

Raisler, J. 2000. ‘‘Against the Odds: Breastfeeding Experiences of Low Income Mothers.’’ Journal of Midwifery and Women’s Health 45 (3): 253–63.

Rao, M., M. L. Hediger, R. J. Levine, A. B. Naficy, and T. Vik. 2002. ‘‘Effect of Breastfeeding on Cognitive Development of Infants Born Small for Gestational Age.’’ Acta Paediatrica 91 (3): 267–74.

Rossi, P. H. 1998. Feeding the Poor: Assessing Federal Food Aid. Washington, DC: The American Enterprise Institute.

Ryan, A. S., Z. Wenjun, and A. Acosta. 2. ‘‘Breastfeeding Continues to Increase into the New Millennium.’’ Pediatrics 110 (6): 1103–9.

Scariati, P. D., L. M. Grummer-Strawn, and S. B. Fein. 1997. ‘‘A Longitudinal Analysis of Infant Morbidity and the Extent of Breastfeeding in the United States.’’ Pediatrics 99 (6): E5.

Schwartz, J. B., B. M. Popkin, J. Tognetti, and N. Zohoori. 1995. ‘‘Does WIC Participation Improve Breast-Feeding Practices?’’ American Journal of Public Health 85: 729–31.

Shu, X. O., M. S. Linet, M. Steinbuch, W. Q. Wen, J. D. Buckley, J. P. Neglia, J. D. Potter, G. H. Reaman, and L. L. Robison. 1999. ‘‘Breast-Feeding and Risk of Childhood Acute Leukemia.’’ Journal of the National Cancer Institute 91 (20): 1765–72.

Silfverdal, S. A., L. Bodin, S. Hugosson, O ¨ . Garpenholt, B. Werner, E. Esbjo¨ rner, B. Lindquist, and P. Olce´ n. 1997. ‘‘Protective Effect of Breastfeeding on Invasive Haemophilus Influenzae Infection: A Case–Control Study in Swedish Preschool Children.’’ International Journal of Epidemiology 26 (2): 443–50.

Silfverdal, S. A., L. Bodin, and P. Olcen. 1999. ‘‘Protective Effect of Breastfeeding: An Ecologic Study of Haemophilus influenzae Meningitis and Breastfeeding in a Swedish Population.’’ International Journal of Epidemiology 28: 152–6.

Singhal, A., T. J. Cole, and A. Lucas. 2001. ‘‘Early Nutrition in Preterm Infants and Later Blood Pressure: Two Cohorts after Randomised Trials.’’ Lancet 357 (9254): 413–9.

Quinn, P. J., M. O’Callaghan, G. M. Williams, J. M. Najman, M. J. Andersen, and W. Bor. 2001. ‘‘The Effect of Breastfeeding on Child Development at 5 Years: A Cohort Study.’’ Journal of Pediatric and Child Health 37 (5): 465–9.

United States General Accounting Office. 2003. ‘‘Food Assistance: Potential to Serve More WIC Infants by Reducing Formula Cost.’’ GA-03-331.

U.S. National Center for Health Statistics. Health, United States. 2003. ‘‘Chartbook on Trends in the Health of Americans’’ [accessed May 30, 2004]. Available at http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/hus/tables/2003/03hus018.pdf

van Odijk, J., I. Kull, M. P. Borres, P. Brandtzaeg, U. Edberg, L.A ° . Hanson, A.Hst,M. Kuitunen, S. F. Olsen, S. Skerfving, J. Sundell, and S. Wille. 2003. ‘‘Breastfeeding and Allergic Disease: A Multidisciplinary Review of the Literature (1966–2001) on the Mode of Early Feeding in Infancy and Its Impact on Later Atopic Manifestations.’’ Allergy 58 (9): 833–43.

Young, T. K., P. J. Martens, S. P. Taback, E. A. Sellers, H. J. Dean, M. Cheang, and B. Flett. 2002. ‘‘Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus in Children: Prenatal and Early Infancy Risk Factors among Native Canadians.’’ Archives of Pediatric and Adolescent Medicine 156 (7): 651–5.

Zheng, T., L. Duan, Y. Liu, B. Zhang, Y. Wang, Y. Chen, Y. Zhang, and P. H. Owens. 2000. ‘‘Lactation Reduces Breast Cancer Risk in Shandong Province, China.’’ American Journal of Epidemiology 152: 1129–35.

Zheng, T., T. R. Holford, S. T. Mayne, P.H. Owens, Y. Zhang, B. Zhang, P. Boyle, and S. H. Zahm. 2001. ‘‘Lactation and Breast Cancer Risk: A Case–Control Study in Connecticut.’’ British Journal of Cancer 84 (11): 1472–6.