The Domestic Stability Pact: Assessment of the Italian experience and comparison with the other EMU countries

Giuriato, Luisa and Gastaldi, Francesca (2008): The Domestic Stability Pact: Assessment of the Italian experience and comparison with the other EMU countries. Published in: Review of economic conditions in Italy No. 1 (January 2008): pp. 37-79.

Abstract

The 1999-2006 versions of the Italian Domestic Stability Pact had many shortcomings and a modest impact with respect to the aim of aligning the fiscal behaviour of sub-national government units with the national commitments under the European Stability and Growth Pact. The Domestic Pact was revised in 2007 and 2008 to tighten the monitoring and sanctions framework and prevent some inefficient behaviour. However, some undesirable features still mar the new regime: no coordination exists between the Domestic Pact and the debt and tax constraints applied to local governments; a clear definition of the contribution of sub-national governments to aggregate compliance with the external rule is still lacking; flexibility has been introduced by means of an artificial reference budget balance; side effects on resource redistribution are ignored; and monitoring and sanctioning remain weak. Remedies for the above shortcomings can possibly be found in the domestic pacts of the other EMU countries. Most of all, the Domestic Pact should be adjusted to the specific characteristics of fiscal decentralization in Italy, where a large fiscal gap exists, revenue autonomy is constrained and a large share of the responsibility for spending is rigid and politically sensitive.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Domestic stability Pact
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H70 - General; H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

AHMAD, E., M. ALBINO-WAR and R. SINGH (2005), Sub-national public financial management: institutions and macroeconomic considerations, in E. AHMAD and G.BROSIO (eds.) “Handbook of Fiscal Federalism”, E.Elgar, Cheltenham (UK) and Northampton (USA), pp. 405-427.

AMBROSANIO M. F. and M. BORDIGNON (2007), Internal Stability Pacts: The European Experience, European Economic Governance Monitor, Papers.

BALASSONE, F., M. DEGNI and G. SALVEMINI (2002), “Regole di bilancio, Patto di Stabilità Interno e autonomia delle Amministrazioni Locali”, Rassegna Parlamentare, no.3.

BALASSONE, F. and D. FRANCO (2001), “Fiscal Federalism and the Stability and Growth Pact: a difficult union”, Journal of Public Finance and Public Choice, XVII (2-3),pp.135-163.

BORDIGNON, M., P. MANASSE and G. TABELLINI (2001) “Optimal regional redistribution under asymmetric information”, American Economic Review, 91/3, pp.709-723.

BOSI, P., M.T. GUERRA and M. MATTEUZZI (2003) Patto di Stabilità e Crescita e Patto di Stabilità Interno: lezioni dall’Europea e Proposte di riforma nella prospettiva della Finanziaria per il 2004, Centro di Analisi delle Politiche Pubbliche, Modena.

BRETON, A. (1977), “A theory of local government finance and the debt regulation of local government”, Public Finance, 32, pp.16-28.

CASELLA, A. (1999), “Tradable deficit permits: efficient implementation of the Stability Pact in the EMU”, Economic Policy, pp. 323-361.

COMMISSIONE TECNICA PER LA SPESA PUBBLICA (2001) Note e raccomandazioni: finanza regionale e locale e “Patto di stabilità interno”, Rome.

DAFFLON, B. (2002), “The requirement of a balanced budget and borrowing limits in local public finance: setting out the problem”, in B. DAFFLON (ed.) Local Public Finance in Europe, E.Elgar, Cheltenham (UK) and Northampton (USA), pp. 1-14.

EICHENGREEN, B. and J. VON HAGEN (1996) “Fiscal Policy and Monetary Union: Is There a Trade-off between Federalism and Budgetary Restriction?”, NBER Working Papers, no. 5517.

FARBER G. (2002), “Local government borrowing in Germany”, in B. Dafflon, op. cit.,pp. 135-164.

GASTALDI, F., GIURIATO L. and RAPALLINI C. (2007) Rapporto sulla Finanza Locale del Lazio CGIL, Rome.

GIARDA, D.P., PETRETTO A. and PISAURO G. (2005) “Elementi per una politica di governo della spesa pubblica”, Paper to the Conference Oltre il declino, Fondazione R. De Benedetti, Camera dei Deputati, Rome.

GILBERT G. and GUEGNANT A. (2002), “The public debt of local governments in France”, in B. DAFFLON, op. cit., pp. 115-134.

ISAE (2007), Finanza pubblica e istituzioni, Rome. JOUMARD, I., R. PRICE and D. SOUTHERLAND (2005), “Fiscal Rules for Sub-central Governments: Design and Impact”, OECD Economics Department Working Papers, no.465, OECD Publishing.

LUBKE A. (2005), “Fiscal Discipline between Levels of Government in Germany”, OECD Journal on Budgeting, vol.5 no.2, pp.23-37.

MIAJA M. (2005), “Fiscal Discipline in a Decentralised Administration: the Spanish Experience”, OECD Journal on Budgeting, vol. 5 no.2, pp.39-54.

PATRIZII, V., C. RAPALLINI and G. ZITO, (2006), “I ‘patti’ di stabilità Interni”, Rivista di diritto finanziario e scienza delle finanze, Vol. LXV Fasc.1-2006, pp. 156-189.

PERSSON, T. and G. TABELLINI (1996), “Federal fiscal constitutions: risk sharing and moral hazard”, Ecomometrica, 64/3, pp.623-46.

PISAURO, G. (2001) “Intergovernmental relations and fiscal discipline: between common and soft budget constraints”, IMF Working Papers 01/65.

PISAURO, G. (2002), “Fiscal decentralization and the budget process” SIEP XIV Conference paper, pp. 688-713.

RAPALLINI C. (2007), “Il Patto di Stabilità Interno: gli accord e le norme adottati in alcuni paesi UE”, Mimeo.

RODDEN, J. (2002), “The dilemma of fiscal federalism: grants and fiscal performance around the world”, American Journal of Political Science, 46.

ROSSI, S. and B. DAFFLON (2002), “The theory of sub-national balanced budget and debt control” in B. DAFFLON, op. cit., pp. 15-44.

TER-MINASSIAN, T. and J. CRAIG (1997), “Controls of sub-national government borrowing”, in T. TER-MINASSIAN (ed.) Fiscal Federalism in Theory and Practice, IMF, Washington, D.C., pp.156-172.

THONI E., G. GARBISLANDER and D.J. HAAS (2002), “Local budgeting and local borrowing in Austria” in B. DAFFLON, op. cit., pp. 45-74.

VANNESTE J. (2002), “Local public finance in Belgium: structure, budgets and debts”, in B. DAFFLON, op. cit., pp. 75-92.

WEINGAST, R.B., K.A. SHEPSLE and C. JOHNSEN (1981), “The Political Economy of Benefits and Costs: a Neoclassical Approach to Distributive Politics”, Journal of Political Economy, 89/4, pp. 642-664.

WILDASIN, D.E. (1997), “Externalities and Bailouts. Hard and soft Budget Constraints in Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations”, World Bank, Fiscal Policy Working Papers, no. 1843.

ZANARDI, A. (2007), “Federalismo fiscale: si riparte?”, in M.C. Guerra and A. Zanardi (eds.), La finanza pubblica italiana- Rapporto 2007, Il Mulino, Bologna, pp.127-154.