Social policy and income distribution: An empirical analysis for the Netherlands

Caminada, Koen and Goudswaard, Kees (1999): Social policy and income distribution: An empirical analysis for the Netherlands. Published in: Department of Economics Research Memorandum No. 99.03 (1999): pp. 1-33.

Abstract

In most OECD-countries income inequality has increased during the last two decades. In this paper, we investigate to what extent changes in the overall distribution of incomes can be attributed to social policy measures. The case for the Netherlands is particularly interesting, because the Dutch welfare state has been reformed rather fundamentally in recent years. The budget incidence analysis indicates that in the period 1981-1996 inequality of adjusted disposable household income increased sharply. The main force behind this phenomenon was a more unequal distribution of market incomes, but social transfers also explain a substantial large part of the rise in inequality. Social security reforms indeed seem to have made the income distribution less equal. The results of a more detailed analysis for 1996 on the redistributive impact of social policy and of specific social programs - using data from an unique income panel survey - can be summarised as follows: - The first five income deciles clearly gain from social security, while the higher deciles loose. Social security causes a reduction in inequality by 26 to 50 percent, depending on the indicator used. - The public old age program and the social assistance program explain by far the largest part of redistribution by the social system, while the disability and unemployment programs do not have strong redistributive effects.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Social Policy, Income Distribution (Indices), Taxes and Transfers
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D3 - Distribution > D31 - Personal Income, Wealth, and Their Distributions; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H55 - Social Security and Public Pensions; H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H22 - Incidence

References

Aronson, J.R., P. Johnson, and P.J. Lambert (1994) 'Redistributive Effect and Unequal Income Tax Treatment' Economic Journal 104:262-270.

Atkinson, A.B. (1970) 'On the Measurement of Inequality' Journal of Economic Theory 2:244-263.

Atkinson, A.B., L. Rainwater, and T.M. Smeeding (1995) 'Income Distribution in OECD Countries: Evidence from the Luxembourg Income Study' OECD Social Policy Studies 18, Paris.

Atkinson, A.B. (1996) 'Explaining the Distribution of Income' in: J. Hills (ed.) New inequalities, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge:19-48.

Bovenberg, A.L. (1997) 'Dutch employment growth: an analysis' CPB Report 2 (2):16-24.

Caminada, K. (1996) De progressie van het belastingstelsel, (Phd in Dutch about Liability Progression and Tax Revenu Elasticity), Thesis Publishers, Amsterdam.

Caminada, K., and K.P. Goudswaard (1996) 'Progression and Revenue Effects of Income Tax Reform' International Tax and Public Finance 3 (1):57-66.

Caminada, K., and K.P. Goudswaard (1998) 'Inkomensherverdeling door sociale zekerheid. De verdeling van uitkeringen en premieheffing in 1990 en 1995' (Research Memorandum in Dutch on Income Redistribution trough Social Security in the Netherlands in 1990 and 1995) Department of Economics Research Memorandum 98.02, Leiden.

Champernowne, D.G. (1974) 'A Comparision of Measures of Inequality of Income Distribution' Economic Journal 84:787-816.

Coulter, P.B. (1989) Measuring Inequality: A Methodological Handbook, Westview Press, London.

Dalton, H. (1936) Pinciples of Public Finance, third edition, George Routledge & Sons, London.

Ervik, R. (1998) 'The Redistributive Aim of Social Policy. A Comperative Analysis of Taxes, Tax Expenditure Transfers and Direct Transfers in Eight Countries' LIS Working Paper Series 184, Luxembourg.

Figini, P. (1998) 'Inequality Measures, Equivalence Scales and Adjustment for Household Size and Composition' LIS Working Paper Series 185, Luxembourg.

Formby, J.P., W.J. Smith, and P.D. Thistle (1990) 'The Average Tax Burden and the Welfare Implications of Global Tax Progressivity' Public Finance Quarterly 18 (1):3-24.

Giles, C., A. Gosling, F. Laisney, and T. Geib (1998) The Distribution of Income and Wages in the UK and West Germany 1984-1992, Institute for Fiscal Studies, London.

Gillespie, W.I. (1965) 'Effects of Public Expenditures on the Distribution of Income' in: R. Musgrave (ed.) Essays in Fiscal Feralism, The Brookings Institution, Washington.

Goodman, A., P. Johnson, and S. Webb (1997) Inequality in the UK, Oxford University Press, New York.

Gottschalk,P., B. Gustafsson, and E. Palmer (eds.) (1997) Changing Patterns in the Distribution of Economic Welfare, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

Gottschalk, P., and T.M. Smeeding (1997) 'Cross-National Comparisons of Earnings and Income Inequality' Journal of Economic Literature 35 (June):633-687.

Gottschalk, P., and T.M. Smeeding (1998) 'Empirical Evidence on Income Inequality in Industrialized Countries LIS Working Paper Series 154 (revised), Luxembourg.

Gustafsson, B., and M. Johansson (1997) ' In Search for a Smoking Gun: What Makes Income Inequality Vary Over Time in Different Countries?' LIS Working Paper Series 172, Luxembourg.

Jeurissen, P.C.J. (1995) 'Robin Hood in Nederland’ (Robin Hood in the Netherlands) Sociaaleconomische maandstatistiek 12 (4):17-21.

Kakwani, N.C. (1977a) 'Measurement of Tax Progressivity: An International Comparison' Economic Journal 87:71-80.

Kakwani, N.C. (1977b) 'Applications of Lorenz Curves in Economic Analysis' Econometrica 45 (3):719-727.

Kiefer, D.W. (1984) 'Distributional Tax Progressivity Indexes' National Tax Journal 37:497-513.

Khetan, C.P, and S.N. Poddar (1976) 'Measurement of Income Tax Progression in a Growing Economy: The Canadian Experience' Canadian Journal of Economics 9 (4):613-629.

Kleijn, J.P. De (1998) 'Inkomensverdeling 1996' (Income Distribution 1996) Sociaal-economische maandstatistiek 15 (3):18-22 and 75-85.

Lambert, P.J., and W. Pfähler (1992) 'Income Tax Progression and Redistributive Effect: The Influence of Changes in the Pre-Tax Income Distribution' Public Finance/Finances Publiques 47 (1):1-16.

Lambert, P.J. (1993) The Distribution and Redistribution of Income: a Mathematical Analysis, second edition, Manchester University Press, Manchester.

Lambert, P.J., and J.R. Aronson (1993) 'Inequality Decomposition Analysis and the Gini Coefficient Revisited' Economic Journal 103, 1221-1227.

Lambert, P.J., and X. Ramos (1997) 'Horizontal Inequity and Vertical Redistribution' International Tax and Public Finance 4 (1):25-37.

Ministry of Social Affairs (1995) Sociale Nota 1996, (in Dutch), Sdu Uitgevers, The Hague.

Ministry of Social Affairs (1997) Sociale Nota 1998, (in Dutch), Sdu Uitgevers, The Hague.

Ministry of Social Affairs (1998) Sociale Nota 1999, (in Dutch), Sdu Uitgevers, The Hague.

Musgrave, R.A., and Tun Thin (1948) 'Income Tax Progression, 1929-48' Journal of Political Economy 56:498-514.

Musgrave, R.A., K.E. Case, and H.B. Leonard (1974) 'The Distribution of Fiscal Burdens and Benefits' Public Finance Quarterly (2), July:259-311.

Odink, J.G., and E. van Imhoff (1984) 'True versus measured Theil inequality' Statica Neerlandica (5):219-231.

Odink, J.G. (1985) Inkomensherverdeling - enkele aspecten van de inkomensherverdeling door de overheid in Nederland, (PhD in Dutch about Income Redistribution), Wolters-Noordhoff, Groningen.

Pechman, J.A., and B.A. Okner (1974) Who Bears the Tax Burden?, Washington D.C., Brookings Institution. (Equivalence Scales for the Netherlands: main results 1986-1990),

Pen, J., and J. Tinbergen (1977) Naar een rechtvaardiger inkomensverdeling (Towards a More Equitable Income Distribution), Elsevier Science, Amsterdam.

Rainwater, L., and T.M. Smeeding (1997) 'Demography or Income Packaging: What Explains the Income Distribution of The Netherlands' Working Paper Ministry of Social Affairs 52, The Hague.

Reynolds, M., and E. Smolensky (1977) 'Post Fisc Distributions of Income 1950, 1961, and 1970' Public Finance Quarterly 5:419-438.

Ruiz-Huerta, J., R. Martínez, and L. Ayala (1999) Inequality, Growth and Welfare: An International Comparison, revised version of a paper presented at the 55th IIPF Congress, August 23-26th, Moscow, Russia.

Schiepers, J.M.P. (1998) 'Equivalentiefactoren: methode en belangrijkste uitkomsten', (Equivalence Scales for the Netherlands: Methodology and Main Results), in: CBS Jaarboek Welvaartsverdeling 1998, Kluwer/CBS, Deventer:117-121.

Silber, J. (1994) 'Income Distribution, Tax Structure, and the Measurement of Tax Progressivity' Public Finance Quarterly 22 (1):86-102.

Smolensky, E., W. Hoyt, and S. Danziger (1987) 'A Critical Survey of Efforts to Measure Budget Incidence' in: H.M. van de Kar, B.L. Wolfe (red.), The Relevance of Public Finance for Policy-Making, Proceedings IIFP Congress 1985, Detroit:165-179.

Sociaal en Cultureel Planbureau (1998) Sociaal en Cultureel Rapport 1998. 25 jaar sociale verandering (Social Cultural Report 1998), SCP, Rijswijk.

Stadt, H. Van der (1988) The Dynamics of Income and Welfare, PhD, Amsterdam.

Statistics Netherlands, CBS (1995) Inkomen en vermogen 1992-1994 (Income and Wealth 1992-1994), Voorburg/Heerlen.

Statistics Netherlands, CBS (1999a) 'Inkomensverdeling 1977-1997. Tabellen’ (Income Distribution 1977-1999. Tables) Sociaal-economische maandstatistiek 16 (5):107-119.

Statistics Netherlands, CBS (1999b) Personele inkomensverdeling 1996 (Personal Income Distribution 1996), Sdu Uitgevers, The Hague.

Statistics Netherlands, CBS (1999c) Jaarboek Welvaartsveding 1999 (Distribution of Incomes and Welfare. Yearbook 1999), Kluwer/CBS, Deventer.

Thoresen, Th.O., and K.O. Aarbu (1999) 'Income Responses to Tax Changes - Evidence from the Norwegian Tax Reform', Statistics Norway Discussion Papers no.260, Oslo.

Trimp, L. (1993) 'Inkomens van huishoudens, 1977-1990' (Income of Households, 1977-1990) Sociaaleconomische maandstatistiek 10 (7):16-18.

Trimp, L. (1999) 'Inkomensverdeling 1977-1997' (Income Distribution 1977-1997) Sociaal-economische maandstatistiek 16 (5):21-27.

Vries, G.J.M. De (red.) (1994) Inkomen en overheid (Income and Government), Wolters-Noordhoff, Groningen.