Official Economic Forecasting: the Relevance of the Canadian Experience for Transitional Economies

Grady, Patrick (1996): Official Economic Forecasting: the Relevance of the Canadian Experience for Transitional Economies.

Abstract

Ministries of Economy (MoEs) in the transitional economies of the Former Soviet Union have been given the responsibility for economic forecasting. They have usually been created out of Ministries of Planning (MoPs). The required transformation from planning to forecasting, which requires a fundamental change in mindset and approaches, is discussed in the first part of this paper.

In making this transformation from a MoP to a true MoE, there is much that official forecasters in transition economies can learn about economic forecasting from the experience of industrialized countries such as Canada. A brief overview of official economic forecasting as it is currently practised in Canada is provided in this paper. This includes econometric modelbased forecasting at the Department of Finance and the Bank of Canada and the recent prudent approach to fiscal forecasting initiated by the current Finance Minister to reduce the risk of unpleasant deficit surprises and thereby gain more credibility for fiscal policy. The adoption of the prudent approach underlines the perceived weakness of economic forecasting even in advanced industrialized economies. A summary of the advantages of forecasting with macroeconomic models based on the Canadian experience is presented in the paper.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: economic forecasting in transition economics, role Ministries of Economy, economic forecasting in Canada
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C5 - Econometric Modeling > C53 - Forecasting and Prediction Methods ; Simulation Methods; P - Economic Systems > P2 - Socialist Systems and Transitional Economies > P20 - General

References

Andersen, Leonall C. and Jerry L. Jordon (1968) “Monetary and Fiscal Actions: A Test of their Relative Importance in Economic Stabilization, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, (November),pp.11-24.

Armstrong, J., R. Black, D. Laxton and D. Rose (1995) A Robust Method for Simulating Forward-Looking Models, Part 2, Bank of Canada Technical Report Number 73 (Ottawa).

Black, R., D. Laxton, D. Rose and R. Tetlow (1994) The Steady State Model: SSQPM, The Bank of Canada’s New Quarterly Projection Model, Part 1, Bank of Canada Technical Report Number 72 (Ottawa).

Bodkin, Ronald G., Lawrence R. Klein, and Kanta Marwah (1991) A History of Macroeconomic Modelling (Aldershot, England: Edward Elgar Publishing Ltd.).

Coletti, D., B. Hunt, D. Rose and R. Tetlow (1996) The Dynamic Model: QPM, The Bank of Canada’s New Quarterly Projection Model, Part 3, Technical Report Number 75 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Duguay, Pierre (1979) Une analyse du modèle à forme réduite et son application au Canada, Technical, Technical Report Number 15 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Ernst & Young (1994) Review of the Forecasting Accuracy and Methods of the Department of Finance (Ottawa: Department of Finance).

Grady, Patrick (1985) The State of the Art in Canadian Macroeconomic Modelling (Ottawa: Department of Finance).

Grady, Patrick (1992) “A Review of A History of Macroeconomic Modelling by Ronald G. Bodkin, Lawrence R. Klein, and Kanta Marwah,” Canadian Journal of Economics, Vol. XXV, no. 1 (February), pp.244-248.

Helliwell, John F., T. Maxwell and H.E.L. Waslander (1979) “Comparing the Dynamics of Canadian Macromodels,” Canadian Journal of Economics, Vol. 12, No. 2, May, pp. 181-194.

Helliwell, John F., Lawrence H. Officer, Harold T. Shapiro and Ian A. Stewart (1969a) The Structure of RDX1, Staff Study No. 3 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Helliwell, John F., Lawrence H. Officer, Harold T. Shapiro and Ian A. Stewart (1969b) The Dynamics of RDX1, Staff Study No. 5 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Helliwell, John F., Gordon R. Sparks, Frederick W. Gorbet, Harold T. Shapiro, Ian A. Stewart and Donald R. Stephenson (1971) The Structure of RDX2, Staff Study No. 7 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada).

Kennedy, Peter (1994) A Guide to Econometrics, Third Edition (Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press).

O’Reilly, Brian, Graydon Paulin and Phillip Smith (1983) Responses of Various Econometric Models to Policy Shocks, Technical Report No. 38 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Robertson, Heather and Michael McDougall (1982a) The Equations of RDXF, Technical Report No. 25 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Robertson, Heather and Michael McDougall (1982b) The Structure and Dynamics of RDXF, Technical Report No. 26 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Rose, David E. and Jack G. Selody (1985) The Structure of the Small Annual Model, Technical Report No.40 (Ottawa: Bank of Canada.

Statistics Canada (1986) Users Guide to Statistics Canada’s Structural Economic Models (Ottawa.