Fiscal Federalism and Decentralization in Mongolia

Lkhagvadorj, Ariunaa (2010): Fiscal Federalism and Decentralization in Mongolia. Published in: (April 2010): pp. 175-178.

Abstract

Fiscal federalism has been an important topic among public finance theorists in the last four decades. Developing and transition countries have developed a variety of forms of fiscal decentralization as a possible strategy to achieve effective and efficient governmental structures. A generalized principle of decentralization due to the country specific circumstances does not exist. Therefore, decentralization has taken place in different forms in various countries at different times, and even exactly the same extent of decentralization may have had different impacts under different conditions. As a former socialist country Mongolia has had a highly centralized governmental sector. The result of the analysis below revealed that the Mongolia has introduced a number of decentralization measures, which followed a top down approach and were slowly implemented without any integrated decentralization strategy in the last decade. As a result Mongolia became de-concentrated state with fiscal centralization. The revenue assignment is lacking a very important element, for instance significant revenue autonomy given to sub-national governments, which is vital for the efficient service delivery at the local level. According to the current assignments of the expenditure and revenue responsibilities most of the provinces are unable to provide a certain national standard of public goods supply. Hence, intergovernmental transfers from the central jurisdiction to the sub-national jurisdictions play an important role for the equalization of the vertical and horizontal imbalances in Mongolia. The critical problem associated with intergovernmental transfers is that there is not a stable, predictable and transparent system of transfer allocation. The amount of transfers to sub-national governments is determined largely by political decisions on ad hoc basis and disregards local differences in needs and fiscal capacity. Thus a fiscal equalization system based on the fiscal needs of the provinces should be implemented. The equalization transfers will at least partly offset the regional disparities in revenues and enable the sub-national governments to provide a national minimum standard of local public goods.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Fiscal Federalism; Decentralization; Revenue Autonomy; Expenditure Assignment; Intergovernmental transfers.
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H7 - State and Local Government ; Intergovernmental Relations > H77 - Intergovernmental Relations ; Federalism ; Secession

References

Alesina, A. & Spolaore, E. (1997) On the Number and Size of the Nations. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 112(4), pp.1027-1056.

Atkinson, A.B. & Stiglitz, J.E. (1980) Lectures on Public Economics, Singapore, McGraw-Hill.

Bahl, R.W & Linn, J.F. (1992) Urban Public Finance in Developing Countries. New York, Oxford University Press.

Baretti, C., Huber, B. & Lichtblau, K. (2000) A Tax on Tax Revenue: The Incentive Effects on Equalizing Transfers: Evidence from Germany. International Tax and Public Finance, 9(6) November, pp.631-649.

Bibbee, A. & Goglio, A. (2002) Public Spending in Italy: Policies to Enhance Its Effectiveness. OECD Economic Department Working Paper 324. OECD Publishing.

Bird, R.M. (1993) Threading the Fiscal Labyrinth: Some Issues in Fiscal Decentralization. National Tax Journal, 46, pp.207-227.

Bird, R.M. (1998) The Central Role of Central Government in Decentraliza-tion. In: Bird, R.M. & Vaillancourt, F. ed. Fiscal Decentralization in Developing Countries. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Bird, R.M & Vaillancourt, F. ed. (1998) Fiscal Decentralization in Developing Countries. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Bird, R.M. (2000) Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations: Universal Principles, Local Applications, Working Paper 2, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Atlanta Georgia.

Bird, R.M. & Smart, M. (2002) Intergovernmental Fiscal Transfers: International Lessons for Developing Countries. World Development, 30(6) June, pp.899-912.

Bird, R.M. & Tassony, A. (2003) Constraining Sub-national Fiscal Behaviour in Canada: Different Approaches, Similar Results? In: Rodden, J.A., Esckeleand, G.S & Litvack, J. ed. (2003) Fiscal Decentralization and the Challenge of Hard Budget Constraints [Internet]. The MIT Press. Available from: <http://books.google.com/books/> [Accessed December 2007]. pp.85-133.

Blankart, Ch. B., (2006) Oeffentliche Finanzen in der Demokratie. Eine Einfuehrung in die Finanzwissenschaft. Muenchen, Vahlen.

Boadway, R. & Flatters, F. (1982) Efficiency and Equalization Payments in A Federal System of Governments: A Synthesis and Extension of Recent Results. Canadian Journal of Economics, 15(3) November, pp.613-633.

Boadway, R., Marchand, M. & Vigneault, M. (1998) The Consequences of Overlapping Tax Bases for Redistribution and Public Spending in A Federation. Journal of Public Economics. 68 June, pp.453-478.

Boex, J., Martinez-Vazquez, J. & Timofeev, A. (2004) Sub-national Government Structure and Intergovernmental Relations [Internet], International Studies Program Working Paper 0401, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University. Available from: <http://ideas.repec.org/p/ays/ispwps/ paper0401.html> [Accessed September 2008].

Bolton, P., Ronald, G. & Spolaore, E. (1996) Economic Theories of the Break-up and Integration of Nations. European Economic Review, 40, pp.697-705.

Bradford, D.F. & Oates, W.E. (1971) Towards A Predictive Theory of Intergovernmental Grants. American Economic Review, 61, pp.440-448.

Brennan, G. & Buchanan, J.M. (1980) The Power to Tax: Analytical Foundations of a Fiscal Constitution. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Breton, A. (1965) Theory of Government Grants. Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, 31, pp.177-187.

Breuss, F. & Eller, M. (2003) Efficiency and Federalism in the European Union: The Optimal Assignment of Policy Tasks to Different Levels of Government [Internet], IEF Working Paper 50, Vienna. Available from: <http://epub.wu-wien.ac.at> [Accessed January 2008].

Brueckner, J.K. (2004) Fiscal Decentralization with Distortionary Taxation: Tiebout vs. Tax Competition. International Tax and Public Finance, 11, pp.133-153.

Buchanan, J.M. (2002) Fiscal Equalization Revisited [Internet], In: Equalization: Welfare Trap or Helping Hand? Conference Co-sponsored by the Atlantic Institute for Market Studies, Montreal Economic Institute and Frontier Centre for Public Policy, October 2001, Montreal Canada. Available from: <www.aims.ca/ library/equalprogrammes.pdf>

Chang Woon Nam & Parsche, R. (2001) Municipal Finance in Poland, the Slovak Republic the Czech republic and Hungary: Institutional Framework and Recent Development [Internet], Kluwer Academic Publishers, Netherlands. Available from: <www.springerlink.com/content/h5176341010x1617/fulltext.pdf> [Accessed September 2008].

Chimid, B. (2002) Bagiin Ungursun Odoo Ireeedui (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Interpress. Chimid, B. (2004) Mongol Ulsiin Zasag Zahirgaa, Nutag Devsgariin Baiguulamjid Soumin Ezleh Bair Suuri (in Mongolian). In: Tudev, Sh. Ed. Soumiin Sudalgaa: onol arga zuin asuudal. Udirdlagin Akademin Hevleh Tasag. Ulaanbaatar. pp. 10-81.

Chimid, B. (2004) Soumiin Hugjliin Zagvar (in Mongolian). In: Tudev, Sh. Ed. Soumiin Sudalgaa: onol arga zuin asuudal. Udirdlagin Akademin Hevleh Tasag. Ulaanbaatar. pp. 170-184.

Cremer, J., Estache, A. & Seabrigh, P. (1996) The Decentralization of Public Services: Lessons from the Theory of the Firm. In: Estache, A. ed. Decentralizing Infrastructure: Advantages and Limitations. World Bank Discussion Paper 290. Washington, D.C.

Dafflon, B. (2002) Revenue Equalization at the State-Local Level: Setting out the Issues. In: G.Faerber & N.Otter. ed. Proceedings of the International Workshop on Reforms of Local Fiscal Equalization in Europe, September 30 – October 2, 2002, Speyer Germany, Deutsches Forschungsinstitut für öffentliche Verwaltung. pp. 1-21.

Dalai, Ch & Ishdorj, Ts. ed. (2003) Mongol Ulsin Tuukh, Ded Devter (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon.

Ebel, R.D., Varfalavi, I. & Varga, S. (1999) Hungarian Intergovernmental Finance. In: Bokros, L & Dethier, J.-J. ed. Public Finance Reform During the Transition: The Experience of Hungary. World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Ehtisham, A. & Giorgio, B. (2006) Handbook of Fiscal Federalism. Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing.

Enebish, S. (2004) Mongolia’s Current Fiscal Situation Review: Challenges and Some Options on Budget Management Reform Surrounding Rest of Countries Experiences. Research Paper. Policy Research Institute, Ministry of Finance Japan.

Fossen, F.M. & Bach, S. (2007) How Should Local Government Tax Local Business? Lessons from an International Comparison and A Micro simulation Analysis for Germany. DIW Discussion Paper 717. Berlin.

Gaadamba, Sh. ed. (1990) Mongolin Nuuts Tovchoo (in Mongolian). 4th ed. Ulaanbaatar.

Gordon, R.H. (1982) An Optimal Tax Approach to Fiscal Federalism [Internet], NBER Working Paper W1004. Available from: <www.nber.org> Published in 1983 Quarterly Journal of Economics, 98(4) November, pp. 567-586.

Government of Mongolia. (2003) Economic Growth Support and Poverty Reduction Strategy. Ulaanbaatar.

Hoyt, W.H. (1996) Tax Policy Coordination and Optimal Taxation in A System of Hierarchical Governments. Department of Economics, Univer-sity of Kentucky, Mimeo. In: Wilson, J.D. (1999) Theories of Tax Competition. National Tax Journal, 52(2) June, pp.269-304.

Hyman, D.N. (1993) Public Finance: Contemporary Application of Theory to Policy. New York, Dryden Press.

Hyman, D.N. (1999) Public Finance: Contemporary Application of Theory to Policy. 6th ed. New York, Dryden Press.

IMF. (2001) Government Finance Statistics Manual [Internet]. Available from: <www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/gfs/manual/index.htm.> [Accessed August 2008].

Inman, R.P. (2003) Transfers and Bailouts: Enforcing Local Fiscal Discipline with Lessons from U.S. Federalism. In: Rodden, J.A., Esckeleand, G.S & Litvack, J. ed. (2003) Fiscal Decentralization and the Challenge of Hard Budget Constraints [Internet], The MIT Press. Available from: <http://books.google.com/ books/mitpress?id=h6DWIXi3CdYC&printsec=frontcover&hl=de&source=gbs_ViewAPI> [Accessed December 2007]. pp.35-83.

Jackson, P.M. (2001) Fiscal Decentralization and Regional Development in Transition Countries [Internet], Discussion Paper 107. Katholieke Universiteit Leuven. Available from: <www.econ.kuleuven.ac.be/licos> [Accessed April 2007].

Joumard, I. & Giorno, C. (2002) Enhancing the Effectiveness of Public Spending in Switzerland. OECD Economic Department Working Paper 332. OECD Publishing.

Joumard, I. & Kongsrud, P.M. (2003) Fiscal Relations across Government Levels. OECD Economics Department Working Paper 375. OECD Publishing. Journal, 46(2), pp. 237-43.

Kirn, T. & Petersen, H.G. (2008) Fiscal Autonomy within an Expenditure Oriented System of Fiscal Federalism: An Example from Liechtenstein. Discussion Paper, Chair of Public Economics, Potsdam University. Potsdam.

Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. (2008) Mongol Ulsin Khuuli (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. I Boti.

Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. (2008) Mongol Ulsin Khuuli (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. II Boti.

Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. (2008) Mongol Ulsin Khuuli (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. III Boti.

Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. (2008) Mongol Ulsin Khuuli (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Khuuli Zuin Undesni Tuv. IY Boti.

Litvack, J. & Seddon, J. (1999) Decentralization Briefing Notes. Washington, D.C, World Bank Institute.

Lhaashid, D. (2009) Mongoliin Haad, Zutgeltnuudiin Joloodohuin Urlag (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Kiton Printing.

Lkhagvadorj, A. (2007) Status Quo on Fiscal Decentralization in Mongolia. Discussion Paper 54, Chair of Public Economics, Potsdam University. Potsdam.

Martinez-Vazquez, J. (1998) The Assignment of Expenditure Responsibilities. Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University. Atlanta. Georgia.

Martinez-Vazquez, J. (1999) The Assignment of Expenditure Responsibilities. Economic Development Institute, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

Martinez-Vazquez, J. & Boex, J. (2001) Russia’s Transition to a New Federalism. WBI Learning Resources Series, World Bank, Washington, D.C.

McLure, C.E. (1967) The Interstate Exporting of State and Local Taxes: Estimates for 1962. National Tax Journal. 20 March, pp.49-75.

McLure, C.E. (1999) Tax Assignment. In: McLure, C.E., Martinez-Vazquez, J. & Wallace, S. ed. Fiscal Transition in Kazakstan. Manila, ADB, pp.273-316.

McLure, C.E. (2001) The Tax Assignment Problem: Conceptual and Administrative Consideration in Achieving Sub-national Fiscal Autonomy. Fiscal Policy Training Program. Georgia State University. Atlanta, Georgia.

Musgrave, R.A. (1959) The Theory of Public Finance. New-York, McGraw-Hill.

Musgrave, R. A. & Musgrave, P.B. (1989) Public Finance in Theory and Practice. 5th ed. New York, McGraw-Hill.

Nam, Ch.W & Parsche, R. (2001) Municipal Finance in Poland, the Slovak Republic, the Czech Republic and Hungary: Institutional Framework and Recent Development. MOST: Economic Policy in Transitional Economies, 2 (2), pp.143-164.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2001) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2000. Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing. National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2001) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2001 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2003) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2002 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2004) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2003 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2005) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2004 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2006) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2005 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2007) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2006 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2008) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2007 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

National Statistical Office of Mongolia. (2009) Mongolian Statistical Yearbook 2008 (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Admon Publishing.

Niskanen, W.A (1971) Bureaucracy and Representative Government. Chicago, Aldine-Atherton.

Oates, W.E. (1972) Fiscal Federalism. 3d ed. Aldershop, Gregg Revivals.

Oates, W.E. (1985) Searching for Leviathan: An Empirical Study. American Economic Review, 75 September, pp. 748-57.

Oates, W.E. & Schwab, R.M. (1991) The Allocative and Distributive Implications of Local Government Competition. In: Kenyon, D & Kincaid, J. ed. Competition Among States and Local Governments, Washington, D.C. The Urban Institute, pp.127-145.

Oates, W.E. (1993) Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Development. National Tax Journal, 46(2), pp.237-43.

Oates, W.E. (1999) An Essays on Fiscal Federalism. Journal of Economic Literature, 37(3) September, pp.1120-1149.

Oates, W.E. (2005) Towards A Second-Generation Theory of Fiscal Federalism. International Tax and Public Finance, 12, pp.349-373.

OECD. (2001) Knowledge and Skills for Life, First Results from PISA 2000, Paris.

OECD. (2002) Fiscal Decentralization in EU Applicant States and Selected EU Member States. In: OECD, CTPA report for the workshop on Decen-tralization: Trends, Perspective and Issues the Threshold of EU Enlarge-ment, October 10-11, 2002, Denmark. Copenhagen, The Ministry of the Interior and Health, Department of Economics.

Petersen, H.-G., (1993) Finanzwissenschaft I. 3rd ed. Stuttgart et al.

Petersen, H.-G., (2007) Fiscal Federalism in Germany and Europe: Basic Issues and Some Modern Developments. Presentation on Strategies for Regional Development and the Reduction of Regional Economic Disparities, Berlin.

Petersen, H.-G., (2008) Integration, Decentralization, Taxation, and Revenue Sharing: Good Governance, Sustainable Fiscal Policy and Poverty Reduction as Peace-Keeping Strategies. Discussion Paper 57, Chair of Public Economics, Potsdam University. Potsdam.

Petersen, H.-G. & Mueller, K. (1999) Volkswirtschaftspolitik. Muenchen, Verlag Vahlen.

Porta, D. & Keating, M. ed. (2008) Approaches and Methodologies in the Social Sciences: Pluralist Perspective. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.

Prud’homme, R. (1994) On the Dangers of Decentralization. Policy Research Working Paper 1252. Washington, D.C.

Prud’homme, R. (1995) The Dangers of Decentralization. The World Bank Research Observer, 10(2) August, pp.201-220.

Qian, Y. & Weingast, B.R. (1997) Federalism as a Commitment to Preserving Market Incentives. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 11(4) Autumn, pp.83-92.

Raich, U. ed. (2005) Fiscal Decentralization and Local Public Finances in Mongolia (in Mongolian). Centre of Mongol Management, Research Report, Ulaanbaatar.

Rinchin, M. (1996) Mongol Ulsin Sankhuugin Albani Tuukh (in Mongolian), Ulaanbaatar, Ylsin Gerel Zurgin Gazrin Khevlekh Uildver.

Robbins, D. (2005) Handbook of Public Sector Economics, New York, Taylor & Francis.

Rodden, J., Gunnar, S. E & Litvack, J. (2003) Fiscal Decentralisation and Challenge of Hard Budget Constraints [Internet]. London, MIT Press. Available from: <http://books.google.com/books/mitpress?id=h6DWIXi3CdYC&printsec=frontcover&hl=de&source=gbs_ViewAPI> [Accessed December 2007].

Rondinelli, D.A & Nellis, G.A. (1986) Assessing Decentralization Policies in Developing Countries: The Case for Cautious Optimism. Development Policy Review, 4 (1). pp.3-23.

Rosen, H.S. (1999) Public Finance. 5th ed. Boston Burr Ridge, McGraw-Hill.

Schneider, F. ed. (2005) The Economics of the Hidden Economy. Vol I. Cheltenham, Edward Elgar Publishing.

Shah, A. (1999) Balance, Accountability, and Responsiveness: Lessons about Decentralization [Internet], World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No. 2021. Available at SSRN: <http://ssrn.com> [Accessed February 2008].

Shah, A. (2004) Fiscal Decentralization in Developing and Transition Economies: Progress, Problems and Promise. World Bank Policy Re-search Working Paper 3282. Washington. DC.

Shah, A., Thompson, T. & Zou, H.F. (2004) The Impact of Decentralization on Service Delivery, Corruption, Fiscal Management and Growth in Developing and Emerging Market Economies: A Synthesis of Empirical Evidence. A Quarterly Journal for Institutional Comparisons, 2 Spring, pp.10-14.

Shah, A. & Shen, Ch. (2006) Fine Tuning the Intergovernmental Transfer System To Achieve A Harmonious Society and A Level Playing Field for Regional Development in China [Internet], Available from: <http://siteresources.worldbank.org/ PSGLP/Resources/ShahandShenP.pdf> [Accessed February 2009].

Simon, J.L. (1978) Basic Research Methods in Social Science: The Art of Empirical Investigation. 2nd ed. New York, Random House. In: Silver, L. (2001) Credit Risk Assessment in Different Contexts – the Influence of Local Networks for Bank Financing of SMEs. Ph.D. thesis, Uppsala University.

Sorensen, P.B. (2002) International Tax Coordination: Regionalism versus Globalism. CESifo Working Paper 483.

Stegarescu, D. (2005) Decentralized Government in Integrating World: Quantitative Studies for OECD Countries. Heidelberg, Physica Publishing.

Steiner, S. (2005) Decentralization and Poverty Reduction: A Conceptual Framework for the Economic Impact [Internet], Working Paper 3: Ham-burg. German Overseas Institute. Available from: <www.duei.de/workingpapers>

Sukhbaatar, G. (2000) Mongolin Ertnii Tuukh Sudlal. I boti. Mongolchuudin Ertnii Uvug (in Mongolian). Ulaanbaatar, Bembi San Khevlel.

Thiessen, U. (2003) Fiscal Decentralization and Economic Growth in High Income OECD Countries. Fiscal Studies, 24(3), pp. 237-274.

Thiessen, U. (2005) Fiscal Federalism: Normative Criteria for Evaluations, Developments in Selected OECD Countries, and Empirical Evidence for Russia. DIW Discussion Paper 518. Berlin.

Tiebout, C.M. (1956) A pure Theory of Local Government Expenditure. Journal of Political Economy, 64 (5) October, pp. 416-426.

Tiebout, C.M. (1961) An Economic Theory of Fiscal Decentralization. In: Public Finances: Needs, Sources and Utilization. Proceedings of the Conference of the Universities-National Bureau Committee for Economic Research, New York USA. Princeton, Princeton University Press. pp. 79-96.

UNDP. (2005) Fiscal Decentralization in Transition Economies: Case Studies from the Balkans and Caucasus [Internet], Available from: <www.undp.org/ europeandcis> [Accessed March 2007].

Wilson, J.D. (1986) A Theory of Interregional Tax Competition. Journal of Urban Economics, 19, pp. 296-315.

Wilson, J.D. (1999) Theories of Tax Competition. National Tax Journal, 52(2) June, pp. 269-304.

World Bank. (2002) Mongolia Public Expenditure and Financial Manage-ment Review. Report 24439-MOG. Poverty Reduction and Economic Management Sector Unit, East Asia and Pacific Region.

World Bank. (2007) Decentralization & Subnational Regional Economics [Internet]. Washington, D.C, Available from: <http://web.worldbank.org> [Accessed March, 2007].

Wurzel, E. (1999) Towards more Efficient Government- Reforming Federal Fiscal Relations in Germany. OECD Economic Department Working Paper 209. OECD Publishing. Yin R.K. (2003) Applications of Case Study Research. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, SAGE.