The Historical Perspective of the Problem of Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility

Drakopoulos, Stavros A. (1989): The Historical Perspective of the Problem of Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility. Published in: Journal of Economic Studies , Vol. 16, No. 4 (1989): pp. 35-51.

Abstract

The starting-point of the article is the inconsistency between the established practice of acceptance in many cases, of economic policy (i.e. progressive taxation, national insurance policies) and the theoretical rejection of interpersonal comparisons of utility who see it as an unscientific value judgement. The inconsistency is explained by identifying three groups of theorists: (1) those who thought of comparability as a value judgement and unacceptable for economic policy considerations (positivists), (2) those who agreed with the positivists, on the normative nature of comparability but accepted it as a basis for economic policy, and (3) those who thought of it as part of a scientific economics. The implication was that, despite the dominance of positivist methodology in other sub-fields, the historical experience points to the difficulty of applying positivist methodology to the issue of comparability. If the inconsistency is thus due to the inappropriateness of the positivist approach, the only possible solution is the explicit abandonment of this approach at least in matters related to the collective aspects of economics.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: History of Economics; Welfare Economics
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B0 - General > B00 - General; D - Microeconomics > D6 - Welfare Economics > D60 - General

References

Aron, R. (1967), Main Currents in Sociological Thought, Penguin, London.

Arrow, J.K. (1963), Social Choice and Individual Values, John Wiley and Sons, New York.

Atkinson, A. and Stiglitz, J.E. (1980), Lectures on Public Economics, McGraw-Hill, London.

Bentham, J. (1882), Theory of Legislation, Trubner and Co., London.

Bentham, J. (1969), in Mack, M.P. (Ed.), A Bentham Reader, Pegasus, New York.

Bergson, A. (1938), "A Reformulation of Certain Aspects of Welfare Economics", Quarterly Journalof Economics, Vol. 52, pp. 310-34.

Blum, W. and Kalven, H. (1953), The Uneasy Case for Progressive Taxation, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Carnap, R. (1981), "Protocol Statements and the Formal Mode of Speech", in Hanfling, 0. (Ed.),Logical Positivism, Basil Blackwell, Oxford.

Cooter, R. and Rappoport, P. (1984), "Were the Ordinalists Wrong about Welfare Economics?",Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. 22, pp. 507-30.

Creedy, J. (1981), "F.Y. Edgeworth", in O'Brien, D.P. and Presley, J. (Eds.), Pioneers of Modern Economics in Britain, Macmillan, London.

Edgeworth, F.Y. (1881), Mathematical Psychics, Kegan Paul, London.

Edgeworth, F.Y. (1925), Papers Relating to Political Economy, Macmillan, London.

Fisher, I. (1927), "A Statistical Method for Measuring Marginal Utility", in Hollander, J.H. (Ed.),Economic Essays in Honor of J.B. Clark, Macmillan, New York.

Fleming, M.(1952), "A Cardinal Concept of Welfare", Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 66, pp.366-84.

Hammond, P. (1977), "Dual Interpersonal Comparison of Utility and the Welfare Economics of Income Distribution", Journal of Public Economics, Vol. 7, pp. 51-71.

Harrod, R.E. (1938), "Scope and Method of Economics", The Economic Journal, Vol. 48, pp. 383-412.

Harsanyi, J. (1955), "Cardinal Welfare, Individualistic Ethics and Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility", Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 63, pp. 309-21.

Henderson, J. and Quandt, R. (1971), Microeconomic Theory, McGraw-Hill, New York.

Hicks, J. (1939), "The Foundations of Welfare Economics", The Economic Journal, Vol. 49, pp. 696-712.

Hicks, J. and Allen, R.G.D. (1934), "A Reconsideration of the Theory of Value", Economica, Vol.1, pp. 52-76.

Hutchison, T.W. (1953), A Review of Economic Doctrines, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Hutchison, T.W. (1960), "Positive" Economics and Policy Objectives, Allen & Unwin, London.

Hutchison, T.W. (1965), The Significance and Basic Postulates of Economic Theory, Augustus M. Kelly, New York.

Jeffrey, R. (1971), "On Interpersonal Utility Theory", Journal of Philosophy, Vol. 68, pp. 647-56.

Jerons, W.S.(1871), The Theory of Political Economy, Macmillan, London.

Kaldor, N. (1939), "Welfare Propositions of Economics", The Economic Journal, Vol. 49, pp. 549-52.

Koutsoyiannis, A. (1979), Modern Microeconomics, Macmillan, London.

Lange, 0. (1942), "The Foundations of Welfare Economics", Econometrica, Vol. 3 No. 4, pp. 215-28.

Little, I.M.D. (1973), A Critique of Welfare Economics, Oxford University Press, London.

Marshall, A. (1961), Principles of Economics, 9th edition, Macmillan, London.

Mill, J.S. (1979), in Warnock, M. (Ed.), Utilitarianism, Collins, Glasgow.

Myrdal, G. (1953), The Political Element in the Development of Economic Theory, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.

Neumann, von J., and Morgenstern, 0.(1953), Theory of Games and Economic Behaviour, Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Ng, Y-K. (1979), Welfare Economics, Macmillan, London.

Pareto, V. (1896), Cours d'Economie Politique, E. Lange, Lausanne.

Pareto, V. (1971), Manual of Political Economy, translated by Schrier, A., Macmillan, London.

Pigou, A.C. (1932), The Economics of Welfare, Macmillan, London.

Pigou, A.C. (1951), "Some Aspects of Welfare Economics", The American Economic Review, Vol. 41, pp. 287-302.

Rawls, J. (1958), "Justice as Fairness", The Philosophical Review, Vol. 67, pp. 164-74.

Rawls, J. (1971), A Theory of Justice, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Mass.

Robertson, D.H. (1954), Utility and All That, Allen & Unwin, London.

Robbins, L. (1938), "Interpersonal Comparisons of Utility: A Comment", The Economic Journal,Vol. 48, pp. 635-41.

Robbins, L. (1969), An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science, Macmillan, London.

Samuelson, P. (1947), Foundations of Economic Analysis, Harvard University Press, Cambridge,Mass.

Scitovsky, T. (1951), "The State of Welfare Economics", American Economic Revieiv, Vol. 41, pp.303-15.

Sen, A. (1970), Collective Choice and Social Welfare, Holden-Day, Oliver and Boyd, San Francisco.

Sen, A. (1982), Choice, Welfare and Measurement, The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

Simon, J. (1974), "Interpersonal Welfare Comparisons can be Made and Used for Redistribution Decisions", Kyklos, Vol. XXVII, pp. 63-98.

Stigler, G. (1950), "The Development of Utility Theory", Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 58, pp. 307-27.

Tarascio, V. (1979), "Vilfredo Pareto and Marginalism", History of Political Economy, Vol. 4, pp. 406-25.

Usher, D. (1980), The Measurement of Economic Growth, Blackwell, Oxford.

Wicksell, K. (1961), Lectures on Political Economy, translated by Classen, E., Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.

Wicksteed, P. (1933), The Common Sense of Political Economy, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.