Interprovincial Barriers to Labour Mobility in Canada:Policy, Knowledge Gaps and Research Issues

Grady, Patrick and Macmillan, Kathleen (2007): Interprovincial Barriers to Labour Mobility in Canada:Policy, Knowledge Gaps and Research Issues.

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to identify the most important knowledge gaps on interprovincial barriers to labour mobility in Canada, and to shed some light on potential conceptual, methodological, and data issues associated with research in this area. Consequently, it provides an overview of the current state of play with respect to the most important issues relating to inter-provincial barriers to labour mobility within the Canadian internal market. The three main barriers to labour mobility in Canada, which are considered, are: residency requirements; certain practices regarding occupational licensing, certification and registration; and differences in how occupational qualifications are recognized. These are the main regulatory barriers that are to be removed or reduced under Chapter 7, the Labour Mobility Chapter of the Agreement on Internal Trade (AIT). It also reviews critically the recent relevant research in Canada and in some other jurisdictions (the United States, the European Union and Australia) on barriers to labour mobility. The paper finds that the most important knowledge gap concerns the extent of the regulatory barriers to labour mobility and their impacts and costs. It also concludes that there is nothing fundamentally wrong with the approach of mutual recognition being pursued in Canada to eliminate such regulatory barriers. However, while there has been a fair degree of success in Canada in achieving occupation-specific Mutual Recognition Agreements for occupational qualifications and reconciliation of differences in occupational standards, this progress has been too slow. Moreover, the functioning of the dispute resolution mechanism with respect to Chapter 7, is overly complex and inaccessible. The dispute resolution mechanism in the Alberta-B.C. Trade, Investment and Labour Mobility Agreement is stronger and simpler than that of the AIT, and definitely one to be considered as a model to improve the AIT.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: : labour, labour mobility, internal markets, internal trade
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F16 - Trade and Labor Market Interactions; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers

References

Agreement on Internal Trade ( 2004) Report of the Article 1704 Panel Concerning a Dispute Brought Forward by Alberta and British Columbia Against Ontario Regarding Ontario ’s Measures Relating to Dairy Analogs and Dairy Blends, November 10.

Agreement on Labour Mobility and Recognition of Qualifications, Skills and Work Experience in the Construction Industry (2006) Between the Government of Ontario and the Gouvernement du Québec , June 2, 2006.

Audus, Rick and James Ted McDonald (2003) “Employment Insurance and Geographic Mobility: Evidence from the SLID,” Social Research Demonstration Corporation Working Paper Series 03-03, April.

Australian Productivity Council (2003) “Evaluation of Mutual Recognition Schemes,” Research Report, October 8.

Bayoumi, Tamim, Bennett Sutton, and Andrew Swiston (2006) “Shocking Aspects of Canadian Labor Markets,” IMF Working Paper No. 83, March.

Bollman, Ray D., Jeff Marshall, Neil Rothwell and Juno Tremblay (2002) “Recent Migration Patterns in Rural and Small Town Canada,” Statistics Canada, Agriculture and Rural Working Paper Catalogue No. 21-601-MIE2002055, September 11.

Bonikowska, Aneta, David A. Green and W. Craig Riddell (2006) “Cognitive Skills and Immigrant Earnings,” paper presented at Canadian Economics Association Annual Meeting in Montreal, May 26, 2006.

California Department of Consumer Affairs (2005) Annual Report Fiscal Year 2004-05, http ://www. dca. ca. gov/reports/04_05_annrpt.pdf

Campus Canada (2005) “Moving Towards the Development of a Common Framework of Foreign Credential Recognition,” Workshop Report, March 21-22.

Certified General Accountants Association of Canada (2004) “Governance in the Agreement on Internal Trade.”

Certified General Accountants Association of Canada (2005) “Public Accounting Rights for Certified General Accountants in Canada,” May.

Certified General Accountants Association of Canada (2006) “Making Trade Dispute Resolution in Canada Work: Certified General Accountants’ Experience with Canada’s Agreement on Internal Trade,” April.

Commonwealth of Australia, Productivity Commission (2003) “Evaluation of Mutual

Recognition Schemes,” Research Report, October 8.

COMPASS (2004) “Interprovincial Trade Barriers: Seriously Damaging to the Economy and Standard of Living and Almost as Harmful as Canada-U.S. Barriers,” BDO Dunwoody/Chamber Weekly CEO/ Business Leader Poll published in Financial Post, September 13, 2004.

Conference Board of Canada (2001) The Brain Gain: The Economic Benefits of Recognizing Learning and Learning Credentials in Canada, Ottawa, Ontario.

Conference Board of Canada (2005) “An Impact Assessment of the BC/Alberta, Trade, Investment and Labour Mobility Agreement,” Ottawa, September.

Conference Board of Canada (2006) Death by a Thousand Paper Cuts: The Effects of Barriers to Competition on Canadian Productivity, Ottawa, May.

Construction Sector Council (2005) “Working Mobile: A Study of Labour Mobility in Canada’s Industrial Construction Sector,” Spring.

Copenhagen Economics (2005) “Economic Assessment of the Internal Market for Services,’ Final Report to the European Commission, January.

Coulombe, Serge and Jean-François Tremblay (2006) “Migration, Human Capital and Skills Redistribution Across the Canadian Provinces,” PRI-Mobility.

Council of the Federation (2006a) Internal Trade Workplan Progress Report, January, www. councilofthefederation. ca.

Council of the Federation (2006b) Progress Report Letter Following CIT Meeting, October 3, www. councilofthefederation. ca.

DeCruz, Joseph (1992) Interprovincial Trade Barriers and Canadian Competitiveness: Report on a Survey by the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, November.

Day, Kathleen and Stanley Winer (1994) “Internal Migration and Public Policy,” in A. Masgrove (ed.) Issues in the Taxation of Individuals (Toronto: University of Toronto Press).

Day, Kathleen M. and Stanley L. Winer (2005) “Policy-induced Internal Migration: An Empirical Investigation of the Canadian Case,” CESisfo Working Paper No. 1605, November.

Dupuy, Richard, Francine Mayer and René Morissette (2000) “Rural youth : stayers, leavers and return migrants,” Catalogue number 11F0019MIE2000152, September.

European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions (2005) “Mobility in Europe: An Analysis of the Eurobarometer Survey on Geographical and Labour Market Mobility.

European Public Administration Network, Human Resources Working Group (2006) “Cross¬border Mobility of Public Sector Workers.”

European Union (2007) “Recognition of Qualifications,” http: //ec. europa. eu/youreurope/nav/en/citizens/working/qualification-recognition/general-system/ index_en.html,

Finnie, Ross (2001) “The effects of inter-provincial mobility on individuals' earnings: panel model estimates for Canada,” Statistics Canada, catalogue 11F0019MIE2001163, October.

Finnie, Ross (2000) “Who Moves? A Panel Logit Model Analysis of Inter-provincial Migration in Canada,” catalogue number 11F0019MIE2000142, September.

Forum of Labour Market Ministers (2003) “Guidelines for Meeting the Obligations of the Labour Mobility Chapter,” Revised Edition, February.

Forum of Labour Market Ministers (2005) “Report of Survey Results: Interprovincial Labour Mobility in Canada 2004/05,” May 18.

Friedman, Milton (1962) Capitalism and Freedom (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).

Goodman, Richard M. and John M. Frost (2000) “International Economic Agreements and the Constitution,” Institute for International Economics, Working Paper 00-2, February.

Gross, Stanley J, (1986) “Professional Licensure and Quality: The Evidence,” Cato Policy Analysis No. 79.

Gunderson, Morley (1994) “Barriers to Interprovincial Labour Mobility,” in Filip Palda (ed.) Interprovincial Trade Wars: Why the Blockade Must End (Vancouver: Fraser Institute, 1994), pp.131-154.

Hailsham, Lord and David Vaughan (eds.) (1986) Law of the European Communities.

Holen, Arlene S. (1965) “Effects of Professional Licensing Arrangements on Interstate Labor Mobility and Resource Allocation,” The Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 73, No. 5, pp. 492-498.

Hong, Duc Nuygen (2000) “Restrictions on Trade in Professional Services,” Staff Research Paper, Australian Productivity Council, August.

Internal Trade Secretariat (2007a) An Overview of the Internal Trade Agreement, http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/ait.htm.

Internal Trade Secretariat (2007b), Progress to Date, http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/progress.htm.

Internal Trade Secretariat (2006) Annual Report 2005/2006, http://www.ait-aci.ca/index_en/reports.htm.

International Monetary Fund (2005) “How Flexible Is the Canadian Economy? An International Comparison,” in Canada: Selected Issues (Article IV Consultation): 92-100.

Lin, Zhengxi (1995) Interprovincial Labour Mobility in Canada: The Role of Unemployment Insurance and Social Assistance, HRDC Unemployment Insurance Evaluation Series 21 (Ottawa).

Lin, Zhengxi (1998) “Foreign-born vs Native-born Canadians: A Comparison of Their Inter-provincial Labour Mobility,” Statistics Canada, Catalogue No. 11F0019MIE1998114.

Macmillan, Kathleen and Patrick Grady (2007) “Inter-provincial Barriers to Internal Trade in Goods, Services and Capital,” paper prepared for Industry Canada and Human Resources and Social Development Canada, March 31.

Magun, Sunder, Laval Lavallée, Jean-Louis Arcand and François Ethier (1994) “The Impact of Removing Interprovincial Barriers to Labour Mobility in Canada,” A report prepared for the Department of Human Resources Development Canada, May 30.

Nguyen-Hong, Duc (2000) “Restrictions in Trade in Professional Services,’ Staff Research Paper, Commonwealth of Australia, Productivity Commission, August.

Ontario Ministry of Labour (2002) “Ontario Plans to Redesignate Quebec Under Fairness Is A Two-Way Street Act,” Press Release, February 11, 2002.

Svorny, Shirley (1999) “Licensing, Market Entry Regulation,” in Encyclopedia of Law & Economics (Cheltenham, U.K.: Edward Elgar and University of Ghent).