Immigration and the Canadian Welfare State 2011

Grubel, Herbert and Grady, Patrick (2011): Immigration and the Canadian Welfare State 2011. Published in:

Abstract

This publication provides an estimate of the fiscal burden created by recent immigration into Canada and proposes reforms to existing immigrant selection policies to eliminate the burden. It uses a 2006 Census database to estimate the average incomes and taxes paid on these by immigrants who arrived in Canada over the period from 1987 to 2004. It also estimates other taxes they paid and the value of government services they absorbed.

The study concludes that in the fiscal year 2005/06 the immigrants on average received an excess of $6,051 in benefits over taxes paid. Depending on assumptions about the number of recent immigrants in Canada, the fiscal burden in that year is estimated to be between $23.6 billion and $16.3 billion. These estimates are not changed by the consideration of other alleged benefits brought by immigrants.

To curtail this growing fiscal burden from immigration, the study proposes that temporary work visas be granted to applicants who have a valid offer for employment from employers, in occupations and at pay levels specified by the federal government and determined in cooperation with private-sector employers. Immediate dependents may accompany successful applicants. The temporary visas are renewable and lead to landed immigrant status if certain specified employment criteria are met.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Canadian immigration, fiscal impacts of immigration to Canada, Immigration policy
• Subjects: H - Public Economics > H2 - Taxation, Subsidies, and Revenue > H22 - Incidence; H - Public Economics > H4 - Publicly Provided Goods > H40 - General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J65 - Unemployment Insurance ; Severance Pay ; Plant Closings; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J6 - Mobility, Unemployment, Vacancies, and Immigrant Workers > J61 - Geographic Labor Mobility ; Immigrant Workers

References

Abbott, Michael, and Charles M. Beach (2009). Immigrant Earnings Distributions and Earnings Mobility in Canada: Evidence for the 1982 Landing Cohort from IMDB Micro Data. CLSRN Working Papers (clsrn_ admin-2009-22), UBC Department of Economics.

Auditor General of Canada (2009). 2009 Fall Report of the Auditor General of Canada: Chapter 2—Selecting Foreign Workers under the Immigration Program. <http://www.oag-bvg.gc.ca/internet/English/parl_ oag_200911_02_e_33203.html>.

Australia, Department of Immigration and Citizenship (2011a). Fact Sheet 31 - Family Stream Migration: Parent (Non-Contributory) Visas. <http:// www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/31parents.htm>.

Australia, Department of Immigration and Citizenship (2011b). Fact Sheet 34 - Assurance of Support. <http://www.immi.gov.au/media/fact-sheets/34aos. htm>.

Banerjee, Robin, and William Robson (2009). Immigration’s Impact on the Growth and Age Structure of the Canadian Labour Force. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 121–144. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/ research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Burton, Peter, and Shelley Phipps (2009). The Prince and the Pauper: Movement of Children Up and Down the Canadian Income Distribution, 1994–2004. Working Paper No. 31. Canadian Labour Market and Skills Researcher Network.

Citizenship and Immigration Canada (2010). Facts and Figures 2009 – Immigration Overview: Permanent and Temporary Residents. <http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/resources/statistics/facts2009/index.asp>.

Collacott, Martin (2003). Canada’s Immigration Policy:The Need for Major Reform. Fraser Institute. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/ research/display.aspx?id=12866>.

DeVoretz, Don J. (2003). NAFTA’s Labor Market Integration Experience: Lessons for the EU? RIIM Commentary Series No. 03-04. Simon Fraser University.

Francis, Diane (2002). Immigration: The Economic Case. Key Porter Books.

Frenette, Marc, and Rene Morrissette (2003). Will They Ever Converge?Earnings of Immigrant and Canadian-born Workers over the Last Two Decades. Research paper series. Catalogue no. 11F0019MIE – No. 215.

Statistics Canada, Analytical Studies Branch. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/ bsolc/olc-cel/olc-cel?catno=11F0019M2003215&lang=eng>.

Friedman, Milton (1999). Quotation from an interview at the 18th Annual Institute for Liberty and Policy Analysis (ISIL) World Libertarian Conference, San Jose, Costa Rica (August 20–22, 1999). <http://www.vdare. com/misc/archive00/friedman.htm>.

Gallagher, Stephen (2009). The Creation of a Global Suburb and Its Impact on Canadian National Unity. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 171–196. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Gibson, Gordon (2009). The Politics of Canadian Immigration Policies. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 213–224. <http://www. fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Globerman, Steven (1999). Perspectives on North American Free Trade: Trade Liberalization and the Migration of Skilled Workers. Industry Canada.

Grady, Patrick (2010). Some Observations on Net Fiscal Transfers to Recent Immigrants Resulting From Income Taxes and Government Transfer Programs. Global Economics Working Paper 2010-1, April 26. <http://www.global-economics.ca/tax_burden_immigrants.pdf>.

Green, Sir Andrew (2009). The Challenges of Reforming Immigration Policy in Britain. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 225–230. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Grubel , Herbert (1981). International Economics. Richard Irwin.

Grubel, Herbert, and Anthony Scott (1977). The Brain Drain: Determinants, Measurement and Welfare Effects. Wilfred Laurier University Press.

Grubel, Herbert (2005). Immigration and the Welfare State in Canada: Growing Conflicts, Constructive Solutions. Public Policy Sources 84. Fraser Institute. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13108>.

Grubel, Herbert, ed. (2009). The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society. Fraser Institute. <http://www.fraserinstitute. org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Horry, Isabella, and Michael Walker (1994), Government Spending Facts Two. Fraser Institute.

Krikorian, Mark (2008). The New Case against Immigration. Penguin Books.

Mansur, Salim (2009). Immigration and Multiculturalism Undermine Culture and Security in Canada. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 197–209. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Merette, Marcel, (2009). The Immigration Option to Population Aging in Canada. In Herbert Grubel, ed., The Effects of Mass Immigration on Canadian Living Standards and Society (Fraser Institute, 2009): 145–167. <http://www.fraserinstitute.org/research-news/display.aspx?id=13504>.

Moens, Alexander, and Martin Collacott, eds. (2008). Immigration Policy and the Terrorist Threat in Canada and the United States. Fraser Institute. <www.fraserinstitute.org/workarea/DownloadAsset.aspx?id=3056>.

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development [OECD](2003). Chapter III: International Migration: Economic Context and Implications, Economic Survey of Canada 2003. Paris: OECD.

Orrenius, Pia, and Daniel Streitfeld (2006). TN Visas: A Stepping Stone toward a NAFTA Labor Market. Southwest Economy 6 (November/December). Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. <http://www.dallasfed.org/ research/swe/2006/swe0606c.html>.

Picot, Garnett (2008). Immigrant Economic and Social Outcomes in Canada: Research and Data Development at Statistics Canada. Catalogue No. 11F0019M No. 319. Statistics Canada. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/ pub/11f0019m/11f0019m2008319-eng.htm>.

Picot, Garnett, Yuqian Lu, and Feng Hou (2009). Immigrant Low-Income Rates: The Role of Market Income and Government Transfers. Perspectives (December). Catalogue No. 75-001-X. Statistics Canada. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/75-001-x/2009112/article/11055-eng.htm>.

Picot, Garnett, and Arthur Sweetman (2005). The Deteriorating Economic Welfare of Immigrants and Possible Causes: Update 2005. Catalogue No.11F0019MIE2005262. Statistics Canada. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/bsolc/olccel/ olc-cel?catno=11F0019M2005262&lang=eng>.

Sarlo, Christopher (1996). Poverty in Canada. Second Edition. FraserInstitute.

Singh v. Minister of Employment and Immigration (1985) 1 S.C.R. 177. <http://scc.lexum.org/en/1985/1985scr1-177/1985scr1-177.html>.

Statistics Canada (2006, October 26). The Daily : 7. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/061026/dq061026b-eng.htm>.

Statistics Canada (2009). Individuals File, 2006 Census (Public Use Microdata Files). Catalogue No. 95M0028XVB. Statistics Canada. <http://www.statcan.gc.ca/bsolc/olc-cel/olc-cel?catno=95M0028XVB&lang=eng>.

Statistics Canada (2010). Table 385-0001 - Consolidated Federal, Provincial, Territorial and Local Government Revenue and Expenditures, Annual (dollars). <http://www40.statcan.ca/l01/cst01/govt48b-eng.htm>.

United States, Department of Homeland Security [US-DHS] (2009).Yearbook of Immigration Statistics: Nonimmigrant Supplemental Table 2: Nonimmigrant Admissions (I-94 Only) by Class of Admission and Country of Residence: Fiscal Year 2009. <http://www.dhs.gov/files/statistics/publications/YrBk09NI.shtm>, “Supplemental Table 2” (xls).

United States, Department of State (2010). Visa Statistics. <http://travel.state.gov/visa/statistics/nivstats/nivstats_4582.html>.

United States Code (2010). Title 8, Chapter 12, Subchapter II, Part II, §1184. <http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode08/usc_sec_08_00001184----000-.html>.

UK Border Agency (2010). Annual Limit for Tier 1 and Tier 2 Visa Applications. November 24. <http://www.ukba.homeoffice.gov.uk/sitecontent/ newsfragments/35-t1-t2-annual-limits>.

Wanner, Richard A. (2003). Entry Class and the Earnings Attainment of Immigrants to Canada, 1980–1995. Canadian Public Policy 29, 1: 53–71.

Worswick, Christopher (2004). Immigrants’ Declining Earnings: Reasons and Remedies. Backgrounder No. 81. CD Howe Institute. <www.cdhowe.org/pdf/backgrounder_81.pdf>.