Why are migrant students better off in certain types of educational systems or schools than in others?

Dronkers, Jaap and van der Velden, Rolf and Dunne, Allison (2011): Why are migrant students better off in certain types of educational systems or schools than in others? Published in: European Educational Research Journal , Vol. 11, No. 1 (March 2012): pp. 11-44.

Abstract

The main research question of this paper is the combined estimation of the effects of educational systems, school composition, track level, and country of origin on the educational achievement of 15-year-old migrant students. We focus specifically on the effects of socioeconomic and ethnic background on achievement scores and the extent to which these effects are affected by characteristics of the school, track, or educational system in which these students are enrolled. In doing so, we examine the ‘sorting’ mechanisms of schools and tracks in highly stratified, moderately stratified, and comprehensive education systems. We use data from the 2006 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) wave. Compared with previous research in this area, the paper’s main contribution is that we explicitly include the tracks-within-school level as a separate unit of analyses, which leads to less biased results concerning the effects of educational system characteristics. The results highlight the importance of including factors of track level and school composition in the debate surrounding educational inequality of opportunity for students in different education contexts. The findings clearly indicate that the effects of educational system characteristics are flawed if the analysis only uses a country- and a student level and ignores the tracks-within-school level characteristics. From a policy perspective, the most important finding is that educational systems are neither uniformly ‘good’ nor ‘bad’, but they can result in different consequences for different migrant groups. Some migrant groups are better off in comprehensive systems, while others are better off in moderately stratified systems.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: migrants; educational performance; educational systems; schools; destination country; origin country; cross-national; PISA
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F2 - International Factor Movements and International Business > F22 - International Migration; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O1 - Economic Development > O15 - Human Resources ; Human Development ; Income Distribution ; Migration; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I2 - Education and Research Institutions > I21 - Analysis of Education

References

Ammermüller, A. (2005), Educational Opportunities and the Role of Institutions, ZEW Discussion Papers, 44.

André, S., Dronkers, J. & Fleischmann, F. (2009), Verschillen in groepsdiscriminatie, zoals waargenomen door immigranten uit verschillende herkomstlanden in veertien lidstaten van de Europese Unie [Differences in In-Group Discrimination as Perceived by Immigrants from Various Countries of Origin in Fourteen Member-States of the European Union], Mens en Maatschappij 84:448–482.

Blau, P. M. & Duncan, O.D. (1967), The American Occupational Structure, New York: The Free Press.

Bourdieu, P. & Passeron, J.C. (1977), Reproduction in Education, Society, and Culture, London: Sage.

Breen, R. & Jonsson, J.O. (2000), Analysing Educational Careers: A Multinomial Transition Model, American Sociological Review, 65(5):754–772.

Breen, R. & Jonsson, J.O. (2005), Inequality of Opportunity in Comparative Perspective: Recent Research on Educational Attainment and Social Mobility, Annual Review of Sociology, 31:223–243.

Buchmann, C. & Hannum, E. (2001), Education and Stratification in Developing Countries: A Review of Theories and Research, Annual Review of Sociology, 27:77–102.

Chiswick, B.R. & Miller, P.W. (1996), Ethnic Networks and Language Proficiency among Immigrants, Journal of Population Studies, 9:19–35.

Chiswick, B.R. & Miller, P.W. (2002), Immigrant Earnings: Language Skills, Linguistic Concentration, and the Business Cycle, Journal of Population Economics, 15:31–57.

Coleman, J.S. (1966), Equality of Educational Opportunity, National Center for Educational Statistics (DHEW/OE), Washington, D.C.

Dronkers J. (2010a), Positieve maar ook negatieve effecten van etnische diversiteit in scholen op onderwijsprestaties? Een empirische toets met internationale PISA-data [Positive but also Negative Effects of Ethnic Diversity in Schools on Educational Achievement? An Empirical Test with Cross-national PISA-Data], Tijdschrift voor Onderwijsrecht en Onderwijsbeleid 6: 483–499. English version paper presented at the conference “Integration and Inequality in Educational Institutions” at the University of Bremen, Teerhof, 24–25 September 2010.

Dronkers, J., (2010b), Features of Educational Systems as Factors in the Creation of Unequal Educational Outcomes, In J. Dronkers (Ed.), Quality and Inequality of Education. Cross-National Perspectives, pp. 299–328, Dordrecht /Heidelberg/ London/ New York: Springer.

Dronkers, J. & Avram, S. (2010a), A Cross-national Analysis of the Relations of School Choice and Effectiveness Differences between Private-Dependent and Public Schools, Educational Research and Evaluation, 16:151–175.

Dronkers, J. & Avram, S. (2010b), A Cross-national Analysis of the Relations of School Choice and Effectiveness Differences between Private-Independent and Public Schools, Sociological Theory and Methods, 25:183–206.

Dronkers, J., R. Van der Velden & A. Dunne (2011), The Effects of Educational Systems, School-Composition, Track-Level, Parental Background, and Immigrants’ Origin on the Achievement of 15-Year-Old Native and Immigrant Students: A Reanalysis of PISA 2006, ROA-RM-2011/6, Maastricht: ROA.

Dronkers, J. & Heus, M. de (2010a), Negative Selectivity of Europe’s Guest-Workers Immigration? The Educational Achievement of Children of Immigrants Compared with the Educational Achievement of Native Children in their Origin Countries, In: E. de Corte & J. Fenstad (Eds.), From Information to Knowledge; from Knowledge to Wisdom: Challenges and Changes Facing Higher Education in the Digital Age, pp. 89–104, London: Portland Press.

Dronkers, J. & Heus, M. de (2010b), The Higher Educational Achievement of Chinese Pupils, Inside and Outside of Asia: the Higher Transparency of Chinese Numbers or a Higher Value of Learning within Chinese Culture? Unpublished manuscript.

Dunne, A. (2010), Dividing Lines: Examining the Relative Importance of between- and within-School Differentiation during Lower Secondary Education. Ph.D. European University Institute (Florence).

Dustmann, C. (2004), Parental Background, Secondary School Track Choice, and Wages. Oxford Economic Papers, 56(2).

European Commission (2008), Migration and Mobility: Challenges and Opportunities for EU Education Systems. Brussels: Green Paper.

Erikson, R., & Jonsson, J. O. (Eds.) (1996), Can Education be Equalized? The Swedish Case in Comparative Perspective, Boulder: Westview Press.

Feliciano, C. (2005), Educational Selectivity in U.S. Immigration: How Do Immigrants Compare to Those Left behind? Demography, 42:131–152.

Filmer, D. & Pritchett, L. (1999), The Effect of Household Wealth on Educational Attainment: Evidence from 35 countries, Population and Development Review, 25:85–120.

Gamoran, A. (1992), Social Factors in Education, In: M. Alkin (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Educational Research (6th ed.), pp. 1222–1229, New York: Macmillan.

Gamoran, A. (2004), Classroom Organization and Instructional Quality, In: H.J. Walberg, A.J. Reynolds & M.C. Wang (Eds.), Can Unlike Students Learn Together? Grade Retention, Tracking, and Grouping, pp. 141–55. Greenwich, CT: Information Age.

Gamoran, A., Nystrand, M., Berends, M. & LePore, P.C. (1995), An Organisational Analysis of the Effects of Ability Grouping, American Educational Research Journal, 32 (4):687–715.

Ganzeboom, H. B. G., Graaf, P. de, Treiman, D. J. & De Leeuw, J. (1992), A Standard International Socio-Economic Index of Occupational Status, Social Science Research, 21:1–56.

Hanushek, E.A. & Woessmann, L. (2006), Does Educational Tracking Affect Performance and Inequality? Differences-in-Differences Evidence across Countries, Economic Journal, 116(510:C63).

Hanushek, E.A. & Woessmann, L. (2010), The High Cost of Low Performance: The Long-Run Economic Impact of Improving PISA Outcomes, Paris: OECD.

Hargreaves, D. (1967), Social Relations in a Secondary School, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.

Hauser, R. M. & Sewell, W. H. (1986), Family Effects in Simple Models of Education, Occupational Status, and Earnings: Findings from the Wisconsin and Kalamazoo studies, Journal of Labor Economics. July 4 (Part 2):S83–S115.

Heus, M. de & Dronkers, J. (2010a), De onderwijsprestaties van immigrantkinderen in 16 OECD-landen. De invloed van onderwijsstelsels en overige samenlevingskenmerken van zowel herkomst- als bestemmingslanden. [The Educational Performance of Immigrant Children in 16 OECD-countries. The Influence of Educational Systems and Other Societal Features of Both Countries of Origin and Destination], Tijdschrift voor Sociologie, 31:260–294.

Heus, M. de, & Dronkers, J. (2010b). The Educational Performance of Children of Immigrants in 16 OECD-countries. The Influence of Educational Systems and Other Societal Features of Both Countries of Origin and Destination, Unpublished Manuscript.

Hopper, E. I. (1968), A Typology for the Classification of Educational Systems. Sociology, 2:29–46.

Horn, D. (2009), Age of Selection Counts: a Cross-Country Analysis of Educational Institutions, Educational Research and Evaluation, 15(4):343–366.

Jencks, C. (1972), Inequality: A Reassessment of the Effect of Family and Schooling in America, Harmondsworth: Penguin Books.

Jencks, C., Bartlett, S., Corcoran, M., Crouse, J., Eaglesfield, C., Jackson, G., McClelland, K., Mueser, P., Olneck, M., Schwartz, J., Ward, S. & Williams, J. (1979), Who Gets Ahead? The Determinants of Economic Success in America. New York: Basic Books.

Kerckhoff, A.C. (1986), Effects of Ability Groups in British Secondary Schools, American Sociological Review, 51:842–858.

Kerckhoff, A.C. (1995), Institutional Arrangements and Stratification Processes in Industrial Societies, Annual Review of Sociology, 15:323–347.

Levels, M. & Dronkers J. (2008), Educational Performance of Native and Immigrant Children from Various Countries of Origin, Ethnic and Racial Studies, 31:1404–1425.

Levels, M., Dronkers, J. & Kraaykamp, G. (2008), Immigrant Children’s Educational Achievement in Western Countries: Origin, Destination, and Community Effects on Mathematical Performance, American Sociological Review, 73:835–853.

Lucas, S.R. (1999), Tracking Inequality: Stratification and Mobility in American High Schools. New York: Teachers College Press.

Mare, R.D. (1993), Educational Stratification on Observed and Unobserved Components of Family Background, In: Y. Shavit & H.-P. Blossfeld (Eds.), Persistent Inequality: Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries, pp. 351–376, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Marks, G.N., Creswell, J. & Ainley, J. (2006), Explaining Socioeconomic Inequalities in Student Achievement: The Role of Home and School Factors, Education Research and Evaluation, 12(2):105–128.

Metz, M.H. (1978), Classrooms and Corridors: The Crisis of Authority in Desegregated Secondary Schools. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Muller, W. & Karle, W. (1993), Social Selection in Educational Systems in Europe, European Sociological Review, 9:1–23.

Oakes, J. (1985), Keeping Track: How Schools Structure Inequality. Yale University Press.

Oakes, J., Gamoran, A. & Page, R. (1992), Curriculum Differentiation, Opportunities, Outcomes and Meanings, In: Y. Shavit & W. Muller (Eds.), From School to Work: A Comparative Study of Educational Qualifications and Occupational Destinations, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (2005), School Factors Related to Quality and Equity: Results from PISA 2000, Paris: OECD.

OECD (2006), Where Immigrant Students Succeed. Pisa 2003, Paris: OECD.

OECD (2007), PISA 2006. Science Competencies for Tomorrow’s World, Paris: OECD.

Peaker, G.F. (1971), The Plowden Children Four Years Later. London: National Foundation for Education Research in England and Wales.

Pfeffer, P.T. (2008), Persistent Inequality in Educational Attainment and Its Institutional Context, European Sociological Review, 25(5):543–565.

Rindermann, H. & Ceci, S.J. (2009), Educational Policy and Country Outcomes in International Cognitive Competence, Perspectives on Psychological Science, 4:551–568.

Rosenbaum, J.E. (1976), Making Inequality: The Hidden Curriculum of High School Tracking. New York: Wiley.

Rumbaut, R. (2004), Ages, Life Stages, and Generational Cohorts: Decomposing the Immigrant First and Second Generations in the United States, International Migration Review, 38(3):1160–1205.

Scheerens, J. & Bosker, R.J. (1997), The Foundations of Educational Effectiveness, Pergamon, Oxford.

Shavit, Y. & Blossfeld, H.P. (1993), Persistent Inequality: Changing Educational Attainment in Thirteen Countries. Westview Press.

Shavit, Y., Arum, R. & Gamoran, A. (Eds.) (2007), Stratification in Higher Education: A Comparative Study. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Snijders, T.A.B. & Bosker, R.J. (1999), Multilevel Analysis: An Introduction to Basic and Advanced Multilevel Modelling. London: Sage Publications.

Spring, J.H. (1976), The Sorting Machine: National Educational Policy since 1945, New York: McKay.

Stolle, D., Soraka, S. & Johnston, R. (2008), When Does Diversity Erode Trust? Neighborhood Diversity, Interpersonal Trust and the Mediating Effect of Social Interactions, Political Studies, 56:57–75.

Tuner, R.H. (1960), Sponsored and Contest Mobility and the School System, American Sociological Review, 25(6):855–867.

Treiman, D. J. & Yip, K.-B. (1989), Educational and Occupational Attainment in 21 Countries, In: M. L. Kohn (Ed.), Cross-national Research in Sociology, Newbury Park/London/New Delhi: Sage.

Tubergen, F. van (2005), The Integration of Immigrants in Cross-national Perspective. Origin, Destination, and Community Effects. Ph.D. Universiteit Utrecht.

Tubergen, F. van, Maas, I. & Flap, H. (2004), The Economic Incorporation of Immigrants in 18 Western Societies: Origin, Destination and Community Effects, American Sociological Review, 69:704–727.

UNESCO (2006), ISCED 1997: International Standard Classification of Education, Re-Edition 2006.

Voas, D., Crockett, A. & Olson, D. V. A. (2002), Religious Pluralism and Participation: Why Previous Research is Wrong, American Sociological Review, 67:212–230.

Willms, J.D. (1986), Social Class Segregation and Its Relationship to Pupil’s Examination Results in Scotland, American Sociological Review, 51:224–241.

Willms, J.D. (1992), Monitoring School Performance: A Guide for Educators. Washington, D.C.: The Falmer Press.