Socially - optimal level of co-determination of labor and the European directive on workers' councils

Josheski, Dushko (2012): Socially - optimal level of co-determination of labor and the European directive on workers' councils.

Abstract

In the past employee interest and influence have been presented mainly through trade unions and collective bargaining (economic regulation). Socially optimal levels of co-determination may be prevented by the existence of high fixed costs of establishing councils. Job security can resolve the adverse selection problem and raise economic efficiency i.e. worker or agent will work efficiently or socially optimal. Co-determination reinforces well functioning social democracy, recent studies discover that consultation and participation increase than innovativeness of the company. The US and EU approach to employment are different under common and civil law, that differ in many ways. The US employment –at- will is liberal individualist model, laissez-faire approach and any regulation is considered to be potentially welfare reducing. And mandatory employment rights model; EU model that seeks it’s rationale in the previously mentioned market failures (agency problems, hold-up problems) caused by asymmetric information and incomplete employment contracts, and the presence of monopolies, monopsonies that reduce workers mobility. Harmonious relations between” social partners” – labor and management are the aim of the European Work Council directive. European law continues to focus on workers and shareholders interest.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Asymmetric informations, European model, Employee councils, Co-determination, European Work Council Directive
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M5 - Personnel Economics > M50 - General

References

1.Adnett ,N and Hardy S.(2005) The European Social Model: Modernization or evolution?, Cheltenham : Edward Elgar , Chapter 3 & 8

2Adnett, Nick , 2008, Lecture Notes, Personnel Economics, Staffordshire university

3.Brewster Chris, Sparrow Paul, Vernon Guy (2007) International Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, Chartered institute of Personnel and development.

4.Bauer T. (2004) High Performance Workplace Practices and Job Satisfaction : Evidence from Europe ,IZA Discussion Paper No.1265. (available at IZA, SSRN)

5.Clark A.(2005) Your Money or Your Life: Changing job quality in OECD countries , British Journal of Industrial Relations 43(3) : 377-400

6.Edwards Paul(2004) Industrial Relations –Great Britain; second edition, Blackwell Publishing ;

7.Freeman Richard, and Edward Lazear, “An Economic Analysis of Works Councils,” in Joel Rogers and Wolfgang Streeck, eds., Works Councils: Consultation, Representation, and Cooperation in Industrial Relations [NBER conference volume], Chicago: University of Chicago Press for the NBER, November 1995

8.Fitz Roy Felix and Kornelius Kraft (2005) Co-determination, Efficiency and Productivity, British Journal of Industrial Relations

9.Gorton, Gary ,Schmid A.Frank (2004) CAPITAL, LABOR, AND THE FIRM: A STUDY OF GERMAN CODETERMINATION ; Journal of the European Economic Association

10.Hubler Olaf ; Jirjahn Uwe (2003) WORKS COUNCILS AND COLLECTIVE BARGAINING IN GERMANY:THE IMPACT ON PRODUCTIVITY AND WAGES, Vol 50 Scottish Journal of Political Economy

11.Hall, Mark (1992), Behind the European work council directive :The Europeans’ Commision’s Legislative ,British Journal of Industrial Relations

12.Hardy, Stephen, Upex , Robert(2006) ,Employment law for Business Students, SAGE publications Ltd

13.Hogler, R, Raymond (1996) Worker Participation in the United States and European Union: A comparative Legal Analysis, Labour Law Journal

14.Lazear, EP, (1995) Personnel Economics, The MIT Press Larsen, Holt , Henrik, Mayrhhofer , Wolfgang(2006) , Managing Human Resources in Europe ,British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data

15.Morley. J . Michael, Gunnigle, Patrick, Collings . G. David(2006) , Global Industrial Relations,published by Routledge

16.Mizrahi Shlomo (2002) Workers’ Participation in Decision Making Processes and Firms Stability British Journal of Industrial Relations

17.Osman, Chris(2001) ,US and EU employment law compared, L&C Publishing Limited., GLOBAL COUNSEL

18.Peccei Ricardo,Bewley Helen, Gospel Howard, Wilman Paul,(2003) Is it Good to Talk? Information Disclosure and Organisational Performance in the UK Incorporating evidence submitted on the DTI discussion paper ‘High Performance Workplaces –Informing and Consulting Employees’ released under ‘Future of Trade Unions in Modern Britain

19.Robinson, Robin, Fox M.J.(1985), Employment at will: A time for Change, Industrial Management

20.Rhodes, Martin(1992) , The Future of the “Social Dimension”: Labour Market Regulation in Post-1992 Europe, volume XXX, Journal of Common Market Studies

21.Salamon Michael (2000) Industrial Relations, Theory and Practice , 4th edition, FT Prentice Hall

22.Sadowski Dieter , Junkes Joahim ,Lindenthal Sabine(1999) Labour Co-Determination and Corporate Governance in Germany: The Economic Impact of Marginal and Symbolic Rights, Humboldt-Forum on Economics and Management on "Corporate Governance"

23.Sargeant, Malkolm , Lewis, David (2000), Essentials of Employment Law ,sixth edition, Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development, CIPD

24.Schneider/Kingsman(1976) , The German Co-determination act 1976,Published in Germany

25.Teague, Paul (1993), Between convergence and divergence: Possibilities for European Community System of Labour Market Regulation, International Labour Review , vol 132