Let’s work it out (or we’ll see you in court): litigation and private dispute resolution in vertical exchange relationships

Lumineau, Fabrice and Oxley, Joanne (2012): Let’s work it out (or we’ll see you in court): litigation and private dispute resolution in vertical exchange relationships. Forthcoming in: Organization Science

Abstract

We examine how partners in vertical exchange relationships actually resolve disputes that are sufficiently serious to get lawyers involved. Reaching beyond the usual domain of organizational and management research we leverage findings from law and economics to offer a novel organizational perspective on litigation and private dispute resolution, and develop hypotheses about the likelihood of litigation in different exchange settings. Our empirical analysis generates three sets of new findings: First, counter to the received wisdom we see that the involvement of lawyers does not necessarily signal the bitter end of an exchange relationship, as firms frequently manage to avoid litigation and resolve their disputes privately, and do so in a manner that accords with our theoretical predictions. Second, we see that familiarity with exchange partners does not automatically lead to increased willingness to work things out: rather, our empirical results suggest that the impact of exchange duration on parties’ willingness to resolve disputes privately is contingent on the development of norms of cooperation; in the event that such norms do not develop, the probability of a litigated outcome actually increases over time. Finally, we see that firms’ willingness to work things out privately is also influenced positively by the shadow of the future. These findings are suggestive of a “discriminating alignment” between exchange characteristics and the choice of dispute resolution procedure, and thus inject important new evidence into ongoing discussions about the legal underpinnings of different governance forms.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Contracts; Dispute resolution; Litigation
• Subjects: M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M1 - Business Administration; D - Microeconomics > D7 - Analysis of Collective Decision-Making > D74 - Conflict ; Conflict Resolution ; Alliances ; Revolutions; M - Business Administration and Business Economics ; Marketing ; Accounting ; Personnel Economics > M2 - Business Economics; K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K41 - Litigation Process; K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior

References

Anderson, E., S. Jap. 2005. The dark side of close relationships. MIT Sloan Management Rev. 46(3) 75–82.

Argyres, N. S., J. Bercovitz, K. J. Mayer. 2007. Complementarity and evolution of contractual provisions: An empirical study of IT service contracts. Organ. Sci. 18(1) 3–19.

Ariño, A., J. de la Torre. 1998. Learning from failure: Towards an evolutionary model of collaborative ventures. Organ. Sci. 9(3) 306–325.

Axelrod, R. 1984. The Evolution of Cooperation. Basic Books, New York.

Bebchuk, L. A. 1984. Litigation and settlement under imperfect information. RAND J. Econom. 15(3) 404–415.

Bouwens, J., L. van Lent. 2006. Performance measure properties and the effect of incentive contracts. J. Management Accounting Res. 18 55–75.

Carson, S. J., A. Madhok, T. Wu. 2006. Uncertainty, opportunism, and governance: The effects of volatility and ambiguity on formal and relational contracting. Acad. Management J. 49(5): 1058–1077.

Daft, R. L., N. B. Macintosh. 1981. A tentative exploration into the amount and equivocality of information processing in organizational work units. Admin. Sci. Quart. 26 207–225.

David, R. J., S-K Han. 2004. A systematic assessment of the empirical support for transaction cost economics. Strategic Management J. 25 39–58.

Deffains, B., T. Kirat. 2001. Law and Economics in Civil Law Countries. Elsevier JAI Press, Amsterdam.

Dyer, J., H. Singh. 1998. The relational view: Cooperative strategy and sources of interorganizational competitive advantage. Acad. Management Rev. 23 660–679.

Farrell, J., E. Maskin. 1989. Renegotiation in repeated games. Games and Economic Behavior 1 327–360.

Golden, B. R. 1992. The past is the past – Or is it? The use of retrospective accounts as indicators of past strategy. Acad. Management J. 35(4) 848–860.

Gould, J. P. 1973. The economics of legal conflicts. J. Legal Stud. 2 279–300.

Grossman, S., O. Hart. 1986. The costs and benefits of ownership: A theory of vertical and lateral integration. J. Political Econom. 94 691–719.

Gulati, R. 1995. Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances. Acad. Management Rev. 38 85–112.

Gulati, R., M. Sytch. 2008. Does familiarity breed trust? Revisiting the antecedents of trust. Manage. Decis. Econ. 29 165–190.

Hamilton, B., J. A. Nickerson. 2003. Correcting for endogeneity in strategic management research. Strategic Organ. 1 53–80.

Heide, J. B., G. John. 1990. Alliances in industrial purchasing: The determinants of joint action in buyer supplier relationships. J. Marketing Res. 27(1) 24–36.

Heide, J. B., A. Miner. 1992. The shadow of the future: Effects of anticipated interaction and frequency of contact on buyer-supplier cooperation. Acad. Management J. 35(2) 265–291.

Hoopes, D., S. Postrel. 1999. Shared knowledge, “glitches” and product development performance. Strategic Management J. 20 837–852.

Jap, S. D., S. Ganesan. 2000. Control mechanisms and the relationship life cycle: Implications for safeguarding specific investments and developing commitment. J. Marketing Res. 37(May) 227–245.

Johnson, S., J. McMillan, C. Woodruff. 2002. Courts and relational contracts. J. Law Econom. Organ. 18 221–277.

Kanter, R. M. 1994. Collaborative advantage: The art of alliances. Harvard Business Rev. 72(4) 96–109.

Klein, B. 1996. Why hold-ups occur: The self-enforcing range of contractual relationships. Econom. Inquiry 34 444–463.

Klein Woolthuis, R. K., B. Hillebrand, B. Nooteboom. 2005. Trust, contract and relationship development. Organ. Stud. 26(6) 813–840.

Knight, F. 1921. Risk, Uncertainty and Profit. Houghton Mifflin, New York.

Lewis, D., A. Weigert. 1985. Trust as a social reality. Soc. Forces 63(4) 967–985.

Liker, J. K., T. Y.Choi. 2004. Building deep supplier relationships. Harvard Bus. Rev. 82(12) 104–113.

Llewellyn, L. 1931. What price contract? An essay in perspective. Yale Law J. 40 704–751.

Lumineau, F., D. Malhotra. 2011. Shadow of the contract: How contract structure shapes interfirm dispute resolution. Strategic Management J. Forthcoming.

Macaulay, S. 1963. Non-contractual relationships in business: A preliminary study. Amer. Soc. Rev. 28 55–70.

Malhotra, D., F. Lumineau. 2011. Trust and collaboration in the aftermath of conflict: The effects of contract structure. Acad. Management J. Forthcoming.

Mattli, W. 2001. Private justice in a global economy: From litigation to arbitration. Internat. Organ. 55(4) 919–947.

Mayer, K. J., N. Argyres. 2004. Learning to contract: Evidence from the personal computer industry. Organ. Sci. 15 394–410.

Mohr, J., R. Spekman. 1994. Characteristics of partnership success: Partnership attributes, communication behavior, and conflict resolution techniques. Strategic Management J. 15(2) 135–142.

Monteverde, K., D. J. Teece. 1982. Appropriable rents and quasi-vertical integration. J. Law Econom. 25(2) 321–328.

Norton, E. C., H. Wang, C. Ai. 2004. Computing interaction effects in logit and probit models. Stata J. 4(2) 103– 116.

Park, S. H., G. R. Ungson. 2001. Interfirm rivalry and managerial complexity: A conceptual framework of alliance failure. Organ. Sci. 12(1) 37–53.

Parkhe, A. 1993. Strategic alliance structuring: A game theoretic and transaction cost examination of interfirm cooperation. Acad. Management J. 36 794–829.

Poppo L., T. R. Zenger. 2002. Do formal contracts and relational governance function as substitutes or complements? Strategic Management J. 23(8) 707–726.

Poppo, L., K. Z. Zhou, T. R. Zenger. 2008. Examining the conditional limits of relational governance: Specialized assets, performance ambiguity and long-standing ties. J. Management Stud. 45 1195–1216.

Priest, G. L., B. Klein. 1984. The selection of disputes for litigation. J. Legal Stud. 13 1–55.

Richman, B. D. 2004. Firms, courts, and reputation mechanisms: Toward a positive theory of private ordering. Columbia Law Rev. 104 2328–2367.

Riskin, L. L., J. E. Westbrook, C. Guthrie, R. Reuben, J. Robbennolt, N. A. Welsh. 2009. Dispute Resolution & Lawyers, 4th Edition. St Paul, MN: West Group.

Siegelman, P., J. Waldfogel. 1999. Towards a taxonomy of disputes: New evidence through the prism of the Priest/Klein model. J. Legal Stud. 28/1 101–130.

Simon, H. A. 1962. The architecture of complexity. Proc. Amer. Phil. Soc. 106(6) 467–482.

Simonin, B. 2007. Navistar cuts off engines to Ford. Financial Times. (February 26).

Slater, G., D. Spencer. 2000. The uncertain foundations of transaction cost economics. J. Econ. Issues 31 61–87.

Tractenberg, P. L. 1984. Training lawyers to be more effective dispute preventers and dispute settlers: Advocating for non-adversarial skills. J. Dispute Resolution 87–118.

Uzzi, B. 1996. The sources and consequences of embeddedness for the economic performance of organizations: The network effect. Amer. Sociological Rev. 61 674–698.

Vanneste, B. S., P. Puranam. 2010. Repeated interactions and contractual detail: Identifying the learning effect. Organ. Sci. 21 186–201.

Williamson, O. E. 1985. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism. Free Press, New York.

Williamson, O. E. 1991. Comparative economic organization: The analysis of discrete structural alternatives. Admin. Sci. Quart. 36 269–296.

Yelpaala, K., M. Rubino-Sammartano, D. Campbell. 1986. Drafting and Enforcing Contracts in Civil and Common Law Jurisdictions. Kluwer Law and Taxation, Deventer.

Zollo, M., J. J. Reuer, H. Singh. 2002. Interorganizational routines and performance in strategic alliances. Organ. Sci. 13(6) 701–713.