When spatial equilibrium fails: is place-based policy second best?

Partridge, Mark D. and Rickman, Dan S. and Olfert, M. Rose and Tan, Ying (2012): When spatial equilibrium fails: is place-based policy second best?

Abstract

Place-based or geographically-targeted policy has been promoted as a way to help poor regions and the poor people who live there. Yet, such policy has often been attacked by economists as slowing needed economic adjustments, redirecting resources to lower productivity regions, and supporting political agendas rather than economic prosperity. The spatial equilibrium model in particular predicts that people readily move to the locations providing the highest expected utility, suggesting that policy interventions only impede needed adjustments. Given the high mobility of Americans, the spatial equilibrium model should then be most applicable to the US. We review the empirical evidence on whether the spatial equilibrium model applies and find that, even in the United States, people are not as mobile as the model suggests and that economic shocks have rather persistent effects. Although this suggests the potential need for place-based policy, we describe the informational and political economy conditions that need to be met before place-based policy can be effective.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Place-based policy, spatial equilibrium
• Subjects: R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R13 - General Equilibrium and Welfare Economic Analysis of Regional Economies; R - Urban, Rural, Regional, Real Estate, and Transportation Economics > R1 - General Regional Economics > R12 - Size and Spatial Distributions of Regional Economic Activity

References

Artz, Georgeanna M. and Li Yu (2009), ‘How You Gonna Keep 'em Down on the Farm: Which Land Grant Graduates Live in Rural Areas?’ Iowa State University, Dept. of Econ., Staff Research Papers. Autor, D.H. Dorn D. and Hanson G.H. (2011) The China Syndrome: Local Labor Market Effects of Import Competition in the United States, MIT Working Papers, http://economics.mit.edu/files/6613.

Bartik, T.J. (1991) Who Benefits from State and Local Economic Development Policies? Kalamazoo, Mich.: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

_____. (1993a) Who benefits from local job growth: Migrants or the original residents? Regional Studies 27(4), 297-311.

_____. (1993b) Economic Development and Black Economic Success. Upjohn Institute Technical Report No. 93-001. Report originally prepared for U.S. Department of Commerce, Economic Development Administration, Technical Assistance and Research Division, January.

_____. (1994) The effects of metropolitan job growth on the size distribution of family income, Journal of Regional Science 34(4), 483-501.

_____. (1996) The distributional effects of local labor demand and industrial mix: Estimates using individual panel data, Journal of Urban Economics 40, 150-178.

_____. (2001) Jobs for the Poor: Can Labor Demand Policies Help? New York and Kalamazoo, MI: Russell Sage Foundation and Upjohn Institute.

_____. (2005) Solving the problems of economic development incentives, Growth and Change 35(2), 139–166.

_____. (2009) How Do the Effects of Local Growth on Employment Rates Vary With Initial Labor Market Conditions? Upjohn Institute Working Paper No. 09-148. Kalamazoo, MI: W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

_____. (forthcoming) The future of state and local economic development policy: What research is needed Growth and Change.

Bayer C. and Falko Jüßen F. (2007) Convergence in West German regional unemployment rates, German Economic Review 8(4), 510–535.

Bayer P. Keohane N. and Timmins C. (2009) Migration and hedonic valuation: The case of air quality, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 58, 1-14.

Beckstead, D., W.M. Brown and G. Gellatly (2008) The Left Brain of North American Cities: Scientists and Engineers and Urban Growth, International Regional Science Review 31(3), 304-38. Blanchard O.J. and Katz L.F. (1992) Regional Evolutions, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1, 61.

Bolton, Roger. 1992. `Place Prosperity vs People Prosperity' Revisited: An Old Issue with a New Angle, Urban Studies 29(2), 185-203.

Bound J. and Holzer H.J. (2000) Demand shifts, population adjustments, and labor market outcomes during the 1980s, Journal of Labor Economics 18(1), 20-54.

Cheng K.M. Durmaz N. Kim H. and Stern M.L. (2012) Hysteresis vs. natural rate of US unemployment, Economic Modelling 29, 428–434.

Clark D.E. Herrin W.E. Knapp T.A. and White N.E. (2003) Migration and implicit amenity markets: does incomplete compensation matter? Journal of Economic Geography 3, 289-307.

Crandall M.S. and Weber B.A. (2004) Local social and economic conditions, spatial concentrations of poverty, and poverty dynamics, American Journal of Agricultural Economics 86(5), 1276-81.

Davis S.J. Loungani P. and Mahidhara R. (1997) Regional labor fluctuations: oil shocks, military spending, and other driving forces, International Finance Discussion Papers Number 578, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System.

Decressin J. and Fatás A. (1995) Regional labor market dynamics, European Economic Review 39, 1627-1655.

Dickie, M. and Gerking, S. (1989) Interregional wage differentials in the United States: a survey. In: Van Dijk, J., Folmer, H.,Herzog,H.W., Schlottmann, A.M. (Eds.), Migration and Labor Market Adjustment. Kluwer Academic, Dordrecht, Netherlands, pp. 111–145.

Dorfman J. Partridge M.D. and Galloway H. (2011) “Are High-tech Employment and Natural Amenities Linked: Answers from a Smoothed Bayesian Spatial Model.” Spatial Economic Analysis (6): 397-422.

DuMond, J.M., Hirsch, B.T., and Macpherson, D.A. (1999) Wage differentials across labor markets and workers: does cost of living matter? Economic Inquiry 37(4), 577–598.

Eberts R.W. Stone J.A. (1992) Wage and Employment Adjustment in Local Labor Markets, Kalamazoo, Mich.: W. E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research.

Fredriksson P. (1999) The dynamics of regional labor markets and active labor market policy: Swedish evidence, Oxford Economic Papers 51(4), 623-48.

Gabriel, S.A. Shack-Marquez, J. and Wascher W.L. (1993) Does migration arbitrage regional labor market differentials, Regional Science and Urban Economics 23(2), 211-33.

Gallin, J.H. (2004) Net migration and state labor market dynamics, Journal of Labor Economics 22(1), 1–21.

Garcia-del-Barrioa P. and Gil-Alana L.A. (2009) New revelations about unemployment persistence in Spain: Time-series and panel data approaches using regional data, Applied Economics, 41, 219–236.

Glaeser E.L. and Gottlieb J.D. (2008) The economics of place-making policies, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, (Spring), 155-239.

Glaeser E.L. and Gyourko J. (2005) Urban decline and durable housing, Journal of Political Economy 113(2), 345-75.

Gomes F.A.R. and da Silva C.G. (2009) Hysteresis versus NAIRU and convergence versus divergence: The behavior of regional unemployment rates in Brazil, The Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance 49, 308–322.

Gordon I. (1988) Evaluating the effects of employment changes on local unemployment, Regional Studies 135-147.

Greenwood M.J. Hunt G.L. Rickman D.S. and Treyz G.I. (1991) Migration, regional equilibrium, and the estimation of compensating differentials, The American Economic Review, 81(5), 1382-1390.

Groenewold N. (1997) Does migration equalize regional unemployment rates? Evidence from Australia, Papers in Regional Science 76(1), 1-20.

Hall R. (1992) Comments and Discussion, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1, 62-65.

Hanson A. and Rohlin S. (2011). Do location-based tax incentives attract new business establishments? Journal of Regional Science 51(3), 427-449.

Holzer H.J. (1993) Structural/frictional and demand deficient unemployment in local labor markets, Industrial Relations, 32(3), 307-328.

Hunt, G.L. (2006) Population-employment models: Stationarity, cointegration, and dynamic adjustment, Journal of Regional Science 46(2), 205-244.

Hyclak T. (1996) Structural changes in labor demand and unemployment in local labor markets, Journal of Regional Science 36(4), 653-663.

Jimineo, J.F. and Bentolila S. (1998) Regional unemployment persistence, Labour Economics 5, 25-51.

León-Ledesma M.A. (2002) Unemployment hysteresis in the US states and the EU: A panel approach, Bulletin of Economic Research 54(2), 95-103.

Levernier, William, Mark D. Partridge, and Dan S. Rickman. (2000) The causes of variation of regional variations in U.S. poverty: A cross-county analysis, Journal of Regional Science 40(3), 473-497.

Marston S.T. (1985) Two views of the geographic distribution of unemployment, Quarterly Journal of Economics 100(1), 57-79.

Martin R. (1997) Regional unemployment disparities and their dynamics, Regional Studies 31(3), 237-252.

Notowidigdo M.J. 2011. The Incidence of Local Labor Demand Shocks, National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 17167, Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Obstfeld M. Peri G. (1998) Regional non-adjustment and fiscal policy, Economic Policy: A European Forum Issue 26, 205-47.

Oswald Andrew J. Wu Stephen. (2011) Well-being across America, The Review of Economics and Statistics 93(4), 1118-1134.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (1997a) The dispersion of US state unemployment rates: The role of market and non-market equilibrium factors Regional Studies, 31(6), 593-606.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (1997b) State unemployment differentials: Equilibrium factors vs. differential employment growth, Growth and Change 28(Summer), 360-379.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (1998) Regional differences in chronic long-term unemployment, Quarterly Review of Economics and Finance, 38(2), 193-215.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (1999) A note on the benefits to current residents of state employment growth: Is there an industry mix effect on migration, Journal of Regional Science 39(1), pp. 167-81.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2003a) Do we know economic development when we see it? The Review of Regional Studies 33(1), 17-39.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2003b) The waxing and waning of regional economies: The chicken-egg question of jobs vs. people, Journal of Urban Economics 53, 76-97.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2005) High-Poverty Nonmetropolitan Counties in America: Can Economic Development Help? International Regional Science Review 28(4), 415-440.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2006a) The Geography of American Poverty: Is there a Role for Place-based Policy? W.E. Upjohn Institute for Employment Research, Kalamazoo: Michigan.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2006b) An SVAR model of fluctuations in U.S. migration flows and state labor market dynamics, Southern Economic Journal 72(4), 958-980.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2007a) Persistent pockets of extreme American poverty and job growth: Is there a place-based policy role? Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics 32(1), 201-224.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2007b) Persistent Rural Poverty: Is It Simply Remoteness and Scale? Review of Agricultural Economics 29(3), 430–436.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2008a) Place-based policy and rural poverty: insights from the urban spatial mismatch literature, Cambridge Journal of Regions, Economy and Society, 1, 131–156.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2008b) Does a rising tide lift all metropolitan boats? Assessing poverty dynamics by metropolitan size and county type, Growth and Change 39(2), 283-312.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2008c) Distance from urban agglomeration economies and rural poverty, Journal of Regional Science 48(2), 285-310.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2008d) Who wins from local economic development? A supply decomposition of U.S. county employment growth, Economic Development Quarterly 23(1), 13-27.

Partridge M.D. and Rickman D.S. (2009) Canadian regional labour market evolutions: a long-run restrictions SVAR analysis, Applied Economics 41(13-15), 1855-1871.

Partridge, Mark D., Dan S. Rickman, M. Rose Olfert, and Kamar Ali. (2012) “Dwindling U.S. Internal Migration: Evidence of a Spatial Equilibrium or Structural Shifts in Local Labor Markets?” Regional Science and Urban Economics 42: 375-388.

Partridge, Mark D., Dan S. Rickman, Kamar Ali, and M. Rose Olfert. 2008. Lost in Space: Population Growth in the American Hinterlands and Small Cities. Journal of Economic Geography 8(6): 727-757. Partridge, Mark D., Dan S. Rickman, Kamar Ali, and M. Rose Olfert. 2009. Agglomeration Spillovers and Wage and Housing Cost Gradients across the Urban Hierarchy. Journal of International Economics. 78(1): 126-140. Payne J.E. Ewing B.T and George E.P. (1999) Time series dynamics of US state unemployment rates, Applied Economics 31, 1503–1510.

Pissarides C.A. and McMaster I. (1990) Regional migration, wages and unemployment: empirical evidence and implications for policy, Oxford Economic Papers 42(4), 812-831

Rickman D.S. (2011) Focus on the fundamentals. In: Developing the Oklahoma Economy. The Oklahoma Academy, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, 74-75.

Roback J. (1988) Wages, rents, and amenities: differences among workers and regions. Economic Inquiry 26 (1), 23–41.

Romero-Avila D. and Usabiaga C. (2007) Unit root tests, persistence, and the unemployment rate of the U.S. states, Southern Economic Journal 73(3), 698-716.

Rowthorn R. Glyn A.J. (2006) Convergence and stability in U.S. employment rates, B.E. Journal of Macroeconomics: Contributions to Macroeconomics, 6(1), pp. 1-42.

Sephton P.S. (2009) Persistence in U.S. state unemployment rates, Southern Economic Journal 76(2), 458-66.

Song, F.M. and Wu Y. (1997) Hysteresis in unemployment: Evidence from 48 U.S. states, Economic Inquiry 35(2), 235-243.

Tani, M. (2003) Have Europeans become more mobile? A note on regional evolutions in the EU: 1988-1997, Economics Letters 23-30.

Treyz, G.I. Rickman D.S. Hunt G.L. and Greenwood M.J. (1993) The dynamics of U.S. internal migration, Review of Economics and Statistics 75(2), 209-14.

Wang B. and Dayanandan A. (2006) Unit root tests of Canadian poverty measures, Economics Bulletin 9(2), 1-7. Winnick, L. (1966) Place Prosperity vs People Prosperity: Welfare Considerations in the Geographic Redistribution of Economic Activity, in: Real Estate Research Program, University of California at Los Angeles, Essays in Urban Land Economics in Honor of the Sixty-fifth Birthday of Leo Grebler, pp. 273-283, Los Angeles, CA: Real Estate Research Programme.

Winters J.V. (2009) Wages and prices: Are workers fully compensated for cost of living differences? Regional Science and Urban Economics 39, 632-643.

Yeo J.H. Sung K.A. and Holland D.W. (2005) Labor market behavior in Washington: A cointegration, Annals of Regional Science 39, 317-335.