Crisis and ‘law of motion’ in economics: a critique of positivist Marxism

Freeman, Alan (2010): Crisis and ‘law of motion’ in economics: a critique of positivist Marxism. Published in: Research in Political Economy No. 26 (2010): pp. 211-250.

Abstract

This is a prepublication version of the paper published in Review of Political Economy Volume 26, 2010 (http://www.emeraldinsight.com/books.htm?issn=0161-7230&volume=26). It should be cited as Freeman, A. (2010). ‘Crisis and “law of motion” in economics: a critique of positivist Marxism’, Review of Political Economy Volume 26, 2010, pp 211-250. This paper restores the concepts of freedom, consciousness, and choice to our understanding of ‘economic laws’, so we may discuss how to respond to economic crisis. These are absent from orthodox economics which presents ‘globalisation’ or ‘the markets’ as the outcome of unstoppable forces outside human control.

They were integral to the emancipatory political economy of Karl Marx but have been lost to Marxism, which appears as the inspiration for mechanical, fatalistic determinism. This confusion arises from Marxism’s absorption of the idea, originating in French positivism, that social laws are automatic and inevitable.

The article contests the organizing principle of this view: that economic laws are predictive, telling us what must happen. Marx’s laws are relational, not predictive, laying bare the connection between two apparently distinct forms of appearance of the same thing, such as labour and price. Such laws open the door to democracy and choice, but do not unambiguously predict the future because what happens depends on our actions.

The commodity form conceals these laws, disguising the true social and class relations of society. Accumulation, however, undermines the circumstances that permit the commodity to play this role. The result is crisis, defined in this paper as the point when the blind laws of the commodity form are suspended and open political forces come into play.

In past crises, capitalism has restored the rate of profit through such destructive interventions as imperialism, war, and fascism. Economic laws, properly defined, offer society the real choice of alternative outcomes from crisis.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Crisis, Rate of Profit, TSSI, Marxism
• Subjects: B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B1 - History of Economic Thought through 1925 > B14 - Socialist ; Marxist; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B3 - History of Economic Thought: Individuals; B - History of Economic Thought, Methodology, and Heterodox Approaches > B5 - Current Heterodox Approaches

References

Bagchi, A. K. (1982). The Political Economy of Underdevelopment (Modern Cambridge Economics). Cambridge University Press.

Baumol, W. J. (1983). ‘Marx and the Iron Law of Wages’. The American Economic Review, Vol. 73, No. 2, Papers and Proceedings of the Ninety-Fifth Annual Meeting of the American Economic Association (May, 1983), pp. 303-308

Besomi, D. (2010). Clément Juglar and the transition from crises theory to business cycle theories, paper prepared for a conference on the occasion of the centenary of the death of Clément Juglar, Paris, 2 December 2005. [ www.unil.ch/webdav/site/cwp/users/ neyguesi/public/D._Besomi_, accessed 14 May 2010]

Bortkiewicz, L. von (1952). ‘Value and Price in the Marxian System’(part I), in International Economic Papers, 1952(2), 5-60.

Brenner, R. (1977). ‘The Origins of Capitalist Development: A Critique of Neo-Smithian Marxism.’ New Left Review I/104.

Brenner, R. (1998). 'The Economics of Global Turbulence'. New Left Review, I/229.

Carchedi, G. (2009). ‘The Falling Profit Rate: from Okishio to Marx’, forthcoming in Capital and Class, No. 99

Carpentier, A. (2001). Explosion in a Cathetral. University of Minnesota Press.

Cockshott, P. and A. Cottrell. (1998). Does Marx Need to Transform? In Bellofiore, Riccardo (ed.), Marxian Economics. A reappraisal. Vol. 2: Essays on volume III of “Capital”: profit, prices and dynamics (London: Macmillan), 70–85.

Cockshott, P. and A. Cottrell. (2005). Robust Correlations between Sectoral Prices and Labour Values: A comment, Cambridge Journal of Economics 29:2, 309–16.

Cohn, N. (1970). The Pursuit of the Millenium. Oxford: OUP.

Coletti, L. (1985) ‘Bernstein and the Marxism of the Second International’ in Coletti, L. (1985) From Rousseau to Lenin. Studies in Ideology and Society. New York: Monthly Review Press. Pp 45-108.

Comte, A (1957[1856]). A General View of Positivism, translated by J H Bridges, Robert Speller and Sons.

Comte, A. (1851-54). System of Positive Polity, or Treatise on Sociology, Instituting the Religion of Humanity, (1851-1854, four volumes)

Day, R. B. (1981). Crisis and the Crash: Soviet Studies of the West, 1917-39. New Left Books.

Desai, R. (2010). ‘Consumption Demand in Marx and in the present Crisis’, in the present volume

Dobb, M. (1973). Theories of value and distribution since Adam Smith. Cambridge University Press.

Duménil, G. and D. Levy (2004). Capitalism Resurgent. Harvard University Press.

Einstein, A., B. Podolsky and N, Rosen (1935). ‘Can Quantum-Mechanical Description of Physical Reality be Considered Complete?’ Physical Review, Volume 47, May 15, 1935.

Emmanuel, Arghiri (1972). Unequal Exchange: A Study of the Imperialism of Trade. Trans. by Brian Pearce. New York: Monthly Review Press

Foley, D. (1997). 'Review of Marx and Non-equilibrium Economics', Eastern Economic Journal 23(4):493—496.

Freeman, A. (1998). ‘The indeterminacy of price-value correlations: a comment on papers by Simon Mohun and Anwar Shaikh’ in Bellofiore, R. (1998) Marxian Economics. A reappraisal. Vol. 2: Essays on volume III of “Capital”: profit, prices and dynamics (London: Macmillan), 225–51. <http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/2040/1/MPRA_paper_2040.pdf>

Freeman, A. (2004). ‘World Empire or a World of Empires?’ in Freeman, A. and B. Kagarlitsky (2004) (eds) The Politics of Empire: Globalisation in Crisis.

Freeman, A. (2003). ‘When things go wrong: the Political Economy of Market Breakdown’ in Westra; R and Alan Zuege (Eds) (2003) Value and the World Economy Today: Production; Finance and Globalization; pp91-118. London:MacMillan; Prepublication version on http://ideas.repec.org/p/pra/mprapa/5586.html

Freeman, A. (2009a). ‘Investing in Civilization’ in Guard, J. and W. Anthony (eds) (2009) Bailouts and Bankruptcies: Winnipeg: Fernwood Press

Freeman, A. (2009b). ‘The Poverty of Statistics’, Third World Quarterly, Vol. 30, No.8, pp1427-1448

Freeman, A. (2010). ‘Marxism Without Marx’. Capital and Class Vol, 34, No.1. February 2010

Freeman, A. and G. Carchedi (1995). Marx and non-Equilibrium Economics. Edward Elgar.

Freeman, C. (1995). The Third Kondratieff Wave: The Age of Steel, Electrification and Imperialism. Sussex: SPRU.

Gunder Frank, A. (1978). Dependent Accumulation and Underdevelopment. New York: Monthly Review Press and London: Macmillan Press

Hayek, F. (1933). ‘Monetary Theory and the Trade Cycle’. New York: Harcourt Brace

Krugman, P. (2010) ‘The Third Depression’ New York Times June 27, 2010

Juglar, C. (1862). Des Crises commerciales et leur retour periodique en France, en Angleterre, et aux Etats-Unis, Paris: Guillaumin.

Juglar, C. (1915).A Brief History of Panics and their Periodical Occurrence in the United States. Downloadable from http://manybooks.net/titles/juglarcletext05panic10.html

Kliman, A. (2002). The Law of Lalue and Laws of Statistics: Sectoral values and prices in the US economy, 1977–97, Cambridge Journal of Economics 26:3, 299–311.

Kliman, A. (2005). Reply to Cockshott and Cottrell, Cambridge Journal of Economics 29:2, 317–323.

Kliman, A. (2007). Reclaiming Marx's Capital: A refutation of the myth of inconsistency. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.

Kliman, A. (2010a). The Persistent Fall in Profitability Underlying the Current Crisis. New York: Marxist-Humanist Initiative

Kliman, A. (2010b). ‘The Disintegration of the Marxian School’. Capital and Class Vol, 34, No.1. February 2010

Kuhn, R. (2007). Henryk Grossman and the Recovery of Marxism. University of Illinois Press.

Labica, G.(1984). Der Marxismus-Leninismus: Elemente einer Kritik. Berlin: Argument

Labriola (1970[1897]). La concepcion materialista de la historia La Habana.

Laplace, P. S. (1951 [1820]). A Philosophical Essay on Probabilities, translated from the 6th French edition by Frederick Wilson Truscott and Frederick Lincoln Emory. New York: Dover Publications. French edition Laplace, P,S. (1820) Theorie analytique des probabilites. Volume VI of complete works, Paris:Gauthier-Villars.

Laplace, P.S. (1836). Exposition de systeme du monde Paris: Bachelier.

Lassalle, Ferdinand (1863). Offenes Antwortschreiben, http://www.marxists.org/deutsch/referenz/lassalle/1863/03/antwortschreiben.htm

Lovejoy, A. O, (1990). The Great Chain of Being: A Study of the History of an Idea. Harvard University Press.

Lukacs, G. (2000). Tailism and the dialectics, London: Verso. German original Lukacs, G (1996) Chvostisms tendus und Dialektik, Budapest, Aron Verlag.

Maksakovsky, P. (2004). The Capitalist Cycle. Brill.

Mandel (1974). Late Capitalism. London: Verso

Marx, K. (1972). Feuerback. Opposition of the Materialist and Idealist Outlooks. Moscow: Progress Publishers

Marx, K. (1991). Capital: Volume III. Penguin Classics.

Marx, K. (1992). Capital: Volume 1. Penguin Classics.

Meek, R. (1956). Studies in the Labour Theory of Value. London: Lawrence and Wishart.

Mitchell, W.C. (1927). Business Cycles: the Problem and its Setting, New York: McGraw-Hill.

Mongiovi, G. (2002). ‘Vulgar Economy in Marxian Garb: A Critique of Temporal Single System Marxism’ RRPE (xxxx find details and check page reference)

Morishima, M. (1973). Marx’s Economics: a Dual Theory of Value and Growth. Cambridge: CUP.

Ochoa, E. M. (1984). Labor-Values and Prices of Production: An interindustry study of the United States economy, 1947–1972. Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Economics, New School for Social Research, New York.

Palloix,C. (1970). 'Inégalité des échanges mondiaux ou inégalité du développement des forces productives à l'échelle mondiale'. La Pensée, no. 150, mars-avril 1970

Patnaik, U. (2006). ‘The Free Lunch: Transfers from Tropical Countries and Their Role in Capital Formation in Britain during the Industrial Revolution.’ Jomo, K. S. ed. Globalization Under Hegemony: The Changing World Economy. New Delhi: Oxford University Press.

Plato, Timaeus (1965). Tr Desmond Lee. London: Penguin.

Potts, N. (2009). ‘Trying to Help Rescue Value for Everyone’, Critique, Vol. 37., No. 2.

Riazanov, D. (1928). ‘Lassalle and Bismarck’, Pravda 14 July 1928, translated in Labour Monthly, February and March 1929. http://www.marxists.org/archive/riazanov/1928/07/lassalle.htm

Rostow, W.W. (1960). The Stages of Economic Growth: a Non-Communist Manifesto. Cambridge: CUP

Schumpeter, J.A. (1965). Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy. London: Unwin.

Shaikh, A.M.(1998). The Empirical Strength of the Labour Theory of Value. In Bellofiore, Riccardo (ed.), Marxian Economics. A reappraisal. Vol. 2: Essays on volume III of “Capital”: profit, prices and dynamics (London: Macmillan), 225–51.

Shanin, T. (1984). The Late Marx and the Russian Road. Monthly Review Press; First Edition edition (March 1, 1984)

Sraffa, P. (1975). Production of Commodities by Means of Commodities. Cambridge University Press.

Stadler, F. (1998). ‘The Vienna Circle’, in E. Craig (ed.) Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy Vol. 9, London: Routledge, pp. 606-616.

Steedman, I. (1981). Marx After Sraffa (New Ed.). Verso Books.

Sweezy, Paul M. (1968). Theory of Capitalist Development: Principles of Marxian Political Economy. Modern Reader Paperbacks.

Trotsky (1923). ‘O Krivoi Kapitalisticheskovo Razvitiya’ (‘The Curve of capitalist Development’), Vestnik Sotsialisticheskoi Akademii, 4, April-July. Cited in Day, op cit.

Tsoulfidis, L, and T. Maniatis (2002). Value, Prices of Production and Market Prices: Some more evidence from the Greek economy, Cambridge Journal of Economics 26:3, 359–69.

VanGiezen, R. And A. E. Schwenk (2002). ‘Compensation from before World War I through the Great Depression’. New York: BLS

Wells, Julian (2009). PhD Thesis, Kingston University

Zarembka, P. (2003) ‘Lenin as Economist of Production: A Ricardian Step Backwards’, Science & Society, Vol. 67, No. 3, Fall, pp. 276-302.