公平与效率的两难抉择——关于养老改革影响因素的一个文献综述

Zou, Tieding (2013): 公平与效率的两难抉择——关于养老改革影响因素的一个文献综述.

Abstract

This paper gives a literature review for the affecting factors of pension reforming,the result indicates that,(1)Efficiency and equity are the two aspects of pension system ,and the aging problem,labor productivity,ma- croeconomic environment,et al. will affect the relationship between efficiency and equity.(2)Parameter adjusting and Structure reforming is a good way to strengthen the ability to cope with aging and improve the budget condi- tion for pension system.(3)In order to narrow the wealth gap ,keep some redistributive function is necessary.(4)D- uring a pension reforming,not only the equity is important ,but also the efficiency,the disequilibrium of capital market and labor market can be improved through pension reforming.(5)Pension reforming must pay attention to political preference of different interest group,the majority voting rule must be obeyed,which is useful to guarantee the system’s universality and impartiality,and will be good to enhance the political feasibility of pension reforming.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• English Title: The Dilemma Between Efficiency and Equity——A Literature Review for the Affecting Factors of Pension Reforming
• Language: Chinese
• Keywords: Pension; Equity; Efficiency; Aging; Decision Mechanism
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G22 - Insurance ; Insurance Companies ; Actuarial Studies; H - Public Economics > H5 - National Government Expenditures and Related Policies > H53 - Government Expenditures and Welfare Programs; I - Health, Education, and Welfare > I3 - Welfare, Well-Being, and Poverty > I38 - Government Policy ; Provision and Effects of Welfare Programs; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J1 - Demographic Economics > J14 - Economics of the Elderly ; Economics of the Handicapped ; Non-Labor Market Discrimination

References

[1] 马克思、恩格斯，1972：《马克思恩格斯全集(第4卷)》，北京人民出版社，1972年出版，第233-34、793-94页。 [2] 约翰·罗尔斯，1971：《正义论》，中译本，中国社会科学出版社，1988年出版，第1-2页。 [3 ] 密尔顿·弗里德曼、罗斯·弗里德曼：《自由选择：个人声明》，中译本，商务印书馆，1999年出版，第133-40页。 [4] 罗纳德·德沃金，2000：《至上的美德》，中译本，江苏人民出版社，2003年出版，第1-2、68-9页。 [5] Zaidi,A., Grech,A.G. and Fuchs,M.,2006,"Pension Policy in EU25 and its Possible Impact on Elderly Pove- rty," Discussion Paper ,No.116, December,London:Centre for Analysis of Social Exclusion, London School of Ec- Onomics. [6] Breyer,F. and Hupfeld,S.,2008,"Fairness of Public Pensions and Old-Age Poverty,"Discussion Paper, Nov- ember , Berlin:German Institute for Economic Research,DIW. [7] Valdes-Prieto,S.,2000,"The Financial Stability of Notional Account Pensions,"The Scandinavian Journal of Economics, The Scandinavian Journal of Economics,Vol.102,No.3,pp.395-417. [8] Palotai,G.,2005,"The sustainability of the Hungarian pension system: a reassessment,"Working Paper,No.4 0, December, Budapest :Economics Department, Magyar Nemzeti Bank. [9] Fenge,R.,1995,"Pareto-efficiency of the Pay-as-you-go Pension System with Intragenerational Fairness,"P- ublic Finance Analysis, New Series,Bd.52, H.3,pp. 357-63. [10] James,E.,1997,"Pension Reform:Is There a Trade-off between Efficiency and Equity?"Working Paper,Ja- nuary,Washington DC: Policy Research Department ,World Bank. [11] 密尔顿·弗里德曼、罗斯·弗里德曼：《自由选择：个人声明》，中译本，商务印书馆，1999年出版，第149-50页。 [12 ] 诺齐克，1974：《无政府、国家和乌托邦》，中译本，中国社会科学出版社，1991年出版，第157-72页。 [13] 阿瑟·奥肯，1975：《平等与效率》，中译本，华夏出版社，1999年出版，第86-97页。 [14] 曲秀芳：《论公平与效率的关系》，硕士学位论文，吉林大学，2006年，第17-8页。 [15] Humes,K.,2005,"The population 65 years and older: Aging in America,"The book of the States.pp.464– 70. [16] Denton, F., Feaver, C. and Spencer,B.,2005,"Population Aging in Canada:Software for Exploring the Imp- lications for the Labour Force and Productive Capacity of the Economy,"Working Paper,No.146,Hamilton:SEDA- P. [17] LaPierre,T. and Hughes,M.,2009,"Population Aging in Canada and the United States,"in "International H- andbook of Population Aging,"edited by Uhlenberg,P.,Lawrence:Springer Netherlands,pp.191-230. [18] Wong,R., Palloni,A. and Markides,K.,2006,"Survey Data for the Study of Aging in Latin America and the Caribbean,"Journal of Aging and Health,Vol.18,No.2,pp.157-79. [19] Gasparini,L., Alejo,J., and Haimovich,F.,et al.,2007,"Poverty among the Elderly in Latin America and the Caribbean,"Working Paper,No.55,July,Plata:CEDLAS. [20] Wong,R. and Palloni,A.,2009,"Aging in Mexico and Latin America,"in"International Handbook of Popul- ation Aging"edited by Uhlenberg,P.,New York:Springer Press. [21] Muenz,R.,2007,"Aging and Demographic Change in European Societies:Main Trends and Alternative Po- licy Options,"Discussion Paper,No.0703,Washington DC:World Bank. [22] Haski-Leventhal,D.,2009,"Elderly Volunteering and Well-Being:A Cross-European Comparison Based on Share Data,"International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations,Vol.20,No.4,pp.388-404. [23] Walker,A.,2009,"International View Commentary:The Emergence and Application of Active Aging in E- urope,"Journal of Aging & Social Policy,Vol.21,No.1,pp.75-93. [24] Yap.,M., Thang,L. and Traphagan,J.,2005,"Introduction: Aging in Asia-Perennial Concerns on Support a- nd Caring for the Old,"Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology,Vol.20,No.4,pp.257-67. [25] Chan,A.,2005,"Aging in Southeast and East Asia: Issues and Policy Directions,"Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology,Vol.20,No.4,pp.269-84. [26] Mason,A., Lee,S. and Russo,G.,2006,"Demography of aging across Asia,"in"Handbook of Asian Aging.," Edited by Yoon,H. and Hendricks,J.,Amityville, NY:Baywood Publishing Company. [27] Menon,J. and Melendez-Nakamura,A.,2009,"Aging in Asia:Trends, Impacts and Responses,"Working Pa- per,No.25,February,Manila:Asian Development Bank. [28] Makoni,S.,2008,"Aging in Africa:A Critical Review,"Journal of Cross-Cultural Gerontology,Vol.23,No.2, pp.199-209. [29] Apt,N.,2012,"Aging in Africa: Past Experiences and Strategic Directions,"Ageing International,Vol.37,No. 1,pp.93-103. [30] Cook,I. and Halsall,J.,2012,"Aging in South Africa,"in"Aging in Comparative Perspective,"Published by Springer US,pp.67-76. [31] Anderson,G. and Hussey,P.,2000,"Population Aging: A Comparison Among Industrialized Countries,"H- ealth affairs,Vol.19,No.3,pp.191-203. [32] Kinsella,K.,2000,"Demographic Dimensions of Global Aging,"Journal of Family Issues,Vol.21,No.5,pp.541 -58. [33] Lutz,W., Sanderson,W. and Scherbov,S.,2008,"The coming acceleration of global population aging,"Natu- re,Vol.451,No.7,pp.716-19. [34] Lloyd-Sherlock,P.,2000a,"Population aging in developed and developing regions:implications for health policy,"Social Science & Medicine,Vol.51, No.6,pp.887–95. [35] Tinker,A.,2002,"The social implications of an ageing population,"Mechanisms of Ageing and Developme- nt,Vol.123,No.7,pp.729-35. [36] Lunenfeld,B.,2008"An Aging World – demographics and Challenges,"Gynecological Endocrinology,2008, Vol.24,No.1,pp.1-3. [37] Lloyd-Sherlock,P.,2000b,"Old Age and Poverty in Developing Countries:New Policy Challenges,"World Development,Vol.28,No.12, pp.2157-68. [38] Shrestha,L.,2000,"Population Aging In Developing Countries,"Health Affairs,Vol.19,No.3,pp.204-12. [39] Auerbach,A., Gokhale,J. and Kotlikoff,L.,1991,"Generational Accounts:A Meaningful Alternative to Deficit Accounting,"in"Tax Policy and the Economy,"edited by Bradford,D.,Vol.5,pp.55-110. Cambridge:MIT Pr- Ess. [40] Schieber,S., and Worldwide,W.,2001,"The Impact of Aging Populations on Private Pension Funds," Pres- entation at the International Pension Seminar, Brighton,UK.,Vol.6.,July. [41] Weil,H.,2012,"On the dynamics of the age structure, dependency,and consumption,"Journal of Population Economics,Vol.25,No.3, pp.1019-43. [42] Jimeno,J., Rojas.J, and Puente,S.,2008,"Modelling the Impact of Aging on Social Security Expenditures," Economic Modelling,Vol.25,No.2,pp.201-24. [43] Giannakouris,K.,2008,"Ageing Characterises the Demographic Perspectives of the European Societies," Working Paper,No.72,Luxembourg:Eurostat Statistics in focus. [44] 周渭兵，2004：《未来五十年我国社会抚养比预测及其研究》，《统计研究》第11期，第35-8页。 [45] Hu,N., andYang,Y.,2012,"The Real Old-Age Dependency Ratio and the Inadequacy of Public Pension Fi- nance in China,"Population Ageing,Vol.5,No.3,pp.193–209. [46] James,E.,2002,"How Can China Solve Its Old-Age Security Problem? The Interaction between Pension, State Enterprise and Fnancial Market Reform,"Journal Of Pensions Economics & Finance,Vol.1,No.1,pp.53-75. [47] Barr,N.,2008,"Pension Reform in OECD Countries:Shifting Tectonic Plates,"Discussion Paper,June,At- hens:Conference on Welfare and Pension Reform in Europe:Learning from each other? [48] Holmqvist,G.,2011,"Fertility impact of high-coverage public pensions in sub-Saharan Africa,"Global Social Policy,Vol. 11,No.2-3,pp.152-74. [49] Whiteford,P.,2003, "From Enterprise Protection to Social Protection Pension Reform in China Global Social Policy,"Global Social Policy,Vol.3,No.1,pp.45-77. [50] Willmore, L.,2004,"Universal Pensions in Low Income Countries,"Discussion Paper,No.IPD-01-05,Octo- ber,NewYork:Initiative for Policy Dialogue, Pensions and Social Insurance Section. [51] Whiteford,P. and Whitehouse,E.,2006, "Pension challenges and pension reforms in OECD countries,"Oxf- ord review of economic policy,Vol.22,No.1,pp.78-94. [52] Fehr,H.,2000,"Pension Reform during the Demographic Transition,"The Scandinavian Journal of Econo- mics,Vol.102,NO.3,pp.419-43. [53] Disney,R.,2004,"Are Contributions to Public Pension Programmes a Tax on Employment?"Economic Po- licy,Vol.19, No.39,pp.267–311. [54] Sin.Y.,2005, "Pension Liabilities and Reform Options for Old Age Insurance,"Working Paper,No.2005-1, January,Washington DC:World Bank. [55] Thøgersen,Ø.,1998,"A note on intergenerational risk sharing and the design of pay-as-you-go pension Pr- ograms,"Journal of Population Economics,Vol.11, No.3, pp.373-78. [56] Kifmann,M. and Schindler,D.,2000,"Smoothing the Implicit Tax Rate in a Pay-as-you-go Pension Syste- m,"Public Finance Analysis,Vol.57,No.3, pp.261-83. [57] Borsch-Supan,A., Ludwig,A. and Winter,J.,2006,"Ageing, Pension Reform and Capital Flows:A Multi-C- ountry Simulation Model,"Economica,Vol.73,No.292, pp.625-58. [58] Scruggs,L.,2006,"The generosity of social insurance, 1971–2002," Oxford Review of Economic Policy, V- ol.22,No.3,pp.349-64. [59] Samuelson,P.,1958,"An Exact Consumption-Loan Model of Interest with or without the Social Contriva- nce of Money,"Journal of Political Economy,Vol.66,No.6,pp.467-82. [60] Aaron,H.,1966,"The Social Insurance Paradox,"The Canadian Journal of Economics and Political Science, Vol. 32, No.3, pp.371-74. [61] Auerbach,A. and Lee,R.,2009,"Notional defined contribution pension systems in a stochastic context: De- sign and stability,"in "Social Security Policy in a Changing Environment,"edited by Brown,J.,et al.,pp.43-68,Illino- is:University of Chicago Press. [62] Munnell,A.,2003,"The Declining Role of Social Security,"Discussion Paper,No.JTF6,February, Boston:C- ollege CenMulvey,J., Pauling,B. and Simsek,K.,2003,"A stochastic network approach for integrating pension and corp-orate financial planning,"in"Innovations in financial and economic networks,"pp.67-83,Edward Elgar Publis- hing.ter for Retirement Research. [63] Bottazzi,R., Jappelli,T., and Padula,M.,2006,"Retirement expectations, pension reforms, and their impact on private wealth accumulation,"Journal of Public Economics, Vol.90,No.12,pp.2187-212. [64] 杨再贵，2008：《企业职工基本养老保险、养老金替代率和人口增长率》，《统计研究》第5期，第38-42页。 [65] Zhao,Y, and Xu,J.,2001,"China's urban pension system: Reforms and problems,"Cato Joumal,Vol.21,No. 3,pp.395-414. [66] 彭浩然、呙玉红，2009：《我国基本养老保险的地区差距研究》，《经济管理》第8期，第169-74页。 [67] Bütler,M.,1999, "Anticipation effects of looming public-pension reforms,"Discussion Paper,Vol.50,pp. 119-59,Rochester:Carnegie-Rochester Conference Series on Public Policy,North-Holland Press. [68] Sayan,S.and Kiraci,A.,2001,"Parametric pension reform with higher retirement ages: A computational in- vestigation of alternatives for a pay-as-you-go-based pension system,"Journal of Economic Dynamics & Control, Vol.25, No.6–7, pp.951–66. [69] Mulvey,J., Pauling,B. and Simsek,K.,2003,"A stochastic network approach for integrating pension and co- rporate financial planning," in "Innovations in financial and economic networks,"pp.67-83,Edward Elgar Publishing. [70] Landsman,W.,1986,"An empirical investigation of pension fund property rights,"The Accounting Review, Vol.61,No.4,pp.662-91. [71] Robalino,D. and Bogomolova,T.,2006,"lmplicit Pension Debt in the Middle-East and North Africa: Magn- itude and Fiscal lmplications,"Working Paper,No.46,June,Washington DC:Middle East and North Africa Series,W- orld Bank. [72] Giang,T.,2006,"Pension Liabilities and Generational Relations: The Case of Vietnam,"Working Paper,Ma- rch,Oxford: Oxford Institute of Ageing. [73] Bravo,J.,2001,"The Chilean pension system: A review of some remaining difficulties after 20 years of reform,"Discussion Paper,March,Tokyo:International Seminar on Pensions,Hitotsubashi University. [74] Chen,V.,2004, "A Macro Analysis of China Pension Pooling System: Incentive Issues and Financial Probl- em,"Discussion Paper,No.195,February,Tokyo:Institute of Economic Research Holded by Center for Intergenerati- onal Studies, Hitotsubashi University. [75] Blackburn,R.,2004,"How to Rescue a Failing Pension Regime: the British Case,"New Political Economy, Vol.9,No.4, pp.559-79. [76] Ahn,N., Alonso,-Meseguer,J. and García,J.,2005,"A projection of the Spanish pension system under demo- ographic uncertainty,"Working Paper,No.20,October,Documento de Trabajo. [77] Brooks,S.,2007,"Globalization and Pension Reform in Latin America,"Latin American Politics and Socie- ty, Vol.49,No.4, pp.31-62. [78] James,E.,1995,"Averting the Old Age Crisis,"Ageing International,Vol.22,No.2,pp.15-22. [79] Werding,M.,2006,"Implicit pension debt and the role of public pensions for human capital accumulation: an assessment for Germany,"Discussion Paper,January,Munich:IFO Institute for Economic Research & CESifo. [80] Diamond,P.,1965,"National Debt in a Neoclassical Growth Model,"The American Economic Review,Vol. 55,No.5,pp.1126-50. [81] Phelps,E.,1961,"The golden rule of accumulation: a fable for growthmen,"The American Economic Revie- w, Vol.51,No.4,pp.638-43. [82] Wigger, B,1999,"Pay-as-you-go financed public pensions in a model of endogenous growth and fertility," Journal of Population Economics,Vol.12,No.4,pp.625-40. [83] 袁志刚、李珍珍、封进，2009：《城市化进程中基本养老保险制度的保障水平研究》，《南开经济研究》第4期，第3-14页。 [84] Barrientos,A.,1993,"Pension reform and economic development in Chile,"Development Policy Review,V- ol.11,No.1,pp.91-108. [85] Acuña,R., and Iglesias,A.,2001,"Chile’s pension reform after 20 years,"Working Paper,No.0129,Washing- ton DC:Social Protection Series,World Bank. [86] Damill,M., and Frenkel,R.,2003,"Argentina: macroeconomic performance and crisis,"Working Paper,Jun- e,Barcelona:the Macroeconomic Policy Task Force of the International Policy Dialogue. [87] Bonin,H.,2009,"15 years of pension reform in Germany: old successes and new threats,"The Geneva Pap- ers on Risk and Insurance-Issues and Practice,Vol.34,No.4,pp.548-60. [88] Davis,E., and Hu,Y.,2004,"Is there a link between pension-fund assets and economic growth?A cross-cou- ntry study,"Working Paper,No.04-23,London:Economics and Finance Working papers, Brunel University. [89] Samwick,A.,2000,"Is Pension Reform Conducive to Higher Saving?"Review of Economics and Statistics, Vol.82,No.2,pp.264-72. [90] Rauh,J.,2006,"Investment and Financing Constraints: Evidence from the Funding of Corporate Pension Plans," The Journal of Finance,Vol.61,No.1,pp.33-71. [91] Walker,E., and Lefort,F.,2000,"Pension Reform and Capital Markets: Are There Any (Hard) Links," Revi- sta ABANTE,Vol.5,No.2,pp.77-149. [92] Baker,M. and Benjamin,D.,1999,"Early Retirement Provisions and the Labor Force Behavior of Older Me- n: Canada," Journal of Labor Economics,Vol.17,No.4,pp.724-56. [93] Martín,A.,2001,"Endogenous Retirement and Public Pension System Reform in Spain," Working Paper,N- o.0135,Madrid:Economics Series 03,Universidad Carlos III de Madrid. [94] Posel,D., Fairburn,J. and Lund,F.,2006,"Labour Migration and Households: A Reconsideration of the Eff- ects of the Social Pension on Labour Supply in South Africa." Economic modelling,Vol.23,No.5, pp.836-53. [95] Razin,Assaf, and Sadka,E.,1999,"Migration and pension with international capital mobility,"Journal of Pu- blic Economics,Vol.74,No.1,pp.141-50. [96] Corneo,G. and Marquardt,M.,2000,"Public Pensions, Unemployment Insurance, and Growth," Journal of Public Economics,Vol.75,No.2,pp.293-311. [97] Edwards,S, and Edwards,A.,2002,"Social Security Privatization Reform and Labor Markets: The Case of Chile,"Working Paper,No.8924, Massachu:National Bureau of Economic Research. [98] Petras,J. and Polychroniou,C.,1998,"Clinton and volunteerism: The Poverty of American Social Policy at the End of the Century,"New Political Science,Vol.20,No.2,pp.223-31. [99] Guo,Y.,2010,"Consideration on the direction of social security reform in China," Financial Theory and En- gineering (ICFTE), International Conference In June.,IEEE,No.11404174. [100] Flachaire,E. and Nunez,O.,2007,"Estimation of the Income Distribution and Detection of Subpopulations: An Explanatory Model,"Computational statistics & data analysis,Vol.51,No.7,pp.3368-80. [101] Pittau,M., Massari,R. and Zelli,R.,2012,"Hierarchical Modelling of Disparities in Preferences for Redist- ribution," Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, Vo.75, No.4, pp.556–84. [102] Hu,S.,1982,"Social Security, Majority-Voting Equilibrium and Dynamic Efficiency,"International Econo- mic Review,Vol.23,No.2,pp.269-87. [103] Sjoblom,K.,1985,"Voting for Social Security,"Public Choice,Vol.45,No.3,pp.225-40. [104] Galasso,V. and Profeta,P.,2002,"The political economy of social security: a survey,"European Journal of Political Economy, Vol.18,No.1, pp.1-29. [105] Breyer,F.,1994,"Voting on Social Security When Labor Supply is Endogenous,"Economics & Politics,V- ol.6,No.2,pp.119-30. [106] Casamatta,G., Cremer,H., and Pestieau,P.,2005,"Voting on pensions with endogenous retirement age,"Int- ernational Tax and Public Finance,Vol.12,No.1,pp.7-28.