Life is now! Time Preferences and Crime: Aggregate Evidence from the Italian Regions

Beraldo, Sergio and Caruso, Raul and Turati, Gilberto (2013): Life is now! Time Preferences and Crime: Aggregate Evidence from the Italian Regions.

Abstract

This paper tests the relationship between time preferences and crime rates as posited by Davis (1988), whose theoretical analysis suggests that individuals’ attitude towards the future significantly affects their propensity to commit crime. Our empirical analysis is based on a panel of Italian regions from 2003 to 2007. Various proxies for time preferences are considered: the consumer credit share out of the total amount of loans to households, the share of obese individuals out of the total population, the rate of marriages out of the total population, and the teenage pregnancy rate. Controlling for a great number of factors suggested by the scientific literature on the determinants of crime, adding to the model also time and regional fixed effects, and clustering standard errors to account for both serial and panel correlations, our results basically provide support to the ‘Davis’ hypothesis’ for property crimes, while for violent crimes there seems to be less evidence that these are higher where people discount the future more heavily. Moreover, there is no evidence of a reverse effect from crime to time preferences at this aggregate level.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: Time Preferences, Property Crime, Violent Crime, Italian Regions.
• Subjects: D - Microeconomics > D9 - Intertemporal Choice > D99 - Other; K - Law and Economics > K4 - Legal Procedure, the Legal System, and Illegal Behavior > K42 - Illegal Behavior and the Enforcement of Law; Z - Other Special Topics > Z1 - Cultural Economics ; Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology > Z13 - Economic Sociology ; Economic Anthropology ; Social and Economic Stratification

References

Akçomak I. S., ter Weel B., 2012. The impact of social capital on crime: Evidence from the Netherlands. Regional Science and Urban Economics. 42, 323-340.

Akerlof G. A., 1998. Men Without Children. Economic Journal. 108, 287-309.

Allen R.C., 1996. Socioeconomic conditions and Property Crime: A comprehensive Review and Test of the Professional literature. American Journal of Economics and Sociology. 55, 293-308.

Andreoni J., Sprenger C., 2012. Risk Preferences are Not Time Preferences. American Economic Review. 102, 3357-3376.

Augé M., 2008. Où est passé l’avenir?. Editions du Panama.

Becker G., 1968. Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of Political Economy. 78, 169-217.

Benson B.L., Kim I., Rasmussen D.W., 1994a. Estimating deterrence effects: a public choice perspective on the economics of crime literature. Southern Economic Journal. 61.

Benson B.L., Kim I. , Rasmussen D.W., 1994b. Deterrence and Public Policy: Trade Offs in the Allocation of Police Resources. International Review of Law and Economics. 18, 77-100.

Beraldo S., Turati G., 2011. The relationship between competition and trust. An essay in an historical and theoretical perspective, in Sacconi L. and Degli Antoni G. (eds), Social capital, Corporate social responsibility, Economic Behaviour and Performance, Palgrave MacMillan.

Bianchi M., Buonanno P., Pinotti P., 2012. Do immigrants cause crime? Journal of the European Economic Association. 10, 1318-1347.

Blundell R., Stoker T. L., 2005. Heterogeneity and aggregation. Journal of Economic Literature. 43, 347-391.

Borghans L., Duckworth A. L., Heckman J. J. and Weel B., 2008. The Economics and Psychology of Personal Traits. Journal of Human Resources. 18, 972-1059.

Borghans L. and Golsteyn B. H. H., 2006. Time discounting and the Body Mass Index Evidence from the Netherlands. Economics and Human Biology. 4, 39-61.

Brandolini, A., L. Cannari, G. D’Alessio, I. Faiella, 2004. Household Wealth Distribution in Italy in the 1990s, Bank of Italy, Discussion Paper No. 530.

Britt C. L., 1997. Reconsidering the unemployment and crime relationship: Variation by age group and historical period. Journal of Quantitative Criminology. 13, 405-428.

Buonanno P., Montolio D., Vanin P., 2009. Does social capital reduce crime? Journal of Law and Economics. 52, 145-170.

Cameron A. C., Gelbach J. B., Miller D. L., 2011. Robust Inference with Multiway Clustering. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics. 29, 238-249.

Cameron S., 1988. The Economics of Crime Deterrence: A Survey of Theory and Evidence. Kyklos. 41, 472-477.

Cantor D., Land K.C., 1985. Unemployment and Crime Rates in the post world War II United States: A theoretical and empirical analysis. American Sociological Review. 50, 317-332.

Carmichael F., Ward R., 2001, Male Unemployment and crime in England and Wales. Economics Letters, 73, 111-115.

Caruso R., Schneider F., (2011), The Socio-Economic determinants of terrorism and political violence in Western Europe (1994-2007). European Journal of Political Economy. 27, s37-s49.

Caruso R., 2011. Crime and Sport Participation, Evidence from Italian regions over the period 1997-2003. Journal of Socio-Economics. 40 , 455-463.

Caruso R., 2009. Spesa Pubblica e Criminalità organizzata in Italia, evidenza empirica su dati Panel nel periodo 1997- 2003. Economia e Lavoro. 43, 71-88.

Cotte Poveda A., 2011, Socio-Economic Development and Violence: An Empirical Application for Seven Metropolitan Areas in Colombia, Peace Economics, Peace Science and Public Policy, 17, 1-23.

Chao L. W., Szreck H., Pereira N. S., Pauly M.V., 2009. Time preferences and its relationship with age, health and survival probability. Judgement and Decision Making. 4, 1-19.

Chesson H.W., Leichliter J.S., Zimet G.D., Rosenthal S.L., Bernstein D.I., Fife K.H., 2006. Discount rates and risky sexual behaviors among teenagers and young adults. Journal of Risk and Uncertainty. 32, 217-230.

Chiricos T.G., 1987. Rates of Crime and Unemployment: An Analysis of Aggregate Research Evidence. Social Problems. 34, 187 – 212.

Cloninger, D. O., Sartorius L.C., 1979. Crime Rates, Clearance Rates and Enforcement Effort. American Journal of Economics and Sociology. 38 , 399-402.

Compton J. 2009. Why do smokers divorce? Time preference and marital stability. Department of Economics, University of Manitoba, mimeo.

Corman, H., Joyce T., Lovitch N., 1987. Crime, Deterrence and the Business Cycle in New York City: A VAR Approach. Review of Economics and Statistics. 69, 695-700.

Daly M., Delaney L., Harmon C. P., 2009. Psychological and biological foundations of time preference. Journal of the European Economic Association. 7, 659-669.

Davis M.L., 1988. Time and punishment: an intertemporal model of crime. Journal of Political Economy. 96, 383-390.

Dills A.K., Miron J.A., Summers G., 2008. What do economists know about crime. NBER working paper 13759.

Dohmen T., Falk A., Huffman D., Sunde U., 2010. Are risk aversion and impatience related to cognitive ability? American Economic Review. 100,1238-1260.

Durlauf S., Navarro S., Rivers D. A., 2010. Understanding aggregate crime regressions. Journal of Econometrics. 158, 306-317.

Durlauf S., Navarro S., Rivers D. A., 2008. On the Interpretation of Aggregate Crime Regressions. In A. Goldberger and R. Rosenfeld (eds.), Understanding Crime Trends. The National Academy of Sciencies Press: Washington, D.C.

Entorf H., Spengler H., 2000. Socioeconomic and Demographic Factors of Crime in Germany: Evidence From Panel Data of the German States. International Review of Law and Economics. 20, 75–106.

Ehrlich I., 1973. Participation in Illegitimate Activities: A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation. Journal of Political Economy. 81, 521-565.

Ehrlich I., 1996. Crime, Punishment and the Market for Offenses, The Journal of Economic Perspectives. 10, 43-67.

Frederick S., Loewenstein G., O’Donoghue T., 2002. Time discounting and time preference: A critical review. Journal of Economic Literature. 40 , 351-401.

Freeman, R., 1999. The Economics of Crime. In O. Ashenfelter and D. Card (eds.), Handbook of Labour Economics. 3C, 3529–3571.

Fougere D., Kramarz F., Pouget J., 2009. Youth Unemployment and Crime in France. Journal of European Economic Association. 7, 909-938.

Glaeser E. L., Sacerdote B., Sheinkman J. A., 1996. Crime and social interactions. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 111, 507-548.

Grogger, J., 1998. Market Wages and Youth Crime. Journal of Labor Economics. 16, 756-791.

Groot W., van den Brink H.M., 2010. The effects of education on crime. Applied Economics. 42, 279- 289.

Gould, E. D., Weinberg, B. A., Mustard, D. B., 2002. Crime Rates and Local Labor Market Opportunities in the United States: 1977- 1997. Review of Economics and Statistics. 84, 45-61.

ISTAT, 2007, Violenza e maltrattamenti contro le donne dentro e fuori la famiglia, Rome.

Kalist D.E., Siahaan F., 2013, The association of obesity with the likelihood of arrest for young adults, Economics and Human Biology, 11, pp. 8-17.

Karadole C., 2012, Femicidio: la forma più estrema di violenza contro le donne, Rivista di Criminologia, Vittimologia e Sicurezza, 6, 16-38.

Lahav E., Benzion U., Shavit T., 2011. The effect of military service on soldiers’ time preference. Evidence from Israel. Judgement and Decision Making. 6, 130-138.

Lederman D., N. Loayza, Menéndez A.M., 2002. Violent Crime: Does Social Capital Matter? Economic Development and Cultural Change. 50, 509–539.

Levitt S. D., 2001. Alternative strategies for identifying the link between unemployment and crime. Journal of Quantitative Criminology. 17, 377-390.

Lochner L., Moretti E., 2004. The Effect of Education on Crime: Evidence from Prison Inmates, Arrests, and Self-Reports. American Economic Review, 94, 155-189.

Loureiro P.R.A., Cardoso de Mendonca M.J., Silva Moreira T.B., Sachsida A., 2009. Crime, economic conditions, social interactions and family heritage. International Review of law and Economics. 29, 202-209.

Magri S., Pico R., Rampazzi C., 2011. Which households use consumer credit in Europe? Questioni di Economia e Finanza n. 100, Roma: Banca d’Italia.

Marselli R., 1997. Estimating a Crime Equation in the Presence of Organized Crime: Evidence from Italy. International Review of Law and Economics. 17, 89-113.

Marvell T.B., Carlisle E.M. Jr (1991), Age Structure and Crime Rates, the Conflicting Evidence, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 7

McCall P.L., Land K.C., Brooks Dollar C., Parker K.F., (2013), The Age Structure-Crime Rate Relationship: Solving a Long-Standing Puzzle, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, vol. 29, 167-190

Mehlum H., Miguel E., Torvik R., 2006, Poverty and Crime in 19th century Germany, Journal of Urban Economics, 59, 370-388.

Meier S., Sprenger C. D., 2011a. Time Discounting Predicts Creditworthiness. Psychological Science. 20, 1-3.

Meier S., Sprenger C. D., 2011b. Present-biased Preferences and Credit Card Borrowing. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. 2, 193-210.

Miron J.A., 2001. Violence, Guns and Drugs, A Cross-country analysis. Journal of Law and Economics. 44, 615-633.

Neumayer E., 2005. Inequality and Violent Crime: Evidence from Data, on robbery and violent theft. Journal of Peace Research. 42, 101-112.

Phillips J.A. (2006), The Relationship between Age Structure and Homicide Rates in the United States, 1970-1999, Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 43, 230-260.

Phillips L., Votey H.L. jr., 1981. The Economics of Crime Control, Sage, Beverly Hills.

Price G. N., 2009. Obesity and crime: Is there a relationship? Economics Letters. 103, 149-152.

Reilly B., Witt R., 1996. Crime, Deterrence, and Unemployment in England and Wales: An Empirical Analysis. Bullettin of Economic Research. 48, 137-159.

Rosenfeld, R., Messner S.F., Baumer E.P., 2001. Social Capital and Homicide. Social Forces. 80, 283-310.

Saridakis, G., 2004. Violent Crime in the United States of America: A Time-Series Analysis Between 1960-2000. European Journal of Law and Economics. 18, 203-221.

Shavit T., Lahav E., Benzion U., (2013), Factors affecting soldiers’ time preference: a Field study in Israel, Journal of Socio-Economics, vol. 44, 75-84.

Soares R., 2004. Development, Crime and Punishment: accounting for the international differences in crime rates. Journal of Development Economics. 73, 155-184. Scorcu A.E., Cellini R., 1998. Economic Activity in the Long Run: An Empirical Investigation on Aggregate Data From Italy, 1951-1994. International Review of Law And Economics. 18, 279-292.

Sjoquist, D. L., 1973. Property Crime and Economic Behavior: Some Empirical Results. American Economic Review. 63, 439-446.

Steffensmeier D.J., Allan E.A., Harer M.D., Streifel C., (1989), Age and the Distribution of Crime, American Journal of Sociology, 94, 803-831.

Stevenson B., Wolfers J., 2007. Marriage and divorce: Changes and their driving forces. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 21, 27-52.

Yamane S., Yoneda H., Takahashi T., Kamijo Y., Komori Y., Hiruma F., Tsutsui Y., 2013, Smokers, smoking deprivation, and time discounting, The Journal of Socio-Economics, 45, 47-56.

Zenou Y., 2003. The spatial aspects of crime. Journal of the European Economic Association. 1, 459-467.