The `Pile-up Problem' in Trend-Cycle Decomposition of Real GDP: Classical and Bayesian Perspectives

Kim, Chang-Jin and Kim, Jaeho (2013): The `Pile-up Problem' in Trend-Cycle Decomposition of Real GDP: Classical and Bayesian Perspectives.

Abstract

In the case of a flat prior, a conventional wisdom is that Bayesian inference may not be very different from classical inference, as the likelihood dominates the posterior density. This paper shows that there are cases in which this conventional wisdom does not apply. An ARMA model of real GDP growth estimated by Perron and Wada (2009) is an example. While their maximum likelihood estimation of the model implies that real GDP may be a trend stationary process, Bayesian estimation of the same model implies that most of the variations in real GDP can be explained by the stochastic trend component, as in Nelson and Plosser (1982) and Morley et al. (2003). We show such dramatically different results stem from the differences in how the nuisance parameters are handled between the two approaches, especially when the parameter estimate of interest is dependent upon the estimates of the nuisance parameters for small samples.

For the maximum likelihood approach, as the number of the nuisance parameters increases, we have higher probability that the moving-average root may be estimated to be one even when its true value is less than one, spuriously indicating that the data is `over-differenced.' However, the Bayesian approach is relatively free from this pile-up problem, as the posterior distribution is not dependent upon the nuisance parameters.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: pile-up problem, ARMA model, Unobserved-Components Model, Profile likelihood, marginal powterior density, Trend-Cycle decomposition
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C11 - Bayesian Analysis: General; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E3 - Prices, Business Fluctuations, and Cycles > E32 - Business Fluctuations ; Cycles

References

Anderson, T.W. and A., Takemura, 1986, ``Why do noninvertible estimated moving averages occur?'' Journal of Time Series Analysis 7, 235-54.

Ansley, Craig F., and Paul Newbold, 1980, ``Finite Sample Properties of Estimators for Autoregressive Moving Average Models,'' Journal of Econometrics XIII, 1959-83.

Berger, J.O, B. Liseo, and R.L. Wolpert, 1999, ``Integrated Likelihood Methods for Eliminating Nuisance Parameters,'' Statistical Science 1999, Vol. 14, No. 1, 1-28.

Beveridge, S., and C. R. Nelson, 1981, ``A New Approach to Decomposition of Economic Time Series into Permanent and Transitory Components with Particular Attention to Measurement of the 'Business Cycle','' Journal of Monetary Economics 7, 151-174.

Campbell, John Y. and Gregory N. Mankiw, 1987, ``Are output fluctuations transitory?,'' Quarterly Journal of Economics 102, 857-880.

Cheung, Y.N., Chinn, M., 1997, ``Further Investigation of the Uncertain Unit Root in U.S. GDP,'' Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 15, 68-73.

Chib, S., 1998, ``Estimation and comparison of multiple change-point models,'' Journal of Econometrics, 86, 221-241.

Chib, S., and Edward Greenberg, 1994, ``Bayes Inference in Regression Models with ARMA(p,q) Errors,'' Journal of Econometrics 64, 183-206.

Christiano, L.J., 1992, ``Searching for breaks in GNP,'' Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 10, 237-250.

Clark, P. K., 1987, ``The Cyclical Component of U.S. Economic Activity,'' Quarterly Journal of Economics 102, 798-814.

Davis R. A., Chen MC, and Dunsmuir, W.T.M., 1995, ``Inference for MA(1) Processes with a Root on or near the Unit Circle,'' Probability and Mathematical Statistics 15, 227-242.

Davidson, J.E.H., 1981, ``Problems with the Estimation of Moving Average Processes,'' Journal of Econometrics 16, 295-310.

DeJong, David N., John C. Nankervis, N. E. Savin and Charles H. Whiteman, 1992, ``Integration Versus Trend Stationary in Time Series,'' Econometrica, Vol. 60, No. 2, 423-433.

DeJong and Whiteman, 1991, ``Reconsidering ‘Trends and random walks in macroeconomic time series’'' Journal of Monetary Economics 28, 221-254.

DeJong, D. N. and C. H. Whiteman, 1993, ``Estimating Moving Average Parameters: Classical Pile-ups and Bayesian Posteriors,'' Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 64, 183-206.

Diebold, Francis X., and Abdelhak S. Senhadji, 1996 ``The Uncertain Unit Root in Real GNP: Comment,'' American Economic Review 86, 1291-98.

Gospodinov, N., 2002, ``Bootstrap-Based Inferences in Models With a Nearly Noninvertible Moving Average Component,'' Journal of Business \& Economic Statistics, Vol. 20, No. 2, 254-268.

Harvey, A. C., 1985, ``Trends and Cycles in Macroeconomic Time Series,'' Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 3, 216-227.

Kang, K. M., 1975, ``A Comparison of Estimators for Moving Average Processes,'' Unpublished Paper, Australian Bureau of Statistics.

Kim, Chang-Jin, and Nelson, C. R., 1999, ``Has the U.S. Economy Become more Stable? A Bayesian Approach based on a Markov-Switching Model of the Business Cycle,'' The Review of Economics and Statistics 81,608-616.

Kim, Chang-Jin and Jaeho Kim, 2013, ``Bayesian Inference of Regime-Switching ARMA Models with Absorbing States: Dynamics of Ex-Ante Real Interest Rate Under Structural Breaks,'' Working Paper, University of Washington.

McConnell, M. and Perez Quiros, G., 2000, ``Output Fluctuations in the United States: What has Changed Since the Early 1980s?'' American Economic Review 90, 1464-1476.

Morley, James C., Charles R. Nelson, Eric Zivot, 2003, ``Why are the Beveridge-Nelson and Unobserved-Components Decompositions of GDP so Different?'' The Review of Economics and Statistics 85, 235-243.

Murray, C. J. and C. R. Nelson, 2000, ``The Uncertain Trend in U.S. GDP,'' Journal of Monetary Economics 46, 79-95.

Murray, C., and C. R. Nelson, 2002, ``The Great Depression and Output Persistence,'' Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 34, 1090-1098.

Nelson, C. R., and Plosser, C. I., 1982, ``Trends and Random Walks in Macroeconomic Time Series: Some Evidence and Implications,'' Journal of Monetary Economics 10, 139-162.

Newbold, Paul, Stephen Leybourne, and Mark E. Wohar, 2001, ``Trend Stationarity, Difference Stationarity, or Neither: Further Diagnostic Tests with an Application to U.S. Real GNP, 1875-1993,'' Journal of Economics and Business 53, 85-102.

Perron, P., 1989, ``The great crash, the oil price shock, and the unit root hypothesis,'' Econometrica 57, 1361-1401.

Perron, P., Wada, T., 2009, Let's Take a Break: Trends and Cycles in US Real GDP, Journal of Monetary Economics 56(6), 749-765.

Pierce, D., 1971, ``Least Squares Estimation in the Regression Model with Autoregressive Moving Average Errors,'' Biometrika, Vol. 58, No. 2, 299-312

Plosser, C. I., and G. W. Schwert, 1977, ``Estimation of a Non-Invertible Moving Average Process: The Case of Over-differencing,'' Journal of Econometrics, 6, 199-224.

Sargan, JD, Bhargava, A., 1983, ``Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Regression Models with First-Order Moving Average Errors when the Root Lies on the Unit Circle,'' Econometrica 51, 799-820.

Shephard, N. G., and A. C. Harvey, 1990, ``On the Probability of Estimating a Deterministic Component in the Local Level Model,'' Journal of Time Series Analysis, 11, 339-347.

Shephard, Neil, 1993, ``Maximum Likelihood Estimation of Regression Models with Stochastic Trend Components,'' Journal of American Statistical Association 88, 590-595.

Sims, C. A., and Uhlig, H., 1991, ``Understanding Unit Rooters: A Helicopter Tour,'' Econometrica Vol. 5, No. 9, 1591-1600.

Smith, Richard and J.C. Naylor, 1987, ``A Comparison of Maximum Likelihood and Bayesian Estimators for the Three-Parameter Weibull Distribution,'' Journal of the Royal Statistical Society Series C (Applied Statistics) 36, No. 3, 358-369.

Stock, J. H., 1994, ``Unit Roots, Structural Breaks, and Trends,'' Chapter 46 of Handbook of Econometrics, Volume IV, Edited by R.F. Engle and D.L. McFadden, Elsevier Science.

Stock, J. H., and Watson, M. W., 1998, ``Median Unbiased Estimation of Coefficient Variance in a Time-Varying Parameter Model,'' Journal of the American Statistical Association 93, 349-358.

Tanaka, K. and S. E. Satchell, 1989, ``Asymptotic Properties of the Maximum Likelihood and Non-linear Least Squares Estimator for Noninvertible Moving Average Models,'' Econometric Theory 5, 333-353.

Zivot, E., and Andrews, D.W.K., 1992, ``Further Evidence on the Great Crash, the Oil-Price Shock and the Unit Root Hypothesis,'' Journal of Business and Economic Statistics 10, 251-287.