Effects of innovation on employment in low-income countries: A mixed-method systematic review

Ugur, Mehmet and Mitra, Arup (2014): Effects of innovation on employment in low-income countries: A mixed-method systematic review.

Abstract

We conduct a meta-analysis of the effect-size estimates from 9 empirical studies and a narrative synthesis of the qualitative evidence from 53 qualitative studies on the relationship between innovation and employment in low-income countries (LICs). The meta-analysis reveals a positive but small effect, with evident bias in favour of skilled-labour employment. Both meta-analysis and narrative synthesis findings indicate that innovation’s effects on employment in LICs tend to be larger when: (i) the evidence is related to manufacturing as opposed to agriculture; (ii) the analysis is at the firm level as opposed to sector level; and (iii) the evidence relates to South Asian countries as opposed to other world regions. Further findings from the narrative synthesis of the qualitative evidence indicate that the positive effect of innovation on employment is likely to be augmented by strong forward and backward linkages; but the adverse effects are likely to be exacerbated by capital-intensity of imports and weaknesses in governance and labour-market institutions.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: innovation, employment, low-income countries, systematic reviews, meta-analysis
• Subjects: C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General; C - Mathematical and Quantitative Methods > C1 - Econometric and Statistical Methods and Methodology: General > C13 - Estimation: General; J - Labor and Demographic Economics > J2 - Demand and Supply of Labor > J23 - Labor Demand; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights; O - Economic Development, Innovation, Technological Change, and Growth > O3 - Innovation ; Research and Development ; Technological Change ; Intellectual Property Rights > O33 - Technological Change: Choices and Consequences ; Diffusion Processes

References

Primary studies included in the systematic review Agarwal, Bina (1981). Agricultural Mechanisation and Labour Use: A Disaggregated Approach. International Labour Review. 120: 115.

Agbesor, Nelson (1984). Employment Creation and Economic Growth through Technology Adaptation and/or Appropriate Choice of Technology: Case Studies of Manufacturing Companies in Nigeria (Criteria, Adjustment Policies). PhD Thesis: University of Miami.

Ahammed, Chowdhury and Robert Herdt (1983). Farm Mechanization in a Semiclosed Input-Output Model: The Philippines. American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 65: 516-525.

Ahammed C S and R W Herdt (1984). Measuring the Impact of Consumption Linkages on the Employment Effects of Mechanization in Philippine Rice Production. Journal of Development Studies. 20: 242-255.

Ahmed, Iftikhar (1987). Technology, Production Linkages and Women's Employment in South Asia. International Labour Review. 126: 21.

Ahmed, Iftikhar (1988). The Bio-Revolution in Agriculture: Key to Poverty Alleviation in the Third World?. International Labour Review. 127: 53.

Almeida, Rita (2010). Openness and Technological Innovation in East Asia: Have They Increased The Demand For Skills?. Asia-Pacific Development Journal. 17(1): 63-95.

Annable James Edward Jr (1971). The Transfer of Technology, Industrialization and The Urban Employment Problem in Low-Income Countries. PhD Thesis: Princeton University.

Aryee, George A (1984). Income Distribution, Technology and Employment in the Footwear Industry in Ghana. In: Appropriate Products, Employment and Technology: Case-Studies On Consumer Choice and Basic Needs in Developing Countries. : A World Employment Program Study. New York: St. Martin's Press; London: Macmillan Press, Pages 120-147.

Baer, Werner (1976). Technology, Employment and Development: Empirical Findings. World Development. 4: 121-130.

Baker, Kathleen and Sara Jewitt; (2007). Evaluating 35 Years of Green Revolution Technology in Villages of Bulandshahr District, Western Up, North India. Journal of Development Studies. 43: 312-339.

Barker, Randolph, William H. Meyers, C. M. Crisostomo, and B. Duff. (1972). Employment and Technological Change in Philippine Agriculture. International Labour Review, 106 (2-3): 111-139.

Berman, Eli and Stephen Machin (2000). Skill-biased Technology Transfer around the World, Oxford Review of Economic Policy, 16(3): 12-22.

Berman, Eli, Rohini Somanathan and Hong W. Tan (2005). Is Skill Biased Technological Change Here Yet? Evidence From India Manufacturing in The 1990s, World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 3761, November 2005.

Bhalla, Sheila (1989). Technological Change and Women Workers: Evidence from the Expansionary Phase in Haryana Agriculture. Economic and Political Weekly. 24: Ws67-Ws78.

Bhatia H C and A C Gangwar (1981). Impact of Improved Technology on Farm Employment. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations. 16: 623-629.

Braun, Sebastian (2008). Economic Integration, Process and Product Innovation, and Relative Skill Demand. Review of International Economics. 16: 864-873.

Edquist C, L Hommen and MD McKelvey (2001). Innovation and Employment: Process Versus Product Innovation, Cheltenham: Edward-Elgar.

Caballero, Ricardo J and Mohamad Hammour (1996). On the Timing and Efficiency of Creative Destruction. The Quarterly Journal of Economics. 111: 805-852.

Cepede, Michel (1972). The Green Revolution and Employment. International Labour Review. 105: 1.

Chand, Ramesh (1999). Emerging Crisis in Punjab Agriculture: Severity and Options for Future. Economic and Political Weekly. 34: A2-A10.

Choi, J-Y, E.S.H Yu and J.C. Jin (2002). Technical Progress, Urban Unemployment, Outputs, and Welfare under Variable Returns to Scale. International Review of Economics & Finance. 11: 411.

Chopra, Kusum (1974). Tractorisation and Changes in Factor Inputs: A Case Study of Punjab. Economic and Political Weekly. 9: A119-A127.

Clayton, Eric (1972). Mechanisation and Employment in East African Agriculture. International Labour Review. 105: 309.

Conte, Andrea and Marco Vivarelli (2011). Imported Skill-Biased Technological Change in Developing Countries. Developing Economies. 49: 36-65.

De Klerk, Michael (1984). Seasons that will never Return: The Impact of Farm Mechanization on Employment, Incomes and Population Distribution in The Western Transvaal. Journal of Southern African Studies. 11: 84-84-105.

Esfahani, Hadi Salehi; (1987). Technical Change, Employment, and Supply Response of Agriculture in the Nile Delta - A System-Wide Approach. Journal of Development Economics. 25: 167-167.

Fagerberg, Jan, Martin Srholec and Bart Verspagen (2010). The Role of Innovation in Development. Review of Economics and Institutions. 1: 1-29.

Garmany J W; (1978). Technology and Employment in Developing Countries. The Journal of Modern African Studies. 16: 549-564.

Inukai I (1970). Farm Mechanisation, Output and Labour Input: A Case Study in Thailand. International Labour Review. 101: 453-473.

Jacobsson, Staffan (1980). Technical Change Employment and Distribution in LDCs. Science and Public Policy. 7(2): 124-135.

James, Jeffrey (1993). New Technologies, Employment and Labour Markets in Developing Countries. Development and Change. 24: 405-405.

Kelley, Allen C, Jeffrey G. Williamson and Russel J. Cheetham (1972). Biased Technological Progress and Labour Force Growth in a Dualistic Economy. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 86: 426-447.

Lalwani, Mahesh (1992). Employment Gains of Technological Change - A Study of Haryana's Dairy Farmers. Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics. XlVII: 236-236.

Lundin, Nannan and Fredrik Sjöholm (2007). Technology Development and Job Creation in China. Lund University: Research Institute of Industrial Economics.

Mehta R, Mohanty S K; (1993). Demand for Labour in Manufacturing Sector: A Decomposition Analysis for Developing Countries. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations. 29(2).: 171-190.

Mitra, Arup (2009). Technology Import and Industrial Employment: Evidence from Developing Countries’, Labour, 23 (4), 697–718.

Moore, Winston and Roland Craigwell (2007). Technology Adoption and Its Impact on Output, Employment and Wages. Journal of Eastern Caribbean Studies. 23(2): 73-81.

Mureithi Leopold (1974). Demographic and Technological Variables in Kenya's Employment Scene. Eastern Africa Economic Review. 6: 27-43.

Nair K N; (1980). Technological Changes in Agriculture: Impact on Productivity and Employment. New Delhi: Vision Books.

Oberai A S; Ahmed Iftikhar (1981). Labour Use in Dynamic Agriculture: Evidence from Punjab. Economic and Political Weekly. 16: A2-A4.

Otsuka Et Al; (1994). Green Revolution and Labour Demand in Rice Farming: The Case of Central Luzon, 1966-90. Journal of Development Studies. 31: 82-82.

Pandit B, Siddhartan N (2008). MNEs, Product Differentiation, Skills and Employment: Lessons from the Indian Experience. In: Pandit B, Siddhartan N High Tech Industries Employment and Global Competitiveness. : , Pages 165-179.

Raju, V T (1976). The Impact of New Farm Technology on Human Labour Employment. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations. 11: 493-510.

Richards A, A Ramezani (1990 ). Mechanization, off-Farm Employment and Agriculture. In: Tully D Ed; Rain-fed Agriculture in West Asia and North Africa. Dordrecht: Kluwer, Pages 49 - 65.

Sabolo, Yves (1983). Trade Between Developing Countries, Technology Transfers and Employment. International Labour Review. 122: 593.

Saviotti, Pier Paolo and Andreas Pyka (2004). Economic Development, Variety and Employment. Revue Économique. 55: 1023-1049.

Sen A (2001). Employment, Technology and Development - Some Policy Issues (3rd Ed.). New Delhi and Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Sharma, R K (1974). Green Revolution & Farm Employment: An Analysis of Experience in the Punjab. Indian Journal of Industrial Relations. 9(3): 417-426 .

Sharma, Rita (1990). The New Economics of The Green Revolution: A Study of Income and Employment Diffusion in Rural Uttar Pradesh, India. PHD Thesis, Cornell University, May, 1990.

Sigurdson, Jon (1974). Technology and Employment in China. World Development. 2: 75-85.

Sison, Jerome F., Robert W. Herdt and Bart Duff (1985). The Effects of Small Farm Mechanization on Production, Income and Employment in Selected Rice-Growing Areas in The Philippines. Philippine Journal of Development. 12(1): 29-82.

Stewart, Frances (1974). Technology and Employment in LDCs. World Development. 2: 17-46.

Tuyen, Nguyen Nhat (1999). Transitional Economy, Technological Change and Women's Employment: The Case of Vietnam. Gender, Technology and Development. 3: 43-43.

Usha, P (1985). Mechanisation and Labour Utilisation: Leather Industry in Tamil Nadu. Economic and Political Weekly. 20: 167-172.

Wills, Ian (1972). Projections of Effects of Modern Inputs on Agricultural Income and Employment in A Community Development Block, Uttar Pradesh, India. American Journal of Agricultural Economics. 54: 452-460.

Zarkovic Milica (1987). The Effects of Economic Growth and Technological Innovation on the Agricultural Labour Force in India. Studies in Comparative International Development. 22: 103.

Other references cited in the review

Abreu, Maria, Henri L.F. de Groot and Raymond J.G.M. Florax (2005). A Meta-Analysis of Beta Convergence: The Legendary Two-Percent. Tinbergen Institute Discussion Papers, no. TI 2005-001/3.

Acemoglu, D. (1998). Why Do New Technologies Complement Skills? Directed Technical Change and Wage Inequality. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 113(4): 1055–1089.

Acemoglu, D. (2003). Patterns of Skill Premia. The Review of Economic Studies, 70(2): 199.230.

Aghion, P. and P. Howitt (1992). A Model of Growth through Creative Destruction”, Econometrica, 60: 323 - 351.

Bardhan, P. (1995). The Contributions of Endogenous Growth Theory to the Analysis of Development Problems: An Assessment, in Behrman, J. and T. N. Srinivasan (eds.), Handbook of Development Economics, Amsterdam: Elsevier Science.

Boyer, R. (1988). New Technologies and Employment in the 1980s: From Science and Technology to Macroeconomic Modelling, in J. A. Kregel, E. Matzner and A. Roncaglia (eds), Barriers to Full Employment, London: Macmillan, 233-68

Card, D. and A. B. Krueger (1995). Time-series Minimum-wage Studies: A Meta-analysis. American Economic Review 85: 238–243.

Chennells, L., & J. van Reenen (1999). Has technology hurt less skilled workers. The Institute for Fiscal Studies, Working Paper Series, (W99/27).

Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical Power Analysis in the Behavioural Sciences, 2nd ed., Hillsdale, NJ and London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

CRD – Centre for Reviews and Dissemination (2009). Systematic Reviews: CRD’s Guide for Undertaking Reviews in Health Care, York: York Publishing Services.

De Dominicis, Laura, Raymond J. G. M. Florax and Henri L. F. de Groot (2008). A Meta-Analysis on the Relationship between Income Inequality and Economic Growth’, Scottish Journal of Political Economy, 55(5): 654-682.

Enthorf, H. and W. Pohlmeier (1990). Employment, Innovation and Export Activity: Evidence from Firm-Level Data, in Florens, J.P., M. Ivaldi, J.J. Laffont and F. Laisney (eds.), Microeconometrics: Surveys and Applications, Oxford, 394-415.

Everitt, B.S., S. Landau and M. Leese (2001). Cluster Analysis (4th edition) London: Arnold.

Harden. A and J. Thomas (2005). Methodological Issues in Combining Diverse Study Types in Systematic Reviews, International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 8(3): 257-271.

Hirschman, Albert O (1969). "The Strategy of Economic Development," in Agarwal, A.N. and S. P. Singh (eds), Accelerating Investment in Developing Economies, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hox, Joop J. (2002). Multilevel Analysis: Techniques and Application, Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

ILO (2000). Current International Recommendations on Labour Statistics, Geneva: ILO.

Inter-Secretariat Working Group on National Accounts (1993). System of National Accounts 1993. Brussels/Luxembourg, New York, Paris, Washington, D.C., 1993.

JBI - Joanna Briggs Institute (2008). Reviewers’ Manual, The Joanna Briggs Institute, Adelaide: Australia.

Krolzig, H. M. and D. F. Hendry (2001). Computer Automation of General-to-Specific Model Selection Procedures. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control, 25(6): 831-866.

OECD (2005). Oslo Manual: Guidelines for Collecting and Interpreting Innovation Data, 3rd edition, Paris: OECD.

Pasinetti, Luigi L. (1981). Structural Change and Economic Growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Pianta, M. (2001). Innovation, Demand and Employment, in Petit, P. and Soete, L. (eds) (2001a). Technology and the Future of European Employment. Cheltenham, Elgar. 142-165

Pianta, M. (2004). Innovation and Employment, in Jan Fagerberg, David C. Mowery, and Richard R. Nelson (eds), The Oxford Handbook of Innovation, Oxford: Oxford University Press, ch. 21

Pissarides, C., and G. Vallanti (2004). Productivity Growth and Employment: Theory and Panel Estimates”, LSE Centre for Economic Performance, Discussion Paper.

Piva, Mariacristina (2003). The Impact of Technology Transfer on Employment and Income Distribution in Developing Countries: A Survey of Theoretical Models and Empirical Studies. ILO Policy Integration Department Working Papers, no. 15 (September).

Popay, Jennie, Helen Roberts, Amanda Sowden, Mark Petticrew, Lisa Arai, Mark Rodgers, and Nicky Britten (with Katrina Roen and Steven Duffy) (2006). Guidance on the Conduct of Narrative Synthesis in Systematic Reviews: A Product from the ESRC Methods Programme’, http://www.lancs.ac.uk/shm/research/nssr/research/dissemination/publications/NS_Synthesis_Guidance_v1.pdf

Romer, P. M. (1986). Increasing Returns and Long-run Growth”, Journal of Political Economy, 94(5): 1002-1037.

Schumpeter, J.A. (1934). Theory of Economic Development, Cambridge (Mass.), Harvard University Press (1st ed. 1911).

Simonetti, R. and Tancioni, M (2002). A Macroeconometric model for the analysis of the impact of technological change and trade on employment, Journal of Interdisciplinary Economics, 13: 185–221.

Singh, K. (1972). The Impact of New Agricultural Technology on Agricultural Wage Rates and Employment in The IADP Districts’, Indian Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1972

Stanley, T. D. (2006). Wheat from Chaff: Meta-Analysis as Quantitative Literature Review, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(3): 131–150.

Stanley, T.D. (2008). Meta-Regression Methods for Detecting and Estimating Empirical Effects in the Presence of Publication Selection, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 70(2): 103-127.

Stanley, T. D. (2010). Meta-Regression Models of Economics and Medical Research, in I. Shemilt, M. Mugford, Luke Vale, Kevin Marsh and Cam Donaldson (eds), Evidence-Based Decisions and Economics: Health Care, Social Welfare, Education and Criminal Justice (2nd ed.), Oxford: Wiley: 134 – 145.

Stanley, T.D. and H. Doucouliagos (2012). Meta-Regression Analysis in Economics and Business. London and New York: Routledge.

Stanley, T. D. & Stephen B. Jarrell (2005). Meta-Regression Analysis: A Quantitative Method of Literature Surveys, Journal of Economic Surveys, 19(3), 299-308.

Stanley, T. D. & H. Doucouliagos (2007). Identifying and Correcting Publication Selection Bias in the Efficiency-Wage Literature: Heckman Meta-Regression, Economics Series 2007_11, Deakin University, Faculty of Business and Law, School of Accounting, Economics and Finance.

Stanley, T. D., Stephen B. Jarrell and Hristos Doucouliagos (2009). Could it be Better to Discard 90% of the Data? A Statistical Paradox. Deakin University, Economics Working Papers No. SWP 2009/13.

Vivarelli, Marco (1995). The Economics of Technology and Employment: Theory and Empirical Evidence. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Vivarelli, Marco (2012). Innovation, employment and skills in advanced and developing countries: A survey of the literature, Forschungsinstitut zur Zukunft der Arbeit Discussion Paper series, No. 6291, http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:101:1-201203145587

Xu, B. and J. Wang (2000). Trade, FDI, and International Technology Diffusion, Journal of Economic Integration, 15(4), 585-601.