Money and Credit as Means of Payment: A New Monetarist Approach

Lotz, Sebastien and Zhang, Cathy (2015): Money and Credit as Means of Payment: A New Monetarist Approach.

Abstract

This paper studies the choice of payment instruments in a simple model where both money and credit can be used as means of payment. We endogenize the acceptability of credit by allowing retailers to invest in a costly record-keeping technology. Our framework captures the two-sided market interaction between consumers and retailers, leading to strategic complementarities that can generate multiple steady-state equilibria. In addition, limited commitment makes debt contracts self-enforcing and yields an endogenous upper bound on credit use. So long as record-keeping is imperfect, money and credit coexist for a range of nominal interest rates. Our model captures the dependence of debt limits on monetary policy and explains how hold-up problems in technological adoption prevent retailers from accepting credit as consumers continue to coordinate on cash usage. With limited commitment, changes in monetary policy generate multiplier effects in the credit market due to complementarities between consumer borrowing and the adoption of credit by merchants.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: money and credit, limited commitment, endogenous record-keeping
• Subjects: E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E4 - Money and Interest Rates > E41 - Demand for Money; E - Macroeconomics and Monetary Economics > E5 - Monetary Policy, Central Banking, and the Supply of Money and Credit > E51 - Money Supply ; Credit ; Money Multipliers

References

Alvarez, Fernando and Urban Jermann (2000): ``Efficiency, Equilibrium, and Asset Pricing with Risk of Default." \emph{Econometrica}, 68, 775--797.

Andolfatto, David (2013): ``Incentive-Feasible Deflation." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}, 60(4), 383--390.

Antinolfi, Gaetano, Costas Azariadis, and James Bullard (2009): ``The Optimal Inflation Target in an Economy with Limited Enforcement." Washington University at St. Louis Manuscript.

Arango, Carlos and Varya Taylor (2008): ``Merchants' Costs of Accepting Means of Payment: Is Cash the Least Costly?" \emph{ Bank of Canada Review.}

Araujo, Luis and Tai-Wei Hu (2014): ``Optimal Monetary Interventions in Credit Markets." Mimeo.

Aruoba, Boragan, Guillaume Rocheteau, and Christopher Waller (2007): ``Bargaining and the Value of Money." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}, 54(8), 2636-2655.

Berentsen, Aleksander, Gabriele Camera, and Christopher Waller (2007): ``Money, Credit, and Banking." \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, 135(1), 171--195.

Bethune, Zachary, Guillaume Rocheteau, and Peter Rupert (2014): ``Unemployment and Household Unsecured Debt." \emph{Review of Economic Dynamics}, 18(1), 77--100.

Bethune, Zachary, Tai-Wei Hu, and Guillaume Rocheteau (2014): ``Dynamic Indeterminacy and Welfare in Credit Economies." Mimeo.

Briglevics, Tamas and Scott Schuh (2013): ``U.S. Consumer Demand for Cash in the Era of Low Interest Rates and Electronic Payments." Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Working Paper No. 13-23.

Chakravorti, Sujit (2010): ``Externalities in Payment Card Networks: Theory and Evidence," \emph{ Berkeley Electronic Press}, vol. 9(2).

Chakravorti, Sujit and Ted To (2007): ``A Theory of Credit Cards." \emph{International Journal of Industrial Organization}, 25(3), 583-595

Chatterjee, Satyajit, Dean Corbae, Makoto Nakajima, and Jose Victor Rios-Rull (2007): ``A Quantitative Theory of Unsecured Consumer Credit with Risk of Default." \emph{Econometrica}, 75(6), 1525--1589.

Dong, Mei (2011): ``Money and Costly Credit." Mimeo.

%Dutta, Rohan (2012): ``Bargaining with Revoking Costs." \emph{Games and Economic Behavior}, vol. 74(1), 144-–153.

Federal Reserve (2005): ``Consumer Credit." Federal Reserve Statistical Release G-19.

Foster, Kevin, Erik Meijer, Scott Schuh, and Michael Zabek (2011): ``The 2009 Survey of Consumer Payment Choice." Federal Reserve Bank of Boston Public Policy Discussion Papers.

Freeman, Scott and Finn E. Kydland (2000): ``Monetary Aggregates and Output." \emph{American Economic Review}, vol. 90(5), 1125--1135.

Garcia-Swartz, D.D., R.W. Hahn, and A. Layne-Farrar (2006): ``The Move Toward a Cashless Society: A Closer Look at Payment Instrument Economics." \emph{Review of Network Economics}, vol. 5 (2), 175--198.

Gerdes, Geoffrey (2008): ``Recent Payment Trends in the United States." \emph{Federal Reserve Bulletin}, vol. 94, A75--A106.

Gomis-Porqueras, Pedro and Daniel Sanches (2013): ``Optimal Monetary Policy in a Model of Money and Credit." \emph{Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking}, 45, 4, 701–0730.

Gowrisankaran, Gautam and Joanna Stavins (2004): ``Network Externalities and Technology Adoption: Lessons from Electronic Payments.” \emph{RAND Journal of Economics}. vol. 35, no. 2, 260--276.

%Gu, Chao, Fabrizio Mattesini, Cyril Monnet, and Randall Wright (2013): ``Endogenous Credit Cycles." \emph{Journal of Political Economy}, forthcoming.

Gu, Chao, Fabrizio Mattesini, and Randall Wright (2014): ``Money and Credit Redux." Mimeo.

Hu, Tai-Wei, John Kennan, and Neil Wallace (2009): ``Coalition-Proof Trade and the Friedman Rule in the Lagos-Wright Model." \textit{Journal of Political Economy}, 117(1), 116--137.

Kalai, Ehud (1977): ``Proportional Solutions to Bargaining Situations: Interpersonal Utility Comparisons." \emph{Econometrica}, 45, 1623--1630.

Kahn, Charles and William Roberds (2008): ``Credit and Identity Theft." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}.

Kehoe, Timothy and David Levine (1993): ``Debt-Constrained Asset Markets." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 60(4), 865--888.

Kehoe, Timothy and David Levine (2001): ``Liquidity Constrained Markets Versus Debt Constraint Markets." \emph{Econometrica}, 69, 575--598. %Kocherlakota, Narayana (1996): ``Implications of Efficient Risk Sharing without Commitment." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 63, 595--609.

Kocherlakota, Narayana (1998): ``Money Is Memory." \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, vol. 81(2), 232-251.

Kocherlakota, Narayana and Neil Wallace (1998): ``Incomplete Record-Keeping and Optimal Payment Arrangements." \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, vol. 81(2), 272-289.

Lacker, Jeffrey and Stacey Schreft (1996): ``Money and Credit as Means of Payment." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}, 38, 3--23.

Lagos, Ricardo and Randall Wright (2005): ``A Unified Framework for Monetary Theory and Policy Analysis." Journal of Political Economy, 113(3), 463--486.

Lagos, Ricardo and Guillaume Rocheteau (2008): ``Money and Capital as Competing Media of Exchange." \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, 142(1), 247--258.

Lagos, Ricardo (2010): ``Asset Prices and Liquidity in an Exchange Economy." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}, 57(8), 913--930.

Lester, Benjamin, Andrew Postlewaite, and Randall Wright (2012): ``Liquidity, Asset Pricing, and Monetary Policy." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, vol. 79(3), 12090--1238.

Li, Yiting, Guillaume Rocheteau, and Pierre-Olivier Weill (2012): ``Liquidity and the Threat of Fraudulent Assets." \emph{Journal of Political Economy}, vol. 120, 815--846.

Liu, Lucy, Liang Wang, and Randall Wright (2014): ``Sticky Prices and Costly Credit." Mimeo. %McAndrews, James and Zhu Wang (1998): ``The Economics of Two-Sided Payment Card Markets: Pricing, Adoption, and Usage." Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland working paper.

%Monnet, Cyril and William Roberds (2008): ``�Optimal Pricing of Payment Services�." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}, 55, 1428--1440.

%Nilson Report (2012): ``U.S. General Purpose Cards Through 3Q 2012." Issue 1006.

Nosal, Ed and Guillaume Rocheteau (2011): \emph{Money, Payments, and Liquidity}. MIT Press.

Roberds, William and Stacey Schreft (2009): ``Data Breaches and Identify Theft." \emph{Journal of Monetary Economics}.

Rochet, Jean-Charles and Jean Tirole (2006): ``Two-Sided Markets: A Progress Report." \emph{The Rand Journal of Economics}, 37(4): 645–67.

Rysman, Marc (2009): ``The Economics of Two-Sided Markets." \emph{Journal of Economic Perspectives}, volume 23, 3, 125--143.

Sanches, Daniel and Stephen Williamson (2010): ``Money and Credit with Limited Commitment and Theft." \emph{Journal of Economic Theory}, Volume 145, 1525-1549.

Shi, Shouyong (1996): ``Credit and Money in a Search Model with Divisible Commodities." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 63, 627--652.

%Stavins, Joanna (2003): ``Network Externalities in the Market for Electronic Check Payments." \emph{New England Economic Review}.

%Stavins, Joanna (2011): ``Consumer Payments Cards: Lessons from the U.S. Experience." Federal Reserve Bank of Boston presentation at Cards and Payments Australasia, Sydney, Australia.

Telyukova, Irina and Randall Wright (2008): ``A Model of Money and Credit, with Application to the Credit Card Debt Puzzle." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 75(2), 629--647.

Telyukova, Irina (2013): ``Household Need for Liquidity and the Credit Card Debt Puzzle." \emph{Review of Economic Studies}, 80(3), 1148-1177.

Townsend, Robert (1989): ``Currency and Credit in a Private Information Economy." \emph{Journal of Political Economy}, 97, 1323-1344.

Wallace, Neil (1998): ``A Dictum for Monetary Theory." \emph{Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis Quarterly Review. }

Williamson, Stephen (1987): ``Costly Monitoring, Loan Contracts, and Equilibrium Credit Rationing." \emph{The Quarterly Journal of Economics}, vol. 102(1), pages 135-45.

Wright, Julian (2011): ``Why do Firms Accept Credit Cards?" \emph{Review of Network Economics}, 9(3), 1--8.

Zhang, Cathy (2014): ``An Information-Based Theory of International Currency." \emph{Journal of International Economics}, 93(2), 286--301.