Will WTO membership really improve market access for Ukrainian exports?

Eromenko, Igor and Mankovska, Nadiya and Dean, James W (2003): Will WTO membership really improve market access for Ukrainian exports? Published in: "Ukraine’s WTO Accession: Challenges for Domestic Economic Reforms" Ihor Burakovsky, Lars Handrich, Lutz Hoffmann (Ed.) No. Hidelberg, Physica-Verlaf (2003): pp. 167-188.

Abstract

Although the WTO embraces over 90% of world trade, several large CIS transition countries have not joined it yet. Delays have not only been due to technical problems, but also to a lack of clear understanding of the consequences of WTO membership. The aim of this paper is to ask how important improved market access might be as an incentive for one of the biggest CIS countries, Ukraine, to join the WTO. We employ the gravity model of international trade and include data on 85 of Ukraine’s trade partners. By looking at initial conditions for Ukrainian exports, we estimate the extent to which Ukrainian exports are hurt by barriers imposed by its trading partners, as well as Ukraine’s potential level of trade. Our estimates show that import barriers imposed by Ukraine’s trade partners do not play an important role in determining the volume of Ukrainian exports. Moreover, Ukraine already exports twice the potential level, predicted by our gravity model. Nevertheless, Ukraine depends on small number of unprocessed and semi-processed export goods and the efficiency of its exporting industries is quite low. These results suggest that the Most Favoured Nation mechanism and putative improved market access might not be an important criteria for deciding Ukraine’s accession to the WTO. Our results are consistent with other studies on transition economies, which found that WTO membership plays a much less important role in improving market access than do increasing FDI, regularising dispute settlements, and improving resource allocation.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: WTO; cost of trade barriers; potential exports; gravity model; Ukraine
• Subjects: F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F13 - Trade Policy ; International Trade Organizations; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F15 - Economic Integration; F - International Economics > F1 - Trade > F17 - Trade Forecasting and Simulation; P - Economic Systems > P3 - Socialist Institutions and Their Transitions > P33 - International Trade, Finance, Investment, Relations, and Aid

References

Akimova, Iryna and Scherbakov, Alexander Competition and Technical Efficiency of Ukrainian Manufacturing Enterprises. Institute for Economic Research and Policy Consulting. Working Paper # 17, 2002

Anderson, James E. A Theoretical Foundation for the Gravity Model. American Economic Review, 1979

Bergstrand, Jeffrey H. The Gravity Equation in International Trade: Some Microeconomic Foundations and Empirical Evidence. Review of Economics and Statistics, 1985

Brocker, Johannes How would an EU-membership of the Visegrad-countries affect Europe’s economic geography? The Annals of Regional Science Springer-Verlag 32:91-114, 1998

CEFIR-Club 2015 Russia in the WTO: Myths and Reality. www.cefir.org, 2001

Davis, Donald R. and Weinstein, David E. Does Economic Geography Matter for International Specialization? HIID Development Discussion Paper # 591, 1997

Deardorff, Alan V. Determinants of Bilateral trade: Does Gravity Work in a Neoclassical World? NBER working Paper # 5377, 1995

Djankov, Simeon and Friend, Caroline Disintegration and Trade Flows: Evidence from the Soviet Union. World Bank, 2000

Drabek, Zdenek and Laird, Sam The New Liberalism: Trade Policy Developments in Emerging Markets. WTO, Geneva, 1997

Feenstra, Robert C. How Costly is Protectionism? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 1992

Jensen, Jesper, Rutherford, Thomas, Tarr, David Economy-Wide and Sector Effects of Russia’s Accession to the WTO. Paper prepared for the New Economic School Tenth Anniversary Conference. Moscow, Russia, December 19-21, 2002

Harrigan, James Specialisation and the Volume of Trade: Do the Data Obey the Laws? NBER Working Paper # 8675, 2001

Langhammer, Rolf and Lucke, Matthias WTO Negotiations and Accession Issues for Vulnerable Economies. Kiel Institute of World Economics, Working Paper # 990, 2000

Martin, Carmela The Impact of EU Trade Agreements with Central and East European Countries: The Case of Spain Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Facultad de Economicas, Documentos de Trabajo series, 1995

Matyas, L. Proper Econometric Specification of the Gravity Model. The World Economy. 1997

Michalopoulos, Constantine The Integration of Transition Economies Into the World Trading System. Paper presented at the Fifth Dubrovnik Conference on Transition Economies, 1999

Michalopoulos, Constantine WTO Accession for Countries in Transition. Post-Soviet Prospects 6, #3, 1998

Michalopoulos, Constantine, Tarr, David The Economics of Customs Unions in the Commonwealth of Independent States, Policy Research Working Paper, World Bank, April 24, 1997

Oguledo, Victor I., and Craig R. MacPhee. Gravity Model: A Reformulation and an Application to Discriminatory Trade Arrangements. Applied Economics, 1994

O’Driscoll, Jr., Gerald P, Feulner, Edwin J and O'Grady, Mary Anastasia Explaining the Factors of the Index of Economic Freedom. Heritage Foundation, 2002 (a)

O’Driscoll, Jr., Gerald P, Holmes, Kim R. and O'Grady, Mary Anastasia The 2002 Index of Economic Freedom. Heritage Foundation, 2002 (b)

Poyhonen, P. A Tentative Model for the Flows of Trade Between Countries. Weltwirtschaftliches Archiv, 1963

Prichett, Lant Measuring Outward Orientation in LDCs: Can it be Done? Journal of Development Economics, 1996

Radelet, Steven Manufacturing Exports, Export Platforms, and Economic Growth. CAER II Discussion Paper # 43, 1999

Rollo, Jim Putting Trade on Track. A Realistic Negotiation agenda for the WTO. A Federal Trust Report. www.fedtrust.co.uk 2001

Rose, Andrew K. Do We Really Know that the WTO Increases Trade? NBER Working Paper # 9273, 2002 (a)

Rose, Andrew K. Do WTO Members Have More Liberal Trade Policy? NBER Working Paper # 9347, 2002 (b)

Sachs, Jeffrey, Zinnes, Clifford and Eilat, Yair Benchmarking Competitiveness in Transition Economies. CAER II Discussion Paper # 62, 2000

Schumaher, Dieter Market Size and Factor Endowment: Explaining Comparative Advantage in Bilateral trade by Difference in Income and Per Capita Income, DIW Discussion Paper #259, 2001

Tinbergen, J. Shaping the World Economy: Suggestions for an International Economic Policy. New York: The Twentieth Century Fund, 1962

The South Centre Issues Regarding the Review of the WTO Dispute Settlement Mechanism, 1999

The South Centre Special and differential Treatment for Developing Countries in the WTO, 1999

The WTO Fiftieth Anniversary of the Multilateral Trading System. Press Brief. www.wto.org 1998

Wall, Howard J. Using the Gravity Model to Estimate the Costs of Protection. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, 1999

Xymena, Clark and Tavares, Jose A Quantitative Approach Using Gravity Equation. HIID Development Discussion Paper # 748, 2000