The Financial Services Authority : A model of improved accountability?

Ojo, Marianne (2016): The Financial Services Authority : A model of improved accountability? Published in: Designing Optimal Models of Financial Regulation in a Changing Financial Environment Nova Publications (April 2016)

Abstract

Prior to the adoption of the FSA (Financial Services Authority) model, supervision of UK banks was carried out by the Bank of England. Although the Bank of England's informal involvement in bank supervision dates back to the mid nineteenth century, it was only in 1979 that it acquired formal powers to grant or refuse authorization to carry out banking business in the UK. Events such as the Secondary Banking Crisis of 1973-74 and the Banking Coordination Directive of 1977 resulted in legislative changes in the form of the Banking Act 1979. Bank failures through the following years then resulted in changes to the legislative framework. This article looks into the claim that the FSA model has improved in terms of accountability in comparison to its predecessor, the Bank of England. It considers the impact the FSA has made on the financial services sector and on certain legislation since its introduction. Through a comparison with the Bank of England, previous and present legislation, reports and other sources, an assessment can be made as to whether the FSA provides more accountability. Evidence provided here supports the conclusion that the FSA is both equipped with better accountability mechanisms and executes its functions in a more accountable way than its predecessor.

• Item Type: MPRA Paper
• Language: English
• Keywords: regulators; accountability; supervision; financial; services
• Subjects: G - Financial Economics > G2 - Financial Institutions and Services > G28 - Government Policy and Regulation

References

Alexander K (October 2004) “ Corporate Governance and Basel II ” Paper Presented at the Institute of Advanced Legal Studies, Russell Square London

Annual Report under the Banking Act for 1994-95 Treasury and Civil Service Committee (1995) , Board of Banking Supervision ; The Report on the Collapse of Barings Bank, Minutes of Evidence : Mr Eddie George, Mr Brian Quinn and Sir Alan Hardcastle Treasury Committee Report No 1 1996 Barings Bank and International Regulation

Ayres I and  Braithwaite J (1992) “Responsive Regulation : Transcending the Deregulation Debate”   New York : Oxford Union Press

Bank of Credit and Commerce International (Overseas) Ltd (in liquidation) and others v Price Waterhouse and Another (No 3)

Bank of England Report and Accounts 1996

Barings Bank and International Regulation; 23 July 1996 Minutes of Evidence.

Barings Bank and International Regulation; 18 November 1996 Minutes of Evidence.

Barings Bank and International Regulation Volume 1 December 1996

Bingham Report, loc cit n 183 October 1992 ; Inquiry into the Supervision of the Bank of Credit and Commerce International , London : HMSO (hereinafter Bingham)

Board of Banking Supervision Report on Collapse of Barings Bank ; July 19 1995 Minutes of Evidence Financial Services Authority Annual Report 2004/05 Trade and Industry Committee Third Report ( 1989 -90) ; Company Investigations House of Commons Treasury and Civil Service Committee (1991-92) , Fourth Report : Banking Supervision and BCCI : International and National Regulation House of Commons

Banking Act 1979

Banking Act 1987

Bank of England Act 1998

Barings Plc v Coopers and Lybrand [1997] 1 BCLC 427 Basel Committee Publications No 87 (January 2002 ) “The Relationship between Bank Supervisors and External Auditors ”

Basel Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision 1997

Barth JR Caprio Jr G and Levine R (November 2001) “Bank Regulation and Supervision : What Works Best?” The World Bank Development Research Group Finance and Financial Sector Strategy and Policy Department

Black J ( 2003) “Decentring Regulation: Undestanding the Role of Regulation and Self-Regulation in a Post-Regulatory World”

Benoit R Decamps JP and Rochet JC (April 2002) “ The Three Pillars of Basel II : Optimizing the Mix in a Continuous Time Model ”

Dewing P and Russell PO (2005) The Role of Auditors, Reporting Accountants and Skilled Persons in UK Financial Services Supervision Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland

Ferran E (2003) “ Examining the UK's Experience in Adopting the Single Financial Regulator Model” Brooklyn Journal of International Law

Financial Services Act 1986

Financial Services and Markets Bill

Financial Services and Markets Act 2000

Gleeson S (2006) Prudential Regulation of Banks under the FSMA Second edition

Gray J and Hamilton J (2006) “ Implementing Financial Regulation : Theory and Practice” Second Edition , John Wiley and Sons

Goodhart C et al (1998) “Financial Regulation : Why, How and Where Now?” Routledge

Goodhart CAE (1998) “The Emerging Framework of Financial Regulation” The Financial Markets Group of the London School of Economics

Hadjiemmanuil C (1995) “Banking Regulation and the Bank of England ” Lloyds of London Press

Hall MJB (1996) “Banking Regulation in the European Union : Some Issues and Concerns , Rethinking Bank Regulation : What Should Regulators Do?” Federal Reserve Bank Chicago 32nd Annual Conference

Hitchins J Hogg M and Mallett D 2001 “Banking : A Regulatory Accounting and Auditing Guide”

Johnson Matthey Plc v Arthur Young and the Governor of the Bank of England [1989] 2 All ER 105

Llewellyn (1999) “The Economic Rationale for Financial Regulation”

MacNeil I (1999) “The Future for Financial Regulation : The Financial Services and Markets Bill” 62 MLR

Research Papers (1999) Houses of Parliament Research Paper 99/68 “Financial Services and Markets Bill” [ Bill 121 of 1998-99]

Vieten HR (1997) “Banking Regulation in Britain and Germany Compared : Capital Ratios, External Audit and Internal Controls”

Wagster JD (1996) “Impact of the 1988 Basel Accord on International Banks Rethinking Bank Regulation : What Should Regulators Do?” Federal Reserve Bank Chicago 32nd Annual Conference

The Economist (1999). “Financial Regulation : Beware of the Watch Dog” June 1999

The Economist (2000). “Basle Bust” April 2000

The Economist (2001). “Don't Bank on Brussels” April 2001

The Economist (2002). “Bubble and Squeak” September 2002

The Economist (2002). “A Bit of Give and Take” October 2002

Treasury Committee Volume 1 Session 1996-1997 First Report Barings Bank and International Regulation